And yet some people seem to mind these laws. But why would they, if it never happens?
It's insane, as you very well put it. They can't get a tattoo, too permanent, but they can get their tits chopped off. Makes total sense, yeah.
You keep trying to move the goalposts, because it's makes for more shock value to talk about operations. But the reality is that operations are a last resort, and one often brought forward due to immense mental harm for patients for whom blockers have not been an option. They are examples of the entirely predictable of the kind of brutally inhumane policy you've been arguing for by opposing blockers.
Think banning them will work? Trans people have been dying from illegal and unregulated surgeries for decades because it's for many been preferable to staying how they are.
Denying desperate people treatment is evil.
Time marches on in the human body, whether we like it or not. Now, show me a "perma-kitten," a cat developmentally frozen in full kittenhood, behaviorally and all (something I think would be immensely popular with some crowds) and then undo it, only then will you be close to this pause button which puberty blockers cannot well emulate.
Plus, on top of the medical risks, starting on puberty blockers will make confused kids who didn't need them more likely to get surgeries later. That's bad, and yes, it's a trade off between not unnecessarily medicalizing confused kids and "helping" "real dysphoria" cases earlier. And I'm telling you very clearly that the answer depends on how many there are of those, but you don't want to engage with the question. Because there just aren't that many "real dysphoria" cases.
And let me preempt your next bad argument: No, a doctor can't tell them apart. That's where we are now, and they get a "dysphoria stamp" after a visit. The incentives are not aligned, they just want the money.
The goal posts have always been firmly on "Don't mess with children". I've told you many times, nobody cares what adults do, sex change surgeries have been around for a long time and nobody cares. Nobody wants to ban them on adults.
But don't mess with kids.
So if you actually believe what you write, then you should be in favour of puberty blockers as an option when medically indicated.
Did you read it another way by accident?
And to answer your question, no, I believe that such matters should largely be decided between doctor and patient. I do not think that highly polarized politics should be driving medical decisions, and that medical ethics boards are much better suited to make policies in situations like this.
"And" is a conjunctive word. It does not mean "the same as" or "a type of." We both know that.
Have you heard about Tavistock, for example?
Trans people often don't even receive hormones until they're 16, I don't know how this idea that they're receiving surgery on a whim makes any sense to anyone.
The blockers are also said to prevent the kids from adapting to their biological gender, leading onto a path to surgery.
I am amazed how willing to lie people are in this forum.
> The blockers are also said to prevent the kids from adapting to their biological gender, leading onto a path to surgery.
Ah, "it is said".
> I am amazed how willing to lie people are in this forum.
Maybe drop the unfounded accusations when you're the one attacking someone for a claim they've not made.
Most people who believe they are trans actually grow out of it. Puberty blockers (and also testosterone) have severe side effects (or main effects). Therefore more harm is done by overprescribing them.
There is not even scientific evidence yet that trans people actually exist (as in somebody born in the wrong body somehow).
"Ah it is said" - yeah in the same way that "it is said" that withholding puberty blockers causes harm and whatever else you claim.
That’s literally satanic by the way. Not just in an abstract overcoming-the-image-of-god kind of way. No, explicitly theory and praxis. As is the (ritual) abuse of children (and a number of other deliberately disturbing acts). But thank Pale Blue Dot, in a post-Epstein world we don’t have to worry about such things anymore!
Citation needed. They're _designed_ to permanently turn people into bad simulacra of the other sex?
> That’s literally satanic by the way.
What? Even if that were true, who cares? Your particular religious beliefs are irrelevant.
Imagine thinking you can mess with processes as complicated as human development without permanent negative consequences. Stop parroting the propaganda which we are all perfectly familiar with and educate yourself. There is already plenty of testimony by “detrans” boys and girls who deeply regret what’s been done to them by people around them, activists, and industry.
You're at least the second person to say "do your research" rather than offer up some evidence. In my experience, that's the mark of a conspiracy theorist.
But I could easily be wrong. Have you got any papers on puberty blockers that support your position?
> Yeah, it’s shockingly immoral to not give children drugs that have existed for something like 0.01% of human existence.
Appeal to nature fallacy?
Last year, at 25, she suffered a seizure that resulted in a cracked vertebra.
“It was the most intense pain I felt in my entire life,” Ward said.
Then came another diagnosis: osteoporosis.
---
Appeal to nature fallacy?
