News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by gjsman-1000 on Saturday May 27, 2023 @12:32AM (#36092082)
> It is not unlawful to plug a DVD player into your iPod and play the DVD back digitally though. That's basically what Dolphin is doing - it runs unmodified disc images, copy protection and all.

If it can play disc images with copy protection, it de facto requires a way around that copy protection that is unlicensed, slamming it squarely into Section 1201.

> The emulator should be clean, outside of any legal complaints about "damages".

Dolphin contains Nintendo decryption keys; which is actually very likely illegal when the rest of the emulator is not. Recall 09 F9…

A competing emulator developer (for Citra) has also commented on this and said what Dolphin did there was legally dangerous and very much not endorsed by courts.

https://www.reddit.com/r/emulation/comments/13ss1o9/comment/...

> Their commercial product is allowed to create iOS VMs on unofficial hardware.

If you read the ruling, the fair use won because Corellium successfully argued there was no way that their product could impact Apple in any substantial negative way in the general market. They also argued that their products do not perform as substitutes to any products that Apple provides. And lastly, their products offer a unique benefit for a unique, niche, special interest, with vetting and similar procedures to ensure only people with those interests used their software.

If, however, they had done that to make their own smartphones, or a general iOS emulator for playing games on PC, they would have been annihilated. Nintendo easily has a case that emulation causes substantial financial and business harm; and that emulation can serve as a replacement for their products. Courts don’t like that.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by smoldesu on Saturday May 27, 2023 @12:39AM (#36092114)
> If it can play disc images with copy protection

> Dolphin contains Nintendo decryption keys

I don't believe it does. Wii U emulator CEMU requires them to boot, and Citra the 3DS emulator also requires them. The Wii seems to have no copy protection to speak of, besides it's rudimentary disk check/hashing routine. I'd love to be proven wrong on this, though.

> the fair use won because Corellium successfully argued there was no way that their product could impact Apple in any substantial way regarding security research

> Nintendo easily has a case that emulation causes substantial financial and business harm

So did Sony. Bleem even used screenshots of their official, licensed games to advertise their commercial alternative to owning a Playstation, and a judge deemed it lawful: https://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar_case?case=1183722407805...

From the ruling:

> The entire premise of comparative advertising is that the consumer is being made aware of the true choices. To the extent Bleem merely approximates what the PlayStation games look like, by generating screen shots through a process of degrading a computer image, it is simply creating a simulation. If Bleem insists on generating simulated approximations of Sony's games, there is no need for Bleem to use Sony's copyrighted material whatsoever.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by monocasa on Saturday May 27, 2023 @02:59AM (#36092644)
> I don't believe it does.

The aes keys checked in to their GitHub are linked elsewhere in this comment section.

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by evandale on Saturday May 27, 2023 @09:03AM (#36094470)
I don't understand how private keys are any different from secret ingredients. You can't stop me from cracking the KFC recipe and if I successfully did it and published the recipe can KFC come after me? What if KFC was sloppy and dropped the recipe on the floor and I found it and published that?

To me the private key is just a secret blend of bits to make the output bits look exactly the way you'd expect. If Nintendo can't keep their private keys private isn't that their problem? Why does someone else have the responsibility to keep Nintendo's key private if they discover it?

Re:Dolphin on Steam Indefinitely Postponed Due to Nintendo DMCA by gjsman-1000 on Saturday May 27, 2023 @09:57AM (#36094876)
DMCA Section 1201 is your answer. Those keys are primarily used for circumventing “technological protection measures” on software. That’s not legal even for otherwise legal uses which is why the Section is morally awful. What you do could be completely legal otherwise, but if it involves circumventing these “TPMs” of which encryption keys are an important part of, you’re screwed.

An emulator, meanwhile, only mimics hardware which is considered legal. An example: It is completely legal to implement the DVD specification; but brute-forcing the keys to decrypt DVDs because you don’t have a license is not.

The same applies to AACS, which protects Blu-ray Discs. It’s actually published publicly - you can just go download the spec for that copy protection right now. But getting a legal, unique device key will require contracts.

Stupid? Yes, but that’s where the law is drawn right now.