Fund free public education. It pays back huge dividends.
A lot of people struggle with complexity and it is telling that a forum focused on computer science, IT and general tech is so challenged to realise this.
Whilst I love the cynical view, and it somewhat sadly clicks. I agree high school education sits in the grey. From personal experience the most valuable lesson I leaned in high school is when I was doing something I was interested in getting sleep didn't matter. But learning how to grind through work is a really useful like skill. There's no way to teach hard work. You just got to do it.
It would probably be more accurate to call them constraints.
> to paint the entire educational system with the same shitty brush is absurd.
I am not claiming it's shitty - I do believe you actually have to socialise kids, and familiarise with functioning of modern society, many families parents won't be able to do it.
> Three - grade people into quality batches, based off their punctuality and ability to perform meaningless tasks to arbitrary and meaningless quality standards
For example, doing math is a useful skill, not a meaningless task.
> Four - because the management has gone though the same system of education, the pupils must learn to read through poorly worded vague instructions and understand what their superior actually wants to see, even though they are not capable of expressing it clearly. Poorly worded exam papers serve as good training
There is a lot of nuance to English communication, at least among native speakers. Things like active/passive voice, hyperbole, and different kinds of logical arguments are implicit to communication in professional circles. It's important to study them.
Also you're ignoring the cultural education that studying literature/writing provides you. There are tons of literary references in everyday communication and you will be at a disadvantage if you don't know them (a "Scarlet Letter", "Big Brother", etc.). These stories are foundational to Western culture and you are expected to know them.
I can't define trig relations, I sort of remember how to do multiple unknowns/linear algebra, can't even remember the definition of a quadratic equation and I couldn't do derivations if my life depended on it.
Funny thing is I used to know this stuff and actually used some of it when I was in to game dev. 10 years later anything that's above elementary school I'd probably need to Google or Wolfram.
> There are tons of literary references in everyday communication and you will be at a disadvantage if you don't know them (a "Scarlet Letter", "Big Brother", etc.)
You can look up idioms/references without reading the works.
Now, could we reform the system? I supposed we could, but society relied on a set of assumptions on how schools work. If you need to implement reforms, you cannot focus on school systems in isolation.
Indeed, but now we are talking about change in two systems.
Like we have 100% proof that starting school later is better for the kids, but many people don't even realise that their taxes are funding childcare, so convincing them to fund additional childcare will be very difficult.
This is not to say that education, especially for boys and young men couldn't be made considerably better.
Maybe just maybe “the system” (as you called it) is just a seemingly more civilized way of doing what was done before: surviving.
Like when the Conquistadors "civilized" mexico Or when the Portuguese and French "civilized" West Africa.
Once you really dig deep into history you can see humans have been wiping off other nations and civilizations left and right. Assyrians, babylonians - all gone. One could make an assumption genocide and warfare are almost instinctive to us.
What's left are few rocks standing, if even that, all ruined by our own hubris and violent nature.
No matter, without organized mechanized agriculture and the nitrogen fixation process and other technology of the present, most of us would be dead and not able to ponder the question.
The education system is an education system. It's bad because it's underfunded, mismanaged, and pulled in multiple directions for political reasons, not to mention occasionally tasked with impossible jobs, such as keeping a roomful of emotionally disturbed children going in the same direction using only one underpaid teacher and a couple para-professionals. If it were actively designed to be malicious, it would be a lot more competent.
1. It has to be compatible with the modern system of employment (feat the 40hr workweek, generally a commute, workers who typically fit into many companies in standardized roles)
2. Opportunities to make it more efficient that don't run directly contrary to its stated goal of educating tend to happen, e.g. standardized testing. And because students move around and its inefficient for everybody everywhere to invent their own curriculum, they need to be standardized.
3. It needs to be legible meritocratically, to justify and measure it's own existence and also as an input into the employment system.
"maxwellhill"? :) https://www.nytimes.com/1989/05/18/business/mcgraw-hill-and-... / https://archive.is/bZKuA
(Because they'll all try to get you to do coke.)
