News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by tjpnz on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:50PM (#36215645)
>Every child will have an AI tutor that is infinitely patient, infinitely compassionate, infinitely knowledgeable, infinitely helpful. The AI tutor will be by each child’s side every step of their development, helping them maximize their potential with the machine version of infinite love.

This bothers me.

Who trains these AI tutors and how do we prevent the system they're embedded in from churning out the same cookie cutter individuals, each with the exact same political beliefs and inability to comprehend the grey and nuanced?

Do we even want perfect tutors at all? The lessons I remember from school didn't always come from the best and brightest the profession had to offer. I would even go as far as to say that some were rather flawed individuals, in one way or another. That "wisdom" though has shaped me for the better as an individual. You're not going to find that in any textbook, much less a LLM.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by soco on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @01:31PM (#36216251)
Since when was something advertised as "perfect", perfect? I'd rather worry that it will be imperfect and try to teach all kind of random weird stuff to gullible kids.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by atleastoptimal on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:56PM (#36215745)
There are more risks from flawed teachers than risks from too perfect teachers
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by fsflover on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @01:01PM (#36215837)
Except that AI teachers trained by for-profit corporations are far from perfect.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by pelagicAustral on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:19PM (#36217775)
Oh let me fix that business model right away, the perfect version costs 100 bucks a month.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by TeMPOraL on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:34PM (#36217988)
And it doubles down on being flawed, as people willing to pay those 100 bucks self-select as both gullible and having discretionary income. More-less the same story as with paying for ad-free versions of ad-supported services.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by sebzim4500 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @06:39PM (#36220072)
If it was truly that cheap it would fundamentally change society.

Unless the field is incredibly competitive though it will cost orders of magnitude more than this.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by thethethethe on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @06:44PM (#36220121)
Regular teachers are trained by for profit corporations too. They are called private universities
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by BeetleB on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @07:06PM (#36220320)
In the US, most accredited private universities are non-profits.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by thethethethe on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:45PM (#36244830)
"Among postsecondary Title IV institutions in 2020–21, there were 1,892 public institutions, 1,754 private nonprofit institutions, and 2,270 private for-profit institutions."

https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=1122#:~:text=Am....

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by BeetleB on Thursday June 08, 2023 @07:16PM (#36250653)
How many of those 2270 private for profit institutions are accredited?
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by lisasays on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:01PM (#36217523)
Bothersome is an understatement. This is snake oil of the most insidious kind.

Oh wait, here's another zinger: "I even think AI is going to improve warfare, when it has to happen, by reducing wartime death rates dramatically."

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by golergka on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:07PM (#36217608)
This is true though. Modern warfare became much less deadly to civilians. Just compare Russia's total brutal destruction of Mariupol with their barbaric indiscriminating artillery barrages and Ukraine's almost bloodless liberation of Kherson, without a single artillery or air strike on the city itself — a very clear contrast between 20th and 21st century's warfare.

Wars will never go away, but by making them more precise and intelligent, we can make them not as horrible as they were in the past.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by joe_the_user on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:32PM (#36217960)
There's nothing about Russia's terror bombing that's related to not having advanced technology. Russia is using terror bombing because their strategic calculations have determined that weakening the Ukrainian nation would give them a strategic advantage - they've used advanced drones for this purpose as well as advanced missiles. If they had even more advanced systems, they would use them similarly.

Perhaps you could argue an advanced social system wouldn't target civilians but that's different issue (and still a hard one).

...by making them more precise and intelligent...

Precise technology is just as effective at precisely targeting civilians as it is at precisely soldiers and there hasn't been end to forces that view various civilians as the enemy.

And indeed, nations have very seldom targeted civilians because of the lack of precision - because civilians were standing next to soldiers or something similar. The human shield phenomena has happened but NAZIs targeted London for bombing because they wanted to break the British Nation. Etc.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by lisasays on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:37PM (#36218021)
But of course.

We have to remember they bombed that theater in Mariupol not in spite of the fact that there were children and mothers inside -- but because of it.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by staunton on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @05:40PM (#36219450)
I agree with your assessment as far as Ukraine is concerned.

