News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by shasts on Monday April 17, 2023 @05:52PM (#35607127)
Interesting, because Indian Government recently jailed an independent fact checker for a tweet he made 4 years ago.

This new body seems to be a tool to suppress dissent and promote the fake news machinery Government and the ruling party is notorious for.

https://www.cnbctv18.com/india/alt-news-pratik-sinha-mohamma...

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:09PM (#35607308)
The “independent fact checker” you are talking about is well known for whitewashing horrific crimes done by radical Muslims in India and abroad. He was the one who manipulated a video and single handedly unleashed terrorists gunning for Nupur Sharma’s blood. Imagine a spokesperson of the ruling party is in hiding for more than 8-9 months now!
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by shasts on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:29PM (#35607502)
You got sources for this claim? If he has done anything wrong, why is he not in jail for that?
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by AverageDude on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:45PM (#35607660)
It’s the usual protocol of astroturfing. Accuse the whistleblower of something vague and discard them with name calling. Straight out of playbook of authoritarian governments. Nothing new.

I searched the name Nupur Sharma and it gave me this article which explains everything.

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-61716241.amp

It says that the fact checker shared a video of what she said.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:59PM (#35607779)
The fact that you have to search for the name shows you are not enough clued in about what is happening in India. Wish you take some time out and get the facts straight from some Indian friends to understand both side of the story. It will become a long comment, all I can say , BBC, NyTimes etc has some axe to grind with the current dispensation.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by random314 on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:25PM (#35607980)
Being Indian, I am clued in well enough.

I understand by "Indian friends" you mean upper caste Hindu Indian friends who are Modi acolytes and his primary voting demographic. Not Indian Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, Dalits or Shudras who form greater than 50% of the Indian population.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:36PM (#35608077)
No, I mean people with loads of common sense who can tell you both side of the story.

>> Not Indian Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, Dalits or Shudras who form greater than 50% of the Indian population.

Acc to you, if they are more than 50% AND not happy with Modi, why is Modi winning back to back elections and almost certain to come to power again in 2024?

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by random314 on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:10PM (#35623823)
You only need 35% to win in Indias multiparty elections.

Additionally, Muslims in Gujarat and UP have been coerced into voting for BJP candidate by threatening them with shut down of municipal services when BJP wins. This is enabled because EVMs report summary statistics from each location which the government employees have access to.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @01:43AM (#35624648)
>> You only need 35% to win in Indias multiparty elections.<<

That reinforces my point.

>>This is enabled because EVMs<<

This EVM story has been peddled by your ilk ad-infinitum but with no substance.

If that were the case, BJP should be winning all state elections right? Delhi, WestBengal, Rajasthan…

So as and when party of your choice win, EVMs are good when opposition party wins , oh they are manipulated.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by random314 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:55AM (#35626288)
Did you even read what I said? EVMs are not being tampered. But they make per polling booth data available to candidates. The BJP candidates use that summary data to withhold municipal services from constituents who didn't vote for them.

They are able to make this threat because of summary data made available by EVMs

https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/maneka-gandhi-s-vo...

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by AverageDude on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:00PM (#35633850)
He doesn’t want to read. It’s always hit and run with the fanboys of these authoritarian regimes.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by dang on Saturday April 22, 2023 @02:11PM (#35669393)
You also posted several flamewar comments to this thread. This is not ok and we ban accounts that do it.

If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by AverageDude on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:44PM (#35608146)
Please do something new than the other authoritarian shills. It’s the same playbook.

Why do you assume that everyone outside of India is incapable of understanding things on their own and need help from Indian friend? Why do you patronise? Isn’t that racist? Isn’t the that some kind of twisted supremest thinking?

I can read the stats and make up my mind on my own.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:56PM (#35608233)
Of course when you come here with a half-baked knowledge and accuse someone* of astroturfing , one has to call you out.

By your own admission, for the first time you heard Nupur’s name, you did a quick search and within minutes you reached the conclusion what you wanted to reach.

Since when asking to understand the issue in depth - rather than a 2 mins cursory look up - racism?

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by commoner on Monday April 17, 2023 @08:06PM (#35608309)
That's correct. Nupur Sharma's comments on the Times Now news channel were incendiary enough that Times Now decided to delete the video of the debate she was featured in and also issue a statement:

> Views expressed by BJP Spokesperson on Newshour@9 last night are her personal views. TIMES NOW does not endorse views of participants. We urge participants on our debates to maintain restraint and not indulge in unparliamentary language against fellow panelists.

