News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yashg on Saturday April 22, 2023 @08:04AM (#35665730)
Crypto is not a financial market. It's a gambling den. Unregulated one. Scammers use financial sounding mumbo-jumbo to lure destitute suckers with promises of infinite riches. Same old game. Wash trading with make believe shitcoins in magic internet tokens keeps the line going up so DCAing idiots keep providing exit liquidity to OGs to unload their magic tokens.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by Datagenerator on Saturday April 22, 2023 @08:50AM (#35666115)
Market makers which are in the game of naked short selling and using Dark markets to route orders to is the real financial market?
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by styren on Saturday April 22, 2023 @09:15AM (#35666303)
Are you implying that they are not providing liquidity to "real financial markets"? In that case do you mind making your argument?
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by weard_beard on Saturday April 22, 2023 @09:26AM (#35666401)
Providing liquidity by infinitely counterfeiting shares and routing them off exchange to prevent accurate price discovery is only “useful” to the cartel who sell options.

If you’re implying that somehow grandma is being done a disservice because her pension fund can’t make the trades they want when they want then YOU need to explain how “liquidity” benefits anyone that matters.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by styren on Saturday April 22, 2023 @10:15AM (#35666817)
I didn't imply anything, I was asking for his reasoning since he didn't provide any.

And I'm not sure how to respond to anyone that buckets people into those that do and those that don't matter. Your argument doesn't seem to be made in good faith.

Such a weird attack and downvote just for asking for a clarification?

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by weard_beard on Saturday April 22, 2023 @12:07PM (#35667957)
Providing Liquidity is a crime that harms everyone except market makers and economists. I’m pretty sure they don’t matter.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by elif on Saturday April 22, 2023 @09:31AM (#35666437)
You are conflating many low cap nonsense coins with actually revolutionary and valued ones.

Gambling returns an expected -2% to -10% by design.

If you pick virtually any 5 year interval for Ethereum or Bitcoin, you see >100% growth. In the current crash, they are up 128% and 187% respectively.

Fiat currencies are not "gambling" even though they fluctuate in relative value and even mimic the -2% to -10% expected return of gambling far more appropriately than major cryptos.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by apnew on Saturday April 22, 2023 @09:36AM (#35666481)
The argument that crypto is not gambling just because some coins reported >0% returns is rather weak.

The first definition of Gambling I found;

>> the act of playing for stakes in the hope of winning (including the payment of a price for a chance to win a prize).

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by elif on Saturday April 22, 2023 @09:43AM (#35666555)
"some coins reported >0% returns" is weak I agree.

Fortunately my point was that the main 2 "report >100% returns for every single 'player' who waited 5 years."

using your gambling definition, I would say that "chance" to return a prize is not accurate as it is a "virtual if not outright certainty" historically speaking.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by Eisenstein on Saturday April 22, 2023 @07:45PM (#35671930)
> for every single 'player' who waited 5 years.

For every player who bought coins and put them in a cold wallet and sat on them? Because otherwise the chances are pretty high that they got scammed, lost their coins in an exchange collapse, lost access to them, or, you know, traded them like every other person who deals with coins who didn't die or lose their wallet keys or forgot about it.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by throwawayadvsec on Saturday April 22, 2023 @09:44AM (#35666559)
i'm not a crypto supporter, but the same applies to the stock market, housing, or any business or investment
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by NickM on Saturday April 22, 2023 @10:44AM (#35667049)
Stock shares are an investment because the stock market is a positive sum game in the long run. Yes there are risks but the returns produced by the market are due to actual value being generated in the form of goods and services.

Investing in Bitcoin is like investing in shares of a company that produces nothing, and which only is able to fund its continued operations by continuing to issue and sell more shares once every ten minutes. Investing in a real compay that worked that way would be considered crazy, but somehow it’s supposed to be different because it’s decentralized. The financial implications are the same though; it’s a negative sum game instead of a positive sum game.

