News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by Y_Y on Sunday May 07, 2023 @10:30AM (#35851920)
The real question here is, why not Toyota? Their autonomous driving division is also a trash fire. Why don't traditional car companies seem to be able to manage "self-driving" projects?
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by bitL on Sunday May 07, 2023 @10:42AM (#35852027)
I believe it's because of the top-down approach to software development. The amount of waterfall in those projects is insane and individual developers are just small cogs in the org and their input is not regarded as important. In German companies one has to be at least a PhD (preferably Privatdozent) to be taken seriously even if their PhD is completely outdated and they never wrote a line of code in their life.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by tchalla on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:18AM (#35852345)
> I believe it's because of the top-down approach to software development. The amount of waterfall in those projects is insane

It's more about consensus driven decision making and waiting to make a decision until all information is present : risk avoidance behaviour. You mix these two and it's a great recipe for disaster.

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by nforgerit on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:39AM (#35852542)
I think it's both. And ignorance/arrogance to the problem being them and their management styles. They still don't understand why they're getting outsmarted by Big Tech and China's KP.

It would be funny if it wasn't so sad because of the economical downward spiral this attitude is causing.

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by germinalphrase on Sunday May 07, 2023 @10:35AM (#35851963)
Best as I can tell from reporting, this is not about self driving at all.

VW (which owns Cariad?) is unhappy with the pace and quality of the structural software being produced. Structural software impacts both operation of the vehicle as well as “infotainment”.

There seems to be a lot of chatter that the German automobile manufacturers are hardware focused to a fault and don’t understand the needs/limitations of software development. Maybe that’s just gossip though.

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by Y_Y on Sunday May 07, 2023 @10:46AM (#35852077)
The article states that the purpose of this new "structural software" was to enable level 4 autonomy in the future.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by detaro on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:17AM (#35852337)
That's mostly because you can't run a big automotive software project and not say that, not because it's in any way doing direct work towards that goal.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by detaro on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:15AM (#35852316)
Not just German ones...

Generally, for a long time they treated components with software the same as any other component: You buy it as a standalone thing from your suppliers, who make it according to your specifications, e.g. lots of the electronics would come from a "tier-1" like Bosch, who many cases farm out making of different parts to their suppliers, who then contract bits from subsubcontractors, ... and in the end everything gets plugged together. The car maker at the top of the pyramid is giving some goals/designs and tests if everything fits together and shouts down the chain if it doesn't. And for physical parts and contained software that does kind of work. It involves a lot of specification writing and -checking, but that's what mech eng orgs are good at. A simple digital instrument cluster isn't that different from an analogue one in that regard, in the end it is "hardware has to have this shape, fulfill this spec, display has to read the following CAN signals to show what's needed". Similarly for a navigation system or software on a engine control unit. Where exactly the lines between what was done in-house and what is contracted fell varied (e.g. some at least nominally controlled the software platform for e.g. the navigation/entertainment unit themselves, others bought that too from the Tier-1 and ordered design customization as needed), but in general the car company is mostly doing "managing" and coordination.

But this has a bunch of downsides:

If you don't have the expertise in-house, you are beholden to what your suppliers can or are willing to do. If they do bad work, you can shout at them (and car manufacturers are quite good at shouting at suppliers), but you can't fix or potentially not even properly evaluate it. Integration across subcontractor trees is difficult to make work well and leads to even more spec-writing and shifting blame if it doesn't go well. Since the tier-1 is probably also not a software company, the software expertise is somewhere deep down the contractor tree and not properly involved with the high-level decisions.

E.g. a common complaint is why the UI in cars is so sluggish: What do you expect if the people deciding about the hardware didn't have trustworthy input from people actually building the software and the software is a hodge-podge from multiple suppliers forced to work against interfaces one supplier made up without concern if its useful for the others... or even pass rudimentary common-sense tests.