It's not someone else's fault that Sharma decided to make those comments on live television in the first place.

https://www.jantakareporter.com/entertainment/times-now-dele...

https://twitter.com/timesnow/status/1530137204999475201

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Monday April 17, 2023 @08:18PM (#35608411)
If you watch the full debate, the Muslim panelists were continuously mocking Hindu Gods, Nupur got fed up and replied to them in the similar manner.

What this fact checker cunningly did was to edit out the Muslim panellist mocking and simply showed her part of the clip. He has a mass following in Islamic nations and it got blown out of proportion.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by commoner on Monday April 17, 2023 @08:47PM (#35608617)
Political leaders are expected to conduct themselves appropriately in public view because they are selected to represent all of their constituents. If a politician makes an appearance on live television and says something that is offensive to their constituents, they can expect political repercussions regardless of what anyone else said on the TV show.

That other people in the debate compared a Shivling (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lingam) to roadside signs and poles does not excuse Nupur Sharma from the repercussions of what she said. Sharma made comments that she knew would be offensive to a religious minority, and she was expelled from her position as the national spokesperson of the Bharatiya Janata Party because that was not the behavior the public expected from a high-ranking political figure.

https://indianexpress.com/article/india/bjp-suspends-nupur-s...

When someone like Mohammed Zubair makes a supercut of Sharma's comments to highlight the fact that a politician is not appropriately representing her constituents, it's not Zubair's fault that Sharma made those comments in the first place.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Monday April 17, 2023 @09:12PM (#35608773)
At the end of the day one is a human being who gets triggered on repeated offensive things. If you look-up, what she said was not incorrect since several Islamic scholars make the same claim. I guess the aggressive tone in what she said made all the difference.

For the record, Nupur does not represent any constituents in the purest sense. She was the spokesperson, that’s it. She is neither an MP nor MLA.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by fellellor on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @03:07AM (#35610873)
She should be able to say anything she wants on Islam and Muhammed. The only consequence to her should be what is in the Indian Penal Code, and ostracisation by her constituents. She doesn't deserve to be lynched by a muslim mob for that.

People like you who justify mob lynching don't belong in civilised society.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by commoner on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @06:52AM (#35612274)
Sharma made incendiary comments on live television. Zubair and many other people called her out for her comments, and in response, her political party (the BJP) expelled her from her position as national spokesperson. She was not "lynched".

When a politician chooses to make incendiary comments that are then met with anger from the public, that politician has nobody to blame but herself for the negative response.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by fellellor on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @08:32AM (#35613120)
Gaslighting at it's finest right here. Nupur Sharma can never live a normal life. The moment her security is removed, and whereabouts are known she will absolutely get murdered by some Muslim fanatic, just like Kamlesh Tiwari.

This is mentally sick.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by commoner on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @09:44AM (#35613914)
You're abusing the word "gaslighting". Nobody is claiming that Nupur Sharma deserves any retribution beyond expulsion from her position.

High-profile figures are more vulnerable than average individuals and it is not in anyone's interest to make incendiary statements that expose themselves to higher security risks. Sharma should have taken this into consideration before saying what she did on national television, even though any violence against her would be unjustified.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:30AM (#35615334)
>> Nobody is claiming that Nupur Sharma deserves any retribution beyond expulsion from her position.

This is your assumption. They are baying for her blood. These Islamic fanatics have already tried several attempts on her. In one case even two Pakistan trained terrorists were employed for the job. Intelligence bureau caught hold of them in time.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by fellellor on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:50PM (#35624054)
It is not even an assumption. GP knows what is happening and is trying to convince any potential audience that the only consequence of "exposing" Nupur's speech is a loss of position.

The speech happened in the national media by the way so there was nothing to expose, but the intention was to turn the attention of muslim lynch mobs on her.

This is literally gaslighting. They are trying to say whatever happened is her fault and not the consequence of a social media influencer framing her utterance (which is a hadith quotation btw) as blasphemy.

GP is literally scum.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @02:01AM (#35624746)
>> They are trying to say whatever happened is her fault and not the consequence of a social media influencer framing<<

That’s their tried and tested modus-operandi. You check any major terror incidents in India or abroad, Islamists use the same playbook.

If they are mocking someone’s religion it is their “freedom of speech” , if it is the opposite, Charlie Hebdo or Nupur Sharma will be done to you.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by commoner on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:32AM (#35626166)
I was responding to your false accusation of "gaslighting". Nobody, as in "nobody in this HN conversation", is calling for violence against Nupur Sharma. The BJP expelled her from her position as national spokesperson because she is no longer a suitable representative for the party.

