News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by theclansman on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @09:45AM (#35787318)
Just the fact that pornography is being taken seriously as something that's dangerous for minors is a good thing really.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by afavour on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @09:56AM (#35787457)
You’ll get some angry responses to this but I think it’s very worthwhile to say. Yes, ID verification in order to watch pornography is deeply Orwellian and terrifying (which is the aspect places like HN tend to focus on) but the bulk of the public support for these measures isn’t because people want government surveillance, it’s because they want to look out for children. Are they misguided? Perhaps. But you can’t win them over without addressing it. Shouting “it’s government overreach!” at those people will achieve nothing.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by ericmay on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:17AM (#35787802)
Just to be clear that:

> but the bulk of the public support for these measures isn’t because people want government surveillance

Does not mean the majority of the public supports those measures, though perhaps those who do support those measures do so because of reasons other than explicitly wanting the government to surveil them.

I don't think you are implying that the majority of the public supports those measures but I did want to make it clear that this was still an open question.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by xdennis on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:43AM (#35789333)
> it’s because they want to look out for children

The issue is that it's _their_ job to look out for their children.

We don't force all beds to have "walls", and give adults the keys to lower them if they show proof of age. Parents are supposed to buy _cribs_ for their children.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by BadThink6655321 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:25PM (#35790019)
Just recently a black child, who was born at home with jaundice, was taken from the parents to be given care in a hospital, because a doctor didn’t think the parents would provide effective treatment.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/temecia-rodney-mila-jackson-ret...

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by haldujai on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:23PM (#35792014)
It's unequivocal that the state has the right and obligation to intervene in cases of child neglect/abuse (which refusal or inability to provide necessary medical care is an example of) and is easily evidenced by the existence of agencies like the Child Protective Services or Children's Aid Society.

It is completely unnecessary to state the child's ethnicity to make this point which is entirely irrelevant to the argument you are attempting to make.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by nathan_compton on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:56AM (#35789555)
But if a parent neglects those responsibilities society is understood to have the right to intervene. In other words, the state has the responsibility to intervene on behalf of society for the well being of children. Given that responsibility, its pretty easy to suggest that the state has the power to make laws which may protect children over and above what individual parents might do.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by rootusrootus on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @07:02PM (#35795352)
I think most of us understand the line for gov't involvement to be much closer to the abuse end of the scale than the ate-too-much-candy end. We know empirically that gov't intervention itself has significant consequences that may completely outweigh the damage being done by whatever bad behavior they were trying to solve.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by wyldberry on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:12PM (#35791851)
It takes a village to raise children. While it is the parent's responsibility to raise a child, it's not unreasonable for them to ask government to make society conducive for raising and protecting the next generation. The incentives are mismatched. The organizations providing access to pornography have no incentive to limit access to their product without legal enforcement.

Hacker News is filled with technical people. However, think about all the workers who are not tech workers who have families. The burden of knowledge for these parents to setup home networks and devices that provide content filtering, monitoring, and alerting is way too high.

Access to pornography ends up being an economic negative externality caused by the increased access to the internet, and we haven't really figured out how to handle the cost.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Curvature5868 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:35PM (#35792193)
Should pornography be allowed to be displayed on billboards or in storefront windows? Is it the job of parents to cover their children's eyes as they stroll through town? As a society we have (mostly) set limits on where pornography can be accessed. Adult shops have a proprietor who can shoo kids out. Is the www different from public streets?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by bart_spoon on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @08:52PM (#35796341)
> The issue is that it's _their_ job to look out for their children.

Perhaps, but society seems to be increasingly creating hostile environments for parents and their children. Immediate and constant access to unlimited pornography is the tip of the iceberg. Social media has been shown to be highly toxic to young adults. Most digital content, be it social media, video games, etc is being explicitly designed to addict users, especially children. Education is crumbling. Food is loaded with artificial sweeteners and additives making them addictive and unhealthy. Local communities and support have decayed. And all the while the average income in comparison to inflation has cratered, making it more difficult for parents to actually spend time away from work to actually parent.

The ability of parents to raise healthy, well adjusted children has gotten much more difficult in recent decades, largely due the pursuit of profit over human well-being. You can disagree with individual laws, but you should not simply bury your head in the sand and respond to every attempt to help parents out with “just do your job and parent!”

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by berkes on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @09:51AM (#35787383)
But is pornography dangerous for minors? Has it been researched? What "dangers" are there? Do these apply to all age groups of "minors"?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:43AM (#35788237)
It's addictive for one. There are increasing number of support groups for men who are struggling with pornography use and for their spouses in dealing with having a dependant partner.

It creates a space for people to explore and normalise their distressing sexual interests without questioning the root causes.

Producers will often intentionally seek out vulnerable young women and groom them with promises of fame and riches, only for them to become reliant on painkillers and other drugs to cope with the reality of it.

It creates a market for the abuse of trafficking victims. Most sites don't require verification of consent and most users don't care.

It teaches men to objectify their partners and to see them as something to be shared. There is a huge market now for non consensual revenge pornography. Reddit has seen multiple subreddiys dedicated to non-consensual intimate media.

It provides a safe space for people to express racist, misogynistic and otherwise antisocial viewpoints.

PornHub in its front page today has videos of stimulated assaults and incest. For young viewers it gives them the idea that it's normal to be sexually interested in these things.

I'm not religious. I'm sex positive and believe in being open with children about the realities of life. Pornography stole years of my life, warped my views of relationships and prevented me from reflecting seriously on my own traumas.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by hvis on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:50AM (#35788359)
Sugar is addictive. And it might have more effect on your lifespan than the consumption of pornography. Quality of life, too.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:58AM (#35788492)
Yes it is, and that's why we teach our children about nutritional health and, in some places, regulate things like school dinners and products aimed at children.

What point are you making in relation to the topic at hand?

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by loeg on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:08AM (#35788661)
I can't read GP's mind, but sugar doesn't require ID verification to buy in the state of Utah, for example.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:12AM (#35788746)
No, but driving a car or possessing a gun does. Different solutions for different issues is hardly a contentious proposal.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by loeg on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:24AM (#35788985)
Earlier you were concerned about the possible risk of addiction. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35788237

Are cars or guns regulated because of addiction? No. So GP compared porn to sugar, which is considered addictive and has probably more concrete evidence of self-harm than porn. I think the comparison is apt? Certainly fairer than comparing porn to driving a car or gun possession, which is sort of absurd.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:35AM (#35789193)
Sure, addictiveness was one of the multiple points I made and we have prior cases of controlling for it.

For example: Utah doesn't allow minors to purchase alcohol because of its addictive nature.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by hvis on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @05:49PM (#35794697)
Most of your other points related to how pornography is produced, not to its consumption. Thus it wouldn't matter who is watching it, and thus ID check seems irrelevant.

Some of the aspects of the porn market are not great, but they should be investigated by the relevant authorities. Hiding them from only certain people won't make them go away.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by bumby on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:13AM (#35788772)
They might if sugar was able to be consumed for free with virtually unlimited access. I'm not sure it's a very good analogy.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by loeg on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:22AM (#35788938)
It more or less is? It's extremely inexpensive.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by bumby on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:42AM (#35789325)
Lottery tickets are extremely inexpensive. But what do you think would happen to consumption of lotto tickets if they went from $3 to free, especially in a frictionless environment where you can just download them?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by loeg on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:07PM (#35789752)
Lottery tickets are substantially more expensive than sugar. And if lotto tickets were free, (1) there would be no harm in consuming them and (2) you would also win $0, and no one would buy them.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by bumby on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:50PM (#35790461)
That’s kinda the point. With your analogy of sugar, there isn’t the same asymmetry of risk/reward as there is with “free” pornography.

The reward of lotto tickets is a function of cost with the current approach, but that’s the wrong point to get wrapped around the axle. Consider instead that if the lotto reward is funded by taxes. The point is the risk/reward profile gets skewed.

As an aside, I’m pretty sure you can find evidence that excessive gambling is a net negative.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:36AM (#35789202)
Extremely inexpensive is infinitely expensive when you're a 13 year old with 2 dollars to your name.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by loeg on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:11PM (#35789813)
It does not need to be literally the same thing to be a useful point of comparison, which is the nitpick argument bumby was making.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:46PM (#35790379)
I was replying to your own position of it being extremely inexpensive. I understand that comparisons and metaphors are never 1 to 1. If you have another point to make then I'll gladly hear it out.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by bumby on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:58PM (#35790632)
Not nitpicking, I’m just saying a weak analogy doesn’t strengthen your case. Equating sugar to porn misses some of the important aspects of what makes porn potentially dangerous.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by GoofballJones on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:25PM (#35790015)
It is free. It LITERALLY is in unlimited access. It's in everything you eat...unless you live in a cave and only eat squirrels and rabbits. Especially in the US where High Fructose Corn Syrup is in nearly every product that's consumed. Pornography is no where near as dangerous as the obesity epidemic in the United States, which costs the citizens and corporations billions and billions of dollars a year on healthcare alone. But sure, let's focus on porn.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by bumby on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:57PM (#35790612)
Nobody is claiming obesity isn’t a risk. But it’s an error to equate sugar to the obesity for one. Two, food is necessary to life but porn is not. That makes controlling food much much harder. Sugar is inexpensive (but still not free) and we’re experiencing the bad effects so I’m not sure what you’re pointing out other than as vices get more free and more accessible, the scale shifts towards worse outcomes. Your whole point boils down to whataboutism rather than debating the actual points.

