News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by rascul on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:40AM (#34992409)
I would be happy if we got rid of timezones, got rid of daylight savings time, and got rid of 12 hour clocks.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by petesergeant on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:48AM (#34992450)
Do you work with people in other timezones? It’s much easier to reason about what a reasonable time is for people when you know how it centers up with noon for them.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by rascul on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:03AM (#34992550)
I do. And the math needs to be done either way, if you're trying to determine a relation to when the sun is at its peak for your area vs their area.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by Aerroon on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:16AM (#34992617)
The math would've been a lot easier if GMT+0 had been somewhere in the Pacific ocean. Going from +1 to -7 is a lot more troublesome for most people than from +11 to +19.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by bonzini on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:43AM (#34993124)
Well, it would just move the issue to Europe wouldn't it? If Europe became a -10ish time zone, they would be the one having to go from +11 to +19.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by midoridensha on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:47AM (#34993157)
Yeah, it would be nice if they made GMT the same as the international date line.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by bonzini on Thursday March 02, 2023 @05:46AM (#34994270)
The international date line is where you go from GMT-12 to GMT+11 or something similar.

So, no matter what time zone you pick as the reference, by definition the international date line is 12 hours away from your reference.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by defrost on Thursday March 02, 2023 @05:51AM (#34994300)
Except where it's -10 or +14 hours away from reference due to jogging around countries or island groups.

See:

https://www.timeanddate.com/time/map/

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by bonzini on Thursday March 02, 2023 @06:24AM (#34994508)
Yeah it zigzags a bit but it hovers on the two sides of +/-12, placing it around 0 would mean half the world operating on a work week that is shifted by one.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by petesergeant on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:19AM (#34993002)
Sure, but I work across three timezones, and I can glance up to the top-right of my computer and see all three at a very quick glance, as well as knowing when people are likely to be having lunch, whether it's early or late for someone, and so on. I'm also now quite used to "Jerry gets up early his time" for certain coworkers.

I guess you could potentially have some sort of graphic to show the same thing for sunrise vs sunset ... but as you point out, the maths needs to be done either way, so why get rid of a system that works pretty well?

DST is the real enemy here.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by wolverine876 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:03AM (#34992554)
'I'll call you tomorrow.'

'Tomorrow clock time or tomorrow after the Sun rises?'

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by scbrg on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:20AM (#34992647)
So we'd need to adjust our terminology a bit. I'm sure the world wouldn't end because of that.

It's always amusing to me how opponents of the idea of abolishing time zones assume that everything will stay the same, except, well abolishing of time zones. Apparently in the moment we do so, humanity will be become incapable of adjusting even the slightest. It will be impossible to invent a couple of new terms to let people communicate easily about time. It will be impossible to replace time zone maps and time zone aware clocks with ones that show regular office hours in different regions, &c.

For the record, I'm not even really for abolishing time zones, but the fact that the word "tomorrow" would become slightly less useful is not a particularly significant reason.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by Taywee on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:47AM (#34992826)
We spend a huge amount of our time talking about and reasoning about time. Destroying the meaning of all of the language we've built up is pretty significant. More importantly, it basically ensures that all that terminology will be vastly different when you live in different parts of the world, where the day changes in the morning vs the middle of the solar day vs the evening vs the middle of the night. Weekday names will be entirely regional, and their implications will be as well.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by mantas on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:26AM (#34993392)
Decoupling day cycle from the sun is quite a big change.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by wkat4242 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:17AM (#34992622)
I usually say "tomorrow your time or my time" :)
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by jameshart on Thursday March 02, 2023 @07:24AM (#34994846)
usually (outside of global business meetings) when you are talking to a person about making plans you are both in the same time zone. So asking ‘your time or my time’ is unnecessary.

But if we got rid of time zones, you’d need new ways to distinguish between tomorrow meaning ‘after the clock ticks over 24:00’ bs ‘after the next night cycle’ because they would not be the same thing.