What Nupur Sharma did is like what Todd Davis, the CEO of LifeLock, did in 2010. Davis published his social security number on LifeLock's website and on billboards to promote his business, only to end up having his identity stolen 13 times. Was the identity theft justified? No. But, should Davis have known better than to do that? Yes.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1358932

As a seasoned politician, Nupur Sharma chose to make incendiary comments that she knew would offend followers of another religion in a country with a volatile religious environment, and the people she targeted responded with anger. Her comments had a negative connotation that in no way resembles a "hadith quotation". Were the resulting threats of violence justified? No. But, should Sharma have known better than to do that? Yes.

In this thread, you have posted multiple comments violating the HN guidelines, including:

> Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.

> When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."

> Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.

The HN guidelines are here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by fellellor on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:29AM (#35627885)
So some dude getting his identity stolen is the same as having your statements pulled out of context, receiving death threats, and be forced to live in hiding for the rest of your life?

Alright.

As far as violation of guidelines goes, I disagree. I was just pointing out the glaring inconsistencies in your argument. Which are nothing short of justifying killing a person because they are perceived to have said something against Islam.

You are defending yourself by saying "Uh uh I didn't say that". But when you ignore the death threats, and don't even bother to elaborate why her statements justify the threats against her, you are actually justifying the mob. You are saying "she brought it on herself". You just can't have it both ways.

That is gaslighting.

[dead]
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by dang on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:15PM (#35634009)
I appreciate your concern for the HN guidelines and have banned the other account. However, fairness obliges me to add that you also broke the guidelines by repeatedly perpetuating this flamewar.

"Please don't respond to a bad comment by breaking the site guidelines yourself. That only makes things worse."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by commoner on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:39PM (#35634213)
Thanks, I'll be more prudent with disengaging from flamewars.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by dang on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:03PM (#35633880)
We've banned this account for repeatedly abusing HN with political, nationalistic, and religious flamewar. It's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for.

If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:26AM (#35615254)
And guess what Muslim fanatics have butchered few Hindus already on this issue. These were the normal people who simply liked or expressed support for Nupur.

The amazing thing is that even after killings, these fanatics cry victim hood.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by dang on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:01PM (#35633865)
Personal attacks will get you banned on HN, regardless of how wrong someone else is or you feel they are.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by dmix on Monday April 17, 2023 @08:50PM (#35608634)
As bad as that is, and it is helpful you've provided some context here, I still don't think that's worthy of jail or any sort of formal state punishment. Which obviously is not a controversial take in most western countries. But more importantly I don't think it's an effective strategy to deal with the problem. Censorship rarely ever works unless you go full-bore and destroy plenty of good will and legitimate human progress in between.

Twitter has a great feature for that not where citizens can provide context / 'fact check' an article without deleting it. That's the best (and IMO only legitimate way) to deal with this stuff, countering bad information with better information. While still exposing publicly that this person is lying to you. As opposed to deleting or censoring it, you put up a big flag that says "there's more to this story".

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by fellellor on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @03:03AM (#35610844)
So according to you, a non believer quoting something from the Hadith/Kuran is justifiable grounds to having them killed? Got it.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:55PM (#35607745)
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by random314 on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:29PM (#35608027)
Nupur Sharma claims.

Apparently, death threats and actual deaths and rapes should only happen to Dalits and Muslims via periodically organized riots. It's also a great idea to jail the lawyer of the survivor of a lynch mob, Teesta Setalvad. Indias Supreme court is pleased.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teesta_Setalvad

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulbarg_Society_massacre

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by screye on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:40PM (#35607608)
Altnews the left wing version of Tucker Carlson. I'd go as far as to say that if Alt-news told me there was no Earthquake in my house, my first instinct would be to find cover.

Local and politicized news in India is notoriously biased. But the direction of the bias varies from news org to news org. Somehow, American & British news orgs are notorious for giving megaphones to the worst faith actors within Indian politics.

I've found that ThePrint is the closest thing to centrist-neutral reporting in India. They are pretty open about leaning left*[1] on social issues and leaning right [2] on economic issues.

[1] The left-right division doesn't work as cleanly in India, but left for the Print means separation of church & state, live-n-let-live, individual freedoms, LGBT support, a kind of French secularism.

[2] which in an Indian context means left of Biden, but right of pre-1991 socialist India. ie. Welfare-ist, but not isolationist.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by rektide on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:17PM (#35607911)
Ok, perhaps. What about the original contention:

> because Indian Government recently jailed an independent fact checker for a tweet he made 4 years ago.

Are you contending the fact that a 4 year old tweet was used to suppress an Altnews? This ad-hominem attack may have basis, but the assertion that there is very filthy gross things being used to suppress doesn't seem to have been addressed.