Lastly, I’m not sure you made any case that pornography is relatively safe.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:58PM (#35790645)
We can tackle multiple issues at once. My country taxes sugar already.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by pnt12 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @04:45PM (#35793932)
And does Utah have a strong sex education curriculum, to teach children about it?

I assume no - it's just a ban on sinful behavior.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @04:50PM (#35794011)
Let's hope they are also exploring the avenues indeed.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by GalahiSimtam on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:32PM (#35791199)
Why do I see this fallacy all over anti-porn threads? Keto diets might be a fad and about as difficult as quitting porn, but still.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by bart_spoon on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @08:55PM (#35796359)
Sounds more like an argument for regulation targeting externalities surrounding sugar and artificial sweeteners than against regulation targeting pornography.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by laserlight on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:32PM (#35790141)
> It's addictive for one.

Citation needed. Porn addiction doesn't exist [0].

[0] https://www.psychologytoday.com/intl/basics/porn-addiction

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:44PM (#35790345)
It would fall under Compulsive Sexual Behaviour Disorder[0] in ICD-10. [1]

Pornography Addiction as a unique pathology is still not recognised but the issue is still young. We can see that it's an issue in that more than half of US divorce cases mention compulsive pornography usage. [2]

You can read more about Pornography Addiction and what I mean by that over at Wikipedia. [3]

You can see support groups for self-identifying addicts in places like Reddit. [4][5]

Furthermore, mutual support groups for partners of addicts. [6]

0: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsive_sexual_behaviour_...

1: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ICD-10

2: https://s3.amazonaws.com/thf_media/2010/pdf/ManningTST.pdf

3: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pornography_addiction

4: https://old.reddit.com/r/PornAddiction/

5: https://old.reddit.com/r/pornfree/

6: https://old.reddit.com/r/loveafterporn/

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by laserlight on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:55PM (#35790583)
Compulsive Sexual Behaviour Disorder is not an addiction. The Wikipedia article that you cited begins with the following sentence: “Pornography addiction is the popular but unscientific[5] application of an addiction model to the use of pornography.”

[5] Science Stopped Believing in Porn Addiction. You Should, Too. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/women-who-stray/2018...

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by haldujai on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:35PM (#35791255)
You're being a bit pedantic here.

Behavioral addictions are acknowledged in DSM-5 although this does not extend to compulsive sexual behavior at this time due to insufficient (yet growing) evidence to suggest similar neurophysiological mechanisms for a clinical textbook to label it as 'addiction' [0].

A recent review article breaks down the differences from gambling which is considered a behavioral addiction in DSM-5[1] and had not been in prior editions.

Whether or not CSB/hypersexuality is an 'addiction' in the medical sense is controversial amongst medical experts and essentially interchangeable with what a layperson considers to be an addiction and it is therefore very reasonable especially noting the overlap of salience, conflict and relapse[1].

Although there is insufficient evidence at this time to conclude either way whether diminished satisfaction has a similar mechanism to tolerance or lack of control has a similar mechanism to withdrawal there is also no strong evidence to support the argument that CSB is not an addiction and consequently they are currently treated as separate entities.

The pertinence of this is to not conflate conflicting/controversial expert opinion with generally regarded truth and therefore stating that parent is 'wrong'.

[0] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/add.13297

[1] https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2006/11/2/article-p166....

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:11PM (#35790848)
I'd love to stop believing in it but it's destroyed a large part of my life.

The issue with defining it as an addiction is more of a question of separating from other compulsive issues than not recognising the compulsive issues of the thing itself.

Yes, I understand there's a difference between compulsion and addiction but I'd expect the users of Hacker News to understand enough about how the dopamine system works to see the relationship between the two.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by laserlight on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:21PM (#35791021)
I'm sorry for your struggles. I hope that you are doing better.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:57PM (#35791616)
Thank you, I greatly appreciatie your well wishes and the human sentiment behind your remark. I'm glad to have places like this and people like yourself that challenge my beliefs, even when, or especially when, they are rooted in my personal experience.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by rootusrootus on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @07:10PM (#35795444)
> I'd love to stop believing in it but it's destroyed a large part of my life.

With all due respect, wouldn't it be more accurate to say that you destroyed a large part of your life? It seems like you're blaming porn, as if everyone who is exposed to it becomes addicted. Is it like heroin? Or is it more like alcohol, where many people consume it without becoming addicted, but a few people ruin their lives over it?

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by cmh89 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:39PM (#35797090)
>Is it like heroin? Or is it more like alcohol, where many people consume it without becoming addicted, but a few people ruin their lives over it?

It's more like a TV addiction or a video game addiction where the over consumption is a coping mechanism for other things that are wrong in your life.

Hence 'porn addiction' not really existing.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by sickofparadox on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:53PM (#35790536)
"It seems that POPU (Problematic Online Porn Usage) is not only one subtype of hypersexual disorder, but currently the most prevalent since it also frequently involves masturbation. Although this is difficult to accurately determine given the anonymity and accessibility factors that make pornography use today so pervasive, we can at least confirm that the patron of consumption for pornography has changed for roughly the last decade. ... As far as we know, a number of recent studies support this entity as an addiction with important clinical manifestations such as sexual dysfunction and psychosexual dissatisfaction. Most of the existing work is based off on similar research done on substance addicts, based on the hypothesis of online pornography as a ‘supranormal stimulus’ akin to an actual substance that, through continued consumption, can spark an addictive disorder. However, concepts like tolerance and abstinence are not yet clearly established enough to merit the labeling of addiction, and thus constitute a crucial part of future research. For the moment, a diagnostic entity encompassing out of control sexual behavior has been included in the ICD-11 due to its current clinical relevance, and it will surely be of use to address patients with these symptoms that ask clinicians for help."

Porn addiction has not been classified as an addiction in and of itself because researchers are unsure that it is its own addiction, or a subset of other sexual related addictions and disorders. So it is highly likely that porn is addictive, but medical professionals are hesitant to declare "porn addiction" as a diagnosis without seeing if it is separated from other problematic sexual behaviors.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6352245/

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by laserlight on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:15PM (#35790922)
Thanks for sharing this reference.

> researchers are unsure that it is its own addiction

Yes. Indeed, this is the reason experts object to the term “porn addiction”. Some “addicts” might be consuming a lot of porn, but that doesn't mean that porn is addictive --- just like how alcoholics use bottles a lot, but bottles are not addictive.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:21PM (#35791019)
Let's hope that public discourse will continue and draw attention to the need for further research.

I've been addicted to pornography myself and spoken with many men who say the same, as well as many women who have had their relationships and mental health destroyed by being partnered with people like myself.

The current state of research and recognition is not always reflective of reality. I'd hope that anyone familiar with the history of science could accept that.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by throwaway675309 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @07:19PM (#35795534)
The fact that you were addicted to pornography means that you probably would have sought out and encountered lots of other people in the same problematic situation as yourself. I would look to your own tunnel vision as to why you tend to see it's perceived negative effects everywhere.

I'll take peer reviewed research over anecdotal data any day of the week.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Georgelemental on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:06PM (#35790769)
I know someone who struggled with porn addiction. The person you replied to admitted to struggling with it. It's real, as an empirically observable fact.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by laserlight on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:20PM (#35791002)
A struggling person finding relief in porn doesn't mean that porn is addictive.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Georgelemental on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:28PM (#35791133)
The porn did not "relieve" anything, it was the source of the problem.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by laserlight on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:33PM (#35791219)
Thanks for sharing your anecdote. Because it hasn't been my experience, I prefer to take scientific studies as my guide.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by haldujai on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:53PM (#35792411)
What studies? The link you shared is a click-baity ("Science stopped believing in X and you should too") article by an individual clinical psychologist referencing (and overstating) the findings of a proposed etiological model and accompanying systematic review which suggested moral incongruity as one underlying cause, perhaps the key cause in these authors opinions[0].

Notably this study predated the addition of compulsive sexual behavior disorder to ICD-11 and was neither validated nor accepted as the correct model (hence excessive use of 'proposed' and 'preliminary'). You may also notice there are seven separate commentaries in response to this study with an eighth by the original authors in which they acknowledge the several limitations of their proposed model[1] and make the following statement:

"Rather than present an argument against CSBD, it is our intention and belief that our model of PPMI adds needed nuance to ensure the accurate use of the CSBD diagnosis."

[0] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10508-018-1248-x

[1] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10508-019-1406-9

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by cmh89 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:34PM (#35797054)
That's like saying 'sleeping too much is the source of depression'. Viewing too much porn is a result of a different problem. Happy and healthy people aren't accidentally becoming addicted to porn.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Georgelemental on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @03:21AM (#35799160)
Happy and healthy people don't usually become addicted to heroin either.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by cmh89 on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @10:16AM (#35802670)
Sure they do. There are literally thousands of stories of people who were in a car wreck, sports accident, or some kind of injury and then they get prescribed Oxy and when that runs out they are so addicted they end up getting black market pills and then when they can't afford that they move to heroin.

Opiates are insanely physically addictive and you can easily accidentally become addicted to them using them as prescribed, hence all the lawsuits.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by loeg on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @11:56AM (#35803943)
The conversation rate from pill addiction to heroin is order of magnitude 10%, even ignoring the logical leap made in saying people who get addicted to pills all have happy fulfilling lives. I think it’s substantially correct to say that happy and healthy people, by and large, don’t get addicted to heroin.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by cmh89 on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @05:54PM (#35808297)
>even ignoring the logical leap made in saying people who get addicted to pills all have happy fulfilling lives.

Well lucky for you, I didn't make that claim!