To be fair the same ambiguity occurs now if you are, say, parting ways with someone after midnight and you say ‘see you tomorrow’, but you actually mean later that same calendar day.

But I think losing the ability to make use, in everyday local conversations with people in the same place as you, of concepts like ‘tomorrow afternoon’, would be kind of a dealbreaker for time zone abolition.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by RheingoldRiver on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:19AM (#34992637)
No, you wouldn't: https://qntm.org/abolish
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by rascul on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:39AM (#34992764)
Yes, I would.

If I need to call someone in their morning, I need to determine the same offset.

I have plenty experience with both ends using UTC regardless of where in the world they are. It's much easier. Either 0425 works for both or we need to adjust one way or the other. I still need to know that your schedule is four hours ahead of mine, but we don't need to do math to figure out what time 0425 is. The cognitive overhead is diminished.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by lifthrasiir on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:49AM (#34992842)
That's a pro for having UTC, not a pro for having no time zones. I believe this is the main reason that going against time zones is flawed---people don't exactly know what they are claiming!
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by rascul on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:03AM (#34992929)
When everyone works on the same timezone it's the same as not having timezones.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by lifthrasiir on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:16AM (#34992983)
The point of the parent article was that it is impossible to make everyone work on the same time zone, as they will inevitably make up their own time zones. This is not even a hypothetical example, the article explicitly mentions western China [1] where the standard time zone was so off that everyone uses an unofficial time zone instead.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xinjiang_Time

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by Juliate on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:27AM (#34993042)
But when everyone doesn’t live in the same spot on earth, it becomes tricky.

Time for living things is primarily based on the course of the sun above their heads.

Hence timezones to adjust between the local needs, and the worldwide synchronization.

UTC is plenty enough to offer a good sync reference for distributed teams. Swatch beats was a good idea too, but failed.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by riffraff on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:22AM (#34992656)
> got rid of 12 hour clocks.

We got rid of 6-hours clocks and it only took a few centuries, there's hope!

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by Taywee on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:25AM (#34992673)
With timezones:

* I want to call my friend in Germany. What time is it for her? I guess I'm UTC-7 and she's UTC+1, so she's 8 hours ahead of me. I know that everybody around the world typically wakes up between 6 and 9 AM and goes to sleep between 8 PM and midnight, and she's an early bird, so she should be awake. * They said the meeting was going to be at 8 o'clock, but they are in a different time zone, did they mean mine or theirs?

Without timezones:

* I want to call my friend in Germany. It's the same time here as there. It rises at 13:00 here, but she's a quarter of the way way around the world. I have to look up their typical waking hours. She's an early bird, so is she on the early side of that, likely. What time does the sun rise there? How much does that change over the seasons? * They said the meeting was at 18:00. I know exactly when that is. * If I live too far from the UTC, the day will change in the middle of my working day. My friend said they'd see me on Tuesday. Do they mean the day that had Tuesday at the beginning of it, or the end? What does "Tuesday morning" mean when morning is at the end of the Tuesday? Is "morning" the beginning of the solar day or the beginning of the clock day?

I agree with DST and 12-hour clocks, those are antiquated and mostly pointless. If you get rid of time zones, you don't simplify anything. You trade one set of complications for another. The complication is that you are interacting with humans that have different hours than you do, getting more different as you get farther away. Without time zones, you still have those complications, and you trade the set of time zone complications for another set of complications, by having your time completely divorced from your local daylight and working hours.

There are stupidities with modern time zones, but the concept exists for a good reason.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by barbazoo on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:00AM (#34992905)
Wow, there's clearly pros and cons for both! It's all about compromise and the way it currently works, works for the majority of people that don't even experience the downsides in their day to day life.

Like having to coordinate meetings around the world or figuring out what time it is for their friend on the other side of the world. Most people never deal with any of that. They just want it to be 12:00 and bright out when they eat lunch (or whenever they eat lunch).

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by once_inc on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:59AM (#34993228)
I've literally heard nobody say they want it to be 12.00 and bright out when they eat lunch, only that they want it to be bright out.

