News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by kelnos on Saturday March 18, 2023 @01:18AM (#35206344)
The last time I ran SETI@home (and Folding@home), I had a fixed desktop machine that I always left on, and I think it was old enough that the fan speeds weren't variable, so it was just constant background white noise.

In that context, running those apps in the background all day and all night was fine, and if they ever noticeably interfered with performance while I was using the machine, pausing them for a bit was easy to do.

I haven't had a desktop computer in at least 14 years. When I'm not using my laptop, I close it and it goes to sleep. Running CPU-intensive apps on my laptop spools the fans up to their loudest, and makes the bottom of its chassis uncomfortably warm. The CPU cores will sometimes hit thermal throttling too. I just don't want to deal with that sort of thing all day.

Then again, I do have a couple Raspberry Pis, an old Mac Mini (running Linux), and a CM4-based NAS in various places in the house running 24/7. I could probably run an @gome-type app on one or more of those. But for whatever reason, doing so just never really occurred to me.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by ge96 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @01:48AM (#35206487)
I run fold@home I'm at 207M points... Sucks I'm in 14K range... I'll probably never hit #1 haha
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by gambiting on Saturday March 18, 2023 @03:58AM (#35207118)
I'm at 466M points and within top 10k donors.....that's just thanks to running folding@home on my own machines for the last 15 years lol.

https://stats.foldingathome.org/donor/id/9171

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by ge96 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @01:41PM (#35211302)
wow that's nuts... I don't know how many months I'd take me to catch up/by that point ahead again

15 years is insane though... I only recently started with an i9 and 3080Ti on medium/highest priority

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by dustymcp on Saturday March 18, 2023 @04:18AM (#35207248)
I just cant get a laptop i feel comfortable working on, they all have that slow feel, where a desktop is just crisp and i can always just switch out anything i dont like about the current build..
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by UberFly on Saturday March 18, 2023 @04:47AM (#35207394)
Amen brother. It's like driving on a mountain highway with the windows down compared to commuting in a subway.
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by kalleboo on Saturday March 18, 2023 @05:07AM (#35207471)
My MacBook Pro with M1 Pro is the first laptop I've had that hasn't had that slight hesitation that laptops have always had. I think this is why people praise Apple Silicon so much even though the benchmark numbers may not always back it up - so many other people are also coming from similarly-hobbled laptops.
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by seanp2k2 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @05:24AM (#35207544)
Agree, I’ll probably never buy another Intel laptop as long as AMD and Apple keep killing it with these things. I was hopeful that the Surface laptops would be good with ARM too but they’re not using the latest chips, they went for low/mid-tier performance, and Windows on ARM still sucks / relies too much on emulation to be fast. Some day maybe we’ll get REAL ARM hardware with dozens of cores, tons of memory bandwidth, USB4, and decent freaking GPUs. Sorry, but the idea of spending $2k on a laptop that runs last year’s mid-tier smartphone processor just doesn’t cut it. Maybe that’s fine for a Chromebook for schools or something.
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by sph on Saturday March 18, 2023 @05:58AM (#35207710)
I have a great desktop, and every day I curse Apple and Tim Cook because I cannot get an iPad Pro that runs full macOS.

That would be the ideal device for me when I'm on the go, that I can still use to watch Youtube videos in the bathroom. I do not need a full laptop when I work at home with a $5,000 desktop PC, nor I want to buy a crappy $300 laptop that always feels slow and underpowered.

It is really sad to have the tech to do something, but it doesn't exist because the bean counters said no.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by LoganDark on Saturday March 18, 2023 @06:55AM (#35207969)
> nor I want to buy a crappy $300 laptop that always feels slow and underpowered.

Meanwhile, the expensive laptops with actual desktop-class components have unacceptably shitty peripherals, so you can't even pay more money for what you want; it simply doesn't exist.

This is what upsets me the most about laptops.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by yafbum on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:16AM (#35209751)
What do you mean by shitty peripherals?
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by LoganDark on Saturday March 18, 2023 @06:12PM (#35213622)
Low-DPI screens, bad webcams, keyboards with the wrong arrows/numpad layout, off-center trackpads etc. it's different for each person what they consider "shitty", but laptops are always a total package deal (except for Framework) and it can just so happen that nobody makes powerful laptops that also have the exact right permutation of peripherals.

You can find all sorts of beautiful 4K ultrabooks with the perfect keyboard and trackpad layout, and great webcams too—if you don't mind putting up with a Celeron and 4GB of RAM... If you want a really modern and powerful CPU with lots of RAM, you'll be looking at the likes of Clevo and AORUS and etc. that put desktop-class parts in a thick chassis, but... that bodes terribly for the peripherals they end up using.