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by loeg on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @07:29PM (#35809243)
Either your comment wasn't responsive to Georgelemental's or you implicitly made some version of that claim.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by mdorazio on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:48PM (#35792348)
Do you have sources for any of these points, or are they all personal opinion?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @03:52PM (#35793193)
I chose these points specifically because I felt I could back them up with sources if pressed.

I began with personal opinion and then removed everything I felt wouldn't stand to scrutiny, even if I do still believe it.

I chose not to include sources immediately because that would have required a great deal of upfront effort on my behalf, which I wasn't willing to spend since this is also a place where I come to find relaxation as well as intellectual stimulation.

If there are any particular points you're interested in discussing I'll be glad to share the basis for my belief and go into discussion.

If it's all of them then that still goes but it may be a week before I get back to you.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by afavour on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:02AM (#35787531)
I suspect any academic study proposing to show pornography to minors is going to get shut down pretty quickly.

In my own anecdotal experience I’d say it definitely can be dangerous and depends on a variety of factors, a key one IMO being what kind of pornography we’re even talking about.

In my youth we discovered a friends dad nudie mag stash. Lots of glamour photography of topless women, some full nudity too but always pretty tame all things considered. I don’t think it had a negative effect on me. But the kind of porn available (and popular) on the internet is not that. From talking to a friends much younger brother I know they all have access to it and it’s led to some weird perceptions about what sex is, should be, etc. It’s rough, it’s often degrading, it’s almost exclusively focused on male satisfaction. It’s much more about one person’s power over another then snore any kind of intimacy.

The solution to all of this is, as always, parental and school sex education to ensure kids are learning the right things. But as a society we’re kind of terrified of that.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by ndsipa_pomu on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:39AM (#35788189)
Meanwhile, people used to (before the invention of chimneys) live in the same room as their family and it would have been common for parents to be having sex whilst their children were sleeping in the same room (or pretending to sleep). I wonder if modern pornography is a response to our society become more prudish and private.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by berkes on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:16AM (#35787793)
> I suspect any academic study proposing to show pornography to minors is going to get shut down pretty quickly.

I highly doubt this, because it's both important and relevant. 16y/o will consume pornography. I know I did, and I was 16 way before internet. Young adults will have had exposure before engaging in actual sex. This is important because it might be problematic. Because it changes behavior. But also because the right nudges, education and context probably make the difference between this growing into problematic behavior or healthy, normal, human behavior.

I know this is a difference between Europe and the US. Where the US (or any society under pressure of religious extremists, really) tries to simply forbid such research or knowledge. And hope (and pray) that by not knowing how this is shaping generations, it might simply go away. I'm pretty sure it won't just go away by praying hard and forbidding research. I'm pretty sure academics in this area know this very well too.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by nathan_compton on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:00PM (#35789617)
Any research which involved actually showing pornography to minors would almost certainly be shut down for ethical reasons. Studies would almost certainly have to be observational and post-facto, studying people who admit to having been exposed as minors.

Medical ethics practices in the U.S. are actually very advanced and restrictive. I cannot imagine an IRB ever approving showing minors pornography especially given that there is a reasonable expectation of harm and essentially no expectation of benefit.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by haldujai on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @03:14PM (#35792687)
You are completely correct with the minor edit that this study would never be shutdown as there is a 0% chance it ever gets approved.

Beyond how strict IRB/REB boards are in general, there are also additional federal requirements that must be satisfied when submitting a study proposal on children including surveys and not just interventions. In the US these are the pathways:

Section 404 requires that research poses no more than minimal risk. As the intervention itself is a federal crime this is not satisfied.

Section 405 allows for more than minimal risk if the anticipated benefit for the study subject justifies the risk. There is no individual benefit to the minor for watching pornography.

Section 406 requires that the risk is "commensurate with the subjects expected or actual psychological and social situations" which is hard to argue is expected when it is illegal to begin with. It also requires that the intervention is "likely to yield generalizable knowledge about the subjects’ disorder or condition which is of vital importance for the understanding or amelioration of the subjects’ disorder or condition", hard to argue that answering whether children viewing obscenity is addictive provides knowledge that is vitally important when there is no clear reason why children should be exposed to pornography.

If an IRB cannot satisfy sections 404-406 the only other way to get such a study approved is section 407 which requires direct approval from the Secretary of Health and Human Services if the "research presents a reasonable opportunity to understand, prevent, or alleviate a serious problem affecting children’s health or welfare, and, in addition, determines that the research will be conducted in accordance with sound ethical principles and that adequate provisions are made for soliciting the assent of children and permission of their parents or guardians". It is impossible that this would be satisfied as children NOT watching pornography (the alternative treatment/status quo) is hardly a problem let alone a serious one.

This has nothing to do with religious justifications but is due to very reasonable and heightened ethics requirements when conducting research on children, be it pornography or a new medication. Canada is essentially the same and I can't speak to Europe but I imagine most countries have similar requirements regarding to needing to demonstrate likely benefit to research subjects or contribute to understanding of a disease (which is nonexistent in paediatrics).

Every researcher thinks their question is relevant and important and that's why we have these rules in place.

https://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/regulations/...

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by zuminator on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:13AM (#35788761)
If the intention is to expose young people to porn and then measure longitudinally how they fare in life, ethical issues aside, I suspect that wouldn't work because your control group is very likely to become contaminated. And good luck getting the experiment underwritten.

Rather I think you'd take a large sample of adults at a given age range, interview them as to the earliest age they recall consuming pornography, and compare it with their life outcomes: income, alcohol addiction, educational achievement, etc. Of course you're only measuring a correlation, but at least you'll be able to get your study funded. And naturally such studies have been done, although I suspect many are agenda driven:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6571756/

https://wchh.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/tre.79...

(Many many more results in a casual web search)

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by htag on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:47AM (#35789406)
If you go the interview approach you'll run into many potential confounds. If the average age of first exposure is 13, and someone says they waited until 17, it's possible that a third variable delayed them from seeking porn and also will have an impact on other life incomes.

This is why random assignment is the gold standard. With a large enough sample size random assignment will account for all confounds. Here, we can only measure likely confounds and attempt to 'account for' them with statistics. All of these introduces more noise and generally reduces the validity of the study.

In general, I dismiss all scientific studies with these looking back questionnaires as little more than well documented hunches.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by babypuncher on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:37AM (#35789224)
Well the state of Utah defines pornography as anything showing a female nipple, so they don't really have any ground to stand on when it comes to defining what is or isn't "harmful".
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by hhjinks on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @09:57AM (#35787464)
I think it's perfectly fine to assume that pornography might warp a child's view of sex and intimacy. The solution shouldn't be to force people to identify themselves, though. Parents have all the tools they need to shield their children from pornhub, if they so wish.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by berkes on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:22AM (#35787891)
I agree that -without more knowledge- it's probably best to presume pornography might warp young peoples view of sex and intimacy.

But isn't that all the more reason to research this and educate people in this? So that adults can provide context and background? And to learn which kind of pornography is more dangerous than others in this? So that, with knowledge kids can be shielded from the stuff that's bad from them, and help understand the stuff that isn't?

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by degentracker12 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:55AM (#35789529)
Some of the world's oldest institutions have already researched this topic significantly and have worked together to compile and provide a common piece of literature that is widely available should you wish to embrace it.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by berkes on Friday May 05, 2023 @07:54AM (#35828086)
The same book that has clothing rules like "don't wear clothing of mixed material" or food safety guidelines like "it is forbidden to eat animals from the water which don't have fins"? A book that was written way before internet porn existed? Before science existed?

Such a book would help? Thanks, but I'll pass.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by bumby on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:18AM (#35788854)
I know HN tends toward the libertarian slant, but this same perspective can be applied to all kinds of ills that are regulated, from smoking to driving.

This falls into the common refrain about "what do we do with kids who don't have responsible parents?"

I'm not sure just letting the chips fall where they may when it comes to kids who got a shit roll of the dice when it comes to parents is a great societal solution.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by least on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:35PM (#35790205)
I'd say that I don't think children should be limited in opportunity due to the circumstances of their upbringing, but with those considerations in mind, protecting them from finding a way to access pornography is pretty low on that list of priorities, especially given that legislation like this will be wholly ineffective at accomplishing its purported goal and will needlessly burden the people who are legally trying to access pornography.

It's just not possible to address this issue without there being an intersection of how adults also access these adult things. A lot of other access controls in society are more reasonable than any proposal that people have come up with in this thread to restrict online pornography access to minors. This is why we place the burden on parents.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by bumby on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @05:33PM (#35794530)
I think it's perfectly reasonable to say the risk isn't sufficient to justify this kind of action. But how exactly are you measuring the risk in terms of the higher priority risks you mention?

I think the danger is people revert to their intuition about what is risky, rather than defining it by an objective measure.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by least on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @11:36AM (#35803690)
Higher priority risks are things that are easily measurable. A child that does not have food to eat or cannot access healthcare they need because their parents cannot afford it is very obviously bad for the child. Educational opportunities are another thing that's pretty easy to measure. Measuring the negative effects, if any, viewing pornography has on children isn't particularly easy to measure. I would say it's not ethically possible.

So ultimately, policy judgments with regards to increasing access controls are going to be dependent on intuition, one way or another, and individuals' political philosophies. I personally don't think there's any case where I think legislation like this is appropriate, though. If it were, it would be overwhelmingly obvious that it is. Clearly Utahan legislators think differently.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by bumby on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @06:06PM (#35808429)
So where do you think the current research on the negative effects of pornography get it wrong?

