Of course some adaptations are more likely than others, but from a pedantic point of view "use sparingly" is all we have.
These are all human issues, the “archea-bacteria” wouldn’t care what we called it, but fun to think about.
what do you know what it would have to do? sure, bleach dissolves bacteria cell walls, so for a change to make bleach coming into contact with cell walls not dissolve them would make the cell walls not belong to a bacterium, but what if the bleach that you apply to a surface to kill bacteria is prevented from making contact with the cell wall of a bacterium through some unforeseeable adaptation of that bacterium? now it's resistant to bleach but still a bacteria, and now it's out-reproducing other bacteria.
what adaptation would cause that? no one could say, it's _unforeseeable_.
the actual situation of interest isn't bleach coming in contact with bacteria, it's humans trying to disinfect surfaces by applying bleach.
Yeah, they'd be archaea instead of bacteria, which is a huge taxonomic leap, but they'd probably make you just as sick as before.
The naming hierarchies of taxonomy are somewhat justified within eukarya because we have family trees, but when you only have one parent and get your genetic diversity via horizontal gene transfer with your peers, taxonomy is just the words of silly humans.
I wouldn't be surprised if mutations happen that take populations across that boundary all the time. It happened at least once, what are the odds of it happening only once?
-----
New-cell-wall technology aside, I think there are other reasons to avoid frequently creating unnecessary sterile zones. At those zones' boundaries you're creating situations that favor rapid recolonization, neighbors-be-damned, potentially at the expense of equilibria-seeking behavior. Fewer Ghandis more Ghengis Khans.
There's a great radio-lab podcast (titled Argentine Invasion) which describes how conditions like these (regarding a floodplain, in this case) lead to the evolution of an especially ruthless species of ant. It seems likely to me that you'd see the same thing in bacteria populations that are frequently partially obliterated.
One thing some bacteria can do is create spores. These are a main reason various disinfectants, including dilute bleach mixtures, say they kill 99.999% of germs, and not 100%. Spores are highly, though not totally, resistant to damage. They can even survive autoclaving at standard autoclave temperatures and pressures. But making spores is the equivalent of sticking baby Superman in a pod and sending him to Earth. Spores are the next generation, the adult generation still dies.
There are apparently better chlorine disinfectants than bleach which show good activity against spores: https://www.cdc.gov/infectioncontrol/guidelines/disinfection...
> Alternative compounds that release chlorine and are used in the health-care setting include demand-release chlorine dioxide, sodium dichloroisocyanurate, and chloramine-T. The advantage of these compounds over the hypochlorites is that they retain chlorine longer and so exert a more prolonged bactericidal effect.
> In vitro suspension tests showed that solutions containing about 140 ppm chlorine dioxide achieved a reduction factor exceeding 10^6 of S. aureus in 1 minute and of Bacillus atrophaeus spores in 2.5 minutes in the presence of 3 g/L bovine albumin. The potential for damaging equipment requires consideration because long-term use can damage the outer plastic coat of the insertion tube. In another study, chlorine dioxide solutions at either 600 ppm or 30 ppm killed Mycobacterium avium-intracellulare within 60 seconds after contact but contamination by organic material significantly affected the microbicidal properties.
Spores and biofilms. Biofilms not only protect against antibiotics but also bleach. Some of them repel water better than Teflon. https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1011033108 "The biofilm surface remains nonwetting against up to 80% ethanol as well as other organic solvents and commercial biocides across a large and clinically important concentration range."
The point is, not all autoclaves destroy everything today.
In order for evolution to function[1], there needs to be differential survival. That is to say, some variants of bacteria must survive at greater or lesser rates than other variants.
For something as strong as bleach, given sufficient concentration and working time, it's not clear to me that that effect exists. My understanding is that it's so powerful and it's means of action is so robust that is just kills everything equally.
---
1. Yes, technically evolution never stops and always functions. I guess a more precise way to word that is: in order for there to be an observable evolutionary effect.
Agreed, and I missed if this article stated otherwise. Also we have been adding chlorine (the active ingredient in bleach) to our water supply for over 100 years ago and that experiment hasn't produced resistant microbes AFAIK.
I wouldn't tell someone to bring their own soap unless they're travelling to a 3rd world country. It's quite reasonable to expect basic hygiene products to not destroy your hands.
> No matter what anyone complains about they won't stop putting it in all the bathroom soap dispensers in our office.
Sounds like someone in HR just is ignoring the requests. Someone should call OSHA.
> Whenever anyone says "you can just," they're probably being unreasonable and not understanding the problem.
Or they're offering a solution that they don't view as being overly difficult.
There are things like microbial cysts that are already protective in these cases but the tradeoffs for the organize are pretty large to adopt something like that. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microbial_cyst
Are you saying if you wet a commercial paper towel with plain water and drop it on some cloth it will bleach the fabric? Why would the bleaching agents still be active any more than with printer paper or toilet paper? Wouldn't these be a hazard if someone wiped ammonia with them?
But there is something I've also always found very mildly irritating specifically about unbleached brown paper towels, as well as uncoated corrugated cardboard. Just kind of like a micro-scratchiness.
I think the most famous example is that bleach (at least at normal cleaning concentrations) doesn't kill MRSA. In theory this would give it an advantage.
"List H: Registered Antimicrobial Products with Label Claims Against Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) and/or Vancomycin-resistant Enterococcus faecalis/faecium (VRE)"
"5813-50 Sodium Hypochlorite Ultra Clorox Brand Regular Bleach Clorox co."
* https://www.epa.gov/pesticide-registration/list-h-registered...
P2: Yes it does, see <points to directions on how to make tea>
P1: Most people don't bother waiting until the water boils, they just pour it on from the faucet.
People who refuse to concede gracefully are insufferable.
Bleach though remains pretty much microbial napalm, with some exceptions (prions, norovirus & C. difficile spores at the dilutions a lot of people use).
By far the bigger risk for bleach, IMO, is chemical exposure hazards.
Call OSHA, or at least threaten to do so.
Retaliation is a thing.
Over soap?
So my advice is that you don't point the gun at your employer in an attempt to coerce them into action. If OSHA intervention is necessary, just call them.
It is interesting they talk about benzalkonium chloride, that stuff absolutely destroys my hands.
When the FDA shut down triclosan all the soaps for paranoid people switched to Benzalklonium Chloride. That stuff absolutely destroy my skin. No matter what anyone complains about they won't stop putting it in all the bathroom soap dispensers in our office. I can go in with my skin fine, if I wash my hands 3x in a day they are almost bleeding by the end of the day.
Also interesting Benzalkloium Chloride last time I looked was in limbo with the FDA, they couldn't decide whether to officially approve it or ban it. They know it causes contact dermatitis. It is currently in a state where the manufacturers are preparing evidence to get it approved but yet it is allowed to be on the market.