News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It Is Happening Again by xeromal on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:45PM (#34843002)
Dang, can we get the title changed to "It Is Happening Again: Industrial toxicity without industrial employment". I don't think title offers much info as is.
Re:It Is Happening Again by bitsinthesky on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:22PM (#34843548)
"It is Happening Again: I'm Clicking on Clickbait" is what went through my mind as I clicked on it
Re:It Is Happening Again by singleshot_ on Saturday February 18, 2023 @09:54AM (#34847315)
"It Is Happening Again: We Are Discussing Authoritarians As If They Are To Be Tolerated" struck me around the 60% mark.
Re:It Is Happening Again by dredmorbius on Saturday February 18, 2023 @02:55AM (#34844939)
The most effective way to get mods' attention is to email [email protected]

(I've done so suggesting the title alteration you've made here.)

Re:It Is Happening Again by dang on Saturday February 18, 2023 @03:15AM (#34845049)
Thanks! done now
Re:It Is Happening Again by dang on Saturday February 18, 2023 @03:14AM (#34845047)
Sure, done.
Re:It Is Happening Again by ThrowawayTestr on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:49PM (#34843036)
Regulations stifle innovation. What's a few ecological disasters in the name of progress?
Re:It Is Happening Again by readthenotes1 on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:00PM (#34843087)
Not that this brightens your day, but it's not just the evil and/or short-sighted capitalists:

"Scientists working in this field might say – as indeed I have said – that the benefits of such experiments and the resulting knowledge outweigh the risks."

Pride is a stronger motivator than greed.

https://news.yahoo.com/fauci-argued-benefits-gain-function-1...

Re:It Is Happening Again by justinclift on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:58PM (#34843744)
"Some of you may lose your lives in this endeavour, but that is a risk I'm willing to take." ;)
Re:It Is Happening Again by lupire on Saturday February 18, 2023 @11:13AM (#34847977)
Fauci's argument was that pandemics happen naturally, so it would be better to get ahead of them in the lab. Was he wrong? Maybe. Or maybe Covid was totally natural and we needed GoF research to help with vaccines. Fauci also acknowledged the validity of concerns, in that same paper.

Is it bad to run a biolab next to a naturally virus -heavy environment? Probably. Is it bad to trust the Chinese Communiat Party with a biolab,given their decades long record of oppression the Chinese epoeple and suppression of the press? Probably.

Vinyl Chloride gas clouds, by contrast, never appear naturally.

Re:It Is Happening Again by readthenotes1 on Saturday February 18, 2023 @06:28PM (#34852249)
Is it wrong to hide a dangerous experiment in a foreign country that has been explicitly forbidden in the United States because it is so dangerous?

I think the answer to that should be obvious.

Re:It Is Happening Again by smitty1e on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:57PM (#34843736)
It's all fun and games until some else's carelessness drive oneself into penury.

At that point, all of the taxes one has paid to fund a government that is supposed to referee these matters... may result in some scant comfort.

Re:It Is Happening Again by Jaygles on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:53AM (#34847783)
The residents can simply stop doing business with that particular freight company. Now that they know they operate unsafely from suffering permanent damage from chemical poisoning, they can make an informed decision on the free market.
Re:It Is Happening Again by AstralStorm on Saturday February 18, 2023 @11:15PM (#34854312)
Right. After the fact and poisoning the swathes of land and tons of water nobody will clean up. And cost of the lost health of people being offloaded onto taxpayers.

The company or its shareholders is not bearing the cost of wrongdoing.

As such, the market is incentivized to do more of this garbage.

Environmental pollution is a classic example of a market failure. Market failures are the rule not some exception - they're a way to maximize profit. Efficient markets have zero profit.

Re:It Is Happening Again by kcplate on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:02PM (#34843096)
I can’t get over the pompous writing of this article. It was so distracting I had to move on.
Re:It Is Happening Again by Gordonjcp on Saturday February 18, 2023 @09:03AM (#34846996)
Someone needs to tell that Erik Baker that using lots of big words doesn't make you sound clever, it just makes you sound like a smartarse 15-year-old trying to impress their English teacher.
Re:It Is Happening Again by andyjohnson0 on Saturday February 18, 2023 @09:12AM (#34847054)
It didn't seem excessive to me. "pusillanimous" stuck out, but apart from that it seemed like fairly normal prose.
Re:It Is Happening Again by dalmo3 on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:25AM (#34847552)
The text read like an inert tornado.
Re:It Is Happening Again by kcplate on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:29PM (#34848833)
> First there was the fire, the smoke billowing infernally into the Appalachian night. It just kept burning. Days of insatiable flame. A black pillar of fumes took up residence above the town like an inert tornado. At its heart, we learned, was the corpse of a train, fifty cars off the rails

To me, even Shakespeare’s Richard III didn’t begin with this level of overly flowery poetic structure.