Back when we had shared classical and religious education people would be familiar with the ancient notions of hybris, pride, and playing God. Today, here, that’s like talking to fish about water. Not that the fish don’t get thrown out of the water, happens all the time, but memories are so awfully short and the incentives to look away and forget are so strong.
You're at least the second person to say "do your research" rather than offer up some evidence.
Educate yourself is a standard phrase of the woke you should be familiar with but I guess we’re just going to pretend 2020 didn’t happen.
In my experience, that's the mark of a conspiracy theorist.
They cleaned up the Epstein operation in broad daylight and people still say stuff like this. In my experience, that's the mark of a mark.
What is the argument here? Drugs haven't existed for long, so it's okay to prevent people from using them? I'm sure we can all agree it would be shockingly immoral to steal cancer drugs from a patient, even if it is natural development.
It is exactly because some regret more invasive changes that puberty blockers are essential when medically indicated to allow decisions to be deferred until patients are more mature. The only one wanting "adult perverts on the internet" to decide medic issues for these kids are those arguing to deny patients medically indicated treatment.
In 2006, some researchers in the Netherlands tested an experimental treatment that would stop the development of sexed characteristics at puberty. A single study of 55 of these patients is the entire basis for the practice of what has come to be known as “gender affirming care.”
more invasive changes
The puberty blockers and hormones are a funnel not an alternative, but you know that already.
Medically indicated
Funny, because historically the big theme of “conversions” was convincing your doctor that you need them, and shopping doctors if they did not cooperate. And these days, it’s all about affirmation, treatment is typically begun almost immediately, few questions asked, backtracking discouraged. But that, too, you know already.
These are the perverts, the organized crime family you’re doing propaganda for. Hope it makes you feel all warm and fuzzy:
https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/billionaire...
Here’s a celebrated trailblazer of all this. Satanist, ritual child abuser too. Pervert doesn’t even begin to describe it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genesis_P-Orridge
At 20, Ward says she felt like her health was failing. She had muscle weakness so severe that she could barely lift her arms to wash her hair. Debilitating pain coursed through her body. Doctors puzzled over her blood disorder. She’s been hospitalized after feeling suicidal and depressed. Etc.
This stuff is as “safe” as abortion is “rare”.
Your comment also says a lot about you.
I don't feel ashamed for worrying about the unwarranted mutilation of children.
What is your excuse?
You have to turn your back on the trans children who grew into adults and pretend they don't exist to spin this lie where transition is a verb you apply to other people rather than a choice that someone makes for themselves.
Your claim that it all only happens because of these kids agencies is unsubstantiated.
How do you explain the doubling of numbers of kids who say they are trans?
And you claim nobody ever regrets transitioning, which is a lie.
Moral of the story is, people aren't lying just because you refuse to read the words written literally on the screen.
Not going to walk back that accusation that I'm a liar, now you know that you were talking about something else?
One would think this position would crumble under the overwhelming evidence but somehow it gets brought up again and again, baffling.
No children (prepubescent) are given surgeries, a tiny minority of 16 year olds are able to receive top surgeries but the vast majority can't even get hormones until late teens.
And this is supposed to be an argument for "it never happens"? You don't see a problem with confused girls who are still coming to terms with their bodies having medically unnecessary surgery to have healthy organs removed? And yes, some of them are regretting that when they grow up. Some of them are even willing to speak up. But I'm sure you will not listen.
If not, can you clearly differentiate between these cases?
But I somehow get the feeling that's not a good thing for everyone.
> And yes, some of them are regretting that when they grow up. Some of them are even willing to speak up. But I'm sure you will not listen.
You do realize this is literally the spotlight fallacy. 99% have no regrets, 1% do, you would like to focus entirely on the 1% to the point of obsession.
How about listening to the 99% who don't have regrets? Why are you so eager to ignore the majority of the people this actually concerns, instead patronisingly deciding you know what's best?
I've seen a parent shun their 3-year old for playing dress-up -- "I can't love you if you do this". That's pushing gender ideology. My kid's grandparents started asking him if he has a "girlfriend" at around 4. That's pushing a sexual ideology.
You don't need to be religious to buy into dogmatic misinformation campaigns, no.
Actually, we call it "instinct". You know, how animals know to have sex with each other and make babies.
It's hilarious anyone can refer to it as ideological with a straight face. It's disingenuous.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-11377391/Age-just...
