News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by paxys on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:06PM (#36384465)
"The company was great when it was just engineers, but then they hired account managers and sales reps and business people and marketers who ruined everything."

Common refrain from developers at SaaS companies who don't realize that the party they were enjoying all these years was directly funded by VC dollars, and these other people who they hate so much in fact do critical jobs and are necessary for converting all their work into a viable business.

Re:Goodbye, Twilio by rewmie on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:17PM (#36384584)
> (...) and these other people who they hate so much in fact do critical jobs and (...)

Just because someone is hired for a position of a sales rep/account manager/business people, that does not mean they walk over water. Those positions attract plenty of types whose primary skill is to leverage their soft skills talent to latch themselves to a organization while delivering no added value at all.

Re:Goodbye, Twilio by paxys on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:19PM (#36384595)
You can say the same for engineers, and really anyone else.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by rewmie on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:21PM (#36384627)
A startup lives and dies by the engineers. Without them there is no product. This very case documents how engineers created value only to get new arrivals whose net contribution is non-positive, to the point they effectively drive out the talent that made everything possible.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by eightysixfour on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:42PM (#36384817)
No, a startup lives and dies by revenue or fundraising. Engineers are a means of achieving revenue for many startups, but that does not mean they live and die by their engineers. There are plenty of large companies that got there without engineering excellence.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by paxys on Sunday June 18, 2023 @06:23PM (#36385151)
And conversely there are plenty of startups (the majority even) that had excellent engineering but failed due to a myriad of other reasons. "Engineering = success" is a very naive view of the industry and the world.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by rewmie on Sunday June 18, 2023 @07:37PM (#36385660)
> And conversely there are plenty of startups (the majority even) that had excellent engineering but failed due to a myriad of other reasons. "Engineering = success" is a very naive view of the industry and the world.

You're putting up lame strawmen. No one claimed "Engineering = success".

The claim is that it is absolutely impossible to have a tech startup without engineers, and no idea, no matter how cunning it might be, can have success if engineering can't turn it to into reality.

A tech startup without engineering is snake oil. Simple as that. Let's not pretend that a salesperson parachuting into a startup with a product in the market can possibly have a comparable impact to those who actually deliver the actual product.

Re:Goodbye, Twilio by dicriseg on Monday June 19, 2023 @02:36AM (#36387981)
What good is a product to a startup if no one's using it? Sales turns the product into money.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by withinboredom on Sunday June 18, 2023 @06:02PM (#36384981)
If you really want an adventure into this 'engineers vs. funding', look up Roberts Space Industries.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by paulryanrogers on Sunday June 18, 2023 @06:57PM (#36385402)
Is that really a representative example though? Roberts basically invented a gaming subgenre despite himself until he had so much money there was no one left who could say "stop, that's enough". His ambition appears to keep engineers busy with an ever growing product scope.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by withinboredom on Sunday June 18, 2023 @07:02PM (#36385435)
That’s… an over simplification. But it’s an example of what happens when sales people are trying to sell jpegs and mpegs before anyone has done any development. It drives development to the point that virtually nothing is “done” and everything is half-done.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by alvarezbjm-hn on Sunday June 18, 2023 @07:12PM (#36385509)
Theranos did well for a while /s (but matches that narrative!)
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by Gordonjcp on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:58PM (#36384933)
I guess these are engineers who somehow don't need to draw a wage then?
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by Turbots on Sunday June 18, 2023 @06:01PM (#36384970)
I was an engineer for 15 years and have been a tech presales for 4 years now. You couldn't be more wrong.

Best engineers making the best product ever will not make a dollar without good sales people and marketing and product managers and VC and ... You need ALL of these to make a succesful company.

Re:Goodbye, Twilio by paulryanrogers on Sunday June 18, 2023 @07:10PM (#36385488)
This has been my experience as well. Some word of mouth counterexamples exist yet are not the norm.

I think it's especially hard to appreciate sales+marketing since they seem so ephemeral while tech is concrete. Sadly there also also too many examples of marketing getting too far ahead of the product, over promising, or devaluing engineering.