Re:It Is Happening Again by mikrl on Saturday February 18, 2023 @09:35AM (#34847211)
That’s some doubleplusgoodthink. Having more words for concepts leads to crimethink, ante-vapourisation.
Re:It Is Happening Again by FooBarBizBazz on Saturday February 18, 2023 @11:39AM (#34848237)
Isn't there some Foucault line about speaking adjacent to things that you can't talk about, in order to make people think about them? Using the identification of writing as spellcasting, we shouldn't be surprised, then, when the author's enemies throw tantrums against his spells... "I'm melting!"

Let me put a few quotes in sequence:

> Were the authorities everywhere just trying to keep their subjects’ spirits [emphasis: authorities everywhere. subjects. spirits.] up? Or was something altogether more sinister transpiring, just out of view? [out of view = occult]

> Which made it all the more surreal when, while the East Palestine crisis [emphasis: Palestine crisis] was unfolding, the government began to shoot down a series of unidentified flying objects across the continent. What the actual fuck was happening? [now we have set the X-files mood]

> Jewish space laser [not literally of course, I'm not Marjorie Taylor Greene]

> no one is talking about this—not the particular event, but the one single catastrophe [hm, what is the "one single catastrophe"?], in Walter Benjamin’s words, that looms behind it [occult, again] and asserts itself spectrally [more spirits!] in its every twist and turn.

> retracing the steps of a cycle [circle, circus] whose grooves were carved [cut] before we were born [emphasis: born].

> As a boy

Are you not thinking about purple elephants yet?

Then finally, an exhortation, almost:

> “This ride, man—it’s like a drug.” He was right. It offered the same fantastic bargain as all intoxication: to move forever in circles and yet to feel like one is going somewhere.

Intoxicated. Drugged. Snap out of it! Wake up a different woke. Unbind thyself, Isaac.

The oracular line in the final scene, in which the boy rides around in circles, is even spoken by a decrepit carnie at a circus (which we might accurately call a clown show).

Yet this isn't garden-variety stuff, because at every turn the author dismisses the so-called "right wing" options on offer as being absurd and entirely complicit in the destruction of what is natural.

Another circle, or revolution, was the Industrial one. Another disaster for the human race.

Of course the author is himself not sure he can escape the futility of what he is doing. He may also be talking in circles.

Re:It Is Happening Again by BaculumMeumEst on Saturday February 18, 2023 @09:36AM (#34847221)
i can hear it in frasier crane’s voice
Re:It Is Happening Again by mplanchard on Saturday February 18, 2023 @09:56AM (#34847328)
For being a crowd that I imagine would often classify itself as intellectual, HN can be surprisingly intolerant of writing with any degree of flair or (non-technical) complexity.
Re:It Is Happening Again by ajross on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:01AM (#34847370)
It's one thing to fling around some words for fun in a web forum. It's rather another to put up an essay on a serious topic with this kind of ornamentation. It makes it look like the author is selling something.

If I want to read a policy paper on rail safety regulation, I want it dry. Give me events, causes, remedies, suggestions, costs. I don't want to read a stump speech.

And in point of fact there aren't any remedies or reasoned argument here, it's all yelling and finger pointing. How might this have been prevented? Why did it happen in the first place (FWIW: we don't actually know yet, AFAIK). How else might we ship these compounds? Do we need to? What industries are they serving? That's the stuff I want to hear.

Re:It Is Happening Again by hinata08 on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:54AM (#34847788)
Read some NTSB reports for dry reports

Or CSB videos on YT

Or some TV shows like Seconds from Disaster or that Air crash one.

or listen to industrial engineers when they do their simulations and Fault trees and HAZOP shenanigans

there are a lot of publications and books and even university courses about how to study the functional safety of systems.

However, all of these dry "remedies, suggestions, costs" only make sense when you can have the "stump speech" about what you want. You need to discuss what industries you want, and what risks do you accept. When you study a risk, you can avoid it (no go), transfer it (mostly to insurance companies), mitigate it (with these new practices and technical solutions you called for, to reduce frequency and/or impact) or accept it (all green).