And it seems like gross government indecency from where I stand. You're talking about ethics in journalism, but this seemingly is a case of government jailing & taking away someone's right, which seems like an act that requires a much much higher standard of conduct than antagonistic-left journalism.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by random314 on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:22PM (#35607958)
> Altnews the left wing version of Tucker Carlson

And the Modi apologist shows up because Altnews has been fact checking right wing misinformation for several years now.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by commoner on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:43PM (#35608138)
Alt News is much more similar to Rappler, a Filipino news website and fact checker whose founder (Maria Ressa) was awarded the 2021 Nobel Peace Prize after she was arrested and convicted by the Filipino ruling government for "cyberlibel" in retaliation for her journalism.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rappler

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maria_Ressa

The Peace Research Institute Oslo nominated the Alt News founders (Mohammed Zubair and Pratik Sinha) for the 2022 Nobel Peace Prize after Zubair was jailed for "hurting religious sentiments" in retaliation for his journalism.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohammed_Zubair_(journalist)

https://www.prio.org/nobelshortlist

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by screye on Monday April 17, 2023 @08:13PM (#35608365)
Oh yes, the Nobel Peace Prize, famously awarded to people who never commit war crimes.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by commoner on Monday April 17, 2023 @08:22PM (#35608453)
"Hurting religious sentiments" by tweeting a screenshot of a 1983 movie is obviously not a war crime. Zubair is a journalist who was jailed for spurious reasons:

> Retired Supreme Court judge Justice Deepak Gupta on Tuesday said that questions arise on the Delhi Police for arresting journalist Mohammad Zubair for allegedly hurting religious sentiments even as suspended Bharatiya Janata Party Nupur Sharma is still free despite making controversial comments on Prophet Muhammad, Live Law reported.

> The first information report against Zubair was based on a complaint by Delhi Police Sub-Inspector Arun Kumar, who said he was monitoring social media when he came across the March 2018 tweet after a handle named Hanuman Bhakt raised objections.

> The handle had taken objection to Zubair’s tweet, showing a hotel signboard with the name “Honeymoon Hotel” repainted to “Hanuman Hotel”. The journalist’s lawyer has argued in court that the photo is a screenshot taken from a 1983 Hindi movie.

> On Tuesday, Gupta said that nobody had complained about the movie for 40 years. “How was it [the tweet] reported based on one anonymous complaint?” he asked.

https://scroll.in/latest/1027652/questions-arise-when-police...

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by ankit108 on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:59PM (#35609810)
Mohammad Zubair is a hardcore Hinduphobe, Islamist & faux reporter funded by Soros apparatus. He was the one responsible for creating the edited video resulting in beheading threats for Nupur Sharma a BJP spokeswoman.

The Hindu phobia & Modi Derangement syndrome of western media is obvious from the recent shooting of notorious gangster Atif Ahmed. While he was responsible for 1000s of murders, extortions, kidnappings & rapes in his 30 year crime spree western media refers to him as a politician. A Politician who murdered his rival Raju Pal with Ak-47 making a sieve of his body because he won. Then he did the same to his brother Umesh Pal few weeks ago because he was eyewitness to his brothers murder.

So In India nobody takes the western media seriously except for fringe activist elements.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by commoner on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @01:12AM (#35610199)
The BJP expelled Nupur Sharma from her position as the national spokesperson of the BJP because of the incendiary comments she chose to make on live television. Mohammad Zubair made a compilation of her comments and did not change any of her words.

As the former Supreme Court judge Deepak Gupta said, one of the problems in this case is that the journalist Mohammad Zubair was jailed for "hurting religious sentiments" because he tweeted a screenshot of a 1983 Hindi comedy film, while the politician Nupur Sharma was not jailed despite her incendiary comments "hurting religious sentiments" on live television.

> “If she [Sharma] could say that…which had a much bigger propensity to incite violence… but she is not arrested, Zubair is...Then some questions do arise on the fairness of the police,” Gupta said, in an interview to Live Law.

Additionally, the fact that there is even a law that allows the government to imprison people for making comments perceived to be "hurting religious sentiments" is a serious violation of freedom of speech.

https://scroll.in/latest/1027652/questions-arise-when-police...

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/6/28/who-is-mohammed-zub...

There are plenty of articles from Western media that describe Atiq Amhed as a mobster, so your accusations are groundless. Examples:

- https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/04/17/atiq-ahmed-k...

- https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-65291781

As a former MP, Ahmed was obviously also a politician and there are plenty of articles from Indian media describing him as a politician. Someone can be both a politician and a mobster at the same time.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by fellellor on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @02:55AM (#35610799)
You lie by speaking selectively. BJP leadership was supportive of Nupur Sharma initially. Prominent Muslim figures like Nasiruddin Shah (who normally despise BJP) have come out and said that Nupur Sharma did not say anything wrong about Mohammed.