Some of the Clevo machines have individual gimmicks like 300Hz displays, but none of them seem to have all of "high DPI, good keyboard layout, good port arrangement, high performance". And this is true for basically all laptop vendors.

OEMs think good peripherals always equate to "thin and light" which results in bad performance, either through bad parts or bad thermals. Maybe Frore Systems' new cooling solution will help slightly with ultrabook thermals, but until that happens, laptops are just suck.

You may notice that this only matters because I even care. You may also notice that this is exactly what building a desktop is for. I am building a desktop, but I also have to build a laptop from scratch for the desktop so I can operate it from bed. Which would have been avoidable if I could've found a laptop in the first place.

The point anyway isn't to say that there aren't any good laptops out there, but rather that if you want high performance (e.g. you are bothered by slowness), you can only get it as a package deal with the rest of the laptop... obviously. But the package deals all suck. The laptop market is so annoying sometimes.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by yafbum on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:16PM (#35215683)
I haven't really been in the market for a non-Apple laptop for a while (previously had to buy MacBook bc of specific software), so this gives me a great idea of what to watch out for when I get my next laptop. Thanks a lot!
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by LoganDark on Sunday March 19, 2023 @01:11AM (#35216240)
For what it's worth, the ROG Flow X16 (2022)[0] has some good specs (8-core CPU with 3070 Ti), a great keyboard layout (with correct arrow keys!), and other niceties like a mux switch and upgradeable RAM. It is so close to perfection—but doesn't have a 4K screen, ruining the whole package.

Big reason why I dislike the market so much: the existence of that machine with only a single flaw that nonetheless ruins the value of the entire product. There's nothing else like it. It seems to be the absolute best machine the market has to offer... and it just barely misses. :(

However, the screen resolution seems to be the only problem with it, so anyone who doesn't require specifically 4K (most people) would probably find it worth considering.

[0]: https://rog.asus.com/laptops/rog-flow/rog-flow-x16-2022-seri...

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by throw6969away on Saturday March 18, 2023 @03:32PM (#35212309)
> what you want; it simply doesn't exist.

Once the patents on Apple's trackpad expire, then we'll see.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by LoganDark on Saturday March 18, 2023 @06:30PM (#35213805)
I love Force Touch trackpads more than anything. I specifically got an Apple trackpad to use with my desktop because it's so much better than anything else out there.

But having a good trackpad doesn't make up for other blunders like an annoying keyboard layout, a low-DPI screen, or etc., and you bet nobody who makes the thick and heavy high-performance machines is going to care about a good trackpad anyway.

You don't really see OEMs that put top-of-the-line hardware inside a thick and sturdy chassis, and then... add a nice 4K screen and a numpad-less keyboard and put the charging/USB ports on the left instead of the back.

The list of possible blunders is so long that you'd be hard-pressed to find a machine that hasn't been subject to most of them. That's just not how laptops work. Laptops are a package deal, all or nothing. You can't ensure every requirement individually like you can with a desktop.

And the reason I don't like the market is because nobody makes a really good one.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by philjohn on Saturday March 18, 2023 @07:41AM (#35208225)
Another option is to get the iPad (and magic keyboard and pencil) and remote desktop into your home machine.

Put it behind a VPN, use wake-on-lan and boom, iPad is essentially a fully blown computer.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by sph on Saturday March 18, 2023 @09:08AM (#35208795)
No, that would turn it into a fully blown thin client.

What is the point of having half a TB of storage, however many gigs of RAM, lidar, radar, sonar, and the best processor architecture money can buy to render a glorified, interactive video?

I would like to be able to write code without having to pay the price of internet latency. I don't need a $1000 tablet to render RDP.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by DANmode on Sunday March 19, 2023 @10:57AM (#35219611)
Termux on Android does what you're asking for, but I doubt it's what you actually want. shrugs
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by yafbum on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:20AM (#35209785)
On the other hand, there's a lot of great tech (including, I think, the iPad pro and Apple silicon) that just wouldn't exist if the bean counters hadn't said yes, it's a good idea to invest a few billions of dollars into this...
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by sph on Saturday March 18, 2023 @06:35PM (#35213858)
Uhm, allocating money to a budget doesn't create great products anymore than wishing very hard for something before blowing the birthday candles.

It's the engineers that actually create the cool things.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by yafbum on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:14PM (#35215673)
> Uhm, allocating money to a budget doesn't create great products anymore than wishing very hard for something before blowing the birthday candles.

I didn't claim that it was sufficient, but it is necessary.

> It's the engineers that actually create the cool things.

Of course. With other people's money (typically).

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by dreamcompiler on Saturday March 18, 2023 @07:49AM (#35208265)
Don't worry. Apple will figure out how to put that hesitation back in with a future MacOS upgrade. Probably with yet more phoning-home daemons in the name of security theater.

