News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by stephc_int13 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @08:15PM (#34829370)
I've read both this paper and the original Seymour Hersh article.

I found the abundance of details a bit weird, to be honest, but not enough to discount the credibility of the thesis.

On the other hand, this paper is poorly constructed, mostly using straw man techniques and sleight of hands to discredit the original paper.

I think it's doing the opposite of what it is trying to achieve, adding free publicity on top.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by MrBuddyCasino on Thursday February 16, 2023 @09:00PM (#34829707)
Some details in Hershs story were weird and made be cautious, but here is some more info that put some of that into new light:

"It looks for all the world like somebody organised two totally separate operations, involving two separately triggered pipeline attacks, and that Hersh’s source only knows about one of them."

https://www.eugyppius.com/p/nord-stream-update-in-lengthy-in...

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by EdwardDiego on Thursday February 16, 2023 @09:35PM (#34829980)
I find that write-up dubious.

> The fear, however, was that the bombs wouldn’t work if they stayed in the water too long. This is actually what happened with two of the bombs.

Seriously? The world's largest military hasn't developed explosive devices that are sufficiently waterproof?

> There were still active explosives on the sea bed as the pipes were leaking their gas, which explains why partially complicit Denmark and Sweden closed the whole area and denied all access, until they themselves had removed everything.

This is bloody stupid. Bubbles reduce the density of water, thus potentially reducing buoyancy (in research based around oil rigs and the like, it was found that a large enough leak pushed enough water upwards to compensate, but this wasn't a large leak). The leakage of residual gas in the pipeline posed a maritime hazard, but sure, it was to remove the faulty bombs, that's why.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by ninjagoo on Thursday February 16, 2023 @09:51PM (#34830089)
>> The fear, however, was that the bombs wouldn’t work if they stayed in the water too long. This is actually what happened with two of the bombs.

> Seriously? The world's largest military hasn't developed explosive devices that are sufficiently waterproof?

The OP might be referring to the triggering mechanism running out of battery and thus unable to receive the triggering signal, rather than to water exposure.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by EdwardDiego on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:38PM (#34830425)
Perhaps, but again I'd posit that the world's most advanced military wouldn't mind slapping on a few more batteries, just to be sure.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by linkjuice4all on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:57AM (#34831321)
Or a drone submarine or some crap like that. The problem with this story is that there are so many ways any capable not-even-super-power could do something like this. There’s also all the 4D chess about Putin keeping his oligarchs trapped since they can’t sell the nation’s largest commodity. Or that’s what insert country with special forces wants you to think.

It’s possible Hersh is 100% correct but without anyone else corroborating him we’re just left with speculation.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by KMag on Friday February 17, 2023 @01:40AM (#34831579)
Right. The most plausible explanation, given the number of Russian petrochemical executives critical of Putin who have died under suspicious circumstances, is that Putin wanted to greatly reduce the incentive of petrochemical oligarchs to stage a coup in order to re-open the pipeline.

Putin has shown he's very wary of the petrochemical oligarchs. If removing Putin from power doesn't open Nord Stream back up, then that's one less incentive for the petrochemical oligarchs to move on Putin, at least in the short term.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by gerikson on Friday February 17, 2023 @01:59AM (#34831686)
This is my theory too. Putin blowing up the pipeline serves a number of purposes:

- removes options from a potential opposition within Russia

- reminds nations around the Baltic that Russia has undetectable underwater assets

- serves to potentially split NATO members (Hersh's story is obviously part of that)

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by red-iron-pine on Friday February 17, 2023 @09:55AM (#34835333)
> - serves to potentially split NATO members (Hersh's story is obviously part of that)

this is the big one. I can't see a reason why the US even the UK would blow the pipelines, esp. when they already have a very strong NATO rallying cry, and Putin turning off the gas already means N. American Oil & Gas will be making big money.

Like, you're already winning, why risk a disaster and blowback? Meanwhile Putin has shown, consistently, that he's capable and willing to play dirty like that, and can actively spite the Baltics and Scandinavia.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by Gud on Friday February 17, 2023 @02:33AM (#34831898)
You repeat “the worlds most advanced military “ like it makes them infallible.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by EdwardDiego on Friday February 17, 2023 @05:54AM (#34833177)
I didn't repeat it :)

First time I said:

"World's largest military"

Second time was "most advanced".

I'm not saying they're infallible, but they're not exactly the Keystone cops, either.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by Gud on Saturday February 18, 2023 @02:53AM (#34844928)
Ok, fair enough!
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by thoeiu4oi234 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @09:30PM (#34829938)
I don't know about you, but I find these "pro-West" side to be quite specious in their arguments. What idiot really believes that Russia of all people would want to kill their own golden goose ?