However, I hope it's not a strawman to assume you're arguing that there is no progress in warfare in the sense of harm inflicted upon civilians. What would you prefer as a civilian: living in a country being conquered by Julius Caesar, Gengis Khan, occupied by Nazis in WWII or living in any of the countries occupied since WWII?

We even used to have a different word for it: "conquered". What was the lastest country in history, where this word would be appropriate?

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by joe_the_user on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @06:37PM (#36220057)
However, I hope it's not a strawman to assume you're arguing that there is no progress in warfare in the sense of harm inflicted upon civilians.

My point is specifically that progress in the technologies of war don't by themselves promise that things will be less brutal. Quite possibly other things have produced progress.

I would also note that technology produces unpredictable changes in the strategic situation and the actual result from a changed strategic is itself unpredictable even from the strategic situation. So where a technology change might take us is unpredictable and unpredictable-over-time. Notably, nuclear deterrence has so far worked well for keeping the world peaceful and is something of a factor for the relative pleasantness of the situation you cite. But if nuclear deterrence were to slip into nuclear war, the few survivors would probably think of this technology advance as the worst thing the world ever saw.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by nemo on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @09:28PM (#36221614)
>What would you prefer as a civilian: living in a country being conquered by Julius Caesar, Gengis Khan, occupied by Nazis in WWII or living in any of the countries occupied since WWII (including Ukraine)?

East Timor, Tibet, Darfur, Iraq, Central African Republic, there's lots of post-WW II events that are easily as wretched for the victims.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by ornornor on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:19PM (#36217776)
I’ll preface this by saying that I have never known war in my lifetime and that I absolutely don’t condone it.

That said, isn’t the point of war also that it’s horrible and barbaric? If war isn’t that anymore, won’t it be much more frequent and casually started as a result?

Again, I’m absolutely not saying it’s a good thing that war maims and kills people, but I see these side effects as a deterrent. There is a component of terror to it and that’s what makes it even worse.

If it’s enlisted professional killing each other, or even robots destroying each other, it can go on for much longer. And how do you determine the “winner” in that case if you can keep feeding robots into the fight, it’s never ending I’d think.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by lisasays on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:30PM (#36217945)
That said, isn’t the point of war also that it’s horrible and barbaric?

Of course - that's precisely the point. The idea that any technical innovation can make it less so (or make war less likely) runs counter to all historical observation.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by InexSquirrel on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:54PM (#36218259)
I'm not sure I agree with that. I don't think the _point_ of war is to be barbaric - that's a by-product of forceful expansion of power. Regardless of how killing another human is done in the context of conflict, it will always be considered barbaric, but the _point_ of the conflict isn't be maximise barbarism.

I think (and know very little, so could be wrong), that the purpose of war is to expand influence. This can take the form of access to new resources (whether that be land, access, air space, whatever) or to form a buffer between one country and another. There's probably other reasons, simply like ego in some cases.

There are other ways to expand powerbases too - such as China's heavy financial and infrastructure investment in Africa and South Pacific nations, or attempting to undermine another country's social structures. These are longer and harder to implement, but yield better results with practically no blood shed.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by lisasays on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @04:07PM (#36218427)
I stand corrected.

The point (in nearly all cases) is to win at any cost. From which the practice of limitless barbarism naturally follows.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by sebzim4500 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @06:37PM (#36220056)
>The idea that any technical innovation can make it less so (or make war less likely) runs counter to all historical observation.

Does it? WWII was less bloody than WW1, and nothing since has had anywhere near as many deaths.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by ojbyrne on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:05PM (#36220895)
“Less bloody” is nowhere close to true.

World War II casualties: 70-85 million

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties

World War I casualties: 40 million

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_I_casualties

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by panxyh on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @04:00PM (#36218340)
Wars and their winners usually emerge.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by dasil003 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @04:10PM (#36218472)
> That said, isn’t the point of war also that it’s horrible and barbaric? If war isn’t that anymore, won’t it be much more frequent and casually started as a result?

Yes (usually), to the first question. The second begs the question though.