To force highly creative people into this routine, is dictatorship of the mind. That's how it was for me.
It’s like trying to cheat your way into professional sports: if you are not a good fit, it won’t be pretty. And indeed we do have a track for athletes.
To think that all students are identical and they all deserve the same track is myopic. Turns out, we are all different people.
And otherwise or for highly creative people, a grounding in most other things is useful. If you're an artist of some sort, you're going to be writing supporting documentation for exhibitions, or running business admin selling your work. To some degree, I think it's healthy for people to be pushed out of their comfort zone here and there.
Yet the flaws in the system are quite real, and you have called some of them out. But calling out the flaws and claiming they are the intended purpose is quite simply wrong.
BTW, you can change who is in control - school boards are locally elected. Your vote has more power to change schools than almost anything else. If you want improvement, get involved.
I don't know your background, but we learned loads of things in school.
Go talk to some kids in the world that are unable to go to schools, and explain them how lucky they are.
On the more serious note, this crap which is so popular among the people who have zero understanding of what education is gets really tiresome.
With that, I think you'd find that most leaders of politics and industry had some manner of classroom education. Homeschooling is not a common practice among the elite. It may still serve the purpose of "habituating chimps into highly unnatural behavior" but if so, it's behavior that is so commonplace as to be indistinguishable from "natural" behavior.
So I'm not sure how we can ascribe all these negative objectives to the Education System as few better methods have come along and found wide acceptance. There's the Waldorfs and the Montessoris and the variety of homeschool co-ops of course, but they are serve a pretty small percentage of students worldwide.
There are some flaws in our education system that are likely the result of the fact that it is huge, serves an incredibly diverse set of people, and thus is a very complex and difficult to manage system.
There's no secret back room of evil people controlling the populace via an imperfect education system. What a weird take.
If I start living in my van to renovate my house, but I never call any contractors or work on it myself, how long is it before I just become a guy who lives in a van? In the same sense as the van, sets of institutions that aren't subject to constant maintenance and orientation towards their purpose evolve to fill whatever broken niche exists by way of stochastic individual action.
> If I start living in my van to renovate my house
Keyword here, "to". "To" imbues the purpose. If you then completely fail to actually do the renovation, sure, that's absolutely a problem, but the van's purpose was still to help you renovate the house. You just happened to fail at it. Intent matters, and the comment I replied to implies a whole lot of malicious intent that is more likely just incompetence or unpredictable outcomes. The difference is important in understanding how to address the issue.
1. In 1945, corporations paid 50% of federal taxes; now they pay about 5%.
2. In 1900, 90% of Americans were self employed; now it's about 2%...
It's called consolidation; strengthen governments and corporations, weaken individuals. With taxes, this can be done imperceptibly over time.
Corporate income tax doesn't matter much when the same money's going to go to an individual and can be taxed there.
…by "90% of Americans were self employed in 1900" do you mean they were farm workers?
An alternate implementation might be a larger condo / apartment where there's a dedicated 'house mom / dad / babysitter' to mind the kids during the day.
In a later stage society with strong / real AI I could see the supervision role entirely as part of the social infrastructure.
+++
Long term we probably need to engineer society for less children and a target of gene propagation at equilibrium / replacement rates.
In actuality education system serves four purposes:
One: make both parents avaliable for the job market. For that it must supervise children during work hours, to make sure they aren't getting in trouble, drugs, or worst of all, into politics and protest
Two - They must habituate little wild chimps into highly unnatural behaviour. Wake up early, commute into arbitrary location, sit in one place for hours on end, stare into paper, whiteboard or screen, perform meaningless tasts tasks that have no meaning to your life. Thats your whole life.
If you don't ease people into this gradually, you run out of psycaotrists.
Three - grade people into quality batches, based off their punctuality and ability to perform meaningless tasks to arbitrary and meaningless quality standards
Four - because the management has gone trhough the same system of educations, the pupils must learn to read through poorly worded vague instructions and understand what their superior actually wants to see, even though they are not capable of expressing it clearly. Poorly worded exam papers serve as good training.