BJP distanced itself from her after they got a lot of push back from friendly Middle Eastern states. BJP are a bunch of opportunist cowards themselves anyway.

There is no case against Nupur Sharma and she only said what she said (on that TV show) after having been provoked by another Muslim panelist about Hinduism and Hindu gods.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by commoner on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @07:40AM (#35612648)
Politicians are responsible for the statements they make. Nupur Sharma is a politician who made a statement that the public took offense to, and she had to endure the political consequences regardless of what anyone else said before or after her comments. The other panelist on the debate is not a high-raking political figure and the public does not necessarily demand the same level of decorum from him.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by fellellor on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @08:34AM (#35613134)
Bullshit. No one deserves to get their life taken away from them for what they said, or live in perpetual fear of being murdered for having quoted a religious book. But that is what people like you are justifying.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by commoner on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @09:35AM (#35613803)
Nobody here is claiming that Sharma deserves to die for her incendiary comments. However, she did get expelled from her position as national spokesperson of the BJP and that is an appropriate response, considering the negative feedback she has received.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by fellellor on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @02:48AM (#35610759)
Zubair has no problems using his megaphone to turn muslim lynch mobs on people who he has differences with. Look up Nupur Sharma, the series of beheadings carried out after he spread misinformation on her, and more recently someone called Kajal Hindustani.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by commoner on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @07:30AM (#35612553)
There is no politician that is immune to criticism. Nupur Sharma made incendiary comments on live television and Mohammad Zubair has the right to quote and criticize those comments. If Sharma did not want to anger the public, she should not have made provocative statements in a public setting.

Sharma's comments did result in violence. The Supreme Court blamed Sharma for inciting a beheading that was carried out by extremist perpetrators:

> The Supreme Court Friday slammed suspended BJP leader Nupur Sharma, for her controversial remarks on the Prophet. While hearing the plea filed by Sharma seeking transfer of the FIRs against her to Delhi, the Supreme Court accused the leader of “igniting emotions across the country” with her “disturbing” remarks.

> “She has threat or she has become a security threat? The way she has ignited emotions across the country. This lady is single handedly responsible for what is happening in the country.” “She and her loose tongue have set the entire country on fire.”

> The Supreme Court said her outburst is responsible for the unfortunate incident at Udaipur, where a tailor was murdered.

https://indianexpress.com/article/india/nupur-sharma-supreme...

As for Kajal Hindustani, it looks like her situation is being handled appropriately:

> Police have registered a first information report (FIR) against a woman activist for her alleged hate speech and detained more than 50 people on the charge of rioting following a communal clash at Una town in Gujarat’s Gir Somnath that left two persons injured, an official said on Sunday, PTI reported.

> “We have registered two FIRs. One is against Kajal Hindustani for hate speech, and another against the mob for rioting," Superintendent of Police Sripal Sheshma told reporters.

https://www.news18.com/explainers/kajal-hindustani-hate-spee...

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by fellellor on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @08:37AM (#35613164)
You can keep spewing non sense like this, but people here are more literate than what you are used to. Your argument boils down to - if you insulted or are perceived to have insulted the prophet of Islam (by even quoting a hadith), then you deserve to die and live in perpetual fear of being murdered by a "ghazi".

No one cares if Nupur Sharma lost a bloody BJP job. You are justifying murder and religious fanaticism.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by commoner on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @09:29AM (#35613728)
Don't put words in my mouth. The murder is not justified and the perpetrators deserve the appropriate penalties. As the Supreme Court explained, Nupur Sharma made the incendiary statements that incited the murder. Nobody here has claimed that Sharma deserves to die for her rhetoric. Sharma knew her comments were provocative, which is why she issued her apology afterward.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by fellellor on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @12:05AM (#35624125)
She literally quoted a Hadith. What is "incendiary" according to you is her tone of quotation. As if people don't quote nonsense from other religions in a non-reverential but mocking manner. Is Islam so fragile that Muslims get provoked by "quoting a hadith"?

I am incapable of putting words into your mouth, you are just taking hilariously diametrically opposite positions in the same conversation.

She apologised after she was thrown under the bus by her party (in a cowardly manner), which got pushback on this issue from India's middle eastern partners. The Supreme Court Judge's comments on her are unprecedented and disgraceful. After having received severe criticism for those comments, the court silently provided her the same relief from prosecution that she had sought in the first place.

The next time you turn up to support islamic barbarism, at least own up to it.

Here is a link in response to all your outdated bogus links: https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/supreme-court-protects-nu...