It also gets way worse the more integrated things become. E.g. if you have a separate box for the navigation system (in some cars it's literally a box somewhere you can take out and replace if you get a map upgrade, which gets power and a screen connector from the car), there's little to no software integration needed. In a modern fancy-ish car, the expectation is obviously that this is all integrated in one UI, the navigation can appear in the instrument cluster, map updates should probably be online and not require bringing the car to a dealer, you want one central computer instead of multiple small ones, ...

So to stop all this falling apart, someone needs to own it. The Tier-1 could, but the manufacturers obviously don't want to give those more power, so they try to bring it in-house. But if you've never had a internal culture for software to grow this from, it is really hard to do that.

VW specifically said they'd do it by force, with plans to hire thousands of software people over a few years to build a totally new software division that would own the entire stack from scratch. It's going about as well as one would think something like that would go...

Other manufacturers who noticed this earlier and let it grow slowly are faring better. Some had more experimental "labs" divisions which were closer to the software world, whose expertise now can be used. Some have accepted they have to farm some of it out and e.g. adopt Android Automotive, even though the industry was very hesitant about that initially (because it gives Google all that juicy user data and ownership over the connectivity services the industry really would rather control itself).

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by konschubert on Sunday May 07, 2023 @12:32PM (#35853122)
> Structural software impacts both operation of the vehicle as well as “infotainment”.

From my limited insight, it seems that they are tightly coupling these two together: operational embedded code and the infotainment layer.

So they cannot roll out a UX update without also updating the embedded code that steers the vents.

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by tjoff on Sunday May 07, 2023 @10:33AM (#35851948)
Thus far waymo is the only company able to manage self-driving projects. Feels weird to single out traditional car companies.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by local_crmdgeon on Sunday May 07, 2023 @03:47PM (#35854949)
Cruise is arguably farther ahead, and is owned by GM. This seems to me more evidence that the EU sucks at software
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by pcurve on Sunday May 07, 2023 @10:43AM (#35852039)
Traditional car companies have always been terrible at softwAre development. It also doesn’t help that auto is a low margin business
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by fmajid on Sunday May 07, 2023 @07:41PM (#35856662)
Not that low, Stellantis' margins are 30% for instance.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by revelio on Sunday May 07, 2023 @10:49AM (#35852103)
It's not just the auto industry. A lot of industries struggle with managing software projects. If you think about it, it's the reason we have such a vaguely named thing as the "tech industry" to begin with. Tech firms are basically just normal firms that are good at managing software projects, and this skill is sufficiently rare/unique that it comes to define them.

As for why that is, well, you have to work in a non-tech company for a while to really see the problems. Suffice it to say that the gap between programmers and non-programmers in how they think and understand the process of developing software is enormous, and too large to bridge. You can't explain even things that would seem obvious and basic on this forum to non-tech people, because they just immediately reject it.

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by bitschubser_ on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:31AM (#35852461)
In a lot of "traditional" industries, because you "can't touch" or put it into inventory software is not seen as important "it is just there at the end". Furthermore there is a huge disconnect, because they don't understand software... everything "can later be fixed in software", the procurement department is incentivized to buy the cheapest hardware/chips they can get and you as a software developer are never asked if the requirements can be implemented on the hardware they procure leading to delays because you have to fit all the promised features into a shitty 5cent cheaper hardware and if it fails it's the software departments fault (looks like this is a bit the case in CARIAD when reading some german forums/articles).
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by 1-6 on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:11AM (#35852282)
The car industry reminds me of the construction industry. It's rife with decades-old institutions that are indifferent to quick changes in an ever software-dominated environment.

The thinking is, "if it ain't broken, then it ain't worth fixing." Unfortunately, recent advances by autonomous vehicle companies and EV makers have shifted the paradigm from a hardware-focus to a software one. I think construction is also headed the same path as stick-built buildings are increasingly on the way out and more modular preassembled manufacturing is coming in.

It's good news for software companies and bad news for traditional construction and traditional auto.

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by tspike on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:17AM (#35852335)
It's also bad news for product longevity, reliability and repairability.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by macintux on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:44AM (#35852601)
I'm hanging onto a 2005 Jeep Wrangler despite several mechanical issues I'd rather not deal with, because I have zero confidence that I can keep a modern car running for decades.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by SoftTalker on Sunday May 07, 2023 @12:06PM (#35852854)
Even 2005 sounds new to me. I drive cars from the 1980s.