That’s why it’s more like gambling than an investment. The amount of money that comes back out is always going to be less than the amount that goes in, in the end.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by throwawayadvsec on Saturday April 22, 2023 @10:59AM (#35667222)
"because the stock market is a positive sum game in the long run"

No, in the actual long run you and every of your descendants dies and the earth get disintegrated.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by tanseydavid on Saturday April 22, 2023 @01:19PM (#35668818)
Is someone who day-trades stocks an "Investor" or a "Gambler"?

I think most people who day-trade would call themselves "investors" but it seems precisely like gambling to me.

Can trading stocks be both "investing" or "gambling" depending on how you approach it?

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by MacsHeadroom on Saturday April 22, 2023 @04:57PM (#35670867)
Day-traders tend to not call themselves investors. They call themselves traders.

Investing involves holding assets long term.

But they certainly don't call themselves gamblers. At least not any that turn it into a successful career.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by stouset on Sunday April 23, 2023 @04:01AM (#35674300)
They are gamblers.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by thunky on Sunday April 23, 2023 @12:48PM (#35677886)
You can gamble with anything, to include things that aren't worthless like food, housing, stocks, etc. You can also invest in them. But you can't invest in worthless things.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by xmcqdpt2 on Monday April 24, 2023 @07:32AM (#35686288)
Is the day trader in your example trading their own money?

Because most traders aren't. They are bank and fund employees with KPIs, risk management oversight, massive support functions and very expensive computer programs.

Retail investors that are day trading on the other side of those professionals are absolutely gamblers though.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by re-thc on Saturday April 22, 2023 @10:44AM (#35667050)
Those you mention are regulated (to some extent). Is crypto? Main issue. Not a level playing field.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by Cardinal7167 on Saturday April 22, 2023 @11:18AM (#35667453)
But crypto _is_ regulated. The SEC has been clear about how to treat and tax crypto.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by JumpCrisscross on Saturday April 22, 2023 @05:22PM (#35671025)
> SEC has been clear about how to treat and tax crypto

The SEC has no authority over how crypto is taxed.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by Cardinal7167 on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:31PM (#35671501)
Their guidance to treat it like a security has clear tax implications, im obviously not saying they control the tax legislation itself.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by JumpCrisscross on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:42PM (#35671571)
> guidance to treat it like a security has clear tax implications

Not really. These are independent decisions. The IRS may incorporate the SEC's views into its guidance, but that's simply a courtesy.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by throwawayadvsec on Saturday April 22, 2023 @11:00AM (#35667237)
we're not arguing about regulations or ethics, he was just saying that it was just gambling, more regulations wouldn't change that
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by spacebanana7 on Saturday April 22, 2023 @11:28AM (#35667533)
The difference is that many consumers used crypto as a gambling tool. More so than in those other classes

The precise definition of gambling varies by jurisdiction, but ultimately the thrill of prizewinning and dangers of addiction/financial loss were enjoyed by large numbers of crypto buyers [1].

I personally bet on Ethereum the same way I bet on sports teams whose players I enjoy watching.

[1] Admittedly my evidence is mostly anecdotal, but it seems like everyone knows somebody who used crypto like this

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yellowapple on Saturday April 22, 2023 @12:19PM (#35668106)
I know plenty of people who used and continue to use stocks in the exact same way, particularly on apps like Robinhood.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by spacebanana7 on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:35PM (#35671533)
I think it’s fair to call that behaviour gambling too.

Options and derivatives that create or extract artificial volatility out of economic prices are gambling tools in the hands of most consumers.

The underlying source of randomness for a gambling instrument doesn’t really matter as long as it’s statistically well behaved. The physical uncertainty of a roulette wheel, the economic uncertainty of the business cycle and the athletic uncertainty of a sports match all do the job.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yashg on Saturday April 22, 2023 @04:12PM (#35670481)
Nope. Businesses and housing have real utility. They are of value. Real value. Crypto tokens are a game of finding a bigger fool to make money.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by MagicMoonlight on Saturday April 22, 2023 @12:43PM (#35668371)
Madoff was also offering >100% consistent growth
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by elif on Saturday April 22, 2023 @07:15PM (#35671771)
That's just not true. Madoff gave 4%-10% annual returns and siphoned off 12% of funds overall.

