Reddit cares more about having an open subreddit then the mods do.
This was the obvious conclusion
> if they are no longer interested in moderating that community
The mods, as GP stated, are interested in moderating that community, they just disagree with Reddit's changes. They wouldn't be taking the path of shuttering their subs in protest if they didn't give a damn.
That is absolutely dishonesty on the part of Reddit.
Christian says it's going to cost him $20M/year with his current API usage. Has he even tried to optimize his app? Relay for Reddit just found a bunch of bugs and reoptimized his calls to get his app down to the new limits.
Let's do the math...
Let's say Apollo, Relay, or RIF charged $2/mo per user and were able to get their calls within the limits (as Relay has). Would that be enough to cover their expenses?
Looking at Reddit's new API pricing, 100 calls per day per average user would cost $0.72 / month.
Google/Apple App Stores take a 15% commission on subscriptions so a total per month per customer average cost would be $0.83 cents.
That means the devs would make $0.98 cents per month per user on a $2 subscription fee. (30 cents to Google, 73 cents to reddit, 98 cents left to pocket).
The Relay for Reddit dev breaks it down here: https://www.reddit.com/r/RelayForReddit/comments/147152b/upd...
Apollo has 1.5 MILLION monthly active users. With a 10% conversion rate and charging $2.00 a month (which is $0.50 more expensive than the Ultra plan he already charges), he would make $150,000 / PER MONTH. That's with the new Reddit fees.
More: https://www.reddit.com/r/RelayForReddit/comments/147152b/com...
To me it sounds like Christian just doesn't want to do the work.
If the price of paper goes up, it's not uncommon for newspapers and magazines to increase prices marginally price per issue.
> Apollo has 1.5 MILLION monthly active users. With a 10% conversion rate and charging $2.00 a month
In other words, if he's willing to tell 1.35 million people to get fucked, he could turn his app that's widely beloved by many into an app that barely anyone knows about and new users are barely willing to consider trying.
These apps live and die by the same model: the paid users subsidize the free users. Who knows, maybe Christian could just tell those 1.35m people to get lost and it would be instantly profitable, but maybe that's not the app he wants to make. That seems entirely fair.
> To me it sounds like Christian just doesn't want to do the work.
Or, alternately, Christian feels betrayed by Reddit, because even though he's worked very closely with them for years, Reddit suddenly decided that yanking the carpet out from under third-party devs with thirty days' notice is the best way forward for them, and then the CEO turned around and slandered him all over the place, criticized Christian for having receipts, and then just continued to trash talk him everywhere.
Reddit has shown repeatedly through this ordeal that they don't actually want to work with people. Tons of other devs have reported that their e-mails are going unanswered. Christian asked about extensions or some other way to make things work and got no response. Reddit's goal here isn't to be profitable by charging 3p clients for API calls, it's to kill 3p clients and force them into their own terrible app.
Why would Christian want to jump through hoops to work with a company that's gone out of their way repeatedly to treat him like shit?
Steve Huffman is a liar. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36246529
It's painful to post a comment that otherwise reads as low-quality flamebait. But I tried to defend his actions, and was dragged to the conclusion that he tried to damage Christian's reputation by making up a lie. He even acknowledged it was false during a phone conversation with Christian, then continued to tell the lie publicly.
It shattered my faith in him, and to a lesser degree in YC's "don't be evil" philosophy.
The problem I think they will run into is that this 100 calls per day average is across all users, even those who don't use it that much.
Once you intersect that with the users who care enough and are willing to pay $2+ per month the average calls per user will blow out.
You pretty much have to be a heavy user in order to justify spending money on it.
And the Relay dev even points that out:
> An example is that a subscription could act as a filter where mostly high-rate users convert.
Not saying that's good or bad, just that it is.
If by "majority of users" you mean users that do not contribute any content and only view the site, sure, you may be right. But a content aggregator that is devoid of content doesn't exactly make a great website.
The vast minority polled the users, from what I can see. None of the subs I visited that went dark had a poll. I just decided to check some others - /r/funny and /r/gaming because they're listed as some of the biggest subs that went private, /r/askhistorians because people often use it as "the best of Reddit," /r/outoftheloop because I used to visit it. None of them had polls, either.
People keep trying to push the narrative that this was a democratic decision, but every piece of evidence I can find is that most mods did this without consulting the people that use the subs.
But I think most people realize that most of the users, who actually create the content, don't want the boycott to continue, and don't have any particular love for the current mods.
The ones who don't like the changes are leaving anyway.
I just don't think mods should be ending the communities, most of which they didn't start themselves. Let other people who don't share their issues take over.
You might be a desktop user (I am too) but Reddit is more than just you and me - it's the communities of people who choose to socialize there. And I have a hunch that Reddit chasing away the kinds of people who tend to use third-party apps is going to have a ripple effect on the quality of the communities contained on the site, not to mention bots that aren't covered under the various exemptions.
> I just don't think mods should be ending the communities
Those communities will only end when Reddit does. The only question is how long it will take to reopen and if there is a new moderation team or not.
>I exclusively use desktop so I'm not affected
[Doubt]
I use old.reddit with RES, toolbox and some ublock rules and all is good.
I've seen this oft repeated, but never backed up. The only poll I've seen results from[0] was overwhelmingly to stay shutdown indefinitely.
