News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by themaninthedark on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:20PM (#35781881)
>The decision to demolish Lützerath was made in accordance with the country’s new coal policy to temporarily increase the use of lignitefor electricity production during the energy crisis, Clean Energy Wire reported.

If only there was another power source that could be used, perhaps one that didn't rely on burning fossil fuels, if only...

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by gtirloni on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:26PM (#35781956)
This news aside, I think the world still associates Germany with engineering excellence so, to see them abandon nuclear power for political reasons comes as a shock.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by astrange on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:41PM (#35782116)
They also have a cultural fondness for green party/hippiedom unfortunately.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by ulfw on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:42PM (#35782136)
Germany as a society tends to be prone to obsessions. The current one is climate. There is no other discussion in the media and politics. Nothing else important to focus on.

Kids are glueing themselves onto streets because their obsessions aren't satisfied strongly enough. The brainwashing is real.

Unfortunately obsessions lead to lack of wider thinking or logic.

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by rjzzleep on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:26PM (#35782538)
I actually think you've put your finger on the actual problem. Sometimes these obsessions lead to success, because obsession and persistence can be the same.

But let's take the last year, sanctions policies that lead them to trade direct resource imports from Russia to having the same imports but paying premium through brokers like Morocco, India and Chinese LNG(all coming from Russia). Let's remember what the BASF CEO said before it escalated.[1]

A lot of people in Germany were begging the government to postpone the shutdown of the remaining power plants until they have replacements, but the ideological Greens just charged ahead replacing Nuclear with Coal to achieve their ideological goal of removing nuclear. They have also been at the forefront of pushing legislation at an EU level to block nuclear in various forms.[2][3]

I've seen these obsessions in various other parts of society. I've had people stand behind me waiting telling me they could not pass anywhere but where I am even though they could just take a turn around me. I've personally experienced and heard from multiple people at the CCC that their Math teachers would punish them for achieving a result with a different technique than what the teacher taught them.

[1] https://www.faz.net/aktuell/wirtschaft/unternehmen/basf-chef...

[2] https://www.brusselsreport.eu/2022/01/04/germany-needs-to-st...

[3] https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/germany-pushes-nucle...

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by kitkat_new on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:52PM (#35782233)
you really have a strange framing here, given climate change is a real threat.

And fighting it isn't something that only Germany is tasked with.

btw. it's not kids, but grown ups of all ages that are gluing themselves onto streets; in various countries

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by pxmpxm on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:00PM (#35782309)
> climate change is a real threat.

I'm rather sure that not being able to afford energy - heat in the winer - is a the real existential threat to a kid in continental Europe.

Worrying about sea level going up 10cm in his/her lifetime is a rich person hobby.

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by danielheath on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:08PM (#35782375)
> Worrying about sea level going up 10cm in his/her lifetime is a rich person hobby.

Worrying about the future past next year is definitely a rich person hobby, if you define "rich" as "not imminently starving".

Sea level rise is the least of the trouble. Look at fisheries decline (yield per inflation-adjusted-dollar spent has been recorded for a long time now - in spite of new tech it's been dropping for over a century), temperature-driven crop failures, increased frequency of severe storms damaging infrastructure.

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by mgfist on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:30PM (#35782566)
About 200 Germans died in the floods last year - far more than those who died from the cold. And climate change increased both the likeliness and the intensity of the rains.

So no, this isn't something rich people will face in 50 years. It's something everyone faces today.

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by bumby on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:16PM (#35782452)
Both are real risks, but humans are biased to be disproportionately sensitive to near term risks and tend to underestimate long term risks. In addition, poor people tend to be disproportionately affected.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by rcxdude on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:17PM (#35782470)
It's those above the poverty line but only just that should be worrying most: the rich will likely be mostly fine, it's everyone else who is going to suffer much more from it.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by scythe on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:10PM (#35782394)
Sea level is projected to rise 30 centimeters over the next 30 years. The rate is gradually accelerating, so the coming century will see more than a meter.

But the primary near-term risks from climate change are heat damaging crops, (wet) heat killing humans, declining soil moisture in some regions, and increased risk of flooding along some rivers. Over two centuries, coastal cities may be inundated, but that is a long time.