Bitcoin gave 25% annual returns and is cryptographically guaranteed to siphon off 0% of funds.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by Eisenstein on Saturday April 22, 2023 @07:48PM (#35671948)
> Bitcoin gave 25% annual returns

Don't you have to sell them to get your money?

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by elif on Saturday April 22, 2023 @08:18PM (#35672130)
Yes
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yashg on Saturday April 22, 2023 @04:10PM (#35670475)
I am not going to educate you on what gambling is, or what is the purpose of money. You made me laugh by calling some magic tokens revolutionary. Yes a revolutionary new way of duping poor people of their money.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by jjtheblunt on Sunday April 23, 2023 @05:08PM (#35680636)
(not being sarcastic, just naive)

what is an example actually revolutionary coin?

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by xk_id on Saturday April 22, 2023 @10:07AM (#35666747)
I remember when I didn’t know anything about crypto and I believed ppl like you proclaiming this kind of stuff. But i was curious so i looked at the “mumbo-jumbo” myself and turns out it’s actually just technical stuff and not even that difficult.

I feel ppl like you act in very bad faith, but you also claim crypto isn’t even financial infrastructure, so perhaps you’re just clueless.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by polygamous_bat on Saturday April 22, 2023 @10:40AM (#35667023)
> I feel ppl like you act in very bad faith, but you also claim crypto isn’t even financial infrastructure, so perhaps you’re just clueless.

You did not present any argument in your defense beyond "I looked at it, trust me br0", and then claimed the person you're responding to is acting in bad faith.

However, the Bayesian in me says that (from a simple search on, say, youtube or twitter), anyone who is extolling the virtues of crypto is highly likely to be selling me something worthless, and thus acting in bad faith. How do you expect people to reconcile these facts?

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yellowapple on Saturday April 22, 2023 @12:16PM (#35668060)
> You did not present any argument in your defense beyond "I looked at it, trust me br0"

Neither did the other person.

> However, the Bayesian in me says that (from a simple search on, say, youtube or twitter), anyone who is extolling the virtues of crypto is highly likely to be selling me something worthless, and thus acting in bad faith. How do you expect people to reconcile these facts?

Opinions are not facts.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by polygamous_bat on Saturday April 22, 2023 @02:22PM (#35669490)
> Opinions are not facts.

Wouldn't expect bagholders to know the difference.

However, if you read my comments carefully, you'll see that I described an experiment that anyone can repeat and reproduce to come to their own conclusion.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yellowapple on Sunday April 23, 2023 @12:51PM (#35677926)
An activity derived from anecdotes and confirmation bias is many things, but a useful experiment ain't among them.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by polygamous_bat on Sunday April 23, 2023 @02:14PM (#35678915)
> An activity derived from anecdotes and confirmation bias is many things, but a useful experiment ain't among them.

Thankfully I'm not a bagholder whose sinking bags rely on shilling and pump and dumping 24/7 on online forums, otherwise I would never have developed observational/experimental skills.

Just as a helpful summary, this is the conversation we're having:

A: Crypto Twitter/YouTube is full of shills and scammers.

B: But that's just like, your opinion, man!

A: Actually no, anyone can experience it for themselves.

B: Ehh, that's still SUBJECTIVE EXPERIENCE. I only bow to OBJECTIVE TRUTH.

A: ???

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yellowapple on Sunday April 23, 2023 @05:22PM (#35680770)
I mean, yes, that is quite literally just your opinion, man. Ain't nowhere else for this conversation to go, really. Would you like to try having a discussion with some semblance of good faith instead of insisting "everything I don't understand is a scam and my subjective experiences are objectively correct and perfectly reproducible because I say so"?
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by polygamous_bat on Monday April 24, 2023 @04:25AM (#35684977)
> "everything I don't understand is a scam"

Ah, the classic "Few understand" attack of the buttcoin pumpers. I fear this may be hopeless, but for anyone else following this thread, I've worked at a DeFi startup during the now famed DeFi summer, and resigned soon after the company narrowly escaped the Terra Luna meltdown despite my repeated warnings.