I’m always a little leery when someone says something like

”I personally don't think there's any case where I think legislation like this is appropriate”

It usually means either someone’s mind is closed to considering new information (I.e., they have a dogmatic position) or their mental model isn’t open to nuance (I.e., they have dichotomous thinking)

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by least on Saturday May 06, 2023 @02:54PM (#35844287)
> So where do you think the current research on the negative effects of pornography get it wrong?

This is a contentious issue. There's no consensus on whether or not use of pornography is harmful. Suppose there was consensus. To what degree is it harmful and is it harmful enough to legislate against it?

There's a very low chance that it'd pass that threshold for me, given that I generally prefer people be allowed to make choices over what they do with their body when it doesn't meaningfully harm others.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by bumby on Monday May 08, 2023 @11:19AM (#35862555)
>There's no consensus on whether or not use of pornography is harmful.

I think a lot of the lack of consensus is due to an unclear definition of what constitutes "pornography". This makes it easy for bad-faith actors to muddle the issue.

>given that I generally prefer people be allowed to make choices over what they do with their body when it doesn't meaningfully harm others.

I generally agree when it comes to adults, but the crux of this discussion is risk to children. Do you extend this same logic to minors? If your stance is that it's up to the parents, do you think there should be safeguards for kids with "bad" parents? If so, what would that look like to you?

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by ndriscoll on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:24AM (#35788991)
I'm not really a fan of the solution (something more along the lines of the v-chip where commercial sites in the US are required to identify their content categories in a standard way so browsers could be configured to block it seems like a better solution), and sites like pornhub are straightforward enough to include in blocking software, but currently sites like Reddit present a problem. Looking at recent dumps[0], it looks like ~40% of posts on Reddit are marked nsfw, but those posts are on the same domain as things like /r/teenagers and /r/roblox. Without a MITM proxy, parents can't really block the porn half of the site unless they block the whole thing.

[0] https://files.pushshift.io/reddit/submissions/

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by mind-blight on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:36AM (#35789215)
There's also the problem that lots is highly viewed NSFW content on Reddit isn't porn. Check out r/AskReddit. There are questions about how people feel about death that are marked NSFW for reasons I can't understand.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by ZekeSulastin on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:11PM (#35789799)
Reddit has an account setting to hide NSFW-marked content from your feed and search results, so people will mark “distressing” content NSFW as a crude opt-in.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by theclansman on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @09:57AM (#35787466)
I feel like in our society we're always beta testing everything before researching its effects, shouldn't we research the effects of internet pornography in kids before allowing them unlimited access to it? I think the same thing should be done with social media. There's obviously a thin line where you have to use common sense (where do we start and where do we stop?) but the consensus has always been that this is adult content just like violent movies and alcohol so it should be enforced in at least some way.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Eisenstein on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:15AM (#35787753)
> shouldn't we research the effects of internet pornography in kids before

How do you propose we do that ethically?

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by berkes on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:26AM (#35787958)
I'm no sociological, or psychological scholar, but I can imagine that simply by asking kids in high school questions, you'll learn plenty.

There are many researches done and still being done on how addictive drugs are, or on the negative (or positive) effects of drugs. Eventhough they are both illegal and often rather dangerous. You don't need to feed a healthy 15 year/old a daily near overdose of cocaïne to learn about the effects of cocaïne on a young persons' brains.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:33AM (#35788083)
You can interview people about their past experiences.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Eisenstein on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:39AM (#35788177)
You can't interview someone about something before that something exists though, which is what the parent comment is proposing.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:43AM (#35788252)
Yes, apologies, I realised that as soon as I said it.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Aachen on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:17AM (#35788842)
Internet pornography exists, last I checked (also when I first checked, but apparently that should have been illegal). What are you referring to?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by loeg on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:26AM (#35789026)
They are talking about this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35787466

> I feel like in our society we're always beta testing everything before researching its effects, shouldn't we research the effects of internet pornography in kids before allowing them unlimited access to it?

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by matt_s on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:24AM (#35788987)
I suspect the effects are mental/emotional and a research team may not be conducting statistical research like group A/group B types of studies but there could be value in research on current 18-25 year olds, their social/mental/emotional well being and gathering info on how early they may have consumed it, frequency, along with rates of clinical disorders. Surveys or research on college campuses would probably be the easiest method of gathering data for that age group.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by megous on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:44AM (#35789342)
Observational studies.

Problem with self selection (identify kids who decided to watch porn in the past, and compare with those that didn't) probably will not be that huge, when the people are only outraged about "kids" self selecting to watch porn.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by megous on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:50AM (#35789449)
> "shouldn't we research the effects of internet pornography in kids before allowing them unlimited access to it?"

Is that a rhethorical question? People of all ages capable of using it already have mostly unlimited access to the internet (and thus to porn). Sans parents understanding the internet more these days, and trying to set limits and failing.

Question should be whether somebody should do research before trying to limit access state/country wide in various ways. Ie. bigotry vs some informed decision making.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by BadThink6655321 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:30PM (#35790115)
Does the testimony of the adults who were negatively affected by it, both as adults and as children, count?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by intrasight on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:40AM (#35788193)
Pornography is that which harms the soul. That's true of all people not just minors.

The question then becomes what should be classified as pornography. Justice Stewart famously said "I know it when I see it". My definition is close: "pornography is that which harms my soul". That means that what is porn will differ for different people and probably by age as well.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by the_doctah on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:44AM (#35788261)
>Pornography is that which harms the soul.

I believe they were asking for research or something measurable, not platitudes.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by intrasight on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:57PM (#35790608)
My point being that it's not measurable, which is another reason for governments to not be involved.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by saberience on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:51AM (#35788364)
Porngraphy harms the soul? What exactly is the soul you're referring to? Something metaphysical? Do you have any science or data behind this assertion?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by DonHopkins on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:03AM (#35788562)
I think what he's trying to say without actually saying it is that pornography is something that makes your eternal soul go to hell if you view it.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by wkat4242 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:20AM (#35788913)
Then don't watch it. Let us have ours.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by intrasight on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:54PM (#35790555)
Which, in case it wasn't clear, is exactly what I'm saying. What harms my soul differs from what harms your soul. The government should not be in the business of preventing the harm to one soul.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by wkat4242 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:53PM (#35791551)
Ah ok sorry for my misunderstanding. In that case we are in agreement.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Aachen on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:27AM (#35789051)
With that reasoning you can also put witches in prison indefinitely for "harming your soul". Sounds like logic from ages past to me
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by mensetmanusman on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:22AM (#35787885)
Is is the wrong word. ‘Can be under a % of circumstances where the % may be too high for societies risk tolerance’ may be more applicable.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by mc32 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:04AM (#35787555)
Usually what happens in this environment is immature/ underage people are exploited. You don’t have to look far. The local track in your nearest city or megalopolises in India where adults sell off children, among other places in the world. In Mexico the local business guys go into the town plaza in the evenings and chat up young girls, in Japan you get “compensated dating”. These are all places where they let those of modest means take advantage of the underprivileged and underdeveloped and treat them as objects.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by berkes on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:10AM (#35787660)
You describe pornography depicting underage people. I'm sure there's consensus on why that is bad.

I was, however, questioning whether minors consuming pornography is (always, and/or provably) bad.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by mc32 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:35AM (#35788105)
Do you think there is or isn't deleterious effects when children watch misogyny at a young age, what about watching programming that would show the beating of animals, even if animated and just for "fun", or programming that shows being "fat" is undesirable and indulging in bulimia is desirable (what could be wrong with over-eating and then just vomiting excess, right?)

No, I think there are things young minds should be shielded from some things to avoid future mental developmental consequences.

You know how movie directors make a movie and in their mind a given movie is supposed to be propaganda against something, but for people lacking this cultivated framework it's a celebration of doing the wrong thing? Take a movie about how being a gangster is bad --but for many moviegoers it's an invitation to the "glamorous" life or power, respect and success...

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Aachen on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:24AM (#35788980)
You're making false equations

GP: is X actually harmful?

You: a specific subset of X is, as well as entirely unrelated topic Y, don't you think? Clearly this should be prohibited

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by funklute on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:06PM (#35789738)
> Do you think there is or isn't deleterious effects when children watch misogyny at a young age, what about watching programming that would show the beating of animals, even if animated and just for "fun", or programming that shows being "fat" is undesirable and indulging in bulimia is desirable (what could be wrong with over-eating and then just vomiting excess, right?)

I think he was asking (and rightly so) what the scientific evidence says, not what someone's opinion is.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by droopyEyelids on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @09:55AM (#35787430)
These are the type of questions that certain French postmodernist philosophers were asking around 1945.
[dead]
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by tnel77 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @09:58AM (#35787473)
This is definitely the thought provoking commentary I look for on Hacker News.

Either make an intelligent argument or hush.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by 0zemp2c on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:13AM (#35787723)
> What "dangers" are there?

turning in to a pathetic, obese lech who sits at home alone blowing another paycheck on Onlyfans, clinging to the misguided notion that women want anal on the first date?

and even worse, when real life doesn't line up with six-minute videos, the even worse outcome of woman-hating manifests

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by berkes on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:28AM (#35787988)
Isn't that all the more reason to educate, research and invest in this? Rather than forbidding it?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by eldritch_4ier on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:47AM (#35788310)
It’s probably about as dangerous to minors as sitting the minor in a room while 2 consenting adults have sex, or taking that minor to a strip club. Does the screen itself prevent trauma? Would you be ok with having your child exposed to either of these?

What about a gentle and loving uncle molesting a child in a way not much different from playful wrestling? Wrestling is fine, but we all recognize the molestation is incredibly harmful, even in this situation (because the harm isn’t the violence of it, it’s the actual sex itself).