Suppose we set the universal time to the current -12h meridian. Everyone works with that exact same time. If I receive a scheduled meeting at 15.00 I know exactly when to be there (wow, that's late for me!). If glance at the clock and see that it is 4.00, I know it's time for my afternoon tea, and that the sun is still out.

I think people would get used to this line of thinking very rapidly, and would scheduling would be arguably made easier, because the proposed time would not need to be parsed by anyone.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by layman51 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @07:16PM (#35003977)
Your comment makes me understand why people would want to abolish time zones. However, my issue with that is that I think it would cause confusion when people in everyday life use the word “afternoon”. I won’t know if they’re talking about the time when the sun is getting lower in the sky, or if they are talking about when it is past 12:00 on whatever clock we are mandated to read. We would all need to ask people to clarify those things, especially if they don’t have the detail-oriented mindset for these kinds of things. Now, granted, you do already have to clarify these things when you are speaking with people around the world already.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by rascul on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:02AM (#34992924)
> * If I live too far from the UTC, the day will change in the middle of my working day. My friend said they'd see me on Tuesday. Do they mean the day that had Tuesday at the beginning of it, or the end? What does "Tuesday morning" mean when morning is at the end of the Tuesday? Is "morning" the beginning of the solar day or the beginning of the clock day?

The problem there is the lack of specificity, and timezones don't help or hurt that. It's already not clear if "Tuesday morning" means my Tuesday morning or yours. Maybe they could say "Tuesday around 1400" and we would both know when that was without considering the offset.

> If you get rid of time zones, you don't simplify anything. You trade one set of complications for another.

You do make a lot of things simpler by not having to figure out offsets. Sometimes you still will, but it will be less often.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by IIAOPSW on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:40AM (#34993105)
As someone frequently half a world off from those I'm scheduling a call with, it helps to adapt a format that explicitly states [calendar date] [24hr time] my time / [calendar date] [24hr time] your time.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by kuboble on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:29AM (#34993051)
> It's already not clear if "Tuesday morning" means my Tuesday morning or yours

In 99% of cases of my communications it's perfectly clear because it's the same for both of us. The GP said that without a local timezone Tuesday Morning would be ambiguous even in a local context.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by bonzini on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:27AM (#34993040)
More often than not, one's morning or afternoon is late in the evening or in the middle of the night for the other person. So morning is almost unambiguously referring to the westernmost person and afternoon to the easternmost.

Instead if the working day begins at 23:00 (as would be the case for Pacific time) for me and 8:00 for you, but the meeting is already at 1:00/10:00, it is unclear if you mean "at 1:00 of Wednesday, which is on the working day that started Tuesday at 23:00" or "at 1:00 of Tuesday, on the working day that started Monday at 23:00".

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by xarope on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:32AM (#34993417)
In the military, there is Zulu (+0 UTC/GMT) and Juliet time ("my" time). Every report with times should always indicate the timezone (whether Z or J or otherwise), e.g. in NYC 2pm would be 1400Y. Any recent/current military folks want to comment?
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by iainmerrick on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:45AM (#34993491)
Is there a different single letter per time zone band? That’s almost elegant if so (as long as you ignore the many places with idiosyncratic time zones).
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by kubanczyk on Thursday March 02, 2023 @09:34AM (#34996120)
I didn't know what a time zone band was, but I was able to find out: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_Zone_(band)

But seriously, in DST world, the numerical offsets (-6, ...) are confusing enough, adding yet another "simpler" notation would only increase confusion.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by iainmerrick on Friday March 03, 2023 @04:29AM (#35007516)
I did say _almost_ elegant...! I just hadn't noticed that the 26 Roman letters are just enough for 24 hour-wide timezones, which seems like a nice coincidence, so I wondered if anyone had tried it. There are way more than 24 different zones in practice, of course.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by yencabulator on Thursday March 02, 2023 @10:38AM (#34996989)
Unfortunately, there's too many timezones for just A-Z, but nautical time does make an attempt. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_UTC_offsets for the funny markings they decided to use when they ran out of letters.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by Zr40 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:48AM (#34993161)
> With timezones:

> * I want to call my friend in Germany. What time is it for her? I guess I'm UTC-7 and she's UTC+1, so she's 8 hours ahead of me. I know that everybody around the world typically wakes up between 6 and 9 AM and goes to sleep between 8 PM and midnight, and she's an early bird, so she should be awake.