Wars are destructive and enormously expensive. Only a tiny fraction of human leaders wielding a disproportionate amount of power have the agency to start wars, and they do so in order to pursue specific (but varied) objectives. Since the cost is high, no one does this lightly (even the "crazy" ones, because they would already have lost power if they weren't smart and calculating).

AI may provide avenues to enhance the efficacy of wars. It may also provide avenues to enhance other strategies to achieve those objectives. In all cases, we can expect AI will be used to further the objectives of those humans with the power to direct its development and applications.

It is therefore ludicrous and self-interested speculation to claim that AI will reduce death rates. Andreessen signals this with the preface "I even think" so that he can make the claim without any later accountability. The reality is, future wartime death rates may or may not decrease, but even if they do, we likely won't even be able to credibly attribute the change to AI versus all other changes to the global geopolitical environment.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by golergka on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @05:00PM (#36219045)
> That said, isn’t the point of war also that it’s horrible and barbaric?

No. The conqueror never wants war — he prefers to get what he wants without any resistance. It's only the defender who has to wage war to defend itself from aggression.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by jrumbut on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:28PM (#36217902)
I don't think that has much to do with AI. Russia is seeking to subjugate Ukraine and terrorize the population into surrendering, while Ukraine is attempting to protect the population.

If Russia had more military AI, they would use it to do more of the same thing they're doing with all of their current technologies.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by lisasays on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:26PM (#36217879)
But the same technology can also be used to make war, you know -- even more indiscriminate and deady. Or even where less so -- it can be used by the wrong side, even help them win in the end. While the companies that A16Z will inevitably invest in just keep raking in the profits, either way.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by rqtwteye on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @06:53PM (#36220210)
The “precision strikes” of the US weren’t very kind to Iraqi civilians either. War is horrible and it probably should never be viewed as anything else. Otherwise the temptations to start wars is too big for some political leaders.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by bbor on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:32PM (#36221110)
This is what happens when a normal person lucks/scams their way into billions: they think their random musings must be profound.

Like, how would such a war even work?? We have AI killbots shoot at eachother in no-mans-land, sure, but then what? The side with less killbots just gives up, like a fantasy novel monarch betting the realm on a trial by combat? Desperate people do desperate things, and those people having nuclear missles already scares me enough - I don't want to see them with self-replicating Von Nueman bomb drones or whatever other horrors the pentagon dreams up for us.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by YeGoblynQueenne on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @09:18AM (#36226431)
Yep. If we ever manage to remove the humans from the battlefield, the battlefield will simply move to where the humans are.

Anyway the point of war is to destroy the civilian infrastructure and the population that operates it, so they can't support an army. Which is kind of insanely circular because the army is there to defend the civilians and the infrastructure in the first place. War is just a mad thing and getting robots to do it will not make it any less mad, only more efficient at being mad.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by lisasays on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @10:57AM (#36227592)
They think their random musings must be profound.

And in the case of the VC community - you can hardly blame them, because everyone else seems to think so, as well.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:23PM (#36217838)
Why not replace imperfect parents too?

If AI can be a perfect tutor, it can certainly be a perfect parent, perfect romantic partner, perfect employee, perfect employer, perfect VC...

In fact why not create a perfect economy, perfect media, and a perfect infinitely wise and knowledgable political system?

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by Ekaros on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @04:17PM (#36218548)
And in the end why not just replace the citizenry and voters...

We could lock up those imperfect humans and just occasionally ship them some food and water. Maybe direct them to not produce so many imperfect new humans too.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by JohnFen on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @07:14PM (#36220414)
What he said is not very far from that.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by moffkalast on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @05:39PM (#36219424)
Actually unironically yes.

If history's proven anything it's that if you put enough humans together we'll do almost nothing but invent more and more elaborate ways to kill each other. And sometimes to kill other things too.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by AllegedAlec on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @04:25AM (#36224334)
All hail the evitable conflict we're hurling ourselves towards.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by eastbound on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @03:24PM (#36217848)
> churning out the same cookie cutter individuals

The question is not how to create individuals with different mind, but how to create them in enough mass that it reaches 51% before governments forbid whatever you are doing. And if you have so much power that the government doesn’t come at you, what kind of power were you looking for.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by dinvlad on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @05:04PM (#36219102)
They were trained by cheap labor in African countries, using abusive practices with no consideration for ethical concerns. The worst part is they didn't even care about how this would be seen by the public, since the public is just so blindingly hyped on it.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by x11antiek on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @06:21PM (#36219871)
Do you have a smartphone? Pretty sure it was assembled by cheap labor in third-world countries using abusive practices with no consideration for ethical concerns. Maybe you have a laptop? Same story. Did you consider this before purchasing and using these devices?
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by crabmusket on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @07:35PM (#36220608)
It doesn't seem helpful to try to impugn a person's morals in an effort to discredit a valid concern.

