News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by arghandugh on Thursday February 16, 2023 @01:12PM (#34822867)
The idea that “getting shot in the head” is a mysterious phenomenon that needs intense sociological research is so utterly fucking insane that it’s hard to breathe.

It’s the guns. It’s the guns. It’s the guns. The phenomena exists because the object exists and is sold in every town in America for reasons that range from the deranged to the sinister.

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by Jimmc414 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @01:22PM (#34823068)
Murder predates projectile weapons.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by happymellon on Thursday February 16, 2023 @01:33PM (#34823318)
Projectile weapons certainly increase its volume though.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by wrycoder on Thursday February 16, 2023 @02:48PM (#34824715)
God created men, and Sam Colt made them equal.

Let’s say you are a fifty year old woman. Just try defending yourself without a gun.

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by arghandugh on Thursday February 16, 2023 @04:38PM (#34826729)
Let’s say your child is shot to death at school. Why didn’t you arm them? Why didn’t your five year old have a handgun? Why didn’t your child know how to shoot to kill? Guns are the great equalizer, you know.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by wrycoder on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:35PM (#34828956)
I know you're just jerking me around, but to answer your question:

An infant isn't capable of handling any weapon. At around the age of twelve, children, if accustomed to guns, are capable of defending themselves, and have done so, both in the pioneer days and currently.

But, we don't allow children to be armed in school, because not all children are emotionally mature. That's why we set age limits on legal firearm ownership.

We depend on the school staff and facilities to keep them safe and we expect that children will be civilized by their families and their schooling to respect authority. Sadly, that is not always the case, especially in the last few decades.

Using a gun in self defense is a last resort. Lawful gun owners are very reluctant to do so, because they understand the responsibility and ramifications of doing that.

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by arghandugh on Thursday February 16, 2023 @08:36PM (#34829513)
I’m not jerking you around, I’m telling you point-blank that your solution to this problem is the actual problem itself. You have created a utter fucking nightmare world, and now you want to fix it with more nightmares. Fuck you. Fuck your guns. Fuck your lawful gun ownership culture. Fuck you.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by happymellon on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:21AM (#34831094)
> Using a gun in self defense is a last resort. Lawful gun owners are very reluctant to do so, because they understand the responsibility and ramifications of doing that.

Found the person who not only didn't read the article, but is essentially summed up by it.

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by wrycoder on Friday February 17, 2023 @01:32PM (#34838479)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_Sta...

VT and NH, with triple the gun ownership of CA, have one half of the CA gun murder rate.

NH and VT are constitutional carry states, with gun laws consistent with the US Constitution. CA is heavily regulated.

How do you account for this?

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by happymellon on Friday February 17, 2023 @04:07PM (#34840596)
So you read the article?
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by wrycoder on Friday February 17, 2023 @06:34PM (#34842057)
Yes. It's a jumble, but it implies California is doing great. Actually, it's not. Besides, it appears that the gun murder rate is independent of gun ownership:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_Sta...

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by happymellon on Saturday February 18, 2023 @03:05AM (#34844993)
It doesn't say that California is doing great. It says that of all the gun laws that California has in place, only 3 have any research behind them to show that is is effective. The other laws may or may not help but the evidence is flimsy.

The point of the entire article is that people are just using simple graphs like the one you linked to without actually doing any studying and then making laws based upon some perceived correlation. California is strict with its rules but it doesn't say that it's a good thing.

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by wrycoder on Saturday February 18, 2023 @05:09PM (#34851628)
You are correct, "great" is probably not the correct word - I think the article claims that California is doing the "right" thing. And, of course, the people who wrote the article know in their hearts what the right thing is, regardless of evidence.

The plot I posted shows that there isn't any correlation between gun ownership rates and the gun murder rates state by state. I haven't looked at the states behind the few outliers, but I suspect that people who do won't like what they find.

It gets even murkier when you include gun suicides, which are half the deaths, in the polemics. People will always find a way, and some states can be more depressing, e.g. winter in New Hampshire.

