You can absolutely still believe the US blew up the pipelines, the same way you could have before Hersh's goofy story ran. But you can't claim to believe Hersh's story while systematically dismantling all of his claims. The story itself is either true or it isn't.
I feel like a lot of people are defending this story because they've independently and axiomatically derived US culpability for the pipeline sabotage. I don't have anything to say about whether the US sabotaged the Nord Stream pipeline. But Seymour M. Hersh has, ever since 2006, been a nutbag, and this story he's telling makes no sense. That's a much more interesting thing to discuss than our rooting interests in geopolitics!
If you think he's right about the particulars, and this analysis is wrong about those particulars, say why! That's an interesting discussion to have!
> ever since 2006, been a nutbag
Two things I found interesting that I didn't know and found fascinating is that western countries would give the US in modern age jurisdiction over their territory. I get how it happens in Japan or Germany that were occupied due to their role in WWII.
It's also worth noting that part of the reason why Iran had a revolution was especially due to the fact that there was no jurisdiction over crimes Americans did.
But why would a western nation sign such a thing in 2022?
I think we can also agree that if they had any hint of Russia doing it(which is an absurd theory to begin with given that they ARE the tap), it would have been blowing into extraordinary proportions. They fact that the story quietly died is a quite telling by itself.
Let's also remember for a moment that both NS1 and 2 were actually built on request of the Germans.
Let's also not forget that there had been an incident with an explosive laden drone in 2015 near the pipeline. Previous discussion from HN
https://www.pipeline-journal.net/news/explosive-laden-drone-...
Nato Seafox Drone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seafox_drone#/media/File:Seafo...
Nordstream sections that were attacked were at a depth of 80-110metres. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_Nord_Stream_pipeline_sabo....
In May 2021 the worlds first wireless underwater drone was available for sale which operates at depths of upto 100mtres. https://www.hydromea.com/exray-wireless-underwater-drone
Maybe these could be used to monitor the pipeline in a semi autonomous fashion in future?
However it's hard to be sure because it works both ways. I.e. veryfieng some details don't make the whole thing true.
I havent made up my mind, and I don't think I will.
But it would surprise me if Biden did it if only for the millions of people half starving because of it.
For one thing. The most plausible reason he can't find the plane dropping the buoy he privides himself.
-It's a small device. -Better to use a boat. -Better to use a non military boat.
Yeah? Maybe that is what they did?
It's not impossible the source filled in a few gaps in his story? Or was mistaken? Or Hersh himself might have?
I don't want to go full conspiracy mode myself here but one thing is for sure. And that is that not finding proof of a covert operation can only mean one of two things. Either that it didn't take place or that it indeed was covert.
And why could the source not have said Stoltenberg worked with the Americans since the Vietnam war as a figure of speech?
Hersh article is not enough to base an opinion on imo. But it's not precisely worse off after this guys rather hollow arguments.
Howrver the analysis is not a bad start.