The argument these geniuses are implicitly making is that either Russians (or more euphemistically "Putin") is a raging lunatic, or that their readers so utterly dim-witted that they'll believe any shit that they'll spin.

OTOH, US/UK... has a very long history of false-flags and extremely sophisticated psychological warfare, esp. given the international dominance of the English language.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by Analemma_ on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:03PM (#34830171)
There’s a very straightforward and plausible rationale for Russia (specifically, Putin) to do it: coup-proofing by forced commitment to not turning the oil back on, like breaking your own steering wheel in a game of chicken and throwing it out the window. There are presumably elites in Russia who would like to see the war end and go back to business-as-usual so they can get their assets and incomes back, and blowing up the pipeline signals to them “that’s not happening. Total commitment is the only option, so don’t even bother trying to replace the current leadership.”

Is this definitely what happened? Of course not, we don’t know who did it. But it is a perfectly coherent and plausible claim, and so your hyperbolic statements about “what idiot really believes…” etc. only serve to demonstrate that you haven’t bothered learning about anyone’s position other than yours, and thus that you yourself probably shouldn’t be listened to.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by ballenf on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:11PM (#34830231)
That is the strongest case, but I'm still confused by the seemingly conflicting claim that Putin is susceptible to a coup but only if there's a pipeline. Don't Russian elites have nearly as much to lose from this war continuing with or without a pipeline?

What exactly would the pipeline change in the these elites calculus, willingness or ability to stage a successful coup?

The pipeline repair cost estimates are much lower than the cost of an ongoing war plus oil embargoes. That is, a coup now benefits these elites roughly as much as it would have with a pipeline.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by shagie on Thursday February 16, 2023 @11:36PM (#34830828)
The remaining pipelines for Western Europe go through Belarus and Ukraine.

https://www.naturalgasintel.com/ukraine-warns-of-gazprom-pre...

https://coffeeordie.com/russia-relies-on-ukrainian-pipelines

The Russia - Ukraine - Slovakia / Poland route is not reliable.

https://www.eurasiareview.com/04022023-russia-energy-profile...

> In May 2022, Ukraine suspended operations at the Sokhranivka measuring station and the Novopskov compressor station, which are part of the Soyuz and Brotherhood pipeline system, because of interference by Russian forces.

https://www.offshore-technology.com/news/ukraine-cease-russi...

> In a press statement, the firm said: “Moreover, the interference of the occupying forces in technical processes and changes in the modes of operation of GTS facilities, including unauthorised gas offtakes from the gas transit flows, endangered the stability and safety of the entire Ukrainian gas transportation system.”

---

From a layperson trying to channel Russian leadership, removing Nord stream would mean that the only way for Western Europe to get natural gas is through stability in Ukraine and an easing of tensions between Ukraine and Russia. Russian leadership obviously has their preferred way of accomplishing this.

My crystal ball also says that even after the war ends in the favor of Ukraine, that gas pipeline will not be available because of the tensions and the... lets call it "unreliable partnership" that exists ( https://www.naturalgasintel.com/ukraine-warns-of-gazprom-pre... )

Note that the gas pipeline through Belarus to Poland has also been turned off. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yamal–Europe_pipeline

> On 26 April 2022, Gazprom announced it would stop delivering natural gas to Poland via the Yamal–Europe pipeline, as well as to Bulgaria, as both countries had rejected Russia's demand that payments for gas be made in Russian rubles - a demand allegedly constituting breach of contract.

Without the Nord Stream, Yamal, Soyuz/Brotherhood; Southern Europe (Greece, Romania, Italy) are being tempted with gas supplies from Russia by way of Turkey. Russia is additionally trying to tempt Turkey into being its energy hub ( https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/turkeysource/turkey-ca... ) with promises of cheap gas, free money (transit fees for the pipeline), and a dependence on Russia for that part of the economy.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by XorNot on Thursday February 16, 2023 @11:46PM (#34830892)
Why would you interpret that motive as "only" if there's a pipeline?

Think of a car seat belt: does it make you immune to dying in a car crash? No. It does however reduce the probability you will. So might removing a bunch of spikes glued to your steering wheel.

Similarly, what do you think a coup is? A coup is when guns get pulled in board rooms and people have to try and remove blood and bodies from the carpet. It's safe to say "the elites" don't plan one idly, and you know, if the stunning rate of Russian executives turning up having committed suicide off balcony's[1] is any indication, one real good way not be one of them is to rat out the people coming to you proposing a coup. Particularly if they're not able to promise big money in return.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suspicious_deaths_of_Russian_b...

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by earthboundkid on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:19PM (#34830289)
The most likely coup scenario right now in Russia is that the head of the Wagner Group deposes Putin from the right.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by foverzar on Saturday February 18, 2023 @07:00AM (#34846218)
> There’s a very straightforward and plausible rationale for Russia (specifically, Putin) to do it: coup-proofing by forced commitment to not turning the oil back on, like breaking your own steering wheel in a game of chicken and throwing it out the window.