> Without timezones:

> * I want to call my friend in Germany. It's the same time here as there. It rises at 13:00 here, but she's a quarter of the way way around the world. I have to look up their typical waking hours. She's an early bird, so is she on the early side of that, likely. What time does the sun rise there? How much does that change over the seasons?

This is actually the same thing. In both cases you have to know or look up that there's an 8 hour difference between the two of you.

The bits about the seasons and being an early bird apply equally to both cases, so it's not really relevant to the comparison.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by watwut on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:45AM (#34993493)
It is not the same thing. I do not need to reason at all right now, I just look at the clock that shows times in relevant timezones. I know all the information instantly, without any calculations in head at all.

In the latter case, you do need to do math, because what you are getting is meaningless number and then you need to convert it to some kind of "how long after typical start of day" format to get information you actually want.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by yencabulator on Thursday March 02, 2023 @10:33AM (#34996911)
Ah, so you're saying you have a clock showing German time, and it did the "math" for you.

Imagine multiple world clocks, in the typical Hollywood command bunker look. Instead of each clock having hour hands pointing in different directions, they'd all have the same hour hand position, but different highlighted zones for waking hours (or "shift 1", "shift 2", "shift 3", for 24h duty).

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by friendzis on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:57AM (#34993220)
The takeaway is that we, humans, tend to reference things in non-universal frames of reference. Be it "morning" for time or "office" for location. Timezones can be seen as an emergent property of long-distance communication. Whatever the algorithm you choose the underlying problem with "inertial" frames of reference remains.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by x3n0ph3n3 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:02AM (#34993248)
It's actually an emergent property of trains needing to be predictable and run on time. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_time
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by sunaurus on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:01AM (#34993244)
> With timezones: * I want to call my friend in Germany. What time is it for her? I guess I'm UTC-7 and she's UTC+1, so she's 8 hours ahead of me

> Without timezones: * I want to call my friend in Germany. It's the same time here as there. It rises at 13:00 here, but she's a quarter of the way way around the world. I have to look up their typical waking hours. ... What time does the sun rise there? How much does that change over the seasons?

You aren't doing a fair comparison. In your "with timezones" example, you are considering it trivial to look up/remember what timezone Germany is in, but in your "without timezones" example, you are making it out to be more difficult to look up/remember what the "day-hours" of Germany would be.

In a world without timezones, you could just Google "what are they day hours in Germany" just like you can Google "what is the timezone in Germany" now. And in fact, it would be much easier to reason about - if you know that the time is currently 10:00, and the day starts at 18:00 in Germany, then you don't need to do any more math, you can just wait until it's after 18:00 to call her.

> If I live too far from the UTC, the day will change in the middle of my working day. My friend said they'd see me on Tuesday. Do they mean the day that had Tuesday at the beginning of it, or the end? What does "Tuesday morning" mean when morning is at the end of the Tuesday? Is "morning" the beginning of the solar day or the beginning of the clock day?

Again, you're assuming that language would not be different in a world without timezones. It's a completely unrealistic scenario, language always evolves to fit our real needs.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by detrites on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:46AM (#34993497)
This is obviously a software problem that could be solved universally at the OS level.

We have all kinds of low-level protocols for coordinating all manner of things. Distilling a coherent system of agreeing on a timezone difference, between two communicating entities and presenting that to the user at any time would be quite basic.

We have location data for all, at all times. We have a local, accurate clock. There's little else we'd need. What remaining issues are all UX. Apple could roll such a thing out parallel on all their multitude devices and it'd be basically trivial.