This is just common sense. Of course sexualizing (sexually activating) children (which porn does) at a young age is harmful. It’s probably very harmful to adults too in large doses like porn addiction.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by newswasboring on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:04AM (#35788582)
> It’s probably about as dangerous to minors as sitting the minor in a room while 2 consenting adults have sex, or taking that minor to a strip club.

I think you have not seen the average porn online these days. Its way, way more extreme than this.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by vxNsr on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:33AM (#35789150)
More likely they have not had sex or been to a strip club.

Whenever I see people argue that porn is just like sex they always turn out to be minors or young adults who have only ever experienced porn and not intimate relationships.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by newswasboring on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:45PM (#35791419)
That feels like a cruel assumption to make. But I think that says more about me than them.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by vxNsr on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @03:06PM (#35792577)
I don’t think it’s cruel. There’s nothing wrong with not having certain life experiences. I think it’s wrong to make assertions without knowing all the facts which is what these types of people do all the time. (See /r/relationships for many examples).
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by filoleg on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:46PM (#35792315)
That's a solid hypothesis.

After being to strip clubs just twice in my life, and with both of those being very different experiences, I have to agree with you. Comparing it to porn (let alone an actual intimate relationship) is like comparing watching fast & furious movies to average driving experiences. While F&F movies are technically more wild, the real life experience of actual driving (even if it is technically waaay more mild than in the movies) is way more stressful/impactful/etc, to the point where even making the comparison feels ridiculous.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Kye on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:25AM (#35788996)
The last time I tried to watch porn aimed at straight people, it seemed like rape simulation. It's no wonder so many people are averse to butt stuff if that's the impression they're getting. And worse, if that's what tops are doing because they learned from porn.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Aachen on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:21AM (#35788932)
GP was asking precisely because it is not common sense.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by mind-blight on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:30AM (#35789097)
It does appear to be a bit more dangerous for minors than for adults. The main issue is that your brain is much more plastic around your teenage years and is more susceptible to building long-term habits.

That manifested in unexpected ways for men recovering from porn-induced ED. The older men - those who hadn't grown up with high-speed internet porn - recovered significantly faster than the younger men.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by jliptzin on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:35AM (#35789181)
I don’t know how one would go about doing that research. Anecdotally I figured out the parental lock code on a cable box when I was 12, watched one of the porn channels, I was more excited that I was able to guess the code than anything else. The porn itself didn’t really have any impact on me.

My school also showed us Holocaust documentary footage around the same age. People getting shot in the head, piles and piles of dead bodies, etc. That plus gory movies like Hostel and scenes where people are chopped up and stuffed into a suitcase fucked me up WAY more than any of the porn I happened to come across at that age.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by megous on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:26PM (#35790041)
Not all porn is just people sticking their penis into someone else's vagina. It can get pretty disturbing. And disturbing porn is not that harder to find as the non-disturbing one. Now it's the age of anyone being able to upload almost anything for anyone to easily see. And people do.

(Anyway, I'm not for the internet wide parental lock. Just noting that things are different than in the past, with ease and breadth of access.)

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by berkes on Friday May 05, 2023 @08:06AM (#35828188)
But isn't the lack of destination a part of the problem, or maybe the whole problem?

It has been proven, scientifically, that making a distinction between soft- and harddrugs help in fighting drug abuse, death and misery. It's, for example, what the Dutch policy is based on.

By making a clear distinction, and decriminalizing it, you can educate people on it. You can say "this is very bad, that is dangerous and that there is merely unhealthy".

I'm sure a lesson can be drawn tlfor porn there too. By criminalizing, or forbidding it all, blanket, you loose all opportunity to teach about what is normal and what isn't. You just get one big pile, where disturbing and terrible stuff is just as (in) accessible as the stuff that's fun, pleasant or even educational.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by ufmace on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:02PM (#35789665)
It seems likely to be, particularly in the forms available today. There seems to be increasing consciousness on this both on the left and the right.

The Left has been increasingly concerned about the abusive acts becoming common in pornography and the seemingly pervasive use of underage or barely-of-age women with consent extremely sketchy or not present at all.

The Right has been increasingly concerned about how the pervasive presence of pornography encourages people to focus on that for their needs rather than pursuing real-life relationships and obsess over extreme acts that very few real partners are actually willing to do.

This is all exacerbated by internet startup tendencies, where maximizing "engagement" at all costs is the priority. It's in their incentives to maximize most of the bad effects that everyone is concerned about.

It's not clear exactly how bad everything is or that this particular thing is the right way to address it. But clearly enough people are concerned about it and aren't willing to accept endless delaying tactics around insisting that you can't do any particular thing about it because it can't be proved to be perfect.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by mustacheemperor on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:12PM (#35789830)
It’s noteworthy to me that in your replies not one single comment links to any research. Multiple comments state point after point as fact with no sources, one comment directly ascribes its entire opinion to an anecdote.

In short…I’m not getting the kind of perspective expanding value I often find on HN from this discussion. Just a lot of back and forth from people exchanging the opinions they already had before opening the parent article.

I would instinctively agree that it's unhealthy for minors to have unchecked access to pornography but on the other hand I don't see how we could effectively address that problem societally without any kind of objective understanding of it. Has the exchange of unqualified personal opinions ever resulted in effective political policy, especially policy meant to manage a vice? That didn't work well for Prohibition or the War on Drugs.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by dopamean on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:26PM (#35790039)
People rarely link to research on this site or any other. It's a social network. People want to share their opinion and so they do. I cant remember the last reply to a comment I saw on here that actually linked to research.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by mustacheemperor on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:39PM (#35790267)
That's generally true, but one common practice that originally drew me to HN was the frequent use of [#] citations by commenters to support their remarks with external sources. So in replies to a user specifically asking about research and evidence for these risks, it's disappointing for me to not see any research or evidence.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Aerbil313 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @03:36PM (#35792971)
All online pornography is scientifically demonstrated to be harmful to people of all ages. See the research: https://www.yourbrainonporn.com/
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by ActorNightly on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @09:58AM (#35787484)
Except despite the vast amounts of counter-evidence, people still are somehow dumb enough to think that hiding stuff from kids works (drugs, guns, porn, e.t.c).

Porn is absolutely fine for kids to watch as long as the parents properly contextualize it. The issue is that somehow societally accepted that its taboo to talk to your kid about sex at an early age, and plenty of otherwise normal parents are embarrassed to do it.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:27AM (#35787975)
You're equating porn with sexuality. I'm a grown man and I find most of what's on the front page of PornHub to be deeply disturbing. I wee racism, misogyny, incest, even simulated assault.

In a world where sexual assault is so common I think we need to seriously reconsider what we're consuming and what we're normalising by calling this stuff harmless.

And I don't get what you're suggesting in saying hiding stuff doesn't work. Like, I like to enjoy a bit of LSD sometimes but I definitely keep that out of reach of children.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by ActorNightly on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:48AM (#35788325)
You are totally right. While we are at it, lets ban video games because they obviously cause school shootings.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:55AM (#35788424)
That's a strawman no? You're trying to colour my argument by associating it with another one.

There are some notable differences though. If I play a violent video game then no one is actually being shot.

If I watch a woman being choked and ejaculated on by 20 men calling her a worthless slut whore in a porno then I'm watching that genuinely happening.

It's more akin to letting children watch videos from actual warzones. Even as an adult I find beheading videos to be disturbing.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by ActorNightly on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:16AM (#35788819)
Except that you skip over the whole "Media contains certain content -> viewing this content leads to bad behaviour -> said media should be banned" argument as being valid, which is not. You have to demonstrate the causal link between the first two.

Also, your subsequent argument is flawed. For the vast majority of popular porn, an actress in a scene where she is "abused" is doing so consensually. Part of having healthy romantic relationships in life is being able to navigate the aspect of consent. For example, a girl may have different standards for sexual intercourse when it comes to having a one night stand, where she may engage in kink or a fetish, versus a long term relationship where she may not want to do that. If you are unable to contextualize this, this means that your parents did a poor job of educating you about sexuality, which further reinforces my argument.

This absolutely does not equate to ISIS beheading videos, where the people being beheaded are most likely not consenting to it.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:31AM (#35789109)
I'm skipping over it because there are inherent differences in different types of media. Sexuality is wired in the mammalian brain in a unique way. We can generalise so easily as you're suggesting.

If I see an actress in a movie being shot, she's not actually being shot. If I see an actress in a porn movie being choked, she's actually being choked. That's not a question of consent, it's a question of content.

But on that note, have you ever worked a shitty or degrading job and had to do things you found painful because you couldn't afford to say no? I have. It's painful to go through. I can't imagine coupling that with the complex layers of human sexuality.

You're saying it doesn't equate because of consent but that's not the aspect I was equating.

Take a look at the front page of PornHub now. There's a video on there showing a man flashing strangers. Yes, they must be actors, but it's filmed in a way that suggests they're not. There's absolutely nothing there that would promote the idea of consent in the mind of a young viewer.

Yes, maybe parents could watch those videos and explain that it's normal to fantasise and play-act about assault. But I'd hope that at the same time we, as adults, would speak with qualified therapists and try to ascertain the roots of our attraction to forcing our genitals onto unsuspecting women.

Final point: PornHub has only required verification from uploaders since relatively recently, after dozens of women took them to court for hosting their rape videos and after it was widely publicised that there was a good deal of underage rape videos on there. There are still other popular sites such as chatpic.org or videos that happily allow abuse content to circulate without any concern for consent. That's only what's on the open web.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by int_19h on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @04:20PM (#35793568)
So, would you be okay with the same kind of porn if it was all 100% simulated (but realistically enough to be indistinguishable from real stuff)?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @05:01PM (#35794146)
That's an interesting point and thank you for raising it.

