News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by defrost on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @03:43AM (#35784522)
I wrote my comment to put your original comment [1] in proportion.

You appear to have since edited your original comment to replace "Carbon-14" with a broader non specific "radioactive waste".

> the "compared to cosmic rays" reminds me of the fuel industry claiming that atmospheric lead is natural

It might remind you of that but I assure the intent was to legitimately compare the actual amount of Carbon-14 in the atmosphere (which originates from cosmic ray collisions) against the additional amount added by PWR + BWR reactors.

Reactors add very little by magnitude to an amount that is already very small and in toto the effect on humans is a very small part of the "normal" human exposure to environmental radiation that has persisted for our time on this planet.

> there is natural radon-222 as well, does that mean the radon exhaust of coal power plants can be ignored ..

Absolutely not, but for a meaningful understanding it should be compared to the already occurring creation of radon from 'natural' uranium decaying within granites and expressing to the surface.

I'd suggest paying attention to ground topography also - radon pools in valleys until stiff breezes clear them of those pools - hence the recommendations for venting in basements in granite rich areas.

> This hides a lot of details, ... will not do justice to details and quality of the source.

If it's hiding details you can find better sources that drill deeper in the individual components.

Eg: Australian AGSO and National Pollution Inventory reports on Olympic Dam [2] and other "uranium mills".

Water usage might be an issue of greater significance there (at Olympic Dam).

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35783728

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olympic_Dam_mine

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by Jon_Lowtek on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @04:07AM (#35784675)
> You appear to have since edited your original comment to replace "Carbon-14" with a broader non specific "radioactive waste".

i did, within minutes of posting it, and before ever knowing about your follow up response, because i was unhappy with pinpointing such a detail and wanted to avoid this exact situation of someone over-focusing on that specific detail, disregarding the larger context of comparing whole sectors. I take full responsibility for pointing at the cherry you picked, before realising i should not.

Re:Wind farm in Germany is being dismantled to expand coal mine by Jon_Lowtek on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @10:15AM (#35787777)
> Water usage might be an issue of greater significance there (at Olympic Dam).

Then you may be happy to hear that the UN report also notes water pollution by the nuclear industry, citing a publication by the Australian Radiation Protection and Nuclear Safety Agency as reference L2 concerning Olympic Dam