Sorry for the snark. I'm just bitter because Apple is about to ruin Dropbox because they don't allow KEXTs any more.

https://tidbits.com/2023/03/10/apples-file-provider-forces-m...

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by throw6969away on Saturday March 18, 2023 @03:25PM (#35212246)
> that slight hesitation that laptops have always had

For me just getting a low latency mouse (e.g., wired g203) and correctly configuring 100hz+ monitors has vastly improved my experience on my M1 Air and the shitty Thinkpad I use for work -- to the point where I haven't used my desktop in a long time.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by seanp2k2 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @05:21AM (#35207526)
Part of the problem is just raw TDP. There’s only so much horsepower you can squeeze out of 45-65w laptop chips. The brand new Ryzen 9 7945HX is damn fast though, with 16 real cores on a way better node size than Intel is using for their 13th gen parts that, at most, get you 8 real cores plus a 16-core Atom on the same die. Stuff like the Asus Zephyrus Duo have RAID-capable m.2 (and that one has two screens, one of which is a 16:10 with high refresh). Get something with a dedicated GPU as well, as that makes a huge difference even for desktop compositing. Despite what Intel says, integrated graphics continue to be a joke compared to even budget dedicated graphics. These mobile workstations are not going to rival 1kw desktops, but they get within 40% or so. The Intel stuff, 12th and 13th gen in particular also get bad battery life, like 4ish hours. Blame the FAA for their 100wh limit on batteries — not many laptop mfgs want to make something that you can’t technically take on a plane, even if the mall cop TSA agents wouldn’t ever notice.
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by Kye on Saturday March 18, 2023 @07:58AM (#35208329)
I lucked out with getting one of these on sale just before they went away: https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1746503-REG/lenovo_82...

The 300W power brick provides enough juice to feed both the CPU and GPU, and the laptop variant of the 3070 ti isn't too much slower than the desktop version in practical terms (I don't feel that 30% less performance). I've never tried it on battery or on the 135W USB-C power limit, but reviews report getting sufficient performance.

I don't have room for a desktop, so it's nice to not feel like I'm compromising on power with something that fits. The memory and SSDs are user accessible, too.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by seanp2k2 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @05:11AM (#35207485)
I remember when power wasn’t 51c/kWh and a powerful PC didn’t suck down >1000w. I know we get way more perf/watt these days, but I don’t feel as a user like that translates into a notably better experience. For most things for $work, Slack, Spotify, GMail, Google Docs, and VSCode feel a lot less responsive than irssi, Winamp, Sylpheed, OpenOffice, and $ide_of_choice did a decade or two ago.

What Dr. Lisa Su giveth, Satya taketh away I suppose.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by int0x2e on Saturday March 18, 2023 @07:15AM (#35208058)
We also used to write code in low-level languages, and system designs were simpler compared to our current approach of writing a lot of stuff in JS and using Electron everywhere, having a huge dependency tree and in general - optimizing for fast development rather than efficient runtime.

Having said that, optimizing for perf is rarely worth it because people don't usually care, and when it is - you can often make the biggest difference by figuring out why some step requires O(n^3) instead of O(n) like it should and fixing that, rather than rewriting the entire stack to get some 10-20% improvement...

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by bbarnett on Saturday March 18, 2023 @08:39AM (#35208607)
Someone should do an accurate figure of compute power usage, including things such as cars, or media centres, and then try to analyse how the existing trend of "wasteful development" affects this.

I bet all the upset over bitcoin power usage, is a tiny thing, compared to (for example) the whole node ecosystem.

Even something such as gmail is massively overengineered. Heck, there are very few improvements over the interface a decade ago, yet I bet it used 5% of the power it does now.

Yet think of how much gmail is used.

And it's not just raw compute. 3d on a page for no reason, massive js binaries for no reason eg ram + bandwidth.

A modern phone could last weeks as a browsing device, if looking at static html.

But all of this means more development skill, less use of fluff and junk, care for size of page loads, and on and on.

Put another way, people concerned about power usage, should realise that using node, means burning more coal/NG. Literally.

Because that's where the excess power comes from.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by andrepd on Saturday March 18, 2023 @10:25AM (#35209383)
Hit the nail on the head. Inefficiency, which has reached gargantuan proportions, and then blown past that, doesn't just mean page loads so slow that loading a news article takes upwards of 20s on a pocket supercomputer (whereas it took barely a second or two on a Pentium II on a 56kbps connection), all the while text and buttons jump around as assets are loaded. It also means very real waste of energy and battery degradation.
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by beebeepka on Saturday March 18, 2023 @01:01PM (#35210833)
I mostly agree with you, however:

> A modern phone could last weeks as a browsing device, if looking at static html

That's what I do. Weeks is a bit of a stretch. Maybe one of screen time is limited. That said, discord (the website) drains my laptop battery almost as fast as gaming does. They do spawn a separate WebGL context for each animated emoticon. Crazy, crazy thing

> Put another way, people concerned about power usage, should realise that using node, means burning more coal/NG. Literally.