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by cubefox on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:48PM (#35782188)
The irony is that our obsession with disabling nuclear power works contrary to any climate obsession. When the two are played out against each other, the anti-nuclear ambitions win. Disabling nuclear power is apparently more important than disabling coal power plants. And than dealing with soaring energy costs and a potential blackout.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by Zardoz89 on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:44PM (#35782154)
Nuclear dissolution is a CDU policy, but good job regurgitiating the rhetoric
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by prottog on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:01PM (#35782314)
The CDU was in power when they proposed the timelines that ended up in the closures we saw recently, but the electoral success of the Green Party in that election cycle was a key factor. Your summary is disingenuous.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by est31 on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:02PM (#35782331)
The original dissolution was passed as a plan during Schröder's first term, aka in the SPD/Green government, in 2002. Later, in 2010, the CDU/FDP government modified the plan and gave the power plant providers more budget. About half a year after this law has passed the Bundestag, the Fukushima nuclear power plant accident happened and a commission was established to study the security of nuclear power. Then, yes, CDU and FDP agreed upon a new plan to exit nuclear power earlier than their original extension planned, and some power plants were turned off right away.

You can point your finger at the CDU, but saying that the CDU was the big driving force is disingenous.

It seems that Germany's descisions on exiting nuclear power plants are always unhappily timed. First, Fukushima happens, making the extension a few months earlier look really weird. Then, the Ukraine war happens, rendering Germany's original plan moot to replace coal with natural gas from russia, and everyone is shaking their head again as Germany is keeping to the original plan.

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by zsz on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:46PM (#35782680)
It was the Greens who campaigned throughout the 80s and beyond to instill irrational fear in German kids in the 80s, so they would opt for an impulsive solution, instead of a rational one in subsequent decades. It was always the Greens whose very platform stood for ending nuclear power, by any means necessary. The reason why Germany today is so staunchly anti-nuclear is because that's how the Greens ("Die Gruenen") defined itself as a political party in the 80s. In fact, that was a (if not the) principal motivation for its inception. The party may seem more mainstream 30 years later, but around the 80s when they laid all the groundwork for the anti-nuclear stance of present day Germany, they were definitely a party still better known for, and even defined by their more radical members.

That the current generation of voters who supported the shutdown of nuclear power production were substantially "encouraged" to adopt such views by said Greens' actions and politics when they were children and teenagers living in the 80s is incontrovertible fact. So, even if Merkel ended up as the one who executed the will of the people as head of the CDU, that will had nothing to do with CDU policy, and certainly not in the 80s and 90s. That was by definition the policy of the Greens, who also laid the groundwork for the irrational fear that Germans in their 40s and 50s have been cultivating for decades.

Why can i say this with complete certainty? Because I was one of those kids.

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by astrange on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:52PM (#35782716)
I said a cultural fondness for it, not that they're party members.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by bumby on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:57PM (#35782283)
There’s also a history of civic distrust when it comes to nuclear. After Chernobyl there was conflicting information about safe thresholds and later revisions. There’s been some write-ups stating government transparency and trust are as big of an issue as safety.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by nemo44x on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:02PM (#35782332)
> I think the world still associates Germany with engineering excellence…

Do people feel that way? Their automobiles are some of the worst from an engineering perspective and the only software company I can think of is the dinosaur SAP.

When I think of Germany I do not think of good engineering but rather automobiles that lose so much value so quickly because the have expensive and frequent maintenance costs and outdated software companies. Germany makes things unnecessarily complex and therefore prone to failure. It’s a cultural thing I believe.

In which ways us Germany considered excellent at engineering today?

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by tbrake on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:15PM (#35782448)
Whoa whoa. The "association" OP speaks of is down to effective marketing - creating a common image of German product/industrial design as meticulous and high performing - not some objective engineering ranking.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by nemo44x on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:34PM (#35782601)
Good point. Germans are good at marketing I guess. But very poor engineers.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by nikau on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:39PM (#35782631)
It's not the engineers, it's the consumer demand for things other than depreciation and longevity.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by nemo44x on Monday May 01, 2023 @11:03PM (#35782797)
Other places make performant things that have far more longevity. Japan for instance. It’s a cultural thing in Germany. I’ve spent a good deal of time there and was surprised how good at marketing they are and how bad at building. German exports of many things are of very low quality but high prices.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by marcosdumay on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:21PM (#35782500)
At the electricity generation, ironically, the two well regarded players are Siemens and GE, only Siemens for its quality (what may or may not reflect the reality of the last decades, no idea).
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by asmor on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:32PM (#35782039)
We could've let the existing plants run for a while, but getting a supply chain restarted and plants recertified when the entire country is phrasing them out is not trivial, especially not on short notice. (And also, the fuel rods usually come from Russia).

We also would have to get foreign workers. A lot of NPP workers went into early retirement.

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by bboygravity on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:26PM (#35781958)
Germany was bought by the Russians. There's no other logical way to explain what's happening IMO. Their decisions are worse than incompetence alone.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by donmcronald on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:38PM (#35782088)
I don’t understand why Germany wasn’t livid when their leader literally went to work for Russian oil interests [1]. That seems like blatant corruption, doesn’t it?

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerhard_Schr%C3%B6der#Criticis...