Indeed I would not.

I think it does come down to a moral issue then, which is related both to the core messages communicated and to the audience.

In terms of violent media I can think of 3 ways of categorising it: A) media with a moral message abut the use of violence (self defence, save the innocent) B) purely whimsical (something like Doom) and C) explicitly brutal material.

Of those three only the first two have popular reach. It's easy for children to understand and it provides a structure for parents to use to educate their youngsters.

When I compare that to pornography I feel that the stuff that would fall into category C is what the norm is, what's popular on the major channels. Therfore it takes on a difference socially for me.

We need way way better education on what healthy sex looks like and why respect for women is important. But I honestly believe that we've passed a sort of critical point and do therefore support the introduction of age based restrictions.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by salawat on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @07:33PM (#35795696)
Explicitly brutal material does have one educative characteristic.

It educates one on the depths of human depravity. It is good to ensure the little ones eventually become aware of the shit we have to deal with. Hiding it helps no one.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @01:52AM (#35798505)
Eventually? At what point do you start showing your kids extreme brutality videos to help their education?

Do you hide it for their first few years or do you begin as soon as they can grasp the content of the videos?

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Aachen on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:37AM (#35789228)
Then we should also ban any material that contains violence until there are no more homicides.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:41AM (#35789302)
Well it depends what you mean by "contains violence."

There's a world of difference between stimulated violence in a Mortal Kombat movie and a video of Taliban members playing football with a human head.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:53AM (#35789496)
To respond to your edit here are some general statistics about sexual assault in the US: https://legaljobs.io/blog/sexual-assault-statistics/

In terms of increase with the availability of pornography, take a look at this chart: https://www.statista.com/statistics/191137/reported-forcible...

You can see that the number of rape reports have almost doubled since the invention of web pornography.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Aachen on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:24PM (#35790001)
Not sure why this got a downvote. I was going to say that this shows only reports without estimating the proportion of unreported rape over time (I tried for the last ~10 minutes to find it myself but no dice), but it's a constructive comment.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:54PM (#35790547)
It got a downvote because I was speaking against pornography in a heavily male and internet dependant environment.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by anigbrowl on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:44PM (#35791413)
I didn't vote either way, but your argument assumes causality without considering other factors (like lower social stigma for reporting rape and higher social expectations of police responsiveness). In general, it's much easier to repot rape and sexual assault and have the report taken seriously than it was 10, 20 or more years ago.

I think you should consider the possibility that your argument was deficient instead of making assumptions based on tropes. Communities are not monolithic and HN is less monolithic than most. For example, I differ strongly from you in not believing in censorship in the name of protecting youth, but I also differ from a lot of people here in saying that tech companies have massively failed to deal with the distribution of CSAM.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @05:03PM (#35794172)
Yes I agree with what you're saying and thank you for calling it out. It's just that I've had many similar discussions to this in many different environments and it's easy to become jaded.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by mdorazio on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:55PM (#35792430)
> You can see that the number of rape reports have almost doubled since the invention of web pornography.

This is the worst case of cherry picking data I've seen in a long time. First, if your supposition is true then why would the number have dropped with the rise of internet pornography from the late 90s all the way through 2012? Second, what's the per-capita rate instead of absolute number? Third, what other confounding factors are there (did the reporting method stay the same)? This chart tells me nothing except that something weird happened after 2012 and that's it.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by fzeroracer on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @04:04PM (#35793343)
This is one of the worst possible arguments I've seen on HN. I'm not going to address the morality issue at stake here, but you've fallen into one of the most common traps when it comes to trying to compare rates of reports over a period of time which is that population also grows. From 1990 to 2020 the US population grew from 250 million to 330 million. Additionally, as the chart you pointed out the FBI changed its definition of what constitutes rape in 2013, hence the rise in reported rape from that year onwards.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by laserlight on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:39PM (#35790260)
> In a world where sexual assault is so common I think we need to seriously reconsider what we're consuming and what we're normalising by calling this stuff harmless.

There's evidence that porn reduces the rate of sexual assaults [0].

[0] Evidence Mounts: More Porn, Less Sexual Assault. https://www.psychologytoday.com/intl/blog/all-about-sex/2016...

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:53PM (#35790535)
Your article claims that rape levels have deceased with the expansion of internet pornography but that's statistically untrue, as they've almost doubled: https://www.statista.com/statistics/191137/reported-forcible...
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by laserlight on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:02PM (#35790699)
Yeah, just like how US spending on science, space, and tech increased suicides by hanging, strangulation, and suffocation [0]. The article I cited talks about natural experiments, which examine what happens before and after porn was legalized.

[0] Spurious Correlations. https://www.tylervigen.com/spurious-correlations

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:15PM (#35790924)
I understand that correlation is not causation but the claims in the article you linked me to rely on correlative factors that are demonstrably false.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by DougN7 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:37AM (#35788145)
Porn is very addictive to many people (Reddit has some great posts by many people trying to break free) - anything that gives you a huge dose of dopamine for little effort can be dangerous to someone’s life (not medically dangerous, but certainly emotionally and motivationally). It’s like saying drugs are absolutely fine because they don’t destroy everyone that take them. Or maybe alcohol is a better comparison.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by ActorNightly on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:45AM (#35788275)
Porn is very addictive because the person has no idea how to form real life relationships and engage in real sex in a healthy way.

In the same way video games are very addictive because it gives you a sense of accomplishment when you have no mental tools to go out and improve your situation in life.

In the same way weed is addictive when you have no mental tools to face hardships in your life and you would rather escape into a care free state of mind.

Nothing to do with the things at hand, everything to do with mental conditioning from an early age, a.k.a upbringing, a.k.a parenting.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by DougN7 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:38AM (#35789250)
That sounds like everything to do with the thing at hand to me. We wish everyone had the awesome perfect parents. That’s never going to happen. And even kids with great parents fall into the traps you mentioned above. All the things above are dangerous to people’s lives for the reasons you mentioned, and more reasons you didn’t mention.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:04AM (#35788580)
Do you think children should be able to purchase cannabis products at dispensaries?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by loeg on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:13AM (#35788785)
As opposed to from some guy at their school, black market?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:33AM (#35789154)
Of course there's a black market for anything but controlling distribution definitely does help.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by wkat4242 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:38AM (#35789245)
Doesn't real sex provide similar dopamine release? If so, what's so bad about it when real sex is not available at the time?

I'm sure some people get addicted but people with talent for it can get addicted to pretty much anything

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Myrmornis on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:08AM (#35787631)
What age would you suggest having these conversations so that the kids' porn-viewing sessions can commence?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by ActorNightly on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:24AM (#35787917)
As early as 4. Not jumping straight to porn, but starting sex ed.

It works very well in Netherlands, where teens end up having much healthier relationships, fewer sexual partners, and less unwanted pregnancies.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by sh4rks on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:34AM (#35788089)
In what world is sex-Ed comparable to hardcore pornography?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by ActorNightly on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:37AM (#35788151)
Who said anything about hardcore pornography?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by sh4rks on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:22PM (#35789970)
> who said anything about hardcore pornography

Well the main article is about PornHub which is a hardcore pornography site, so...

I have no problem with sex-Ed for kids

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by mariusor on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:45AM (#35788281)
I think in a world in which teenagers have a realistic/healthy view on their sexuality and human sexuality in general is a world in which they are capable of inferring that what can be seen in porn is unrealistic, most of the time demeaning, and not something to be idealised.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by wkat4242 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:34AM (#35789165)
Sex ed provides context to pornography. It doesn't compare but it sets a baseline as to what's normal and what's fiction.

I'm sure none of my school peers thought bukkake sessions were actually normal behavior even though they would have been aware of them.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Eisenstein on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:16AM (#35787783)
Puberty age sounds logical.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by 0zemp2c on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:18AM (#35787814)
> Porn is absolutely fine for kids to watch as long as the parents properly contextualize it

seek help

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by ActorNightly on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:25AM (#35787938)
This isn't the place to preach about your religious "purity" dogma.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:28AM (#35787990)
What did they say about either religion or purity?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by ActorNightly on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:37AM (#35788141)
Anti porn or anti sex sentiment is rooted in religion. Even if the person isn't practicing religion, him or her holding these views are indicative of some religious upbringing with the standard amount of brainwashing.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:50AM (#35788344)
And what's your basis for that belief?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by ActorNightly on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:55AM (#35788423)
Where else would someone gain this sentiment?

Certainly not rational thinking, people aren't discussing specific psychological research at mass. The instant ad hominem attack instead of rational discussion is highly indicative of ideological underpinning.

United States certainly and unfortunately has a strong religious background. Quite a few remnants of it are in peoples minds without it realizing it. For example, lot of people would consider it rude not to say "Bless you" when someone sneezes, which is 100% religious origin.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:01AM (#35788540)
There are many non-religious arguments being made in this very thread, some of which can be backed up by science and others which can be supported by evidence.

You're accusing them of lacking rational thinking and leaping to personal attacks while doing the same.

Many of the users of this site are not from the US and many live in some of the world's most secular societies.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by dennis_jeeves1 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:52AM (#35789488)
I have even wondered why it's that big a deal for many people. I guess idle minds have nothing better to do other than think about solely sex, porn, food or drugs. And the only way they can prevent themselves from overindulging in these things is to have an external authority figure like the government impose strict restrictions on them.