And there is an even more straightforward debunking of that version:

a) these pipelines have nothing to do with oil, they pipe gas

b) these pipelines are only a fraction of all the gas transportation infrastructure: there is a huge pipeline in Ukraine that dwarfs NS1/2 combined (and Ukraine happily accepts Russian money as a transportation fee, they've even raised it recently), there is a pipeline in Belarus, there is Yamal, and there is TurkStream.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by debatem1 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:22PM (#34830317)
I'm really surprised to hear people talking about the US, UK, Russia, etc but not talking about Ukraine.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by foverzar on Saturday February 18, 2023 @06:27AM (#34846045)
This is actually a very good point. As much as I love sticking it to the US, it's hard not to notice how much Ukraine benefitted from this.

The whole goal of NS1/2 was to avoid dealing with Ukraine, but now there is little threat to their gas transportation system and Russia has to pay extra to Ukraine for pumping gas to Europe (and they even raised the fee recently).

Still, I doubt Ukraine could have done it alone, but I expect it would make a perfect scapegoat if things get too dangerous for the real mastermind.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by lispm on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:25PM (#34830348)
The pipeline is not completely destroyed. It could be repaired.

Putin attacked the Ukraine and used Energy Dependence as a weapon against Europe. Russia bought energy companies. Russia influenced energy politics and politics in general in these countries. Russia reduced the storage and flow of natural gas before the invasion and prepared it to be used as a political instrument in this war, which is not just a war against the Ukraine, but a war against the West (US, EU, NATO, ...).

Energy is one of Russias main weapons against Europe in its expansion politics towards the west.

One would be naive to underestimate the will and evil of Putin to use his weapons, to influence European politics - for example by inducing fear in the population because of energy supply shortages. There is plenty further escalation possible. Putin thought that the Ukraine would fall easily into his hands, Controlling the Energy supplies then would be his many insurance. Now he is in a lengthy war against the Ukraine and he needs to instrument more pressure, like creating fear and panic in the western europe population, which could force western politics to make compromises. Russia still has the gas&oil, it has other pipelines and enough existing or future customers. In a conflict the value of this goes up. Temporarily blowing up a pipeline is only increasing this value.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by lispm on Friday February 17, 2023 @01:35AM (#34831546)
Let me add: the blown-up pipelines were three of four newly built. One of the four is not damaged. The damage to the other three pipelines was only in a small area. The pipelines are repairable. The pipeline was mainly a project of Russia and Germany, meant to supply natural gas to German markets (and beyond). The pipelines were not in use, yet. There was zero chance that the pipelines would go in use in the next decade, given the political situation.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by foverzar on Saturday February 18, 2023 @06:19AM (#34846010)
> The pipelines are repairable

That is really doubtful, especially at this point when they've been full of seawater for so long.

> The pipelines were not in use, yet.

NS1 was operational for years, and NS2 was technically too: all the equipment was running and the pipe was pressurized - just turn the tap on.

> There was zero chance that the pipelines would go in use in the next decade, given the political situation.

I don't think that's fair. Political situation can change easily. Lap journalists could just dust off the ol' narrative of "Ukraine is full of nazis", which was prevalent in pro-western media before the war gone hot and all of this suddenly became "Russian propaganda"

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by lispm on Saturday February 18, 2023 @07:40AM (#34846465)
> That is really doubtful, especially at this point when they've been full of seawater for so long.

They have coating inside. They need to be cleaned from dirt.

> NS1 was operational for years

"Was". It wasn't when the explosion happened. Russia had stopped the gas transport already.

There was never any natural gas transported via NS2 and NS1 was stopped end of August 2022.

> I don't think that's fair.

It is. There is zero chance that Germany will take any gas exports via these pipelines without a full political change in Russia.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by foverzar on Sunday February 19, 2023 @07:18AM (#34856989)
> Earlier this year there were reports of a cost estimate of $500 million and a time duration of one year for a repair.

So basically like building the pipe part anew.

> There was never any natural gas delivered via NS2

Technically there was. It was pressurized. Meaning it was full of gas delivered up to the tap on the German side.

> If Russia ever wants to sell natural gas (again) via these pipelines

Gosh, I really hope not. I also hope it stops pumping gas through Ukraine and doesn't waste time on Turkish gas hub. Dealing with Europe who acts like this is some kind of privilege is a waste, IMO.

> It is. There is zero chance that Germany will take any gas delivered via these pipelines

You are being categorical at the expense of being realistic. It's been gorging on gas from these pipelines like crazy, while filling the reserves. And it still uses Russian gas via various "latvian blend" like schemes, as Russia continues to pay a huge-ass fee to Ukraine for using old soviet huge-ass pipeline. This implies a huge-ass demand on the other side of that pipe. (It's actually quite fun to observe reiteration of history as the whole anti-NS1/2 deal is so hugely similar to anti-Ukrainian pipeline back in the Soviet era)

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by lispm on Sunday February 19, 2023 @02:15PM (#34860793)
> So basically like building the pipe part anew.