So I understand the nature of this scam very well, probably better than the shiller above.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yellowapple on Monday April 24, 2023 @06:12AM (#35685631)
> Ah, the classic "Few understand" attack of the buttcoin pumpers.

You can actually demonstrate proper understanding of things rather than continue the same old tired "I can cherrypick a couple scammers therefore the literal entirety of a whole category of technology and financial instruments must be a scam" at your leisure.

> I've worked at a DeFi startup during the now famed DeFi summer, and resigned soon after the company narrowly escaped the Terra Luna meltdown despite my repeated warnings.

Good for you. That doesn't mean your experience is representative. Not sure how many times you have to be informed that anecdotes are fundamentally flawed evidence-wise before it starts to stick.

> probably better than the shiller above.

You can name the thing I'm allegedly "shilling" at your leisure.

In the meantime, anyone else following this thread can see full well that you have no substantial argument here other than "crypto bad, my anecdotes matter more than your anecdotes, anyone who disagrees with me is a bagholder shill". If you've got nothing else to add beyond the same bullshit folks have been parroting for more than a decade now, then I rest my case.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yashg on Saturday April 22, 2023 @04:28PM (#35670619)
Crypto crowd suffers from confirmation bias and are a classic example of the Dunning–Kruger effect. Any research that doesn't conclude the greatness of crypto is not valid research.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yellowapple on Monday April 24, 2023 @01:22AM (#35683964)
Anti-crypto crowd suffers from confirmation bias and are a classic example of Dunning-Kruger effect. Any research that doesn't conclude the worthlessness of crypto is not valid research.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by xk_id on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:18PM (#35671435)
I mean, ignorance is worthless too. You’re still getting scammed by trusting the skeptics blindly, you just get scammed intellectually instead of financially.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by Eisenstein on Saturday April 22, 2023 @10:34AM (#35666969)
> But i was curious so i looked at the “mumbo-jumbo” myself and turns out it’s actually just technical stuff and not even that difficult.

I don't see how this refutes anything above. Just because it is technical doesn't mean it isn't a gambling den and that it isn't being used to fleece suckers.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by thehumanmeat on Saturday April 22, 2023 @10:46AM (#35667083)
Just because it is a gambling den, doesn't mean there aren't truly revolutionary ideas and projects in there. Same as 2000 tech.

The argument can go both ways.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by Eisenstein on Saturday April 22, 2023 @10:59AM (#35667220)
Sure, there could be. Where are they and what have they revolutionized besides gambling?
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yieldcrv on Saturday April 22, 2023 @02:05PM (#35669322)
I think that question relies on looking at how any infrastructure that gets mentioned also supports the people gambling. And then it relies on "revolutionizes" to be a greater improvement than an arbitrary metric.

Reason I point that out is there are somethings I like, that I don't find comparable t o other services and just convenient, not necessarily revolutionary.

For example, give me a cloud platform that has the same pricing structure for developers. The pricing structure is that I only pay once application deployment, and then get unlimited reads at any amount of bandwidth for free, and all my users pay to update my variables and database, instead of me. That's not the case with GCP, Azure, AWS and anything non-blockchain that I've looked at. I like that development environment. I like that the users are willing to pay and have an insatiable demand of doing so. I don't care that the same application could work at orders of magnitude greater throughput on other cloud systems when the users now have to be found and then go through a 12-step funnel to be convinced to use credit card rails. So that observation is going to continue attractive developers and their whole networks.

I enjoy the instant collateralized lending. That's revolutionary in the sense that the speed is light years better.

I enjoy the price discovery that allows for the instant collateralized lending.

I enjoy the free and standardized API access that allows for the price discovery.

I enjoy being able to chain actions across distinct services. Especially consequential financial actions, but also not necessarily.

I enjoy being able to simulate the state of the entire economy, to see what affects what. Since you can branch off of a blockheight and prod locally.