You can do a text search on "Nupur Sharma" on livelaw as well.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by commoner on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @04:39AM (#35625852)
Nupur Sharma did more than "literally quote a hadith". She accused a religious figure of "rape" on live television, which is not a quotation of any hadith. As a politician in a country with religious tension, Sharma knew that her incendiary comments would inflame this tension.

The Supreme Court correctly assessed Sharma's comments as irresponsible and inflammatory, which even your LiveLaw link affirms:

> On July 1, a vacation bench comprising Justices Surya Kant and JB Pardiwala refused to entertain Sharma's petition. During the hearing, the bench made strong oral comments against Sharma, saying that she was "singlehandedly responsible for what is happening in the country". The bench said that being a spokesperson of a political party is not a license to make irresponsible comments. The bench had also said that the petition "smacks of arrogance that the Magistrates of the country are too small for her", and added that she should avail alternate remedies than approaching the Supreme Court. Following the critical remarks of the bench, Sharma's lawyer chose to withdraw the petition.

The fact that Sharma made incendiary comments does not justify the act of violence against her. However, as a politician, she should have known better than to inflame the people she is assigned to serve. The BJP removed her from her position because her behavior made her unsuitable for representing the party.

Your accusation that I am "supporting Islamic barbarism" is unfounded. Criticizing a politician for making incendiary statements is not the same thing as "supporting Islamic barbarism".

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by commoner on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:28AM (#35626138)
There is no hadith with the negative phrasing Nupur Sharma used in her comments. As a politician in a country with religious tension, Sharma knew that her incendiary comments would inflame this tension.

The Supreme Court correctly assessed Sharma's comments as irresponsible and inflammatory, which even your LiveLaw link affirms:

> On July 1, a vacation bench comprising Justices Surya Kant and JB Pardiwala refused to entertain Sharma's petition. During the hearing, the bench made strong oral comments against Sharma, saying that she was "singlehandedly responsible for what is happening in the country". The bench said that being a spokesperson of a political party is not a license to make irresponsible comments. The bench had also said that the petition "smacks of arrogance that the Magistrates of the country are too small for her", and added that she should avail alternate remedies than approaching the Supreme Court. Following the critical remarks of the bench, Sharma's lawyer chose to withdraw the petition.

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/supreme-court-protects-nu...

The fact that Sharma made incendiary comments does not justify any threat of violence against her. However, as a politician, she should have known better than to inflame the people she is assigned to serve. The BJP removed her from her position because her behavior made her unsuitable for representing the party.

Your accusation that I am "supporting Islamic barbarism" is unjustified and also a violation of the HN guidelines (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html). Criticizing a politician for making incendiary statements is not the same thing as "supporting Islamic barbarism".

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by CommanderData on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:12PM (#35607343)
India has one of the most robust Internet trolling, astroturfing apparatus in the world.

You will not be treated well if you criticise the government.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by Freedom2 on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:29PM (#35608018)
That doesn't match my experience. My ex-colleagues and I used to criticize the government regularly, and publicly, when I lived there, and we faced no hostility or opposition.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by theWreckluse on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:32PM (#35608050)
Been my experience too. It's annoying/sad, but not hostile.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by mrcheesebreeze on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:02PM (#35607220)
It is supposed to be against dissent, the current ruling party is straight up unironically fascist and descends from the same political party that inspired the german nationalist socialist party.

They constantly lie to the indian people to promote a possible genocide against the muslim minority.

The ruling bjp party is just another fascist party following the fascist playbook.

The ruling party promotes laughable lies like india having had nuclear technology and satellites in antiquity.

Modi and his cronies just want control, nothing else.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by nsenifty on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:37PM (#35607588)
> the current ruling party is straight up unironically fascist and descends from the same political party that inspired the german nationalist socialist party.

This is false. There is no link between the German Nazi party and BJP. If you are talking about RSS, the link comes from a quote in a book published in 1939 (well before the world found about the holocaust) by the RSS founder [0]. Admiration for Hitler and his Nazi party in the 30s wasn't unique to the RSS founder [1][2].

Golwalkar was also supportive of allies in their war against Nazis and supported the formation of Israel.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M._S._Golwalkar

[1] https://www.historyextra.com/period/20th-century/britain-ado...

[2] https://time.com/5414055/american-nazi-sympathy-book/

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by mrcheesebreeze on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:41AM (#35615507)
The bjp is descendant from the rss and is basically its replacement after it was banned, thats why I said what I said.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by mrcheesebreeze on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:45AM (#35615564)
Also Golwalkar is 100% pro-nazi, he only went against them later for gains.