Edit: That 18 / 100,000 outlier seems to be bogus, I don't see it in the data table.

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by happymellon on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:19AM (#34831089)
Ah, and this is why they don't have mass shootings in the USA, only other countries because Americans are all well armed!

Oh wait...

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by wrycoder on Saturday February 18, 2023 @10:55PM (#34854185)
You do know that the “mass shootings” are almost always done in locations where citizens with legal pistols are not allowed to carry them, i.e. gun-free zones? And when there are armed citizens present, the shooters are usually quickly stopped?
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by dokem on Thursday February 16, 2023 @01:28PM (#34823219)
Guns are not complex devices. Making them illegal does not make them go away. People are not hard to kill and if you want to do a lot of damage it’s hard to beat a can of gasoline or a U-haul. Find something else to cry about.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by happymellon on Thursday February 16, 2023 @01:32PM (#34823303)
The article talks about the irrational conversations that gun ownership has in the USA.

You can't study it.

By banning any observation no one can prove whether the majority of shootings come from the gun owner or someone who stole the gun.

As such the negative "making them illegal does not make them go away" also cannot be proved by you.

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by vlovich123 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @01:47PM (#34823631)
That’s neither here nor there. Legislation certainly can change the amount of guns available. Compare Canada or Australia which too had similar gun cultures prior to legislation.

Sure it doesn’t get rid of all guns. No one is claiming that it would but that’s an unreasonable bar that’s only set by critics. Even countries with strict gun control still have guns. However gun deaths are more rare because the penalty associated with even holding a gun illicitly are quite high, so in practice the number of guns floating around is lower and their use is really constrained (mainly because the cost of acquiring a gun is higher). Sure, the US has way more private gun ownership than other countries when they took steps towards effective legislation. It’ll take longer for any meaningful legislation to take effect, and only if it’s a national thing to mitigate cross-border transport. And SCOTUSes current ideological bent and strange 2nd amendment interpretation further complicates things at all levels. For what it’s worth the 2nd amendment seems to only ever have been interpreted about national regulations of formal state militias (eg the state’s National guard, police, etc). The reinterpretation in Heller to mean protection of private ownership is both recent (2008) and quite strange. A significantly worse decision than whatever Roe got wrong in legal theory and one that had strict social harm vs Roe which actually at least had positive social outcomes.

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by torstenvl on Thursday February 16, 2023 @02:38PM (#34824549)
> SCOTUSes current ideological bent and strange 2nd amendment interpretation

You mean a century of precedent and extensive historical record?

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by dokem on Thursday February 16, 2023 @01:56PM (#34823809)
You are willfully misinterpreting 2a. Police and national guard are not militias. 'The people' does not mean the state. This is not a recent interpretation. The bill of rights outlines citizen's rights not the state. Obviously the state can have weapons. If you are a US citizen you have some learning to do.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by technothrasher on Thursday February 16, 2023 @02:45PM (#34824679)
> Police and national guard are not militias.

Uh, what? The National Guard most definitely IS the militia. Did you miss the Militia Act of 1792? A whole four years after the 2nd became the law of the land, they formalized the militia into what became the National Guard. You can argue about the militia clause in the 2nd being prefatory, but you really have nothing to stand on when you say the National Guard is not the militia.

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by ianburrell on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:26PM (#34825461)
Up until recently, the "colective right" interpretation was the law of the land. The "individual right" interpretation was argued about but was less than twenty years since became accepted.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by vlovich123 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:35PM (#34825618)
Please educate me then cause I could be mistaken. Why was Heller so monumental if the 2nd amendment hadn’t traditionally meant that it applied to state’s rights to armed forces separate from that of the federal?
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by ianburrell on Thursday February 16, 2023 @02:04PM (#34823948)
Guns are a lot more deadly than other weapons. They are also easy and quick to use. It is pretty common for people to fight and then one pulls out gun and shoots and kills the other. You can kill with knife or improvised weapon but have to mean it. You also have to get close; drive-by shootings are pretty common around here.