I'd love to be able to buy a new car without any software. My phone does anything I would want to be able to do in a car. But it's not possible, due to a combination of regulations and what the mass market wants.

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by regularfry on Sunday May 07, 2023 @12:43PM (#35853215)
2006 Mazda here. The thing's bulletproof.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by ocimbote on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:44AM (#35852616)
Hopefully the shift is rather a pendulum and the auto industry will strike a reasonable balance between hardware and software.

Because really the reliability of software is much lesser than that of hardware (exceptions may apply).

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by version_five on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:01AM (#35852206)
I think an analogy is "enterprise software". You always get the worst software when it's designed and approved by a committee that doesn't get hard user feedback (feedback in the sense that people just won't use it if it's bad). So things are released with shit usability. Add on the cost overruns and scope problems that come from people that don't really know software dictating top down what they think it should do, and you get what happens in most industries.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by revelio on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:08AM (#35852263)
Yes, but they struggle with consumer software too (car software being consumer software, but also finance stuff is often terrible even when targeted as the mass market).
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by Dalewyn on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:01AM (#35852198)
>Suffice it to say that the gap between programmers and non-programmers in how they think and understand the process of developing software is enormous, and too large to bridge.

Programmers speak programming languages. Common men speak human languages.

Incidentally, this is also why "AI" became such a big hit with the masses in such a short period of time: For the first time ever, common men can communicate with computers using human languages instead of programming languages.

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by jq-r on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:25AM (#35852408)
> Programmers speak programming languages. Common men speak human languages.

Thats just a stereotype.

Lawyers speak legalese, managers speak managerial, electricians speak electrical, designers speak design languages, and politicians speak bullshit. And all of those languages can be employed/"translated" by "AI", there is no difference.

Or to put it another way, it all depends on the context. If you don't want to be understood by others you'll just come out as an asshole, and rightly so, whatever your profession.

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by hotpotamus on Sunday May 07, 2023 @12:33PM (#35853128)
If you aren't aware, the word "jargon" is the term for industry-specific language. It will organically evolve in any industry for a reason but it can be used intentionally or unintentionally to condescend to others outside that industry.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by ricardobeat on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:13AM (#35852297)
That is kind of tangential to software architecture, user interface and product development, the activities that define what the software will do. Speaking “human language” (aka user-centered design) is the utmost focus at this level.

Reducing such issues to “normal people can’t understand programmers” would be best left as a trope from the early 2000s.

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by ResearchCode on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:30AM (#35852447)
Common men are not communicating using AI, but AI is generating plausible-sounding corporate-speak faster and better than common men.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by Dalewyn on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:46AM (#35852632)
Let me put it this way then: "AI" allows common men to ask a computer questions using human languages, instead of using a string of esoteric keywords and symbols arranged in a way a computer understands (aka programming languages).

If you don't see or understand the true value behind that, well, I suppose you're a programmer.

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by ResearchCode on Sunday May 07, 2023 @12:29PM (#35853088)
I don't see any common men programming with AI. I see AI doing all the common man office jobs. It's great at generating emails, slide decks and spreadsheets.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by helge9210 on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:14AM (#35852313)
> For the first time ever, common men can communicate with computers using human languages instead of programming languages.

Was the same phrase used when compilers appeared? Or SQL?

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by VirusNewbie on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:00AM (#35852190)
Pay. The auto industry on a whole pays not just less than FAANGMULA, but also less than banking, telco, and consulting.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by jylam on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:14AM (#35852311)
No. The pay is mostly ok, the project management is shit. Basically in the automotive industry, you get important in your company when what you produce is a big part of the BOM of the car. Software is $0 in the BOM, so you are treated like shit.

Source: I've worked for the automotive industry for ~20 years, on and off.

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by yjftsjthsd-h on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:30AM (#35852455)
> Software is $0 in the BOM, so you are treated like shit.