The articles underlines how the current risk of derailment was known and accepted by the Department of Transportation. There was nothing more to do technologically, if the risk was accepted as it was.

If you want a remedy or suggestions, go see the government and the companies to tell them chemicals plumes aren't acceptable when they happen every few years. Technical solutions will come, if they want to continue to operate trains but more safely.

Re:It Is Happening Again by ajross on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:42PM (#34848985)
> However, all of these dry "remedies, suggestions, costs" only make sense when you can have the "stump speech" about what you want.

What do you interpret the author wanting, then? It's genuine question. The linked article is a list of grievances, but you can't grieve your way out of modern industry. If you want a world with no dangerous train accidents (which is pretty much all I can gather the author desires) you need to explain how to do that, because we can't reasonably have a world where we don't ship dangerous stuff by train.

Re:It Is Happening Again by hinata08 on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:42PM (#34849711)
I hate the opposition of risk and 'modern industry'. Some companies do it all the time.

Make a lot of money for years doing finance, then having to pay for losses some day ? -> "we're too big to fail, we have to be covered" Make a lot of money doing illegal stuff ? -> "we're too big to jail, and we need business" Stop to carry dangerous chemicals on unsafe trains ? -> that's "a cost"

Now, as far as understand from the linked blog, the author is an environmentalist, and want to address three points in regards to the modern industry :

- Risks and externalities need to be actually internalised to companies, so that they could use processes and business plans to avoid or mitigate them.

> “We basically nuked a town with chemicals so we could get a railroad open,” > To “nuke,” metaphorically, is to decide to unleash the full destructive powers placed at our disposal by modern science with less than full heed paid to the ultimate consequences.

- he wants an analysis of risks and impacts of the industry, even in a distant time and out of the plants :

> Quietly, unspectacularly, toxic chemicals [...] have for over a century been leaking steadily out of tankers and pipelines and mines and barrels and factories and into Ohioan soil, water, and bodies.

>This is the consequence of a life lived in the shadow of the infrastructure of the US chemical industry: you could be murdered and not even know it.

>The derailment catastrophe underscores the cruel fate to which the hinterland of an increasingly automated and geographically dispersed chemical industry has been condemned: industrial toxicity without industrial employment.

- And he wants the government to do something about it.

At first, by comparing what is happening with some dystopia.

And then by reminding that a lot of poeple are already concerned with these issues, which has already been documented by authors and some part of the citizens.

> It is not just that we are talking about what’s happening in East Palestine [, Ohio]. It’s that it feels like we have always been talking about it.

> We mean that everyone is talking about it, but in a way that isn’t making a difference.

Sadly, the article doesn't seem to offer a turnkey solution !

it's up to the reader and the society to find it !

In my humble opinion, business can be done responsibly, if regulated, and if accountability actually exists.

Train protection systems have been used in Europe for decades, and it didn't ruin any train company. They would even seem cheap compared to paying decades of hospital costs to poisoned citizens, or to clean the environment, if train and chemicals company had to pay for any of these (and not the victims or the taxpayer)

Other industries in here have been asked not to pollute, and to do some prevention, with the Seveso directive. They have also been asked to avoid some chemicals, with the REACH regulation. (including chrome VI, the one in the famous Brokovitch case)

They are still there and profitable ! So stop to have the vision that opposes environmental protection and the modern economy. We could do the transition like in cleveland, as mentioned in the article.

Re:It Is Happening Again by AstralStorm on Saturday February 18, 2023 @11:12PM (#34854295)
The key is capitalism, which always good for short term profit even at the expense of dooming everyone.

Do you think any of the institutional or otherwise detached investors will pay for any of the safeties? Lose money or sleep?

The companies will rather circumvent or ignore the regulations, outsource the toxicity, diffuse it over the entire world. When caught, they're just slapped on the wrist, if at all.

Even in EU, cases like VW systematically breaking ecological regs on cars, undetermined someone killing tons of fish in Oder river... Creative bookkeeping and monitors being underfunded and understaffed is rampant. That where they exist at all.

Nobody wants to seriously touch it or the whole facade falls apart. The things you mentioned are fig leaves. Minor steps ahead at best.