"German Race pride has now become the topic of the day. To keep up the purity of the race and its culture, Germany shocked the world by her purging the country of the Semitic races -- the Jews. Race pride at its highest has been manifested here. Germany has also shown how well-nigh impossible it is for races and cultures, having differences going to the root, to be assimilated into one united whole, a good lesson for us in Hindusthan to learn and profit by." (Golwalkar, MS, “We Or Our Nationhood Defined”, Nagpur, 1939, p. 45)

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by nsenifty on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @01:20PM (#35616921)
The whole point was that most of the world was pro-nazi until the events of WW2 and the holocaust. And if you are comparing someone's views in the 30s to the current worldview, I hate to break it to you that everyone's racist and fascist, including Roosevelt, Churchill and MK Gandhi. Gandhi pretty much called for the Jews to offer themselves up to be butchered by Nazis and Arabs.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by random314 on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:17PM (#35623869)
Yes, there were so many racists, Golwalkar is actually such an honorable man :)
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:19PM (#35607412)
Since Modi came to power in 2014 there has been no civilian-terror incident anywhere across the country. During the earlier regime, bomb blasts became a quarterly event. They were so busy with corruption filling their coffers, didn’t bother about national security.

If this is “fascism” as you say, majority of the Indians are happy living under it.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by honkler on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:26PM (#35607477)
lol what? There have been plenty of Hindutva terror incidents, one as recent as the day before yesterday, when 3 men killed a couple of undertrials in front of live camera and then went on to scream the terror warcry of "Jai Sree Ram".

> If this is “fascism” as you say, majority of the Indians are happy living under it.

Do you have a sense of irony? Majority is always happy under fascism. It is the minority who matters in that case.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:35PM (#35607568)
The 2 brothers who were killed were notorious gangsters involved in 100+ cases of murders, loot, kidnapping etc. At least read-up before trying to win with your ignorance.

India has Buddhists, Parsis, Jains, Zoroastrian as “true” minorities. They don’t have any problems in India. In fact they are among the most prosperous folks. Why is that only Muslims have problem everywhere on the globe? France, US, UK, Israel and the list goes on.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by honkler on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:39PM (#35607601)
Great that you poured your heart out for others to read. Made my job much easier.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:21PM (#35607950)
The last part is a common knowledge. Don’t worry.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by random314 on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:11PM (#35623827)
It's okay to kill Muslims - this much is known and established. Actually, we could also add Sikhs and Dalits too if the situation demands it.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @01:22AM (#35624540)
Few months back, in a similar fashion a Hindu Don was encountered by the UP cops. All Hindus still supported the cops. For people like you, if the person is a Muslim irrespective of whether he is a terrorist, serial murderer he should be supported at any cost.

And don’t club Sikhs and Dalit among yourself to look good. They have a far larger contribution to society and don’t cry victimhood at any given opportunity.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by random314 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:04AM (#35625984)
Please be flexible, please think of Khalistani Sikhs and reservation grabbing Dalits demanding protection from racism in California.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:30AM (#35626146)
Khalistanis are the fringe elements promoted by your favourite country Pakistan.

Keep supporting terrorists and murderers, do whataboutery when encountered with facts and play victim after committing a crime. Over n out!

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by random314 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @05:53AM (#35626275)
Ain't no Pakistanis sponsoring Khalistanis in Canada. You forgot the Dalits and missionary Christians.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by dang on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:04PM (#35633895)
We've banned this account for repeatedly abusing HN with political, nationalistic, and religious flamewar. Regardless of how right you are or feel you are, it's not what this site is for.

Posting like this will eventually get your main account banned as well, so please stop.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by dang on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:12PM (#35633982)
We've banned this account for repeatedly abusing HN with flamewar comments, breaking the site guidelines, and ignoring our many requests to stop.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by ankit108 on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @12:28AM (#35609957)
Where was your outrage when two Hindu Sadhus holy men were lynched by Islamist mob in Phalghar & police did nothing. Now you feign outrage for notorious criminal connected with Paki ISI responsible for funding 9/11 bomber and many bombings in India. ISI most likely eliminated him to protect unravelling of their India Jihadi terror network.

Wow, human rights for your gangster criminal but not for Hindu holy men.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by sanmon3186 on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @01:20AM (#35610251)
This is failure of law and order. What bothered me is how liberal media portrayed these individuals.

The identity of individuals killed isn’t undertrials (as you rightly mentioned) or murderers or criminals, but lawmakers and MPs.

Check these headlines out.

1) https://www.reuters.com/world/india/former-indian-lawmaker-s...

2) https://www.theguardian.com/world/video/2023/apr/16/former-i...