(And I say this as someone who does think about electronics supply chains, has previously owned a Fairphone and since has only purchased second-hand phones.)

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by x11antiek on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:03PM (#36220864)
It's not helpful neither fair to attach systemic issues of capitalism to the novel technology you personally don't like.

Yes this is a valid concern. Yet it's about the same as jumping on a random person in the grocery store with a lecture about the unsustainability of the product that person is taking off the shelf.

Sadly, buying second-hand devices for personal use won't affect these issues of the economic system we live in.

I am making no statements about anyone's morals.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by crabmusket on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:02AM (#36222672)
This isn't a grocery store, it's a comment threat incited by a highly positive take on AI. I think that's an appropriate place to mention these issues.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by dinvlad on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:34AM (#36222867)
Exactly, plus the kinds of things these people were forced to see are very illegal in the US. And eventually they had to get out of that job, despite not having good economic alternatives.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by dinvlad on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:37AM (#36222881)
There’s a difference between violation of working conditions like working hours/underpayment, and forcing people to see CP with dogs.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by _-____-_ on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @07:32PM (#36220578)
They were trained by people who agreed to do a job in exchange for payment.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by dinvlad on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:26AM (#36222822)
I don’t think they agreed to see the kinds of things they ended up seeing. As a result, they actually pushed to eventually excuse themselves from those jobs, despite not having a good alternative. That’s how bad it was.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by throw310822 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @06:13PM (#36219779)
> Every child will have an AI tutor that is infinitely patient, infinitely compassionate, infinitely knowledgeable, infinitely helpful.

Which also means: infinitely capable of performing a job in their place. What will these children study for? Teachers have always transmitted to the only available recipients the knowledge that otherwise would have disappeared with them. When intelligent beings can simply be replicated at zero cost and have no expiration, what are children even learning for?

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by amelius on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @06:24PM (#36219915)
They learn how to maximize their happiness.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by briHass on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @07:35PM (#36220605)
Because, at least for many, the desire to learn is hardwired and gives us an immense feeling of satisfaction and pleasure. I read/study/try many things that have no (or negative) material value and are done far better and more efficiently by someone else or by a mechanical/electronic device. Chess, for example, seems to still be pretty popular even though even the best grand masters can be easily trounced by a computer.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by wilg on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @07:40PM (#36220657)
In my opinion, you can view (nearly?) everything humans to as a desire to learn
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by BizarreByte on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @09:34PM (#36221657)
I have been around enough humans to know this is naive. There are so, so many humans who want nothing more than to laze around and indulge in vices while generally being completely useless.

You don't have to look very hard to find them and I really believe this world become the norm if people weren't required to work and thus got no real reward for their efforts.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by robocat on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @10:51PM (#36222282)
> who want nothing more than to laze around and indulge in vices

Or is that the effect of poor-stimulation environments?

Like the study that showed teenage drinking plummeted[1] in Iceland when teenagers were given stimulating activities to do instead.

Anecdotally, I mostly drink when I’m bored, and I don’t drink when I am doing interesting things.

[1] https://duckduckgo.com/?q=iceland+teenage+drinking+sports It was a variety of programs including a curfew for teenagers, but one leg of the programs was “Through the program, the municipalities funded and expanded after-school activities, from sports to gymnastics, to music, art, and ballet. The basic idea is to keep kids busy – and out of trouble – and help them find meaning in their lives that dissuades them from seeking alcohol or drugs in the first place.”. The nighttime curfew wouldn’t have prevented drinking during daytime or evenings, which reduced.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by bbor on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:27PM (#36221077)
> When intelligent beings can simply be replicated at zero cost and have no expiration, what are children even learning for?