No, the cost of the Northstream 2 alone was roughly $11 billion. Much of the pipeline could be used, the explosion was only in a small region.

> Technically there was. It was pressurized. Meaning it was full of gas delivered up to the tap on the German side.

It was filled, but nothing was delivered into Germany. There was also no permission given to do that.

> Dealing with Europe who acts like this is some kind of privilege is a waste, IMO.

Russia has all the responsibility. They attacked the Ukraine. It's their choice. It has nothing to do with a 'privilege'.

> You are being categorical at the expense of being realistic.

Realistically Russia has removed themselves from being someone who we want to trade with for at least a decade. They are not a partner and they are not reliable.

Russia started a war against not only the Ukraine, but also against the rest of Europe and they used the energy dependency as a weapon. Russia was preparing for the war for some time.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by foverzar on Monday February 20, 2023 @01:24PM (#34871022)
> No, the cost of the Northstream 2 alone was roughly $11 billion. Much of the pipeline could be used, the explosion was only in a small region.

Yes. You are citing the cost of the whole project, with all the infrastructure, pumping equipment, pipelaying ships, etc. The pipe is only one component.

Besides, it doesn't matter if it's "a small region". As soon as the pipe gets full of water, it's basically dead in the water (pun intended). Lookup how these pipes get built. The sections are connected and hermetically sealed above the water, and then lowered so that no water gets in.

You seem to be imagining that pumping out a few countries length of seawater is some kind of an easy task, but it's actually cheaper to disassemble and rebuild the whole thing.

> It was filled, but nothing was delivered into Germany. There was also no permission given to do that.

That's just rhetorics. If you turn off the water tap at your home, that doesn't mean the water is no longer delivered. It's still there, practically at your home. Not sure what "permissions" you are referring to.

> Russia has all the responsibility. They attacked the Ukraine. It's their choice. It has nothing to do with a 'privilege'.

I am not talking about Ukraine. I am talking about weird European attitude like it's some kind of privilege to supply them like everyone around owes them something. If they don't want Russian gas, then that's just businesses.

> Realistically Russia has removed themselves from being someone who we want to trade with for at least a decade. They are not a partner and they are not reliable. > Russia started a war against not only the Ukraine, but also against the rest of Europe and they used the energy dependency as a weapon.

Well that's just propaganda bullshit.

First of all you've said it yourself that it's a matter of politics. European leaders themselves decided to use the energy in political context and saying that Russia "uses energy as a weapon" when their politics had bitten them in their collective ass is plain stupid.

And secondly it was Europe who decided to engage into economic war with Russia and that was the cause of all the disruptions - that's anything but being "reliable" on their part. Russia merely didn't do anything to appease the stubborn princess who decided to shot herself in the leg. I mean, c'mon, there was a moment when Europe actually expected to receive gas, but not pay for it due to sanctions - how idiotic is that? This exactly the kind of weird attitude I was talking about above.

And given the confessions of former German chancellor, former French president, former and current Ukraine presidents making statements like "prepared for war" is super rich. We all saw how "well prepared" Russia was - both in combat and in the amount of frozen assets.

I just don't get what the European leaders were expecting. Probably fell victims to the same attitude and totally forgot that when you ruin business relations they actually get ruined and no one owes them anything.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by lispm on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @03:32PM (#34886727)
> As soon as the pipe gets full of water, it's basically dead in the water (pun intended). Lookup how these pipes get built. The sections are connected and hermetically sealed above the water, and then lowered so that no water gets in.

No, Nord Stream 1 pipeline was filled with water during construction.

Anyway, Russian news agency TASS reported about a possibility of a pipeline repair: https://tass.com/economy/1555677

> If you turn off the water tap at your home, that doesn't mean the water is no longer delivered. It's still there, practically at your home. Not sure what "permissions" you are referring to.

It wasn't open. There was no gas delivered and sold to Germany. "permissions" means that the German authorities would have to permit the Nord Stream AG to deliver natural gas into the German market. Such a permission wasn't given.

> I am not talking about Ukraine.

I was talking about Russia. Russia has removed themselves from the European market because of their war against the Ukraine.

> I mean, c'mon, there was a moment when Europe actually expected to receive gas, but not pay for it due to sanctions - how idiotic is that?

There was no such moment.

> I just don't get what the European leaders were expecting

European leaders were expecting that Russia would be a peaceful neighbour. One which one wants to have trade with.

