we get public domain in 70 years just like everything else, and i can't think of an argument for any game being more of a public good than works of other types like lolita, the search for animal chin, or paul's boutique.
I don't think Nintendo gets a cut of used game sales; †he first-sale doctrine should still apply.
Nitpick: video games are almost always a work-for-hire, so it's 95 years after publication (or 120 years after creation, in the unusual event that publication gets delayed long enough for this deadline to expire first).
You may already enjoy that creation by paying for it, just like you would for many other cultural items.
This is one of the most important purposes of emulation: it allows for digital archival of otherwise-obsolete hardware and software.
I thought I heard that this is actually a specific brand with chip defects.
Googling found: https://hackmd.io/d12Fq9g-QlCjN2HJp7Yvew
Its mostly the hynix flash chips.
Someone made a thing. They get to decide who they share it with. It's very smug and entitled to then go to that person and tell them "actually no. the thing you created.. its not yours anymore. It's now ours - and we're going to use it how we want to use it".
It's cool you like to play my game and you had fun - but that doesn't mean you suddenly have a right to play it whenever you want - unless we came to that agreement. I'm not a creator myself, but I could see how that just feels incredibly violating. I frankly feel this copyright-reform sentiments come from people that have never created anything that they felt personal ownership over.
I'd argue that copyright expiration is not at all about some imagined exchange of legal protections for .. the use of courts (since when is the use of courts treated as a privilege?) and is more about historical preservation and the fact that ownership is often eventually lost. Most copyright provisions are so long that by the time they expire there is noone left to feel robbed, slighted or taken advantage of. It's a fuzzy line but at some point graverobbing becomes archeology
That is the entirety of copyright in a nutshell, though. There comes a time when it really isn't entitlement to say "you don't get to control this work anymore", and that time has to come before copyright expiry in a practical sense, or there would be no works to enter the public domain, in a very real physical sense. Copyright owners are horrible stewards of their work, thousands of works have been lost due to gross mismanagement of archives (if the company even decides to give a shit about archiving anything).
Today's pirates are tomorrow's preservationists. Without the works that are being pirated, right now, they run the risk of being lost to time.
If used game sales actually resulted in money going to the copyright holders, I might have some more sympathy for that argument. But whether I pirate a copy of game X, or buy it from a secondhand seller, the original copyright holder sees zero of that money, and that's actually a good thing, and protects actual property rights, those of the person who buys a physical copy of a piece of media.
But I have a larger issue with the premise. So say I write a book - it seems to me you're saying I have a moral obligation for that book to be persevered for future generations to read. How about if I actively don't want that to happen? Should the cops come to my door and take it away?
Or if let one other person read it, now they inherit some right over my work to reread it?
I just don't find the whole anticopyright argument cohesive and coming from a clear moral premise
A lot of it kinda boils down to companies mismanage their IP and it's annoying. And the weird particulars of the medium of exchange. Okay, SNES/PS1 games came on cartridges/CDs, so you can physically introspect and extract the data... you feel entitles to circumvent whatever protections there are. In the future its likely games will be streamed and played in the cloud. You will never have physical access to the actual executed bits. Does that mean your rights as a user are different now? Or should you send the cops to seize the code on the servers at some point?
You're always free to not publish your work, and you'll never be compelled to publish your work. But at some point, you (or your heirs) will lose the right to use copyright law to prevent other people from publishing your work.
> Or if let one other person read it, now they inherit some right over my work to reread it?
Copyright only gives authors/owners a limited set of exclusive rights over their works, mostly concerning physical copies, derivative works and public performance: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/106 Copyright law is not about ideas or knowledge in your head. Reading a book is not an activity that copyright law is concerned with.
> In the future its likely games will be streamed and played in the cloud. You will never have physical access to the actual executed bits. Does that mean your rights as a user are different now?
Being a user isn't what gives you rights under copyright law. Being a legal owner of a copy of a game is what matters. If you only use a streaming service, you probably have never purchased a copy of the game. You may have purchased a license authorizing a hosting provider to run their copy of the game on your behalf (commercial software vendors like to use contract law to try to wield powers that copyright law doesn't grant them).
> Being a user isn't what gives you rights under copyright law. Being a legal owner of a copy of a game is what matters.
This is meaningless legal/semantic gymnastics. If that's your definition of "owning a legal copy" then companies will simply not sell you a "legal copy" and instead will give you an "indefinite lease" or some other jargon they make up. Or make you sign an EULA.