This is probably the most depressing thing I've read all year. And it's been a rough year. I hope you just had a "brain-fart" as the kids say, but if not: I implore you to think of the purpose of your life, and what it would be without the need to work 40h/week to survive.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by esafak on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @03:33AM (#36223968)
And what it would be like to live in a society of uneducated people.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by GCA10 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @06:54PM (#36220222)
Amen on the value of imperfect tutors. I'd say that the best moments of early adolescence come when you dispute something with an adult -- and are able to establish they they're wrong and you're right.

Later on, we have to learn how to do this delicately enough that we don't make enemies. But the journey to adulthood takes a big step forward during those early rushes of realizing that we can see/recognize things that our elders cannot.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by Karrot_Kream on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @06:56PM (#36220236)
> Who trains these AI tutors and how do we prevent the system they're embedded in from churning out the same cookie cutter individuals, each with the exact same political beliefs and inability to comprehend the grey and nuanced?

I understand you're trying to dig into some idea of political homogenization and bias by pushing this point but I really think you're missing the forest for the trees.

I grew up in a low income area in the US and the standard of public education was abysmal. The teachers were overworked with huge class sizes and they spent so much time helping kids simply graduate that they had no time to help any student who was average or above. If you learned in a non-standard way, forget about it. Forget "cookie cutter individuals", half the time the teachers would show up and not actually teach (they'd put some music on and work on other things.) "perfect tutors"? In an era before digitized gradebooks, teachers could give you whatever scores they wished, no accountability. One big function of standardized testing is to push teachers to be accountable. Even the teachers that were trying their best just didn't have the time to do any more than the absolute basics.

I studied for SATs and AP exams by downloading textbooks from filesharing websites and studying those. Wikipedia filled in the gaps for non-STEM subjects. Nobody at my school could help me. At the time all the teachers and councilors knew is that I was going to be okay without any help from them, at least better than the other kids. I knew that nobody succeeded where I grew up and I needed to look outside to level myself up to succeed.

I can only see AI tutors as much better than the nothing that often is public education. The status quo is just overworked, ineffective teaching. Being able to bounce off questions from an AI tutor when it's late and you're up with homework and your parents either can't help or are hostile to your educational goals (the reality in a low income area) would go a long way. Of course the reality is that maybe AI tutors aren't actually coming and all we'll get are LLMs trained on the contents of school textbooks, but even that is a lot better than what we have now. The important problem will be making sure that everyone gets access to these AI tutors and not just the privileged in the elite schools who were going to be funneled into an elite college anyway.

Would it be best if we were able to shrink class sizes and have world-class teachers for children? Of course. Are countries going to be willing to pay the tax burden needed to make this happen? Probably not. In the meantime it's best for the poor kids to have the cookie-cutter, AI tutor while the wealthy have their own private tutors. It's not very different from the status quo today except the poor kids have nothing.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by tjpnz on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @09:26PM (#36221607)
If you live in a country which doesn't value giving everyone a good education to begin with, how will this be better? There will be few incentives to train new models, and when it does happen it might not be for the soundest of reasons (removal of references to LGBT on one side, or language deemed hateful by the other). Meanwhile the wealthy will have the option to opt out while continuing to get the best education for their children that money can buy.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by Karrot_Kream on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @12:53AM (#36222983)
It's not a matter of valuing a good education, it's a matter of making a limited education investment go further. I doubt the harms of whatever ideological tampering are so severe as to outweigh the sheer educational benefits a low income American and probably many middle income folks from developing nations.

It's not like individuals are free from their biases either. Humans can always learn more and change their beliefs, but without the basics of education they'll never get to a point where they can critically analyze the world around them.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by JohnFen on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @07:12PM (#36220395)
That was a deeply disturbing part. Especially "[...]with the machine version of infinite love."