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by largepeepee on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:48PM (#35782195)
Same reason why we have ex-US generals working for foreigners like the Saudi govt and no one seems to care.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by legulere on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:37PM (#35782086)
How do? Germany completely got rid of Russian dependence in the energy sector. It’s France that is blocking sanctions on Russian nuclear industry.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by bumby on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:58PM (#35782292)
Russia was the second largest provider of uranium to the EU.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by g42gregory on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:02PM (#35782327)
Didn’t Germany shut down nuclear energy plants too? This problem seems to be entirely of their own making. Why would they do this?
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by bumby on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:10PM (#35782393)
Yes, the plan was set in motion many years earlier. But the reliance Russian energy (whether fossil or uranium fuel) would have been there in either case. Energy exports are a big lever for Russia in foreign affairs.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by g42gregory on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:18PM (#35782472)
But the Russians didn’t use the energy leverage so far, did they? Germany seemingly decided to do the damage to themselves on their own. Wouldn’t it be better to take time and find alternative sources of energy first? This is what I don’t understand.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by bumby on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:24PM (#35782519)
I think the idea is that Russia fosters interdependence on their natural resources as a way to limit retaliation for territorial expansion. It worked with Georgia and Crimea, but they may have miscalculated with Ukraine.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by bboygravity on Monday May 15, 2023 @05:19AM (#35945539)
That's very recent isn't it?

Even in the early days of Putin's war Germany was still sponsoring Putin by buying many 100's of millions of EUR of gas from him.

They "got rid of Russian dependence in the energy sector" by reopening old German coal mines, firing up coal power plants and shifting gas imports from Russia to the US + importing tons of nuclear energy from France.

Germany only stopped buying Russian gas for > 50% of their energy needs AFTER a war started AFTER the pipelines to Russia got bombed and AFTER they had no other choice.

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by nailer on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:33PM (#35782041)
What I would do, if I wanted to increase Germany’s reliance on Russia, is use money to ensure the voices of real German people who oppose nuclear power were amplified.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by bboygravity on Monday May 15, 2023 @05:14AM (#35945509)
In my opinion it's extremely likely that this happened:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-nuclear_movement_in_Germa...

All Russia had to do is use their unlimited money (from selling gas to Germany) to buy some influence in German news papers (difficulty level: easy) and maybe pay some people to organize protests.

Of course the fact that Russians bought Schroder isn't even speculation (unlike the above). To me the above is extremely likely to have happened (and probably still on-going).

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by jacooper on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:50PM (#35782213)
They don't even use Russian gas anymore.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by karp773 on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:40PM (#35782641)
Paraphrasing Ford: "A customer can have clean energy from any source he wants as long as it’s gas from Russia."
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by legulere on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:35PM (#35782062)
There is with renewables which are massively being built out. So far they completely replaced nuclear while also reducing coal power production from 45% in 2013 to 24% in 2020. By law there will be no more coal power in 2038, although 2030 or earlier is a more realistic date because of rising costs.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by toomuchtodo on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:41PM (#35782125)
Germany is actually ideal for maximizing renewables because of the 12 interconnects to other electrical grids, along with their ~10GW hydro storage and ~5GW hydro. It should only take another few tens of GW to phase coal out.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renewable_energy_in_Germany

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by iab on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:25PM (#35781948)
I think it’s too expensive to build a dam there
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by niemandhier on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:06PM (#35782357)
Storage of nuclear wast turned out to be a hard to solve problem.

As of now Germany has no “Endlagerstätte”, all current wast storage sides are intermediate. The last attempt to establish a permanent storage side failed horribly and the nuclear wast that was interned there will be extracted under high costs.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asse_II_mine

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by mgfist on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:39PM (#35782627)
The intermediate solutions last for many decades. It's completely sufficient, especially if the alternative is coal plants.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by niemandhier on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @02:30AM (#35784084)
Even intermediate storage is an issue, but one that is conveniently disregarded due to its intermediate nature .
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by mgfist on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:36PM (#35797077)
On a philosophical level everything is an intermediate solution. Casks designed to last 50-100 years are much longer in duration than our solutions for most other things.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by aeternum on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:23PM (#35782514)
No one seems to care about the nuclear radiation release from coal-fired plants.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by midoridensha on Monday May 01, 2023 @10:38PM (#35782623)
Unlike nuclear waste which takes up space in barrels, coal-fired radiation and pollution isn't a problem, because it goes into the air where everyone can breathe it. This is clearly better for the environment and also human health: just ask any German environmentalist.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by Jon_Lowtek on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:31AM (#35783728)
most radioactive waste created by coal power plants is filtered and ends up in barrels as well, and nuclear power also release radioactive waste into the atmosphere for everyone to breath, especially when looking at the whole cycle, including mining, milling and reprocessing.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by midoridensha on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:39AM (#35783771)
Citation needed.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by Jon_Lowtek on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:43AM (#35783791)
United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation - 2016 Report to the General Assembly - Scientific Annex B
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by defrost on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:56AM (#35783871)
> release radioactive waste

Well, BWRs and PWRs release Carbon-14 into the atmosphere where it is dwarfed by the Carbon-14 created by cosmic rays banging into Nitrogen ... and the total amount from both sources is truly tiny with a half life (of remaining in atmosphere) of 12 to 16 years.