The fact that "legal copies" are distributed is 99% of the time not because companies want to allow you to copy their games - it's simply a practical limitation on the means of distribution. In the system you describe (which might correspond to the current reality) a cloud streamed game just inherently will always have more legal protection that a physically distributed game. There is no way to transmit a person executable bits without "loosing control" of them.
The big cloud providers would love this reality! The end result is that everyone is compelled, by market forces in effect, to shift their distribution to a jankier alternative because the physical medium doesn't allowed the same level of IP control.
So in the end your societal objectives are not achieved. It's in fact severely hampered.
- People get a worse products - everything turns to online streamed garbage
- People loose complete access at the whim of the company - when they decide to shut down their servers.
- The IP never ever reaches the public domain b/c it's never "distributed"
The game is eventually probably lost to time as some intern wipes the last copy from some backupdisk
You also create a weird universe where linear media that's streamed and can be captured (eg. a movie or a book) can be copied b/c you necessarily received "every bit" while something nonlinear like games can't - b/c you never get all the bits to "rerun" it locally. The whole setup is just nonsensical
Well, you're simply wrong on that score. The US Constitution empowers Congress to establish copyright laws thus:
> To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries
It's not about archeology, it's about promoting the development of new stuff. To that end, at some point it's better to free a work for others to build upon than to allow continued profiteering by the existing author/owner.
As would the legal recognition of format shifting in multiple jurisdictions around the world…
I bought it and the hardware stops working… I still have the legal right to do what I want with the data on that disk.
If I’m a legitimate customer and you sold not licensed me the software… fuck you Nintendo I have the right to emulate your hardware (which I also own thus providing a right to whatever software was sold on that device, so that angle isn’t a solid argument either.)
The only question that should be legally argued over is do the documented infringement cases of people recording themselves doing this on streams, have a legal defence for the allegations Nintendo could level at them. They are innocent until proven guilty by law and it would be more effort for Nintendo to bring charges…
So they took the morally reprehensible cheaper action of going after the legal emulator software rather to save themselves time and money attacking developers not in a position to fight back because while they are standing firmly in legal territory making the software, you would have to be very optimistic to think the arguments Nintendo could make with their expensive lawyers about “facilitating crime” wouldn’t be persuasive.
Yes, you can. You own the product, you may choose to stop selling it.
You also can’t mandate what formats a publisher makes their media available on.
"Stop selling it" isn't the same as making everybody "stop experiencing it". A publisher can choose to stop selling more copies, but they can't undo what they've already sold, and they have limited powers to control what people do with the copies they previously bought, and those powers have an expiration date—which may need to be moved closer to the present.
First of all, despite the legal handwaving around the topic, copyrights and related works are not property in and of themselves. They can manifest in physical property, but they are not property themselves. I reject the use of the term "intellectual property", as it is a complete misnomer.
Secondly, copyrights are not absolute. There are acts that the rightsholder would not want you to do, but that are still legal.
"Protected in any way possible"? Why should copyright holders with money get that benefit, but those without money are screwed?
Anybody who thought that was a good game is now looking for the second and third installments in the trilogy which Nintendo offically said they weren't going to develop (oops). So those are effectively only available on Dolphin/Wii.
Yeah, Nintendo got caught with their pants down (Metroid Prime sold way better than they expected) and are losing future sales for every person who pulls up Dolphin and the next two Metroids.
The Wii was the first console to use digital signatures; which would make it the first console to really invoke DMCA Section 1201 when prior consoles did not. Establishing out the gate that this tramples on 1201 could be extremely important in the future. Section 1201 is also what overrides Bleam and other prior emulator lawsuits - they didn’t have cryptographic keys protected by law flying around.
Because, how long until Yuzu is on the Steam store? And if Nintendo didn’t take action for the Wii (the first one protected under the title), defending against Yuzu is much harder.
> to “circumvent a technological measure” means to descramble a scrambled work, to decrypt an encrypted work, or otherwise to avoid, bypass, remove, deactivate, or impair a technological measure, without the authority of the copyright owner;
Nintendo has no standing.
“The "act" prohibition, set out in section 1201(a)(1), prohibits the act of circumventing a technological measure used by copyright owners to control access to their works ("access controls"). So, for example, this provision makes it unlawful to defeat the encryption system used on DVD movies. This ban on acts of circumvention applies even where the purpose for decrypting the movie would otherwise be legitimate. As a result, it is unlawful to make a digital copy ("rip") of a DVD you own for playback on your video iPod.
The "tools" prohibitions, set out in sections 1201(a)(2) and 1201(b), outlaw the manufacture, sale, distribution, or trafficking of tools and technologies that make circumvention possible. These provisions ban both technologies that defeat access controls, and also technologies that defeat use restrictions imposed by copyright owners, such as copy controls. These provisions prohibit the distribution of "DVD back-up" software, for example.