Re:It Is Happening Again by kcplate on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:22PM (#34848736)
I’m not intolerant of it, but if a writer chooses a poetic literary style in an essay like this, I think it should enhance the communication of the topic of the essay. I became more focused on how poetic and literary they were trying to make the essay than the topic of essay themselves. It distracted more than enhanced.
Re:It Is Happening Again by yakubin on Sunday February 19, 2023 @07:43AM (#34857136)
Good writing makes the reader feel smart. Bad writing makes the reader feel the author is smart. The former is harder than the latter.
Re:It Is Happening Again by ruined on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:30AM (#34847589)
it's n+1, they're a literary magazine, writing is kind of their thing.

it lasts about a paragraph. there's more effort in this thread already

Re:It Is Happening Again by petermcneeley on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:11PM (#34843145)
plus one to the icon of this page.
Re:It Is Happening Again by mturmon on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:17PM (#34843161)
Impressionistic review of the repeated industrial accidents in Ohio, written by someone who originated from the area, in the light of the wearied, sleepwalking response to the latest one in East Palestine, Ohio.
Re:It Is Happening Again by goodSteveramos on Saturday February 18, 2023 @07:10AM (#34846286)
Why are people still living there? The smell of chemicals permeates the entire town and people are getting sick. Why isn't FEMA paying to have these people housed temporarily somewhere safe? Why are people being told to drink local well water before their well is tested? Unless this disaster is politicized, no one will help these people. The US Federal government spend billions every year housing non-White economic migrants from all over the world but cant take care of White people in the heartland? If this happened in a Black city like Flint Michigan it would have been front page news for months and gotten billions in aid, but White people in America are frankly second class citizens at this point. You cant prove me wrong by calling me racist. The only way to prove me wrong is to actually give these people somewhere safe to stay.
Re:It Is Happening Again by andrekandre on Saturday February 18, 2023 @09:16AM (#34847088)

  > The only way to prove me wrong is to actually give these people somewhere safe to stay.
actually, the burden of proof is on you firstly, since you are the one making the initial claim that this is happening "because they are white"
Re:It Is Happening Again by goodSteveramos on Saturday February 18, 2023 @12:27PM (#34848816)
Notice how your comment os not a reason to get these people help and mine is. Unless you think the US government will deliberately punish White people by not helping them if they call foul, which would only prove my point further.
Re:It Is Happening Again by thatsso1999 on Saturday February 18, 2023 @09:47AM (#34847274)
“More than a week after the crash, CNN discovered that some East Palestine residents had served as extras in the recent Netflix film adaptation of Don DeLillo’s White Noise—specifically while filming the novel’s “Airborne Toxic Event” sequence, in which an errant rail car spills chemicals that produce a noxious black cloud over a midwestern town.”

Hadn’t heard this tidbit about the crash before, what a truly insane coincidence. The airborne toxic event in the novel/movie causes deja vu, too.

Re:It Is Happening Again by starkd on Saturday February 18, 2023 @09:55AM (#34847323)
Very good novel, but very different. Don Delillo has a very unique writing style. His novels reflect some very keen insights into contemporary life.
Re:It Is Happening Again by starkd on Saturday February 18, 2023 @09:48AM (#34847282)
>> And precisely because they were nuclear accidents, Three Mile Island and Chernobyl left their surroundings contaminated for years, even decades.

Perhaps a small point, but the incident at Three Mile Island did not lead contaminate surroundings for years. Or at least, the extent is somewhat disputed.

From wiki:

According to the American Nuclear Society, using the official radioactivity emission figures, "The average radiation dose to people living within 10 miles of the plant was eight millirem (0.08 mSv), and no more than 100 millirem (1 mSv) to any single individual. Eight millirem is about equal to a chest X-ray, and 100 millirem is about a third of the average background level of radiation received by US residents in a year."

Although some epidemiological studies cast some doubt on that:

A peer-reviewed research article by Dr. Steven Wing found a significant increase in cancers between 1979 and 1985 among people who lived within ten miles of TMI.[113] In 2009 Dr. Wing stated that radiation releases during the accident were probably "thousands of times greater" than the NRC's estimates. A retrospective study of Pennsylvania Cancer Registry found an increased incidence of thyroid cancer in some counties south of TMI (although, notably, not in Dauphin County itself) and in high-risk age groups but did not draw a causal link between these incidences and the accident.[13][14] The Talbott lab at the University of Pittsburgh reported finding a few, small increased cancer risks within the TMI population.[15] A more recent study reached "findings consistent with observations from other radiation-exposed populations," raising "the possibility that radiation released from [Three Mile Island] may have altered the molecular profile of [thyroid cancer] in the population surrounding TMI", establishing a potential causal mechanism, although not definitively proving causation.[114]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Mile_Island_accident