You don't have to make them go away, just reduce the numbers so they don't get used in everyday murders. Most murders are crimes of passion and the difference between pulling out gun and having to find weapon will stop most of them. Britain still has a few illegal handguns, they get used in crimes, but their murder rate is much lower. A good indication that ease-of-killing matters is that murders with shotguns and long guns are pretty rare.

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by torstenvl on Thursday February 16, 2023 @02:46PM (#34824689)
Deadliness/volume is a losing policy argument. There are between 4x and 7x as many knife homicides as assault rifle (or rifle of any kind) homicides in any given year. https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2019/crime-in-the-u.s.-...

The single most-common weapon used is a handgun, around 4x as common as knives. But the Supreme Court has unambiguously ruled on the constitutionality of handgun bans and refusal to grant handgun licenses. And even under the most expansive gun control position that the Second Amendment only protects guns that existed in 1789... well... pistols were invented in the late 1500s.

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by arghandugh on Thursday February 16, 2023 @04:33PM (#34826662)
A handgun in the house increases the rate of successful suicide by a factor of nine. Sleep tight!
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by OkayPhysicist on Thursday February 16, 2023 @05:08PM (#34827185)
So I, a perfectly adequately fit of mind and body individual, should give up my constitutional rights because some people can't control themselves?
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by arghandugh on Thursday February 16, 2023 @05:29PM (#34827430)
Yes. Correct. Also yours is a a bullshit interpretation of a bullshit constitutional amendment that should be amended out. Also you’re not always the best judge of your behavior, which is a natural consequence of the fact that there’s more than one person inhabiting this planet.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by OkayPhysicist on Thursday February 16, 2023 @06:06PM (#34827972)
I never expressed an interpretation of the 2nd amendment. Clearly you jumped to conclusions about that, as you did my ability to judge my mental state. I'd be perfectly happy to form a militia with some of my comrades, and have the right to bear arms restricted to that context, so long as the government likewise recognized that the right to bear arms has nothing at all to do with personal defense, and thus justifications around "civilians don't need X weapon because it's a weapon of war" don't stand muster.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by arghandugh on Thursday February 16, 2023 @06:55PM (#34828551)
Insane, boring, tendentious, or some combination thereof? Who knows! Bye.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by twretgfsd on Thursday February 16, 2023 @05:16PM (#34827292)
hopefully my gun doesn't jump out of the safe and shoot me while i sleep that would be scary!
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by dokem on Thursday February 16, 2023 @05:31PM (#34827461)
I'm sure your wife sleeps tight knowing if someone breaks in the only thing protecting her sanctity is your begging. Sounds like you're more concerned with killing yourself than protecting.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by arghandugh on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:05PM (#34828663)
Laws circumscribing the behavior of 330 million people should not be made on the basis of lurid rape fantasies that center you as a righteous hero and you personally should not have a gun.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by dokem on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:40PM (#34829018)
You truly are a coward and the type of man that stands for nothing and allows tyranny to flourish.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by Georgelemental on Thursday February 16, 2023 @01:23PM (#34823103)
> The idea that “getting shot in the head” is a mysterious phenomenon that needs intense sociological research is so utterly fucking insane that it’s hard to breathe.

> It’s the shooters. It’s the shooters. It’s the shooters. The phenomenon exists because the criminals exist and are not imprisoned in every town in America for reasons that range from the deranged to the sinister.

Did I do it right?

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by sorethescore on Thursday February 16, 2023 @01:47PM (#34823622)
That’s nice, but what are they shooting? Peas? Water? I’m curious.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by Georgelemental on Thursday February 16, 2023 @02:03PM (#34823938)
> That's nice, but who is doing the shooting? Dogs? Potted plants? I'm curious.

We could do this all day.