Sure. At the same time, though, a single car trip to the movies burns orders of magnitude more energy than all your gadgets running JS for an year.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by redeeman on Saturday March 18, 2023 @10:16AM (#35209315)
shit like slack and other electron abominations are not just 10-20% improvement going native. We are talking a simple chat application, irc glorified to load images and preview, and this somehow takes more memory and cpu than the total resources I had in 1995 times 100.

these systems are so abominable, and people have just gotten used to it, hell, many users never even tried anything else, but saying 10-20% is just ridiculous

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by pbronez on Saturday March 18, 2023 @01:25PM (#35211118)
Man I want a native TUI client for Teams.
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by btdmaster on Sunday March 19, 2023 @07:07AM (#35217831)
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by mysterydip on Saturday March 18, 2023 @08:04AM (#35208367)
Make a windows XP VM and install some of those old versions and see how fast it runs on modern hardware (even while emulating the entire PC to run it on!). Many modern devs chose ease of development over end user efficiency/performance.
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by flangola7 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @09:57AM (#35209164)
Powers is around $0.10/kWh for residential, even lower for industrial
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by pridkett on Saturday March 18, 2023 @10:20AM (#35209345)
Power prices vary dramatically in the United States - and are even higher in most of the rest of the world.

Here’s the prices for the United States - https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.ph...

Even these data are noticeably low for my area where we had a _massive_ rate hike in January that results in total prices for electricity (generation + delivery) without an alternative supplier being up around $0.48/kWh.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by jvdvegt on Saturday March 18, 2023 @10:21AM (#35209351)
I'd pay 0,77 euro per kWh if the government hadn't introduced a 0,40 euro per kWh price cap.
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by pclmulqdq on Saturday March 18, 2023 @10:45AM (#35209508)
Big cities in the US tend to have very expensive power ($0.50/kWh or higher), while rural areas can have nearly free power, particularly if you are near a dam or a nuclear power plant. The price you're quoting is definitely not a big city price.
Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by maccard on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:56AM (#35210121)
It's closer to 50c/kWh here in the UK [0]

[0] https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/energy-bills-supp...

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by PaulDavisThe1st on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:31AM (#35209877)
> a powerful PC didn’t suck down >1000w

My Ryzen Threadripper 2950X, which isn't a top-of-the-line system at this point, but is still a 16 core beast-ish machine, sucks down (much) less than 400W

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by maccard on Saturday March 18, 2023 @11:55AM (#35210116)
My 3990x is almost 500w. My last dual socket Xeon workstation was closer to 750w.

That's before you add on a GPU. My 3080 uses 350w under load.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by HankB99 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @10:48PM (#35215490)
Are these power figures measured at the wall? If so, both are astonishing. My file server with an old Xeon, 16GB RAM and 5x 7200RPM HDDs uses about 95W when idle and about 150W when I throw something at it that works the drives. My desktop with an I7-4770K, 32GB RAM, some SSDs and a single spinner ids about the same. IIRC if I push something compute intensive at it, it can break 200W.

OTOH a Pi 4B with 2 7200RPM HDDs uses about 25W and another with an SSD uses about 7W.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by maccard on Sunday March 19, 2023 @06:56PM (#35224609)
I don't have a kill-a-watt meter handy anymore, but I do have a smart meter. Guesstimating using that, I hit ~ 850w with my threadripper when compiling and my work project and running a game at the same time, and about 650w when _just_ compiling (so presumably the difference there is GPU being under full load).

They're obviously extreme examples, but on the flip side, I've got an M1 Macbook Pro which lasts an entire day on a single charge of battery including running docker, slack, and some "mild" compiling (not large C++ projects). I'm not sure how to measure the energy consumption of it on battery, but suffice to say it's "very low".

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by wkat4242 on Sunday March 19, 2023 @11:29AM (#35219946)
51c / kWh?? I pay 20 in Spain even now with the energy crisis.

I think back in those days the price was around 10c

I know this is euro cents but the dollar exchange rate is not too big to make a huge difference.

Re:SETI@home Is in Hibernation by zitsarethecure on Saturday March 18, 2023 @10:45AM (#35209507)
Personally I no longer use laptops, and instead do 99% of my computing on a fast desktop with a great keyboard, great monitors, etc. If something breaks or needs to be upgraded, I can pop it open and get it done, usually on the same day. On the rare occasion I need to travel I'll take my smart phone and a note pad if there is some need to take notes.