I like that there's enough people there for any of this to matter. I'm not someone that needs the "revolutionizes" and "a billion users" goal posts. I think its right for people to be disillusioned by crypto enthusiast's ideological claims. Its still financial services, merely because there are finances to service. The same as how the non-crypto financial services industry works (the largest industry on the planet). It doesn't have to have utility to you, it just needs to reduce friction for the people that are already there, and there are lots now.

This doesn’t require the decentralization or chains, just the same development environment and distributed use of it amongst many organizations. But without the speculation component and confidence in the system, that won’t happen.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by Eisenstein on Saturday April 22, 2023 @03:29PM (#35670151)
Are those things you enjoy worth the massive transfer of wealth from many people to a few people that seems to be the result of crypto markets?
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yieldcrv on Saturday April 22, 2023 @04:02PM (#35670397)
Yes, it is worth it. Crypto doesn't aim to solve what you just described about every market. Crypto has the same distributions seen in other markets and economies.

Crypto just lets you watch it in real time. The efficacy of its transparency selling point is actually at the crux of criticisms.

Whether its simple noticing there’s a big market for collectibles, but pretending crypto’s version of collectibles are uniquely speculative problems.

Or seeing that the cryptocurrencies have wealth consolidated in the hands of a few, as if that undermines something about an infinitely divisible asset, while the criticism is describing state currencies.

We can see the phishing attacks and hacks globally, compared to not being able to see and quantify that outside of crypto, we choose not to make an international headline every time someone falls for a scam outside of crypto.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by Eisenstein on Saturday April 22, 2023 @07:38PM (#35671898)
> Crypto has the same distributions seen in other markets and economies.

I find that very hard to believe without data.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yieldcrv on Saturday April 22, 2023 @08:35PM (#35672225)
you need proof that the 1% own the lions share of the currency in both systems?

I think you can corroborate that easily, you’ve put your attention on the verifiable aspect of crypto and can already see the consolidation

You haven’t seen the headlines about the traditional reality in a place you respect?

Seems like thats the only missing piece for that specific criticism.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by Eisenstein on Saturday April 22, 2023 @10:24PM (#35672781)
~2,000 addresses own ~45% of all bitcoins.

* https://bitinfocharts.com/top-100-richest-bitcoin-addresses....

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yieldcrv on Saturday April 22, 2023 @11:12PM (#35672995)
and the top 1% owns over 50% of all wealth

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-10-08/top-1-ear...

https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/wealth-inequality-o...

Pick whichever source you respect more so

A) we know its the same distribution with bitcoin

B) now you know its the same distribution as with other markets

C) knowing that and knowing that bitcoin didn't set out to change that, lets us focus on other things within the crypto ecosystem

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by Eisenstein on Sunday April 23, 2023 @02:31AM (#35673862)
The top 1% of the USA which you linked about is over 1.3million people. As opposed to fewer than a few thousand? And bitcoins can't don't inflate, so... those 2000 addresses (probably only 50 to 100 people, at most) own most of the bitcoins, forever. I don't think you realize how big of a deal that is.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yieldcrv on Sunday April 23, 2023 @09:26AM (#35676046)
its an infinitely divisible asset, and nodes can debate tail emissions all they want without any input from old holders. and it also depends on what you care about, what do you care about that makes you care about that? something about bitcoin being a universal reserve asset or something? because that has nothing to do with anything I care about.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by Eisenstein on Sunday April 23, 2023 @06:47PM (#35681484)
Sure. Convince yourself that that an infinitely worse system is an improvement on a system that is already terrible. Either you are entrenched due to sunk cost fallacy, libertarian brain-rot, or you are naive. I hope the lesson you end up learning doesn't cost too much in the end.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yieldcrv on Monday April 24, 2023 @01:57PM (#35690924)
I told you what i like and you presented strawman arguments

The developer story is not the same as a speculator story

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by foepys on Saturday April 22, 2023 @10:13AM (#35666799)
> Just technical stuff

There is nothing technical about the biggest "stable coins" not being able to produce a single audit of their financials. The only thing they were able to show were "attestations" of USD in a bank account and even that was done by some shady accounting firms.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by thinkmassive on Saturday April 22, 2023 @12:01PM (#35667896)
Are those stable coins actually cryptocurrencies?
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by pcthrowaway on Saturday April 22, 2023 @07:50PM (#35671965)
Not sure why you were downvoted for what seems like an honest question.