Best is definitely a balance, where all sides respect others' work and can see both the effort and its benefits.

Re:Goodbye, Twilio by Aeolun on Sunday June 18, 2023 @07:21PM (#36385569)
Marketing/sales is fine. As long as they sell what we have, not a pie in the sky that we might at some point in the future have.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by unusualmonkey on Sunday June 18, 2023 @06:20PM (#36385134)
I'm sorry, but that's kinda of nonsense.

You can build a fairly successful startup with little to no engineering.

Sure, engineers are usually pretty important (they're great at automating tasks to improve efficeincy)... but so are many other roles.

Re:Goodbye, Twilio by Aeolun on Sunday June 18, 2023 @07:19PM (#36385552)
You can, but then you generally do not try to build a first in class telephony service.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by ramraj07 on Sunday June 18, 2023 @06:49PM (#36385342)
How wrong can someone be? Unless the startups core proposition is some advanced algorithm (like openai), something very hard to replicate, it absolutely does not matter how great their engineers are. They merely need to be barely competent. Of course, better engineers means more efficiency and a different structure but that never fails a startup. Bad growth does. But growth numbers expected of VC backed startups can fail it. Thus the factors that fail or succeed most startups is not the engineeers.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by xeromal on Sunday June 18, 2023 @08:34PM (#36385965)
You can say the same thing about marketing. If there's no marketing, who buys the product.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by throwaway675309 on Sunday June 18, 2023 @06:50PM (#36385348)
Perhaps, but I would argue that the door in order to be able to get access to these positions is more heavily barred when the interview process can include clinically quantifiable demonstrable competency in the form of architectural whiteboarding, algorithm design etc.

It's more difficult to assess and measure soft skills that you would find in sales positions.

Re:Goodbye, Twilio by Gooblebrai on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:29PM (#36384703)
Very interested in knowing why do you think they don't add any value?
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by lumost on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:53PM (#36384909)
I’ve been on sales calls as the primary tech contact with 10 other people on the line. After 4 months on that account, only one other person actually did anything in my opinion. Perhaps the other bodies gave the perception that a lot of people “cared” about the customer?

Unfortunately, this is a common outcome. Sales/marketing will quantify revenue/profit goals, these goals often implicitly assume that it is only because of sales that those numbers were hit. Sales then grows headcount and gains influence in the organization. Eventually, you get some insane ratio of dev:sales and things get strange. The terminal state of such firms is the sales team driving acquisitions of products - so that they can sell the new product. By the time you’ve reached this point “technical” innovation is impossible.

On the flip side, there is nothing intrinsically wrong with driving a business from the sales side. There is lots of room for business process innovation. However, as an engineer - I’d much rather work at an engineering driven firm.

Re:Goodbye, Twilio by afavour on Sunday June 18, 2023 @05:19PM (#36384602)
> viable business

A developer run and developer focused business could absolutely be a viable business. But it wouldn’t be the 10x hockey stick growth company venture capitalists demand and ultimately they hold the power here. So we get the inevitable.

Re:Goodbye, Twilio by sethammons on Sunday June 18, 2023 @06:46PM (#36385321)
Where does the money come from? Customers don't magically appear. Any, and I mean _any_ example you can dream of, will require something more than just the product.

Price, promotion, product, and distribution. You need all four.

Re:Goodbye, Twilio by afavour on Sunday June 18, 2023 @06:53PM (#36385368)
> Where does the money come from?

You realise that businesses are successfully formed without venture capital, right?

I’m not saying “create a business and ignore the entire concept of marketing”. I’m saying that you can create a small business with a tight focus and it can be a success, a great success even, without the necessity of scaling to the level VC investments usually require you to.

Re:Goodbye, Twilio by sethammons on Sunday June 18, 2023 @07:06PM (#36385457)
I agree. I misread and thought you were saying a product is enough, which is obv. not the case. You need all four things I mentioned.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by quickthrower2 on Sunday June 18, 2023 @08:36PM (#36385980)
You can sort of get it in the post-unicorns: see AWS, Microsoft. Smaller examples, Digital Ocean, Hashicorp. They are certainly dev focused, and probably dev run to a high enough level (but not the top). They wont always do things you like/agree with as a dev, but that is different to not being dev focused.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by gamesbrainiac on Sunday June 18, 2023 @06:53PM (#36385370)
I think you read a different article. Miguel is aggrieved by the fact that it is no longer a developer focused company, which was the reason for its success.