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by makerofthings on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:05PM (#34825064)
In the uk, we realised it was the people and not the guns. We also saw that you can’t stop people being unreliable and dangerous, but we can get rid of the guns. We did, and we’re better for it.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by stuckinhell on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:43PM (#34825756)
The UK is island nation with controlled borders. America is the size of continental Europe. In America a rocket launcher was found near a elementary school in California.

Rocket Launchers are highly illegal. We have a massive amount of illegal weapons coming from south of the border. That's Obama had a big scandal called the fast and furious (https://www.politico.com/story/2016/04/obama-relents-in-figh...). The illegal guns they sold the cartel were coming back over the border and being used in crimes.

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by arghandugh on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:44PM (#34825771)
No, you got it entirely wrong on purpose. Maybe don’t do that.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by e_i_pi_2 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @04:35PM (#34826686)
We have one of highest (or the highest) incarceration rates in the world, we have 4% of the world population but 20% of the prison population[1].

If the solution was putting people in jail then we'd have the lowest rate, so it's gotta be something else

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_United_States_in...

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by ajhurliman on Thursday February 16, 2023 @05:08PM (#34827182)
We have a pretty low rate of disappearing people, compared to China, Russia, etc. which might explain the prison situation.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by e_i_pi_2 on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:50AM (#34837014)
Possibly, but you'd need some big evidence for that, it would need to be a huge population that was hidden from the world in order to make up for the difference. Population stats are pretty hard to hide, so "disappeared" people would count towards the incarceration stats

This is also compared to every other country, so to explain the discrepancy then it would have to be something every country does more than the US

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by Georgelemental on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @12:58PM (#34899772)
Putting killers in jail is working wonders for El Salvador, they went from highest murder rate in the world to safer than US in a few years.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by throwayyy479087 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:34PM (#34825602)
New Hampshire and Vermont and Montana have murder and gun ownership rates that refute this. It’s a hard topic.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by ParksNet on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:52PM (#34825902)
Its an easy topic: demographics.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by drekipus on Thursday February 16, 2023 @04:16PM (#34826334)
That's the dirty topic that no one wants to address in the gun debate.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by arghandugh on Friday February 17, 2023 @12:28AM (#34831135)
How dare you play coy and cute? The entire fantasy and brand promise of guns is that you (white) will be able to confront nonwhites with deadly force. It’s all vile racism on top, on bottom, and in the interior. Fuck right off with this dogwhistle bullshit.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by drekipus on Saturday February 18, 2023 @04:11PM (#34851134)
I'm saying it's a dirty topic, precisely because of responses like yours. That might be your brand promise but it's not mine.

Who said I'm white?

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by red-iron-pine on Thursday February 16, 2023 @04:47PM (#34826857)
you're burying the lede.

tell us what those demographics are.

Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by twretgfsd on Thursday February 16, 2023 @04:53PM (#34826974)
i own guns, somehow they still havent managed to walk around on their own and start shooting people
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by krapp on Thursday February 16, 2023 @05:23PM (#34827373)
Oh hey look, it's the bad faith green account. We've all been waiting for you to show up. It wouldn't be a political thread on Hacker News without you.
Re:Why Most Gun Laws Aren’t Backed Up by Evidence by 908B64B197 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @05:10PM (#34827208)
Let me see if I get it right

"It’s the trucks. It’s the trucks. It’s the trucks. The phenomena exists because the object exists and is sold in every town in America for reasons that range from the deranged to the sinister."

In foreign countries without second amendment rights criminals just ram trucks into people instead. Since no guns are involved, these don't get reported as "mass shootings", not that it would bring any comfort to the victims and their families [0] [1] [2].

In all seriousness, this isn't Harry Potter where the wand "speaks" to the wizard. An inanimate object won't "convince" someone to commit a crime. Focusing on the human shooting the gun would yield much better results. But say "mental health" and watch everyone suddenly go very silent and ignore the issue. Much easier to blame the evil inanimate object!

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Nice_truck_attack

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Berlin_truck_attack

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_Toronto_van_attack