> ruin business relations

Right, Russia ruined the business relations. A customer can choose where to buy from. Europe chose to reduce and minimize economic relations with Russia.

Sure, selling into a foreign market is a privilege. Russia lost that privilege. Given that the trust for Russia is currently zero, it will take many years to repair that - which will be much more complicated than repairing the pipelines.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by foverzar on Thursday February 23, 2023 @09:31PM (#34920010)
> No, Nord Stream 1 pipeline was filled with water during construction.

Not exactly, at least not like that: https://www.nord-stream.com/download/document/74/?language=r...

> Anyway, Russian news agency TASS reported about a possibility of a pipeline repair: https://tass.com/economy/1555677

Did you even read the article? "Maybe, possibly, requiring money and time". How does this counter my point that underwater pipes will have to be rebuilt? Are you sure you are not confusing the underwater component of the pipeline with the whole pipeline itself, with all the related infrastructure, compressing stations and so on and so forth?

> It wasn't open. There was no gas delivered and sold to Germany. "permissions" means that the German authorities would have to allow the Nord Stream AG to deliver natural gas over Nord Stream 2 into the German market. Such a permission was never given.

We are going in circles. NS2 was delivering gas up to Greifswald. The fact that Greifswald wasn't delivering it further is not a property of NS2.

> I was talking about Russia. Russia has removed themselves from the European market because of their war against the Ukraine.

"Russia has removed themselves from the European market", yeah, right. This was purely a decision of several (not all, mind you) European states. Followed by "heeeeelp, evil Russia wants to freeze us to death!". All while acting like any interaction with it is some kind of privilege. Pathetic.

> There was no such moment.

Well that is just denialism. Europe expected to freeze the payments as soon as they hit the accounts, along with other assets. The whole shenanigans with paying "with roubles" was exactly about this whole deal. Yeah "technically" they would pay, but Russia would never receive the funds and they would remain circling through European economy by remaining in European banks. This was exactly "such a moment".

> European leaders were expecting that Russia would be a peaceful neighbour. One which one wants to have trade with.

Well if that's your tune, then back at you, I can refer you to Putin's Munich speech in 2007. In any case, you are engaging in demagogy and digressing. Point is, European leaders started an economic war against Russia and suddenly it hit them too. So that's why we are hearing narratives like "Russia using energy dependency as a weapon" - this is basically an attempt to hide incompetence.

> A customer can choose where to buy from. Europe chose to reduce and minimize economic relations with Russia.

Sure, that's just business. And it is you who says that it is Europe's own choice. So tell me, how come the customer making their own choice is whining that "Russia uses energy as a weapon"?

> Sure, selling into a foreign market is a privilege. Russia lost that privilege.

No, normally that's just business relations. It's only "a privilege" with Europe, just like basically any other interaction with it. Which is just another iteration of the same lesson learned time and time again over centuries of interacting with that chauvinistic culture.

> Given that the trust for Russia is currently zero, it will take many years to repair that

Fat chance. This will be Turkey's business from now on. Dealing with Europe directly is worthless pain. And in any case, someone on the other end of the Ukrainian pipeline is still buying a shit load of Russian gas, mixing it and distributing it to the rest of the Europe under the guise of non-Russian gas ("Latvian blend" like schemes). So as long as the funds keep flowing, all this is just a cheap self-appeasing talk.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by rurp on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:29PM (#34830366)
> What idiot really believes that Russia of all people would want to kill their own golden goose ?

Putin killed his own golden goose by invading Ukraine. Starting this war has been a disaster for Russia's economic future. Putin either doesn't care about that, or drastically miscalculated. Blowing up the pipeline would be consistent with either mindset.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by stephc_int13 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:35PM (#34830412)
Blowing up the pipeline is not consistent with either mindset.

Putin very likely miscalculated his "special operation", that does not mean he is completely crazy or stupid.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by fwungy on Thursday February 16, 2023 @11:10PM (#34830653)
Putin repeatedly tried to avoid the Ukraine war.

Americans don't understand that Russia has a thousand year history of brutal wars and Putin was not going to tolerate a NATO member a few minutes of rocket time from Moscow. It's non-negotiable. He would have accepted a neutral Ukraine.

The fact that NATO fought itself over sending 100 mostly out of date tanks to Ukraine after they lost over 1000 is all the indicator you need to know how things are going.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by nkozyra on Thursday February 16, 2023 @11:28PM (#34830786)
> Putin was not going to tolerate a NATO member a few minutes of rocket time from Moscow.

But ... that's already there and has been for a long time. And now two more neighbors have pledged to join.

If the intent was really to stop or reduce the neighboring countries who are NATO members, it hasn't really worked out that well.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by fwungy on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:25AM (#34831117)
I follow both the NYT and Wapo, and The New Atlas, Douglas MacGregor, and Alexander Mercouris.