The decay half life of Carbon-14 is almost 6,000 years .. ie: it decays slowly and the small amounts of Carbon-14 release even smaller amounts of ionising radiation due that slow decay.

Per human body Carbon-14 (mostly from cosmic ray interactions, magnitudes less from reactors) makes up a very very small part of regular mean environmental radiation per year per kilogram.

Source: a decade+ running numbers on global geophysical exploration surveys: background magnetics, radiation, gravity, etc instrumentation running 12/7/360 (daylight hours, all days of the week, little downtime) across multiple airframes.

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by Jon_Lowtek on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @03:17AM (#35784380)
Looking at table 13 of annex b, how does the plutonium-239 emitted in the atmosphere by the reprocessing plants compare to naturally occurring atmospheric plutonium? (scnr - the "compared to cosmic rays" reminds me of the fuel industry claiming that atmospheric lead is natural) I know the answer, i am just highlighting the cherry picking ;-) Sure there is natural carbon-14, but there is natural radon-222 as well, does that mean the radon exhaust of coal power plants can be ignored when comparing coal and nuclear power generation industries to each other? I think not.

The UNSCEAR boils all these complex details down to a collective effective dose per generated electricity (in man-sievert per gigawatt year) for atmospheric discharges. This hides a lot of details, including the mentioned plutonium as well as the carbon-14 releases, the radon exhaust, and the uranium-238 traces being discharged to the atmosphere both by coal burning power plants and the uranium mills required for nuclear power. How half life plays into that and why nuclear accidents were taken out of scope, and why you don't want an italian geothermal complex in your backyard. As i said, any TLDR i can give will not do justice to the details and quality of the report.

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by defrost on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @03:43AM (#35784522)
I wrote my comment to put your original comment [1] in proportion.

You appear to have since edited your original comment to replace "Carbon-14" with a broader non specific "radioactive waste".

> the "compared to cosmic rays" reminds me of the fuel industry claiming that atmospheric lead is natural

It might remind you of that but I assure the intent was to legitimately compare the actual amount of Carbon-14 in the atmosphere (which originates from cosmic ray collisions) against the additional amount added by PWR + BWR reactors.

Reactors add very little by magnitude to an amount that is already very small and in toto the effect on humans is a very small part of the "normal" human exposure to environmental radiation that has persisted for our time on this planet.

> there is natural radon-222 as well, does that mean the radon exhaust of coal power plants can be ignored ..

Absolutely not, but for a meaningful understanding it should be compared to the already occurring creation of radon from 'natural' uranium decaying within granites and expressing to the surface.

I'd suggest paying attention to ground topography also - radon pools in valleys until stiff breezes clear them of those pools - hence the recommendations for venting in basements in granite rich areas.

> This hides a lot of details, ... will not do justice to details and quality of the source.

If it's hiding details you can find better sources that drill deeper in the individual components.

Eg: Australian AGSO and National Pollution Inventory reports on Olympic Dam [2] and other "uranium mills".

Water usage might be an issue of greater significance there (at Olympic Dam).

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35783728

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olympic_Dam_mine

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by Jon_Lowtek on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @04:07AM (#35784675)
> You appear to have since edited your original comment to replace "Carbon-14" with a broader non specific "radioactive waste".

i did, within minutes of posting it, and before ever knowing about your follow up response, because i was unhappy with pinpointing such a detail and wanted to avoid this exact situation of someone over-focusing on that specific detail, disregarding the larger context of comparing whole sectors. I take full responsibility for pointing at the cherry you picked, before realising i should not.

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by Jon_Lowtek on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:15AM (#35787777)
> Water usage might be an issue of greater significance there (at Olympic Dam).

Then you may be happy to hear that the UN report also notes water pollution by the nuclear industry, citing a publication by the Australian Radiation Protection and Nuclear Safety Agency as reference L2 concerning Olympic Dam

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by Jon_Lowtek on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:24AM (#35783694)
The United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation cares, you can read about it in their 2016 Report to the General Assembly, Scientific Annex B, chapter V, including a comparison of different energy generation technologies in chapter VIII

https://www.unscear.org/unscear/uploads/documents/publicatio...

You should read it yourself because any TLDR will not be able to mention all the intricate details