Is it maybe just habit that we gravitate to a manual process, when an automated one would be rather easy in this situation?

On iOS, the existing clock app already provides a basic form, tapping the plus button allows the addition of multiple zones and provides useful additional context in the form of offsets and what day it is relative to the users local date and time.

That's halfway there, it would only need contact awareness to be able to provide a solution.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by bb123 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @04:02AM (#34993600)
Why do we need to make it a software problem? The existing system makes it a trivial mental calculation.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by detrites on Thursday March 02, 2023 @05:38AM (#34994211)
The amount of people complaining here about how difficult it is to keep a handle on illustrates it's not a trivial mental calculation, even for HN. I would agree, especially when coordinating multiple, distant parties.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by tengwar2 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @06:41AM (#34994597)
Apple already do have support for specifying the time zone in appointment times, and the Clock application can show the current time in different places. What woudl you want to add to this?
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by detrites on Thursday March 02, 2023 @07:20AM (#34994824)
Attach the current, local time to all contacts, at the basic, fundamental level. If contacts are in a different zone, every app accesses an OS-defined UX, that displays a contacts local time in a ubiquitous, familiar fashion all users get used to.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by TeMPOraL on Thursday March 02, 2023 @04:02AM (#34993599)
Yeah, I hate timezones with a passion but the more I think about them, the more I recognize they're the least bad option available. They correctly optimize for making most common cases trivial, while rare cases relatively easy.

I think it needs to be said here: cross-timezone scheduling and datetime math are extremely rare relative to people's daily experience. It may not be obvious to us here, because we're much more likely to be dealing with the unusual case - building distributed systems, having international users/customers, working for multinational companies or cooperating with companies from other countries, etc. Almost nobody ever does that, and it makes no sense to make everyone do extra mental arithmetic when thinking or talking about other places, just for the sake of a minority of white-collar workers who can't be arsed to add a second column to their Outlook calendar, or double-check when they have a Zoom meeting.

Getting rid of timezones would make most of everyday matters location-dependent. Timezones allow us to use the same numbering of times of day regardless of where any of us lives. 08:00 is morning. 22:00 is night. 12:00-14:00 is around when people have lunch. Etc. We can talk about our days in all kinds of ways (movies, plays, songs, novels, guides, etc.), retaining a precise numerical scale (vs. much less useful terms like "morning" or "afternoon"), and everyone everywhere can relate. Getting rid of the timezones makes this impossible.

Note the difference between talking about daily experience with people around the world, vs. doing things in sync with people around the world. Timezones make the former trivial, and the latter easy. Removing timezones makes the latter trivial, but the former hard. Hard enough that people would quickly recreate timezones for convenience.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by mschuster91 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @04:23AM (#34993740)
The worst problem with timezones IMO is that they are way too big [1], compared to what they should be if the world were equally divided into 24 hour "strips". Europe for example has CET which stretches all the way west to Spain, despite UTC+1 ending somewhere along the French-German border - so Spain and France are 1 hour "ahead" despite not needing to.

[1] https://www.timeanddate.com/time/map/

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by prmoustache on Thursday March 02, 2023 @05:38AM (#34994215)
Add to that cultural and climate differencies and it makes it even harder to schedule things. Like there is not a huge difference between France and Spain in term of solar hour, but rhythm is different because people in the south are used to take their lunch break when at the hottest moment of the day and tend to stay outside and up longer because they are most pleasant in the summer.