Personal observation: most people just do fine if they are exposed to porn as kids. In fact they are more well-rounded, and intellectually mature compared to their peers who were never exposed to those things early on, just like all other topics.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by yamtaddle on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @03:47PM (#35793122)
> Except despite the vast amounts of counter-evidence, people still are somehow dumb enough to think that hiding stuff from kids works (drugs, guns, porn, e.t.c).

It's super effective. Not perfect, but "hiding stuff from kids" has excellent ROI—relatively easy, and damn effective. Ask any parent, we do it all the time, and if it didn't work, we'd stop.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by threatofrain on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @04:19PM (#35793558)
Making things even 1% harder works in public policy. Even just putting chocolate milk on a higher shelf works.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by jupp0r on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:59PM (#35824739)
Hiding away guns from kids (ie gun safe) is working well and often required by law.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by welshwelsh on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @09:55AM (#35787426)
Why do you think that? I think it's a good thing for minors to have unrestricted access to porn
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by e40 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:08AM (#35787637)
My 22 year old son vehemently disagrees. And from what I've read from young men, many agree with him. When I (we?) were kids porn was Playboy or Penthouse or Hustler. Tame by comparison to today. As my son stressed with me, you can find _anything_ via the internet. Anything. ANYTHING. A developing brain can't unsee stuff and it does warp people's perceptions of what is normal.

Having said that, I am deeply suspicious of any move to "protect the children" because it's always used as a cover for a move toward authoritarianism.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Aachen on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:31AM (#35789111)
I'm not that much older than your son and had a different experience. (My youth was definitely not magazines, if that's what playboy and penthouse are supposed to refer to.) I think we'll need more than n=2 before being able to come to an informed conclusion here.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by sbaiddn on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:29AM (#35788012)
Call me a prude.

Call me old fashioned.

Call me small minded.

But watching a woman getting chocked while DPed in her anus while a half dozen men ejaculate on her is not the type of extra-curricular activity [1] I want my soon to be teenaged daughters' boyfriends interested in.

Im just... overprotective I guess.

[1] If anyone calls me out for knowing what's on the front page of all of these smut sites, guess what? We all know what's on those sites!

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by jnwatson on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:41AM (#35788213)
I’m sympathetic to your argument, but consider the case where you remove the sex from the above picture. It is normal and not specially restricted to have violent torture-like scenes in modern media.

The problem isn’t the sex. The problem is the violence.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by the_doctah on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:47AM (#35788299)
Getting choked is a common fetish though.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by 3np on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:13AM (#35788766)
Would it be as prevalent if minors weren't exposed to hardcore porn?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by wkat4242 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:41AM (#35789301)
Does it matter? Why is it bad when people like getting choked and it's happening consensually?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by kemayo on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:32PM (#35790144)
Choking's sort of an interesting case for this, because it's one where someone should (ideally) also be doing it safely. Someone can enjoy it and consent to it, but not be sufficiently educated to do it without more risk than they realize. (This applies to many acts, but this one's particularly potentially-lethal.)

Porn, being a fantasy, rarely shows the prep-work required to do something properly. This is what I personally worry about when it comes to setting the wrong expectations in kids who haven't had that whole "this isn't representative of real sex" context properly set, leaving them thinking they can reproduce what's happening on-screen without realizing the background work required...

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by wkat4242 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:53PM (#35790526)
It's the same with Shibari, that's in fact a lot more dangerous than choking if not done properly. Because choking you can simply stop when you notice it's going wrong. A Shibari rope that isn't secured and suddenly slips to the neck takes time to cut.

Yet Shibari is viewed as an art form because it's much more stylish.

But people really into this kind of stuff are also very much into consent and safe practices. Is there really a wave of accidental chokings?

School shootings on the other hand... Maybe we should look at violent movies first?

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by drdeca on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:00AM (#35788524)
What is a fetish? It is the scar that guides the knife.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Timon3 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:27AM (#35789053)
Do you have any evidence?

Seems like a whole lot of people were deeply hurt by feet.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by iamleppert on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:48AM (#35788315)
If you're that concerned about it you should talk to your daughter about the risks of consenting to group sex, and the risks of hanging out with boys who are interested in it.

All this content was available when I was a teenager and my friends watched it. Those who actually follow through with having group activities quickly find out that it's way different than porn and not really all that enjoyable anyway.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by wkat4242 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:26AM (#35789028)
This kind of porn has been around for decades and very few people actually do that kind of stuff. Something that's published isn't automatically a role model.

And the ones that do are really and truly into it. Yes it happens, it's not my kind of thing either but I know some people that love it.

What helps more is real sex ed. Explaining what sex is about, how to respect a partner, about safety. Rather than really easily circumventable bans. I got good sex ed when I was young in the Netherlands and I turned out fine and very respectful to women just like my peers despite having access to porn. The problem are religious schools not wanting to do serious sex ed. So the kids only have porn to go by.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by dageshi on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:28AM (#35789071)
If you've ever taken a look at the "Popular with Women" category on PH or similar sites, it seems like women sometimes actively seek out more degrading porn than you might expect.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by wnolens on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:54AM (#35789520)
haha.. as if it would be her boyfriend's fault. Way to pass the blame.

Download the latest dating app - Feeld - and peruse for yourself what women explicitly state that they are looking for when the shame for stating so is removed/reduced.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Brybry on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:01PM (#35789636)
But high school kids are having less sex and, those that do, with fewer partners and it continues to trend down. [1]

So, assuming porn has any effect at all, it's possible highly available internet porn is decreasing the amount of sex kids are having.

The sexual violence trend on page 56 is concerning however it looks like the CDC has not been tracking that question as long either (only 4 year trend instead of 10+ like other categories).

Another concerning thing to me is the decreasing condom use, especially with current abortion trends. If we think porn drives behavior, maybe porn actors should be mandated to use condoms.

[1] https://www.cdc.gov/healthyyouth/data/yrbs/pdf/yrbs_data-sum... [Page 14 (17 pdf)]

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by claudiawerner on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:43PM (#35792294)
>But watching a woman getting chocked while DPed in her anus while a half dozen men ejaculate on her is not the type of extra-curricular activity [1] I want my soon to be teenaged daughters' boyfriends interested in.

If this is consensual, it actually sounds rather fun. But it's interesting that the example is simply an amalgamation of relatively common things:

* Choking is a common kink * Anal sex is a common sex act * Group sex is at least a common fantasy; I don't know how common double anal penetration is outside porn though * Providing and receiving facials is also quite common as an alternative to spitting.

All of the acts are relatively innocuous on their own, but the combination is portrayed to be almost demonic :)

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by salawat on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @07:38PM (#35795736)
Function composition is the essence of perversity.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by 0zemp2c on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:19AM (#35787832)
> I think it's a good thing for minors to have unrestricted access to porn

seek help

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by mensetmanusman on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:27AM (#35787985)
“Children, after we watch Daniel Tiger, we will watch what happens to this school teacher by all these men”

There is actually a long dark history of adults abusing children by exposing/exploiting them in regards to such topics. It was rife in Germany post WW2 in certain communities, currently a huge issue in Pakistan. Child trafficking on an absolute basis is higher now than it has been.

That’s just to say, people like who you are asking to seek help are numerous and unchecked behavior in this area has a dark history in humanity.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by scarface74 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @09:57AM (#35787463)
Yes “think about the children”. If anything, there should be a law that forces all ISPs and even device manufacturers of “internet enabled devices” to have clear instructions on how to use parental controls.

This would be far less onerous since it’s already a feature they have and it protect privacy.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by tomjen3 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:07AM (#35787608)
Porn is not dangerous, it is just parents that don't want to talk about sex with their kids.

What is dangerous is social media, which should be banned < 21.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:32AM (#35788060)
Pornography is dangerous. It's extremely addictive and users become increasingly tolerant to what their viewing, often leading to the development of distressing fetishes or real life intimacy issues.

I'm sex positive and I believe in being open with children about the realities of life but the dangers of pornography are real.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by juve1996 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:49AM (#35789432)
> It's extremely addictive and users become increasingly tolerant to what their viewing, often leading to the development of distressing fetishes or real life intimacy issues.

This is a strong claim - please provide a source. I think it may be true, but is it?

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:57AM (#35789573)
The Wikipedia page for pornography addiction lists several good sources: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pornography_addiction

And YourBrainOnPorn gathered together some of the literature about escalation: https://www.yourbrainonporn.com/nl/relevant-research-and-art...

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by laserlight on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:43PM (#35790334)
Here's the first sentence of the Wikipedia article:

> Pornography addiction is the popular but unscientific[5] application of an addiction model to the use of pornography.

[5] Science Stopped Believing in Porn Addiction. You Should, Too. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/women-who-stray/2018...

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:50PM (#35790464)
Yes, I read the article and the sentences which followed the first. I was referring you to the references below it.

See this comment about the difficulty of getting pornography addiction recognised in the DSM: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35790536

It's more of an issue of classifying it separately from other sexual disorders than recognising the addictive potential of pornography itself.

I myself have been addicted to pornography so I understand the reality of it intimately. I have been in groups with other men who are distraught with their lack of control. I have spoken to countless women whose relationships have been destroyed by this.

I can point you towards some large support groups online if you'd like to inform the men who are suffering that their issue is not scientifically recognised.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by erenyeager on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @03:02PM (#35792525)
Thanks for recognizing this problem, really online support groups helped so much when it seemed so much of common society didn’t know or care about these issues.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Aachen on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:49AM (#35789434)
When you use the word "extremely", what kind of incidence are you referring to?