It was very hard to keep reading after that maximal bit of creepy delusion.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by _-____-_ on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @07:29PM (#36220558)
I think it's much simpler than this. Either you're an autodidact or you're not. Children who are predisposed to teaching themselves stuff will now have more tools to help them learn what they want to learn.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by wil421 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @07:42PM (#36220680)
When I learned through Encyclopedias and later from CD-ROM based formats like Microsoft encarta or The Way Things Work there were actually people creating the chapters. Later Wikipedia came about and spun up its own flavor of community based information, however flawed, there’s still a person curating information.

Now there’s this AI who can spit out information with the hubris of Harvard professor. The language model has no idea if it’s correct or not and there no one curating answers. No one can explain how it came up with the answer but it’s correct in a lot of cases.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by _-____-_ on Wednesday June 07, 2023 @06:03PM (#36234253)
I don't think there's a big issue with an unreliable tutor; a Harvard professor can spit out incorrect information, too. It's up to the learner to cross-check and verify the information. If you're uncritically ingesting facts from some other intelligence (artificial or otherwise), you won't be learning much anyway. The best lessons come when you make connections between different bits of information, so if an unreliable tutor forces you to make more of those connections in the process of checking its work, so be it.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by quickthrower2 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @07:39PM (#36220642)
m3gan film is based on this idea
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by throwaway675309 on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @07:46PM (#36220721)
"The AI tutor will be by each child’s side every step of their development, helping them maximize their potential with the machine version of infinite love."

Somebody clearly took a lot from the scene in Terminator 2 with John Connor trying to teach Arnold how to do a high five.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by parentheses on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @07:52PM (#36220770)
Where will the hard knocks come from?

I don't necessarily like the idea of paying for AI to train my children to be AI dependent life long children who spent their whole life around benevolent AIs.

That said to move up the stack, the point is to paint a generally rosy picture. Not tell us that our kids will be raised by AI to be part of the futures uniform culture.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by JKCalhoun on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @07:55PM (#36220800)
First thought, oh, so he's been reading Neal Stephenson lately.
Re:Why AI Will Save the World by bko on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:04PM (#36220883)
Whats the alternative? A lot of kids are left behind in the current education system. It happens on both ends. Kids that don't get it just get pushed through the system. That's why you have schools with <20% reading proficiency and <50% math proficiency but >95% graduation rates [0]. Do you think an 10th grade English teacher is going to stop his class to teach kids how to read?

It happens on the upper end of course and smart kids end up building bombs because they're bored [1]

AI tutors would be a huge benefit and allow people to explore the topics they're interested. Maybe a kid isn't so interested in historical battles but is more interested in the clothing people wore at the time. Or someone else might be interested in something completely different. The breadth of LLMs is a real killer feature for creativity and exploration. I think this would result in the opposite of cookie cutter as the current system where 30 kids sit in a room and study the same thing produces cookie cutter individuals, albeit extremely poorly as many don't learn anything

[0] https://www.publicschoolreview.com/hoboken-high-school-profi...

[1] https://nextshark.com/steve-wozniak-fake-bomb-ahmed-mohamed

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by bbor on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @08:25PM (#36221050)
A) no one (sane) is recommending that we don't have teachers. I suppose you didn't grow up around those with wealth, who give their children massive advantages with focused, targeted, extensive 1:1 tutoring.

B) Who trains the human teachers? I don't think I need to cite any sources for the claim that many, many people in our society are already concerned about excessive uniformity and political brainwashing in our schools. I mean, just look to the nature of religious education in most of U.S. as a perfect example of completely AI-free objective brainwashing.

Re:Why AI Will Save the World by crazygringo on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @11:10PM (#36222401)
> how do we prevent the system they're embedded in from churning out the same cookie cutter individuals

Everybody's already so crazy different, both from genetics and from family influence, there's no need to worry. There's so much diversity in people.

> each with the exact same political beliefs and inability to comprehend the grey and nuanced?

Education (at least in the US and Europe) is usually about teaching critical thinking, not political indoctrination. Why do you think tutors would change this? (Teaching political science, for example, is very likely to reduce your strongly-held political beliefs and lead you to see things as much more gray and nuanced.)

> Do we even want perfect tutors at all?

There's no such thing as perfect. All it said was infinitely patient, infinitely knowledgeable, etc. Computers are already infinitely patient, and even just Wikipedia alone is getting qualitatively similar to inifinitely knowledgeable.