The latter group has been far more accurate in their predictions and their analysis is far more logically composed.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by IIAOPSW on Friday February 17, 2023 @02:35AM (#34831921)
Mice have a gestation period of about 8 weeks.

(your response is an irrelevant non sequitur)

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by red-iron-pine on Friday February 17, 2023 @10:51AM (#34836033)
All politics threads on HN are full of shillbots, and very likely bots now that GPT-3 is big.

It's not as well moderated or as complex as reddit w/r/t brigading, fighting obvious shills, or obfuscating upvotes, etc. Not that reddit is particularly immune to this, either.

I wouldn't trust jack shit about politics on HN. Details about the latest implementation of systemd? Absolutely. Anything not STEM? Dubious at best.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by IIAOPSW on Saturday February 18, 2023 @05:59AM (#34845904)
This is a very dangerous line of thinking because it lets you dismiss any comment you don't agree with as a bot or a shill without having to address the merits of it. Its an unfalsifiable yet plausible suspicion to have, which makes it dangerously tempting to believe on spurious evidence. The way I see it, our only good option is to engage with it anyway (provided they aren't gaming the platform itself via spam or similar). An argument isn't inherently bad or wrong because GPT3 wrote it, and the volume of these types of comments isn't insurmountable.

Maybe the guy I was replying to was a bot. Maybe he was a human who fails the Turing test. In either case it was worth the time I spent pantsing him for the benefit of the discourse.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by foverzar on Saturday February 18, 2023 @06:52AM (#34846176)
> Starting this war has been a disaster for Russia's economic future.

Or maybe not. I feel like a lot of this comes from misjudging sale of crude resources as "economic future" and a wishful thinking that us Russians are just brainless dummies, incapable of anything else.

I've seen the same rhetorics back in 2014 when the first sanctions kicked in, and that lead to automatic protectionist policy and economic growth - new projects, new businesses, new supply chains.

One has to realize that current globalized supply chains weren't benefiting Russia at all

But that's just my 2 cents.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by stephc_int13 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:31PM (#34830385)
This is no doubts this sabotage was conducted as a "special operation", and the nature of those is usually to remain secret for a long time.

I think Occam's razor is helpful in this case.

And I honestly don't care either way. But, I find the media treatment to be interesting. Most of the big ones don't want to touch it with a ten foot pole.

Why?

They don't hesitate to publish news about UFOs, I don't see why they should be more careful about a Russian pipeline sabotage...

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by freejazz on Friday February 17, 2023 @01:03AM (#34831357)
I'm not sure if the alternative to Hersh being wrong is that Russia did it
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by tptacek on Thursday February 16, 2023 @09:48PM (#34830071)
Be specific. Which of the arguments in this do you find "poorly constructed"?
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by miguelazo on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:11PM (#34830229)
Literally every paragraph. Let’s start with this completely unsubstantiated and incoherent section:

> The US Air Force officials reportedly proposed “dropping bombs with delayed fuses that could be set off remotely”. One could write an entire post on the reasons why sounds entirely made up by someone with no real grasp of what that suggestion would actually technically entail.

During the supposed initial planning of this operation, from the way it is described by Hersh and his source, it appears that the CIA and entire interagency group were unaware of the fact that the Nord Stream pipelines were in fact pipelines.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by tptacek on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:16PM (#34830267)
I don't think you've picked up the argument being made there, which is that, being a pipeline, the Norwegian Navy wasn't constrained to one particular spot to disable it: it runs seven hundred and fifty miles under the Baltic Sea. The author of this post is saying Hersh doesn't know what a pipeline, not that the USG doesn't.

Try another paragraph. Let's interrogate it. For instance: why is the Norwegian Navy allocating a minesweeper, a large ship that is certainly tracked by the Russian military, to serve as a diving platform for a bunch of EC-UBA divers? Why wouldn't they use a civilian ship instead?

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by Jerry2 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:25PM (#34830344)
Instead of getting lost in minutia, can you explain why Biden, Nuland, Blinken and the rest of the neocon and lib imperialist gang would go on record about getting rid of NS1 and NS2 and then deny they had anything to do with it?
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by tptacek on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:40PM (#34830441)
It's not "minutia". These are the details of the story Hersh chose to tell.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by rjzzleep on Friday February 17, 2023 @01:06AM (#34831377)
I'm a bit confused, do you have some personal relationship to the author? Or why do you get personally offended when people question (not attack) the author of this particular substack?

NATO had plenty of big navy drills around area last year. Who would complain about NATO ships in the area? Russia? Why do you even get hung up on that point?

https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/news_196240.htm?selectedL...

