News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Are the Risks of Cleaning with Bleach and Other Disi... by withinboredom on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:56PM (#35278695)
I think in this case it destroys the cell walls, so they’d have to completely evolve how cells work in order to evolve. Thus by definition, if they evolved to survive these substances, they’d be an entirely different organism.
Re:What Are the Risks of Cleaning with Bleach and Other Disi... by pasquinelli on Thursday March 23, 2023 @03:07PM (#35279768)
anything evolving in any way at all makes it a different organism. evolution is the word for organisms changing at the population level.
Re:What Are the Risks of Cleaning with Bleach and Other Disi... by withinboredom on Thursday March 23, 2023 @03:11PM (#35279841)
I don’t think you understand. Like it would have to evolve into an entirely different class of life, it would no longer be “bacteria” thus “bacteria” can never become resistant to it because to become resistant means that it is no longer “bacteria”
Re:What Are the Risks of Cleaning with Bleach and Other Disi... by fvold on Thursday March 23, 2023 @04:09PM (#35280608)
You can't outgrow your lineage in evolution. We're monkeys. KFC is made of dinosaurs. Anything descended from bacteria would still be bacteria.
Re:What Are the Risks of Cleaning with Bleach and Other Disi... by withinboredom on Thursday March 23, 2023 @05:51PM (#35281789)
They would change taxonomy to archea (see MatrixMan’s comment) thus no longer being bacteria.

These are all human issues, the “archea-bacteria” wouldn’t care what we called it, but fun to think about.

Re:What Are the Risks of Cleaning with Bleach and Other Disi... by pasquinelli on Friday March 24, 2023 @04:23PM (#35294920)
> Like it would have to evolve into an entirely different class of life

what do you know what it would have to do? sure, bleach dissolves bacteria cell walls, so for a change to make bleach coming into contact with cell walls not dissolve them would make the cell walls not belong to a bacterium, but what if the bleach that you apply to a surface to kill bacteria is prevented from making contact with the cell wall of a bacterium through some unforeseeable adaptation of that bacterium? now it's resistant to bleach but still a bacteria, and now it's out-reproducing other bacteria.

what adaptation would cause that? no one could say, it's _unforeseeable_.

the actual situation of interest isn't bleach coming in contact with bacteria, it's humans trying to disinfect surfaces by applying bleach.

Re:What Are the Risks of Cleaning with Bleach and Other Disi... by __MatrixMan__ on Thursday March 23, 2023 @03:24PM (#35280009)
> they’d be an entirely different organism.

Yeah, they'd be archaea instead of bacteria, which is a huge taxonomic leap, but they'd probably make you just as sick as before.

The naming hierarchies of taxonomy are somewhat justified within eukarya because we have family trees, but when you only have one parent and get your genetic diversity via horizontal gene transfer with your peers, taxonomy is just the words of silly humans.

I wouldn't be surprised if mutations happen that take populations across that boundary all the time. It happened at least once, what are the odds of it happening only once?

-----

New-cell-wall technology aside, I think there are other reasons to avoid frequently creating unnecessary sterile zones. At those zones' boundaries you're creating situations that favor rapid recolonization, neighbors-be-damned, potentially at the expense of equilibria-seeking behavior. Fewer Ghandis more Ghengis Khans.

There's a great radio-lab podcast (titled Argentine Invasion) which describes how conditions like these (regarding a floodplain, in this case) lead to the evolution of an especially ruthless species of ant. It seems likely to me that you'd see the same thing in bacteria populations that are frequently partially obliterated.