Sure, you need sales, marketing and the rest of it; it does not mean that you need to forget what made you great in the first place.

Re:Goodbye, Twilio by OJFord on Sunday June 18, 2023 @07:11PM (#36385495)
I agree; to make the point clearer: you can be a company full of salesmen etc. and still be focussed on engineers as the target market.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by Solvency on Sunday June 18, 2023 @07:46PM (#36385701)
The article is all over the place. Miguel spends most of it bemoaning the change of his favorite billboard, as if that can be universally unpacked and extrapolated by others as why Twilio is no longer "for developers".

The remainder of his post says only that their shift from focusing on one specialization (communications) to another (customer data and engagement) doesn't align with HIS values.

Now, that's ok. He doesn't have to be down for it. But it also doesn't prove how they're no longer for developers. They could still have the best API, documentation, and developer support in the game. They could pay developers well, respect their input, and their process.

And yet he doesn't speak to any of this. I want to know how Twilio is no longer for developers. What actually changed! That was his root proposition, and he doesn't address it or substantiate it ever.

Re:Goodbye, Twilio by WWLink on Sunday June 18, 2023 @08:03PM (#36385800)
" The article is all over the place. Miguel spends most of it bemoaning the change of his favorite billboard, as if that can be universally unpacked and extrapolated by others as why Twilio is no longer "for developers"."

I think his point is hella clear with the two screenshots. Originally they provide "Voice, SMS, and Video APIs"and then they switch to "Customer Engagement Platform"

Both messages are likely nonsense for the vast majority of people that drive by them. The "ask your developer" one specifically targets software devs and mentions why. The "How can I reduce acquisition costs by 65%?" targets business owners ... but it's a little vague because the first thing I'd think when I hear "acquisition costs" is buying another business lol. What the hell is a "customer engagement platform"? Well, a developer isn't gonna give a shit then.

So the first billboard goes with a "hey boss I found out about this cool twillo stuff we can use!" to "Hi it's the CEO, we're now going to use twillo and if you don't like it, eat shit"

Re:Goodbye, Twilio by mbesto on Sunday June 18, 2023 @08:28PM (#36385940)
Rubbish.

Money doesn't magically show up at your doorstep even if your product is focused on developers. How do you think SaaS companies are able to hire developers? Do those $350k bay area salaries magically come from nothing? Yes, they often initially fueled by VC dollars, but eventually customer revenues pay for them.

The "anti sales" drivel from engineers on HN who are largely some of the highest paid positions in the world always puzzles me.

It's OKAY to be okay with Sales & Marketing in companies. It isn't some evil function, and discounting it means future entrepreneurs are doomed to fail.

Re:Goodbye, Twilio by wpietri on Sunday June 18, 2023 @08:49PM (#36386042)
You are arguing with something that was not said.

Neither the original article nor the person you are replying to said that sales wasn't needed. Indeed, the person you're replying to explicitly said the opposite.

The actual complaint is that they shifted their target audience from engineers to something much broader and fuzzier. The complaint is not that they have salespeople, which they needed in either case. It's that the lack of clarity in who they're selling to and why is making it worse for everybody.

Re:Goodbye, Twilio by anaganisk on Monday June 19, 2023 @12:05AM (#36387219)
I think I can play both sides, GIMP vs Photoshop, Photoshop Vs GIMP. Both have great engineers but sales and marketing is subject to opinion based on how you see them.
Re:Goodbye, Twilio by Quarrelsome on Sunday June 18, 2023 @09:52PM (#36386446)
the interests of account-managers/sales-reps and developers are often in conflict over resource allocation. Its natural for those interests to compete and I feel like brushing off one side of this coin as juvenile whining is a partisan position to take.

Its a common problem in tech and finding the balance between the two is arguably a big part of long-term success for an org in this industry.