3) https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-65290042.amp

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by throwaway_9120 on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:22AM (#35615178)
For those crying oceans, read this Twitter thread. These two “undertrials” were monsters of the worst kind who killed anyone with impunity. Shame on people who support such monsters just because they happen to share the same religion. https://twitter.com/Sanity_3/status/1647304754002010113?s=20
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by dang on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:07PM (#35633929)
We've banned this account for repeatedly abusing HN with political, nationalistic, and religious flamewar. It's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for.

If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by rektide on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @12:26AM (#35609950)
This is a pretty sorry minimum standard to elect people by.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by cubefox on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:27PM (#35607484)
> They constantly lie to the indian people to promote a possible genocide against the muslim minority.

What evidence do you have for that?

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by honkler on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:28PM (#35607493)
That India is on the highest level alert as per GenocideWatch, and plenty other institutions.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by nsenifty on Monday April 17, 2023 @06:44PM (#35607649)
Ironically fearmongering that there's an imminent genocide is one of the justifications used by the the Government for internet shutdowns and censorship. Law and order is precarious in most parts of the country and anybody can spark an unrest by sparking rumors and it spreads like forest fire causing riots and loss of life.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by sanmon3186 on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @01:28AM (#35610289)
Last I checked India is home for second largest Muslim population, and Muslim population has been growing more than other sections of societies in India.

Sure things aren’t same for Muslims post 2014 and People should raise their voice. But for every Muslim atrocity, there is one against Hindus and other religions.

Should we take comfort in that? Absolutely no, however this genocide nonsense is utter rubbish.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by fellellor on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @03:01AM (#35610834)
You should be the one presenting evidence of planned genocide. And proper evidence, not some bullshit he said she said. Maybe some leaked papers from the Indian Government showing attempt to arm mobs, moving battalions of the military or the paramilitary expressly for the purpose of mass murder etc.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by jaldhar on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:12PM (#35607877)
“the current ruling party is straight up unironically fascist and descends from the same political party that inspired the german nationalist socialist party.”

Oh can we stop with this bullshit? In hindsight Nazism is an almost cartoon like singular epitome of pure evil but in its day it was considered by many throughout the world not just in India to be a cutting edge political philosophy whose ideas were to be taken seriously.

Nazism like many other ideologies including some varieties of Hindutva was an offspring of 19th century Romanticism. The idea of one’s culture having a primitive yet glorious mystical past was appealing to many freedom fighters the world over and implied nothing about their feelings towards Jews or German expansion etc. Similarly the superficial adoption of e.g. the swastika doesn’t imply Germans were rushing to make a yatra to the Himalayas.

In fact the most prominent example of a “Nazi” Indian is not any RSS member but Subhash Chandra Bose. His nickname Netaji is a direct translation of “fuehrer”! He died in the Burmese jungles where, bankrolled by Berlin, he was trying to open an attack against the British colonial regime. However he wasn’t so much pro-German as he was anti-British. And that’s how India remembers him; as a freedom fighter. A couple of years ago he briefly came into the news in the US because Saikat Choudhary (the architect of the Democrat party’s “Green New Deal”) wore a t-shirt with his picture on it. When a “fascist” is on an ultra-leftists apparel, the word fascist has lost all meaning.

I’ll leave you with an assignment. Find out about the prominent Indian Muslims of they 1930’s who made pro-Nazi comments. It’s an interesting historical exercise (especially their reasons why.) but I don’t think it would reveal much about the views of todays Muslims. Do you?

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by dragonwriter on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:38PM (#35608093)
> In hindsight Nazism is an almost cartoon like singular epitome

Not that singular, even in its time, which is why we usually call the more general thing that it is an example of by the name of its Italian contemporary and ally.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by random314 on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:30PM (#35608037)
Whataboutism is not the awesome argument you think it is.
Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by jaldhar on Monday April 17, 2023 @07:46PM (#35608167)
Argumentam ad Hitlerum isn't awesome either.

Let me restate my point. A persons reasons for supporting the Nazis in 1933 may be quite different from the reasons you think people are pro-Nazi in 2023. So such comparisons don't add very much to the discourse.

That's not whataboutism right?

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by dang on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:10PM (#35633965)
It looks like you've been using HN primarily for political/national/religious/ideological battle. That's not allowed here, regardless of what you're battling for or against.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

We ban accounts that cross this line (for more explanation see https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...), so please stop doing this.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by dang on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:09PM (#35633951)
We've banned this account for repeatedly the site guidelines and abusing HN for political and ideological battle. That's not allowed here, regardless of what you're battling for or against.

If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

Re:Indian government empowers itself to “fact check,” delete... by amriksohata on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @02:28PM (#35617904)