On top of that, you're probably going to be getting into sampling bias with larger subs, since most users that care are purposefully avoiding the site trying to "starve" them and wouldn't even know about the polls.
[0]: https://www.reddit.com/r/homelab/comments/149o61f/should_rho...
[0]: https://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/1429lkh/meta_thread...
I still see pro-blackout threads regularly shooting to the top of /r/all - which wouldn't get that far if they were down-voted by an angry populace.
> They're still interested. They're just protesting your policies.
seems like theyre more interested in pushing an agenda, than in moderating the community that theyre a part of - and its an agenda that most of the community doesnt understand/care about. How many folks in the seattle mariners baseball team subreddit, for example, know what "API" stands for?
After the protest announcements started, yes.
But these antics have me thinking I should find alternatives to the very few subs that actually matter. So if anyone knows a good web community for cooking... so far I've learned I'm too old for Discord.
Stack Exchange Cooking.
If subs are private, they are still accessible to subscribers. If the moderators don’t moderate the really bad stuff, Reddit has historically replaced them. I would think the same applies here.
No, this is not accurate.
A private subreddit is only accessible to "approved users", i.e. those on a list managed by the moderators. Subscribing is completely different; it's a private, user-settable flag whose only significant effect is to make the subreddit's content eligible to show up on your home page.
If you can't view a subreddit's content because it's private and you're not approved, then subscribing makes no difference. In fact, subreddit mods can't even see who's subscribed, nor can they prevent anyone from subscribing, even by banning them.
Subscription is about curating your homepage, news subscriptions (ugh), etc. Subscription means you want to see and know about popular stuff in that sub. And you can still view stuff you're not subscribed to, if you're an approved member.
The access levels that are allowable are: approved only, public but only approved can submit links, and public. You can also set access on items individually, and lock comments on those items, etc. So it's also possible to just blank or remove all the old posts with a bot (API!) and leave only a "fuck u" thread that's uncommentable.
At that point reddit probably reverts it and calls it vandalism and puts in new mods and starts banning anybody who's tantruming. Like, be disruptive get banned. You have less freedom here than with a TLD registrar (better ask nicely to get a .edu or .mil or .gov cert issued). Their system, their rules, their call. You already agreed to license your content to them. Shreddit could probably even be undone if they have history etc. And there already is a public dataset already on the internet for like... 10y+ now? how does that work exactly?
Who wins in the argument of GDPR vs users having agreed to a perpetual irrevocable license and several other parties already having used those API access to republish those comments under CC (fh-bigquery:reddit-comments, pushift, etc)? Can you revoke an irrevocable license under GDPR as the originator, and if so how does that leave IP licensing in general, just "fuck it GDPR it, it's mine, I don't want a licensee to use it"? I mean probably all social media licenses include something like that, if it's durable then GDPR is relatively meaningless and nobody has to respond to GDPR if they publish their dataaset/API output (interesting outcome perhaps). If it's not durable it kind of fucks up IP law and subassignment in general, everything was always done by someone at some point, then sublicensed to their employer, etc. Can you just be like "patent license revoked, boss, I did the GDPR?".
The idea of Google/etc being forced to publish their codebases under permissive licenses to avoid random "nah fuck you"'s from departing engineers would be an extremely funni legal outcome though, like that would have massive implications for knowledge/creative work in general. Maybe the same thing would happen to social media providers... maybe that paradoxically makes the incentive to publish fh-bigquery:reddit and pushift stronger, because now it's irrevocable. And that's the minimum ask for 3PA tooling more or less.
On the other hand if the CC sublicense holds in any way, most likely it's legal to say "ok this is the vandalism reversion dataset, it's CC, patch it over the api response inside the client" both for the vendor and the others.
I guess to put it another way: would wikipedia have to edit out every line and commit a user has interacted with, if they filed a GDPR? How do you begin to back that out on a word by word basis?
Reddit chooses not to unwind history and revert. But does Reddit have a license to do so? What about Wikipedia? It seems like in this case the answer may be "probably, if they want to, it's just normally not a problem but we can do it if people get disruptive".
The implication is that prioritizing the latter at all points in time is incompatible with the former. Seems reasonable enough. What does it mean to be "interested in moderating" if the outcome is that you do no actual moderation?
>And they're still insulting everyone's intelligence, as if a single mod reopening against strong subreddit consensus was something Reddit Inc. needed to begrudgingly "respect", rather than something they're eagerly encouraging.
For the sake of grandstanding you might want them to come out and say "any of you scabs want to cross the picket line for us?", but only spez would be stupid enough to actually do that.
The implication by Reddit is that prioritizing the latter at any point in time is incompatible with the former.
Important distinction/bit of nuance.
It's transparent, sure, but it doesn't mean it won't be effective. They're counting on a few people's greed plus most people's apathy.
reddit seems happy to go all in on the low-effort content mill market, and those users are the kind to get more upset over the protest than losing nice third-party apps or tools.
> if they are no longer interested in moderating that community
They're still interested. They're just protesting your policies.
> [if] at least one mod [...] wants to keep the community going, we will respect their decisions and remove those who no longer want to moderate from the mod team.
This one takes the cake. They're dangling a carrot: hey, any low-ranked mod interested in taking over the subreddit for yourself? And they're still insulting everyone's intelligence, as if a single mod reopening against strong subreddit consensus was something Reddit Inc. needed to begrudgingly "respect", rather than something they're eagerly encouraging.