2. You're kinda proving my point; the Daily Mail is one of the sensationalist tabloids that were flogging the Satanic Panic bullshit back in the day.
Show me the lies in the article instead of attacking the publisher. Bad faith argument.
Why bother loving your kid for who they are when you can just ask the docker to slice them up before they can consent? Or deny them access to Healthcare based on your own feelings because you really like your kids genitals...
/s
Or push "gender affirming care" on your kids based on your own feelings because you really don't like your kid's genitals...
Grooming is absolutely a thing. It is well recognized that kids are not capable of making many kinds of decisions. Most people also don't end up doing what they imagined as a kid.
How about we support kids for being what they are and teach them to do the same without making permanent changes to their bodies (which includes hormone blockers) before they even had a chance to grow into the bodies they have. And yes, the same should go for traditional but unnecessary surgeries - bringing that up is not some kind of gotcha.
How about we dismantle unneccessary gender roles and stereotypes instead of encouraging people to get surgery because they don't like what society expects of their gender.
It just doesn't seem to be about facts at all.
The apparent fact that the people who are pushing for personhood of embryos and rage against people reading a book in drag seem perfectly fine with male genital mutilation really highlights that this isn't about the welfare of the children at all.
As the father of a young son: damn, people are stupid.
(Advertising works on me, too).
Children _can_ receive puberty blockers, which _by definition_ are 100% completely reversible. The process to start treatment is universally difficult and involves multiple years of therapy and concurrence of multiple medical providers over time.
Source: https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2022/aug/10/ron-desant...
As to the real risks, time and again it has been shown that the comparative risks of a) receiving puberty blockers vs b) growing up a gender you do not feel you are, strongly points to puberty blockers being a significant net benefit. Those taking puberty blockers rarely regret it; whereas those growing up a gender they do not identify with mostly regret it are are significantly more prone to abuse, mental health issues and suicide.
The issue here is manipulation of children. If children were fed tons of harmful pain blockers, there would be a "panic", too.
It's because acetaminophen is extremely hepatotoxic at levels not very far above the recommended dosages.
> Hepatic injury and subsequent hepatic failure due to both intentional and non-intentional overdose of acetaminophen (APAP) has affected patients for decades, and [...] remains a global issue; in the United States, in particular, it accounts for more than 50% of overdose-related acute liver failure and approximately 20% of the liver transplant cases.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4913076/
I would assert that acetaminophen is far more likely to be dangerous to far more children than puberty blockers and yet I don't see any moral panic over children's Tylenol.
https://chiro.org/pediatrics/ABSTRACTS/Acetaminophen.shtml
Is that enough?
Maybe this story had some details. https://www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-i-was-saving-trans-kids
In the UK they had to close a gender clinic (Tavistock) when all the misconduct became public.
And Tavistock was not doing surgeries.
Many of those kids who are given hormones will end up getting surgery, as blocking hormones is also said to block the process of people settling in their "gender".
And of course a lot of the kids given hormones will end up getting surgery, because their dysphoria is highly unlikely to resolve itself with or without hormones and for those whose dysphoria does not resolve surgery will be the best option for many - hence the very low regret rates.
And hence the drive to get puberty blockers to delay the need to decide on either.
You're buying into a hysteria founded on ignoring the actual and immoral harm being inflicted on trans youth by those seeking to deny them care in order to try to pretend they mostly don't exist. It's at best deeply misguided, at worst deeply bigoted.
Since most people end up not actually being trans, more people are now hurt by pushing transitioning as the solution for everything.
And you absolutely can not deny that it is being pushed.
It is not being pushed.
I'm on my phone so I can't back that up, but we've already established in this thread that is sufficient grounds to be believed.
Not sure how you manage to live in so much denial, but if you can truly pull it off, congratulations! May it work out well for you!
Unclear how many of the kids who receive hormones end up getting surgery.
And yet you're arguing for denying them the option that'd reduce the demand for these surgeries.
And you don't know how many are pushed into surgeries later by the hormone blockers, which already have irreversible effects themselves.
And numbers also haven't tripled in a few years just because society is more accepting or whatever (while we supposedly have a moral panic against it, too).
This is such an absurd statement. You don't "define" how the body works.
No, girls as young as 12 years old are getting 'gender affirming' double mastectomy, because they say they want to be boys. This has been published in the medical literature.
14 isn't a child anymore? Your left-leaning political fact checking source sucks. Here's some reading for you. Do some real research.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-11377391/Age-just...