Most people in europe keep scheduling meetings between 14 and 16 which is pretty much lunch time here in Spain so most of the time I am having lunch during my video calls or take a quick bite in between calls without a proper break.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by Kwpolska on Thursday March 02, 2023 @06:10AM (#34994427)
This might be a “problem” for people who like arbitrary lines to define their lives. Keeping most of Europe on one time zone lets people from different neighbouring and culturally close countries work together without needing to think about time zones.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by ElectricalUnion on Thursday March 02, 2023 @11:03AM (#34997386)
If keeping most of Europe on one timezone lets people work together without needing to think about time zones, so does unifying the entire earth on a single TAI or UTC "timezone".
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by Kwpolska on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:26PM (#34998773)
No, that does not scale. Sunrise and sunset are at very similar times in CET countries, meaning they have similar business hours, and I can set up a meeting between Spain, Poland, and the UK (which is on UTC/BST, but that’s close enough) at 11:00 CET and everyone will be fine with it and well awake at that time. If we extended CET around the world, and wanted someone in New York to join our meeting, they would be furious because they would need to ~~wake up~~ (edit: be awake and at a computer) at 5:00 ex-EST, or 1.5 hours before sunrise.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by zamnos on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:58PM (#34999259)
Quick, someone tell China this won't work! China has only one official time zone, China Standard Time (CST) which is centered on Beijing, which is on the east side of the country. Some how, the country still hasn't fallen apart since this was established in 1949. Prior to this, China had 5 time zones.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by Kwpolska on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:04PM (#35001189)
Do you have an example that is not from an oppressive regime that does not care about the happiness of its citizens? Do you have an example that does not have an unofficial time zone [0] observed by people in the easternmost part of the country?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xinjiang_Time

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by tengwar2 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @06:38AM (#34994578)
I'd say that the biggest problem with time zones is that most people confuse them with time offsets (which unfortunately is what you are doing). A time zone is a geographical area. That area can run on different time offsets - "times". So the UK runs on UTC in winter, and UTC+1 in summer. It's wrong to think of the UK as being in the "UTC time zone".

This may seem pedantic, but the confusion causes real problems with software.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by mschuster91 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @08:48AM (#34995552)
> I'd say that the biggest problem with time zones is that most people confuse them with time offsets (which unfortunately is what you are doing).

The problem is, say, I have a colleague in Spain. I ask him for a meeting today at 0800 CET, which for him means sunrise was at 0746, while I in Munich have had sunrise and got woken up by the cats at 0652.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by BurningFrog on Thursday March 02, 2023 @05:54AM (#34994318)
As the world becomes more global, coordinating with people in other times zones will become the norm, not the exception.

I expect time zones will fade away then.

No need to rush it prematurely though

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by zvr on Thursday March 02, 2023 @06:28AM (#34994525)
I cannot imagine a world where "the norm" of human interaction would be with people in other times zones.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by Tor3 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @08:27AM (#34995368)
Huh? For me it is, and has been like that for a very long time. I work with various customers throughout the day, and they are in various different timezones. When I'm not working I almost daily interact with family, again different timezone. I am always aware of various timezones.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by wasmitnetzen on Thursday March 02, 2023 @10:23AM (#34996764)
Is this the norm for those people too, or are you basically the only one they ever talk to where timezone matters?
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by Tor3 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:24PM (#34999630)
They do indeed talk to people in other timezones as well. We may have online meetings sometimes, with at least three timezones involved.

I can't see how one would only contact in touch with people in a single timezone, unless one only wants to have contact with people in continental Europe (excluding e.g. Portugal and Finland), or people in a single timezone in the US. Timezones are everywhere. The earth is a sphere, so.. can't be avoided.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by TeMPOraL on Thursday March 02, 2023 @08:07PM (#35004468)
If your work involves coordinating across timezones daily, you're part of the small minority cases I was talking about. Offline world is still mostly local, and almost all interactions almost everyone has, online and offline, are local too.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by Tor3 on Friday March 03, 2023 @02:40AM (#35006879)
Firstly, that's not a small minority case, and secondly, in my small town there are people from around 100 nations, and they have family and friends from all over. And, as I said, even central Europe has 3 timezones just inside EU. It's not like most people only have contact with their 50 neighbours, and never go anywhere. When I talk with friends, timezones come up reasonably often. It's not something people can walk around and not be aware of.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by BurningFrog on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:34PM (#34999768)
That's just the online world.