Section 1201 includes a number of exceptions for certain limited classes of activities, including security testing, reverse engineering of software, encryption research, and law enforcement. These exceptions have been extensively criticized as being too narrow to be of real use to the constituencies who they were intended to assist.“
https://www.eff.org/pages/unintended-consequences-seven-year...
If you want a further example, look into Apple v Psystar, where Psystar broke Apple’s DMCA 1201 locks to run macOS on unofficial hardware with “interoperability between hardware” being one of their many legal defenses. They were squashed in hearing after hearing and declared bankruptcy after having exhausted all legal options.
Strictly speaking, this is true. It is not unlawful to plug a DVD player into your iPod and play the DVD back digitally though. That's basically what Dolphin is doing - it runs unmodified disc images, copy protection and all. They've even abstained from using code or insights gained from the Wii's source code leak. The emulator should be clean, outside of any legal complaints about "damages".
You're correct to highlight that it's still an ambiguous area, but in a post-Bleem! world it's hard for Nintendo/Microsoft/Sony to find the legal willpower to stop these people. They'll settle for easy wins like harassing Valve's legal staff with scary looking letters instead.
> If you want a further example, look into Apple v Psystar
There's more recent precedent with Corellium. Their commercial product is allowed to create iOS VMs on unofficial hardware. Running their code is considered fair use, the most valid legal claim Apple had for shutting them down was their violation of icon and wallpaper trademarks.
If it can play disc images with copy protection, it de facto requires a way around that copy protection that is unlicensed, slamming it squarely into Section 1201.
> The emulator should be clean, outside of any legal complaints about "damages".
Dolphin contains Nintendo decryption keys; which is actually very likely illegal when the rest of the emulator is not. Recall 09 F9…
A competing emulator developer (for Citra) has also commented on this and said what Dolphin did there was legally dangerous and very much not endorsed by courts.
https://www.reddit.com/r/emulation/comments/13ss1o9/comment/...
> Their commercial product is allowed to create iOS VMs on unofficial hardware.
If you read the ruling, the fair use won because Corellium successfully argued there was no way that their product could impact Apple in any substantial negative way in the general market. They also argued that their products do not perform as substitutes to any products that Apple provides. And lastly, their products offer a unique benefit for a unique, niche, special interest, with vetting and similar procedures to ensure only people with those interests used their software.
If, however, they had done that to make their own smartphones, or a general iOS emulator for playing games on PC, they would have been annihilated. Nintendo easily has a case that emulation causes substantial financial and business harm; and that emulation can serve as a replacement for their products. Courts don’t like that.
> Dolphin contains Nintendo decryption keys
I don't believe it does. Wii U emulator CEMU requires them to boot, and Citra the 3DS emulator also requires them. The Wii seems to have no copy protection to speak of, besides it's rudimentary disk check/hashing routine. I'd love to be proven wrong on this, though.
> the fair use won because Corellium successfully argued there was no way that their product could impact Apple in any substantial way regarding security research
> Nintendo easily has a case that emulation causes substantial financial and business harm
So did Sony. Bleem even used screenshots of their official, licensed games to advertise their commercial alternative to owning a Playstation, and a judge deemed it lawful: https://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar_case?case=1183722407805...
From the ruling:
> The entire premise of comparative advertising is that the consumer is being made aware of the true choices. To the extent Bleem merely approximates what the PlayStation games look like, by generating screen shots through a process of degrading a computer image, it is simply creating a simulation. If Bleem insists on generating simulated approximations of Sony's games, there is no need for Bleem to use Sony's copyrighted material whatsoever.
The aes keys checked in to their GitHub are linked elsewhere in this comment section.
To me the private key is just a secret blend of bits to make the output bits look exactly the way you'd expect. If Nintendo can't keep their private keys private isn't that their problem? Why does someone else have the responsibility to keep Nintendo's key private if they discover it?
An emulator, meanwhile, only mimics hardware which is considered legal. An example: It is completely legal to implement the DVD specification; but brute-forcing the keys to decrypt DVDs because you don’t have a license is not.
The same applies to AACS, which protects Blu-ray Discs. It’s actually published publicly - you can just go download the spec for that copy protection right now. But getting a legal, unique device key will require contracts.
Stupid? Yes, but that’s where the law is drawn right now.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Computer_Entertainment,_I....
Decided in 2000, and the DMCA was signed into law in 1998?
Also, the last original Wii game was Just Dance 2020. Not joking, a Wii game was released 3 years ago.