If someone says "water is extremely common in the solar system", I'd expect maybe two in three planets to have it. Half at minimum.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by AlecSchueler on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:02PM (#35789673)
More than half of divorce cases in the US mention compulsive pornography usage: https://s3.amazonaws.com/thf_media/2010/pdf/ManningTST.pdf
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Aachen on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:06PM (#35789739)
... I gotta say, that's a surprisingly good comeback. One would have to dive into the stats on how many people get married in the first place and then divorce (iirc the latter is about a third? At least in my country) and then halve that rate, so it's not going to be an "extremely" by any definition I think, but I do better see your point.

Makes me think about gambling. Most people either don't do any or do it in normal proportions. For those that do have trouble, as this argument is about addiction after all, there's a self-imposed timeout mechanism that gets centrally registered so that any gambling place will enforce the timeout on this person. I don't know how much it helps, and it also goes into having to identify users to avoid circumventing even a self-imposed safeguard, but it might be an industry to compare against and draw research from (I haven't seen it mentioned yet in the greater thread).

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by rchaud on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:49AM (#35788338)
Porn absolutely is dangerous if it becomes a habit.

But just like binge-drinking and narcotics, parents and kids should have conversations and work together to build healthy ideas of sexuality. It shouldn't be a government decree thing, because that seemingly takes the responsibility off parents. But we all know a decree won't work, kids will find a way, so it will return to being the parents' problem.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by mrweasel on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:18PM (#35789929)
This was actually what I was thinking, but sort of the other way around. We already have an age limit drinking, narcotics are more or less banned.

I don't know how the US handles this, but online gambling is a pretty good model for this. You need to be of a certain age, verified with a government ID (here in Denmark at least) and if you have a gambling problem, you can add yourself to a list the ensures that you're blocked on all gambling sites (and casinos).

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by rchaud on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:44AM (#35788255)
That is something that your parents or community elders could have told you. Why does the state need to intervene?

Phub is also a legitimate business that has commercial advertising interests in the US, so they're incentivized to play nice. There are about a million other websites that aren't based in North America, contain only pirated material, and don't care about what laws are applicable where.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by mind-blight on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:22AM (#35788941)
PornHub refused to take down child porn and rape videos (not actors, actual assaults) on their platform for years. They only took them down when the victims in the videos took them to court and the NYT published an exposé. They're in the middle of being sued right now, and the evidence that's coming to light in that case is pretty damning.

Given how poorly they've behaved so far, I don't agree that they're incentivized to play nice.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by rchaud on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:27PM (#35792070)
You're just making my point. This is the new and improved PH that's trying to go legit and abides by local laws and regulations.

All the other sites? Not so much.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by armatav on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:49AM (#35789435)
Half the kids in this nation don’t have the parental guidance to avoid addictions in general.

The point of the US is to let the states self-regulate things like this.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Longlius on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:24AM (#35788978)
I think it's good, but I really wish the solution was, "We need parents to take a more active role in their children's lives and supervise their internet usage" and not, "Lockdown and de-anonymize the web."
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by tbihl on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:11PM (#35797380)
On the other hand, if you as a legislator perceive a social evil, and your options are to pass a law or to get all the parents to take away their kids' phones and switch back to desktop computers (used only in a common area), which do you pick?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:16PM (#35797411)
I dunno, is the law unlikely to work at its nominal goal and likely to, in practice, substantially burden adults in activities that they are and ought to be free to do, and also largely being advocated by people who fairly openly want to curtail adults practical access, but have been frustrated by Constitutional protections in their efforts in that direction?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by tbihl on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:27PM (#35797512)
I don't find your line of thinking to be consistent with a legislator.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by GoofballJones on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:19PM (#35789933)
Is it? Is this a States thing? That in the United States that nudity and pornography is "dangerous", yet in other cultures throughout Europe, it's not taken as seriously, nor does it have this overall "dangerous" tag to it (generally speaking that is. Prudish people trying to impose their will on others can be a world-wide phenomenon).

And does this put a curb on explicit R rated movies that has nudity and acts of sex? Is it just the penetration shots that are "dangerous"? Also, it doesn't even touch on if ultra violent content strewn around, well, EVERYWHERE isn't "dangerous"? Where is the state bans on violence in movies and TV (they've already tried with video games)? But OMFG, if you dare to show a woman's breast, it's "dangerous".

Give me a break.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by throwaway743 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:25PM (#35790021)
It's embedded by the puritanical roots of the US. It's nonsense really.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by tivert on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:39PM (#35790274)
> It's embedded by the puritanical roots of the US. It's nonsense really.

It's worth noting that the reactionary response to that (e.g. porn is good and totally healthy and everything bad said about it is fake news) is also nonsense.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by throwaway743 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:27PM (#35792064)
You're absolutely right, but the issue is more nuanced than simply "porn is good" or "porn is bad.". The root of the problem lies in the fact that the discussion around sex and sex health in the US is often clouded by puritanical beliefs and an aversion to discussing these topics in an open and honest manner. This typically leads to a lack of comprehensive sex education and the stigmatization of porn, which has never done anyone any good. As a country, we need to be more open and honest about sex, and recognize that censorship and puritanical attitudes have no place in shaping our laws or social norms.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by freedomben on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:21PM (#35791986)
I agree generally that there is some serious puritanical roots in the US that are still at heavy play today. But there must be more to what's happening than just that. in other threads it's bewing shown that many European countries and Canada are passing similar laws. Puritanical roots of Europe?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by throwaway743 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:41PM (#35792260)
Honestly, idk enough about what's happening in Europe or Canada as it relates to this topic, but it's possible that there are other cultural or historical factors at play. My initial assumption is maybe it's due to a rise in conservatism in certain countries? Again, idk, I haven't been keeping up with the news on this.

What's going on exactly? Which countries?

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by rootusrootus on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @06:56PM (#35795285)
You're not at all sure why it's happening in multiple other countries, but you're completely confident it must be the 'puritanical roots of the US'?
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by throwaway743 on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @10:23AM (#35802761)
The US has a different history than Europe. One aspect of that history being the strong influence of religious puritans who were among the earliest colonizers, and whose impact has and can still be seen today in various aspects of American society and culture.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Mindwipe on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:49PM (#35790436)
> Is it? Is this a States thing? That in the United States that nudity and pornography is "dangerous", yet in other cultures throughout Europe, it's not taken as seriously, nor does it have this overall "dangerous" tag to it (generally speaking that is. Prudish people trying to impose their will on others can be a world-wide phenomenon).

France and Germany have similar laws, and the UK is about to pass one.

It would be nice if this were true, but it's not.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by 4gotunameagain on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:13PM (#35790879)
Anything that can hijack the dopaminergic system should not be allowed to kids. Gambling, tiktok & smartphones in general, porn, drugs etc.

We used to have shame as a societal mechanism to deal with these issues. It was shameful to be an alcoholic, which was how alcoholism was kept in check. The same way it was shameful in ancient Greece to surrender to your carnal urges.

Shame is disappearing. Our societies are going haywire.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by jbar32 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:48PM (#35791472)
> Anything that can hijack the dopaminergic system

This is far too broad, just because something could be used for evil is not enough to ban it for all children. What about TVs? Candy? Stimulating toys? I think all of these can have negative outcomes when abused, but that isn't enough for me to say all children should not access them.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Aerbil313 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @03:33PM (#35792922)
All online pornography is scientientifically demonstrated to be harmful for both children and adults, see the research: https://www.yourbrainonporn.com/
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Seattle3503 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @03:11PM (#35792633)
Is there evidence shame prevents or treats addiction? Everything I've seen suggests the opposite.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by HaZeust on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @03:23PM (#35792796)
Places with robust systems for shame and conformation to its populace - particularly religious nations - are less civilized and developed than their "shameless" national counterparts. This isn't the only variable, and it's clearly not the determining factor. Push an agenda elsewhere.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by bart_spoon on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @08:37PM (#35796235)
Japan would like a word
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by HaZeust on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @05:41PM (#35808167)
And I would like to repeat my words:

"[Shame and conformation aren't] the only variable, and it's clearly not the determining factor."

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Aerbil313 on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @03:34PM (#35806653)
Depends on how you define development and civilization. There are plenty who see Western nations as became more barbarian (as opposed to being more civilized) with and due to development of technology. They don't see development of technology as good either.
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by throwaway675309 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @07:14PM (#35795485)
Our societies are going haywire....

We really need to get back to the good old days – you know the ones – where slavery was legal, women didn't have the right to vote, and homosexuality could be punished with forced sterilization.

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by Aerbil313 on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @03:31PM (#35792887)
It's simply science, see the research for yourself: https://www.yourbrainonporn.com/
Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by skrbjc on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @06:02PM (#35794831)
Surely you understand that happening to see a woman's nipple is completely different to a 14 year old sitting up at 4am masterbating to whatever intense porn they can get their hands on are two completely different things. And if you think the latter is bad, as you should, then it makes sense to err on the side of caution when figuring out a way to reduce the likelihood of a young person, who has not fully developed a sense of self control, getting sucked into the wormhole of a porn addiction. If that means reducing the likelihood of an innocent breast being seen, then that seems like a reasonable trade-off.

Also, you say Europe is more open about nudity, implying that is a good thing, but Asia and the middle east are in many cases more prudish than even the US, so why not look to them or use them as an example? Where's your objective measure for which societies we should admire and emulate?

Re:Adult website Pornhub blocks users in Utah from accessing... by marcod on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:57PM (#35792465)
Forgot who said it, but every 12 year old with their unrestricted iPhone has 24/7 access to Bukakke.