Most people we interact with on this site are likely in a different timezone, for example.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by Tor3 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @08:24AM (#34995339)
I have no issues with timezones at all. Morning will be in the morning (as per the clock), wherever you are, and timezones are reasonably well defined. Without timezones you would still need a system defining what the local equivalent of "morning" or "evening" or "working hours" is, in whatever town the person you're calling is in - and I feel we'll be going back to how things worked before the railway chaos forced the introduction of timezones.

What I hate is DST. That's not only useless, it's problematic. Heck, my old mother never managed to handle the change this last fall, in her nursing home - meals didn't come at the optimal time, she got undernourished, it destroyed her sleep cycles, and her health went all downhill.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by smallerfish on Thursday March 02, 2023 @05:25AM (#34994123)
> * I want to call my friend in Germany. It's the same time here as there. It rises at 13:00 here, but she's a quarter of the way way around the world. I have to look up their typical waking hours. She's an early bird, so is she on the early side of that, likely. What time does the sun rise there? How much does that change over the seasons?

You look up her profile in teleappnal, and it says she's online, so you give her a call. Easy. Or, you book a calendar appointment like anybody civilized, and she either accepts or rejects it. (Telephones are another abhorrent Victorian invention which we'll get rid of, and sooner than you think.)

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by aflag on Thursday March 02, 2023 @05:45AM (#34994260)
"* I want to call my friend in Germany. It's the same time here as there. It rises at 13:00 here, but she's a quarter of the way way around the world. I have to look up their typical waking hours. She's an early bird, so is she on the early side of that, likely. What time does the sun rise there? How much does that change over the seasons?"

In both cases you need to do some maths. You know early birds wake up at 11 where you live. If you know she's 8h ahead, just add 8. So, 19 is when you should call.

For calling people nothing really change. Adapting when moving somewhere else is the tricky bit. If I move to another city or country I just adjust my clock and automatically know when things will be open, working hours, etc. Otherwise, whenever you move you have to keep mentally reminding yourself that the work day starts at 12 here, not 7 like I'm used to and so on.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by soneil on Thursday March 02, 2023 @08:59AM (#34995680)
Every time I see someone propose scrapping timezones, they end up in one of two traps. Either unilaterally dictating that Australia, NZ, etc become fully nocturnal - or they end up re-inventing timezones with a different name.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by plufz on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:26AM (#34992678)
I’m with you on the last two but a life without timezones sounds horrible.

So many issues, like having to relearn the clock when you are in another timezone. I’ll meet you for lunch at 06.00! Life is based around the sun.

Having some sort of agreed upon world timezone would be neat though, whether that was GMT or something less euro centric. So everyone would understand “we have a zoom meeting at 11.00 WT” instead of having to decide which timezone to refer to.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by likis on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:46AM (#34992818)
> "Having some sort of agreed upon world timezone would be neat though ..."

Don't we already have that with UTC / Zulu time?

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by ACS_Solver on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:40AM (#34993458)
Do you encounter people using UTC regularly? While it's the closest we have to a world timezone, in my experience people don't use it much outside of a technical context.

I usually see Americans treat Eastern Time as a standard, with references to Pacific sometimes. In the EU, where I am, CET is the usual timezone used for specifying a time internationally. And regardless of the location, it's very common for people to specify a time in their local timezone first and leave it to the other party to figure out what the difference is.

I haven't encountered situations like someone saying "let's have a discussion at 16:00 UTC" to set up an EU-US meeting.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by Symbiote on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:53AM (#34993553)
> let's have a discussion at 16:00 UTC

My colleagues and I do this, but we're often involving 3, 4, 5+ timezones. Everyone knows their own offset from UTC, but I easily forgot whether Australia is on DST this month.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by likis on Thursday March 02, 2023 @04:22AM (#34993732)
I agree to an extent, but I don't really see the problem either. If I book a meeting or something through any calendar application, the timezone will be fixed to the local timezone. Let's say I book it for 13:00 in my calendar, it will show up as a meeting at 14:00 in their calendar if they are +1 from me.