So it's just bad accounting?

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by SoftTalker on Sunday May 07, 2023 @12:10PM (#35852904)
No. The marginal cost of the software in a car is zero. There is a development cost, sure -- just as there are other design costs. But in terms of what the company has to spend to build one more car, the software costs nothing, unlike the steel, wire, tires, glass, etc.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by ChuckNorris89 on Sunday May 07, 2023 @12:19PM (#35853004)
No, it's that SW is the component on the BOM that's the easiest to offshore so it's subject to the strictest race-to-the-bottom account engineering possible.

All these big auto companies like VW, GM, etc. used to do in terms of SW dev is write the spec and requirements and then contract out the dev work to the lowest bidder (Continental, Bosch, Valeo, Denso, etc.)

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by froh on Sunday May 07, 2023 @01:09PM (#35853448)
no, it's just unintuitive but also it makes sense.

first, the software is traditionally up-front cost, development cost, and as such it's not accounted for in the production cost aka BOM of an individual vehicle.

but even if you'd jump the accounting hoop of spreading the software costs to the vehicles it's neclegible compared to other cost factors.

VW group builds 10mio cars a year. the core ECUs board computers are shared across all models and makes. a major revision happens every 3-4 years. that's 30-40 mio units you spread the software creation costs to.

the major cost (as in 90% of that) is going to be silicon, PCB, housing, the physical part. and share of ECU costs in the overall vehicle costs likewise is in the low 2 digit percentage, should it even reach that.

the accounting makes sense.

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by MrVitaliy on Sunday May 07, 2023 @12:47PM (#35853262)
This makes sense how Tesla markets FSD in terms of traditional accounting. While not a part of official BOM, $15k for self driving is a big chunk of the final price for those who select it.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by Oddskar on Sunday May 07, 2023 @12:24PM (#35853048)
This is not the case in Europe from what I’ve heard. SW devs with the right domain knowledge in cars get very well compensated.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by VirusNewbie on Sunday May 07, 2023 @02:25PM (#35854128)
But still peanuts compared to American tech companies… so is the majority of talent going to stay in auto or go to big tech?
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by ChuckNorris89 on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:36PM (#35856277)
Then you heard wrong. I left European automotive SW because they paid peanuts. Sure, maybe there's some requirements engineers at Porsche or some niche freelance consultants in safety who makes bank, but everyone else makes peanuts. IC pay tops out at 80k per ear and that's in an expensive city like Stuttgart or Munich.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by Oddskar on Monday May 08, 2023 @02:56AM (#35858862)
I didn’t hear anything “wrong” at all. I know people personally which make a lot more than that. If you did R&D for 80k in a senior role you got robbed.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by ChuckNorris89 on Monday May 08, 2023 @05:22AM (#35859670)
Then can you please enlighten me which companies pay good?
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by nforgerit on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:35AM (#35852508)
Would their CEO be able to make a commit into the code base? If yes, you're fine. If they don't know what that is at all, you're screwed.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by tomp on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:42AM (#35852570)
"Geeks will figure out cars before car people figure out computers."

Heard this quote a very long time ago, it took a while before I fully believed it, but it just keeps coming more and more true.

Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by hef19898 on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:51AM (#35852701)
As shown by Tesla being the boggest car maker by now. Oh, wait...
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by fmajid on Sunday May 07, 2023 @07:38PM (#35856645)
By market cap it is, by a wide margin.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by hef19898 on Monday May 08, 2023 @02:08AM (#35858621)
Market cap is such a bad indicator for size. I don't know, maybe number of units sold might be better?
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by qwytw on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:45AM (#35852625)
Isn't Mercedes doing relatively well? Supposedly they'll be first to introduce a level 3 self driving system at some point this year.
Re:VW to fire top executives at software unit Cariad, source... by rad_gruchalski on Sunday May 07, 2023 @07:34PM (#35856622)
Not really, limited to selected parts of the Autobahn and the car will throw you under the proverbial bus 10 seconds before it would make a fatal mistake. It’s all just PR.