Stable coins and other tokens which are not native blockchain assets are referred to as cryptocurrencies (shiba inu is one such example of this which is not a stablecoin).

Cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana, Avalanche, and a bunch more are also the native token of their blockchain. In other words, they're the primary mechanism for rewarding participants in the blockchain at the node/consensus level for their efforts, and they're also the currency used for getting transactions included into blocks on their blockchains (for paying the transaction fee, also called "gas" on many chains).

Blockchains which have the capability of running user-submitted code are said to have "smart contracts", bits of code which execute when certain conditions are met during a transaction. Most chains with smart contract functionality also include standards for deploying what are referred to as "tokens" which are essentially smart contracts which provide a conforming interface for interacting with the token and tracking the balances of users on that blockchain.

While all tokens provide the same basic interface, they can also have custom code which affects the behaviour. In the case of most stablecoins (the centralized ones), that means privileged parties who can do things like mint new tokens, or blocklist addresses from being able to transact those tokens.

USDC for example, operates by allowing users to create an account with the issuer (Circle), deposit USD, and then have Circle "mint" new USDC tokens to your address. They also let users go the other way and redeem their USDC. However, not everyone who wants to hold USDC needs to mint it; they can also buy it on a centralized or decentralized exchange (decentralized exchanges also being governed by specialized smart contracts of various types).

There are also "algorithmic stablecoins" which, in theory, don't have privileged issuers, and use various protocols to attempt to "peg" the price to the price of some stable asset / USD (these are complicated, have many different methods of operation, and are not really proven to be completely resilient at this point). UST/LUNA was the big one that exploded about a year ago, vaporizing several billion dollars over the course of a few days.

So, "stablecoins" are a cryptocurrency, but not a native blockchain asset (unless there's a chain that primarily accounts in a stablecoin which I'm not aware of), and the primary stablecoins people hear about are also not decentralized.

Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by yashg on Saturday April 22, 2023 @04:23PM (#35670573)
Just because I have a different opinion than you don't mean I haven't done my research or don't know shit. For you crypto folks the only legitimate research is the one that concludes that it is a magical cure to every problem known to mankind. You guys keep harping about doing your own research but if someone does research and conclude that it's a decentralised ponzi, you dismiss it as bad research.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by xk_id on Saturday April 22, 2023 @06:27PM (#35671480)
Surely you can appreciate how difficult it is to take someone seriously who claims to have done research, only to conclude it’s mumbo jumbo?
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by Eisenstein on Saturday April 22, 2023 @07:51PM (#35671967)
Religious people would say the same thing about non-believers.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by xk_id on Saturday April 22, 2023 @08:52PM (#35672319)
Then it’s a good thing we’re dealing with literally open source code implementing financial primitives deterministically; and not with mythological fictions.
Re:U.S. crypto exchange Coinbase secures Bermuda licence by survirtual on Sunday April 23, 2023 @09:03PM (#35682498)
Most of these people we are talking to online do not deal with code and logic. They rely on others to spoon feed them information, like little babies, but with fancy suits on. Many of them are very accustomed to the existing system working very favorably for them. They cannot comprehend how corrupt and dishonest it is, as it provides for their every want and material need. There is a lot of effort going in to discrediting crypto because it is the first genuine threat to the status quo. That sort of fundamental purification of the underlying mechanisms attacks the heart of a vast, powerful, and unimaginably corrupt piece of society.

Let the talkers talk. They are acting in bad faith by speaking as if knowing something when knowing the thing will 100% convert you to its side, unless you are a bad actor that profits off the corruption. There is a beautiful elegance to that. Since most people, I think, are "good," then naturally the conclusion is rightly just ignorance.

People who read the code and understand what the real deal looks like will profit. Fighting against math is always a losing battle.