So whenever I specify a time with someone that could be in a different timezone, I would either make sure that I am using some application that solves it for me, or I would AT LEAST include the timezone.

Maybe I'm just not encountering the same problems that you do.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by benj111 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @05:38AM (#34994216)
I use it all the time. But then I live in the UK.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by bonzini on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:37AM (#34993088)
UTC is nice not because it is euro centric, but because there is a lot of sea on the opposite side of GMT and therefore it is pretty easy to place the date change line. There are multi-timezone countries on both sides of the oceans (USA, Russia, and the European Union basically counts as a third) so the date change line has to stay on the sea.

There is only one good alternative, which would be to place the date change line in the middle of the Atlantic (between UTC-3 and UTC-2) and the fundamental time zone in Japan or somewhere Australia (UTC+9/UTC+10).

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by billpg on Thursday March 02, 2023 @06:52AM (#34994671)
I wonder which side Greenland, Iceland and the Falkland Islands would pick.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by bonzini on Thursday March 02, 2023 @07:04AM (#34994733)
Iceland and the Falklands would likely be respectively -9 and +12 from Japan.

Greenland is probably the best reason to keep Greenwich as the reference time zone. :) Most of the population (so to speak) is on -13 to -12. I have no idea if the people there have more ties to continental Europe and Iceland, or to Labrador.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by beebeepka on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:44AM (#34992799)
Of course you've been downvoted.

I believe humanity is just one generation away from being able to get rid of the idea that noon is 12:00 and 24:00 is midnight.

I think I've heard all the arguments against and they all boil down to "no, old days are best".

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by tossaway0 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:20AM (#34993004)
I'll meet you half way: let's place UTC next to the local time everywhere we can. It could be in parenthesis, in a tooltip, etc. It could get us all used to knowing our time in UTC and eventually help in cross-timezone communication.
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by throwaway049 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:25AM (#34993035)
Do you mean replace conventional wall clocks with 24 hour versions, all set to UTC?

I object on the grounds we could no longer say it's five o'clock somewhere in the world when we open a bottle in the daytime.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by sen on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:55AM (#34993202)
Ah but you could say "It's evening somewhere in the world!" ;)
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by mchaver on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:26AM (#34993393)
I think even if governments around the world abolished time zones, tried to ban their use and forced a universal time, you would still end up with folk implementation of time zones that ends up being worse where people translate the universal time to and from the non-standard local time. You can see some of that behavior here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xinjiang_Time
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by Archelaos on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:34AM (#34993425)
Just use Julian dates. This way you can also get rid of years, months, weeks, ... You only need to change the Julian period every now and then, ie. every 7980 years. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julian_day
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by darkwater on Thursday March 02, 2023 @04:24AM (#34993748)
The trade-off balance is not that big towards your desire to justify such a gigantic mentality shift for all humanity. In other words, it will never happen. (Ok, maybe the DST and the 24h clock only can go away at some point, but TZs will stay)
Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by billpg on Thursday March 02, 2023 @06:57AM (#34994696)
If we're going to have major time reform, can we start the daily cycle at dawn?

1am on Tuesday is known as "Monday Night".

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by rendaw on Thursday March 02, 2023 @08:17AM (#34995262)
I was thinking getting rid of timezones would be crazy, but I work at a globe spanning all remote company and any time anyone discusses times it's always in UTC because everyone's in a different time zone and have no idea what each other's timezones are.

So I guess I'm in the "this could work" camp.

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by coldpie on Thursday March 02, 2023 @09:38AM (#34996173)
Without timezones, you need a lookup table for what daylight hours are for every location on earth. For convenience, rather than publishing a table for every latitude/longitude, let's group these locations into zones along geographical borders nearby longitude lines. We can call these grouping "zones", or in more broad contexts, "time zones."

Hang on a second...

Re:Europe pushing for lunar time zone by poulpy123 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @11:57AM (#34998289)
No time zone would make everything extremely complicated for everyone