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by Jerry2 on Friday February 17, 2023 @01:56AM (#34831664)
tptacek, you still haven't explained how Biden, Nuland, Sullivan and Blinken are all on video saying that NS pipelines will be destroyed. Why are you so heavily invested in this and why are you defending this insane criminal cabal that is pushing us into WW3?
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by IIAOPSW on Friday February 17, 2023 @02:30AM (#34831881)
You're response to the question of logical consistency in the Hersh story is "who cares about consistency, I don't like Biden or the US so it must be true, anyone who disagrees is 'heavily vested in an insane criminal cabal'". Why are you so heavily invested? Answer the question
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by Jerry2 on Friday February 17, 2023 @02:37AM (#34831935)
These people are on record for threatening the pipeline. They had the motive and the means. So why should we disbelieve their threats? Sy Hersh is the most trusted living investigative reporter today. I'll take his word over some OSINTbro shill any day of the week. And to claim that Russians destroyed their own pipeline is ludicrous. Once they start cutting our undersea cables and destroying our pipelines, I guess they'll claim we're doing it to ourselves. Same "logic".
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by IIAOPSW on Friday February 17, 2023 @03:23AM (#34832225)
You're entire system of reasoning comes down to choosing what to believe based on how much you like the person saying it. And when you don't like the person saying it you can't even say their name without inserting a stupid insult like "criminal cabal" and "OSINTbro shill". You systematically sidestep all questions on matters of fact in favor of naked tribal social reasoning. Even in this discourse you opted to reason about the motivation semantics of the GP, speculating outloud that they are "invested" in defending a certain position, rather than directly addressing the arguments they made for that position. Your follow up comment is based 100% in elaborating on which sources you think are more reputable and 0% in analysis of what these sources are actually claiming.

Did you just get here from Twitter?

I don't care if its Hersh or otherwise, if someone says 1+1=3 then what they are saying doesn't add up. Debunking the Hersh story isn't a claim about Russia doing it to themselves, nor even a rejection of the hypothesis that the US did it. It merely refutes the Hersh story as evidence one way or the other.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by Jerry2 on Friday February 17, 2023 @06:41AM (#34833491)
Hersh's report adds up more than "Russia did it" nonsense that's coming out of CIA-approved sources.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by tptacek on Friday February 17, 2023 @08:17AM (#34834276)
It doesn't do that at all if it's false in all its particulars. You need to separate the idea that the US is behind this sabotage from the idea that Hersh is a kook. Both things can be true at the same time!
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by miguelazo on Monday February 20, 2023 @11:06PM (#34876416)
What are the chances that Hersh made up the whole thing? What are the chances that his source is just completely faking him out and he doesn’t know better? If Putin had threatened to “end” some US internet cable to Norway, would anyone be doubting the nature of that threat if the cable suddenly blew up?
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by tptacek on Saturday February 25, 2023 @02:41PM (#34939739)
The chances that somebody made this whole story up are very high, a near certainty.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by IIAOPSW on Friday February 17, 2023 @06:24PM (#34841985)
Even after I point out your "reasoning" system and its flaws, you come right out the gate with "CIA approved sources". Are you even capable of anything other than bashing the source?
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by miguelazo on Friday February 17, 2023 @01:53PM (#34838737)
Thank you for calling out the OSINTbros! They're insufferable and until now, I didn't know what to call them. Much appreciated.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by glennvtx on Thursday February 16, 2023 @11:15PM (#34830693)
Biden is literally on video promising that these pipelines would be destroyed, so there is that.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by spurgu on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:14AM (#34831060)
Not sure you'd be downvoted for a clear and definite fact?
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by miguelazo on Friday February 17, 2023 @03:25PM (#34840060)
Happens all the time around here, unfortunately. Simping for empire is very popular among libs these days. The security state is very adept at leveraging identity politics for imperialism. Also, some people really go out of their way to come up with creative interpretations of what Biden meant. If Putin had said the same thing, you can be sure they would interpret it as a direct, kinetic threat, of course.
[dead]
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by tptacek on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:25PM (#34837524)
No, it's not a no brainer: it's US divers either way, according to Hersh. See? None of this makes sense.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by throwoutway on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:03PM (#34843772)
> it runs seven hundred and fifty miles under the Baltic Sea.

That's not a realistic measurement. Did you mean the length? The deepest part of the Baltic Sea is 459 meters deep. The ocean's deepest point is roughly 7 miles deep.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by tptacek on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:51PM (#34844008)
The length, is the point.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by miguelazo on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:08PM (#34830209)
Same. I was hoping for something compelling to refute. This piece is trash and it’s a sad comment on the state of critical thinking (and liberal simping for empire) that it even garnered this much traction on HN.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by maybelsyrup on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:31AM (#34831164)
> liberal simping for empire

To me, there are few issues more overlooked than this stuff. Structurally there's no mainstream constituency that'd do so, of course, but still. Crazy under the radar.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by miguelazo on Monday February 20, 2023 @12:42PM (#34870530)
Agreed. It's glaringly obvious and yet libs make such a concerted effort to not acknowledge it. You can see them squirm as soon as you try to present them with the evidence they very intentionally ignore or even the blatant inconsistencies of their reasoning. The "Goodness" of the state has become bound up with their very identities-- not that different than the MAGA crowd's cult of personality.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by astro19238_ on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:30PM (#34830373)
Even if the Hersh thesis is completely made up, he still makes more sense than what this guy does.

For one thing. The most plausible reason he can't find the plane dropping the buoy he privides himself.

-It's a small device. -Better to use a boat. -Better to use a non military boat.

Yeah? Maybe that is what they did?

It's not impossible the source filled in a few gaps in his story? Or was mistaken? Or Hersh himself might have?

I don't want to go full conspiracy mode myself here but one thing is for sure. And that is that not finding proof of a covert operation can only mean one of two things. Either that it didn't take place or that it indeed was covert.

And why could the source not have said Stoltenberg worked with the Americans since the Vietnam war as a figure of speech?

Hersh article is not enough to base an opinion on imo. But it's not precisely worse off after this guys rather hollow arguments.

Howrver the analysis is not a bad start.

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by tptacek on Thursday February 16, 2023 @11:02PM (#34830590)
It's not what they did, according to Hersh! It's not a minor gap in the story! Hersh claims the Norwegian Navy allocated an Alta-class minesweeper to the task of operating as a diving platform for American divers. You can't say "well, maybe that's not what happened then!" and act like the story is intact. If major details in the story are false, that's a big deal!

You can absolutely still believe the US blew up the pipelines, the same way you could have before Hersh's goofy story ran. But you can't claim to believe Hersh's story while systematically dismantling all of his claims. The story itself is either true or it isn't.

I feel like a lot of people are defending this story because they've independently and axiomatically derived US culpability for the pipeline sabotage. I don't have anything to say about whether the US sabotaged the Nord Stream pipeline. But Seymour M. Hersh has, ever since 2006, been a nutbag, and this story he's telling makes no sense. That's a much more interesting thing to discuss than our rooting interests in geopolitics!

If you think he's right about the particulars, and this analysis is wrong about those particulars, say why! That's an interesting discussion to have!

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by maybelsyrup on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:29AM (#34831137)
> independently and axiomatically derived culpability

> ever since 2006, been a nutbag

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by rjzzleep on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:53AM (#34831298)
I really needed to know if tptacek was somehow mixing in some ad homimem attacks to discredit the author.

Two things I found interesting that I didn't know and found fascinating is that western countries would give the US in modern age jurisdiction over their territory. I get how it happens in Japan or Germany that were occupied due to their role in WWII.

It's also worth noting that part of the reason why Iran had a revolution was especially due to the fact that there was no jurisdiction over crimes Americans did.

But why would a western nation sign such a thing in 2022?

I think we can also agree that if they had any hint of Russia doing it(which is an absurd theory to begin with given that they ARE the tap), it would have been blowing into extraordinary proportions. They fact that the story quietly died is a quite telling by itself.

Let's also remember for a moment that both NS1 and 2 were actually built on request of the Germans.

Let's also not forget that there had been an incident with an explosive laden drone in 2015 near the pipeline. Previous discussion from HN

https://www.pipeline-journal.net/news/explosive-laden-drone-...

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by moremetadata on Friday February 17, 2023 @01:52AM (#34831644)
https://twitter.com/KimDotcom/status/1579608838118191105 Gazprom just released these photos of a NATO Seafox drone that was found right next to Nord Stream 1 in 2015.

Nato Seafox Drone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seafox_drone#/media/File:Seafo...

Nordstream sections that were attacked were at a depth of 80-110metres. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_Nord_Stream_pipeline_sabo....

In May 2021 the worlds first wireless underwater drone was available for sale which operates at depths of upto 100mtres. https://www.hydromea.com/exray-wireless-underwater-drone

Maybe these could be used to monitor the pipeline in a semi autonomous fashion in future?

Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by IIAOPSW on Friday February 17, 2023 @02:21AM (#34831823)
To play some devils advocate, is it possible for either Hersh or the supposed source changed some of the more superfluous details to obfuscate exactly what they know and who could have leaked it? Not trying to root for anyone or be an America-bad type here. Just having a hard time believing that the specific delivery vehicle used is anything more than a pedantic detail for future historians.
Re:Debunking Seymour Hersh's Alta-Class Claims by astro19238_ on Thursday February 23, 2023 @10:33AM (#34911863)
Yes. I agree. I'm just not sure some faulty details makes all of it untrue.

However it's hard to be sure because it works both ways. I.e. veryfieng some details don't make the whole thing true.

I havent made up my mind, and I don't think I will.

But it would surprise me if Biden did it if only for the millions of people half starving because of it.