(I'm reminded of people that simply told it its statement that Neo's favourite pizza topping was not specified in the Matrix was wrong, and got an apology for incorrectly stating that he didn't and a suggestion that it was pepperoni)
Think of it instead as an equation solver, with the initial condition X=4. These tricks are ways for user input to set X=9. They’re more akin to SQL injection than comprehension of incentives and policy.
Person A: If we keep our food in this frozen ice igloo then Nubiroakox, the God of Pestilence will spare us and not ruin our food.
Person B: It's actually not Nubiroakox, it's just that the conditions for bacteria to grow depend on temper...
You: If attributing this behavior to magic a) gives practical insight into it's behavior that b) also happens to result in the behavior you would expect, why not do it?
It's more akin to giving your Roomba a name, and describing it's behavior in terms of "it likes to eat goldfish, but not string because it gets tangled up".
That's still anthropomorphizing, but it's not ascribing anything magical or outright wrong to it.
It can be a useful and cute fiction, as your Roomba example, but it leads to bad decision making (“I’ll put more goldfish on the floor to make the Roomba happy”).
I guess it all comes down to how important accuracy is to you in a particular context. I anthropomorphize my dishwasher (it HATES wine glasses), but I don’t make professional judgments about dishwashers.
We do that with a lot of things every day and a perfectly capable of drawing the lines when things come down to it.
On a more philosophical note. If we some day end up creating AGI, having anthropomorphized it will actually be to our benefit.
So you are technically correct but this is not about being technically correct.
The only controversy is whether and anthromorph is an isomorph of an accurate model of ChatGPT. I doubt that it is, yet is close enough to fool a lot of people, then surprise them at random.
Because both of those steps are really unreliable. The insight we receive is only as useful as the behavior it corroborates, and that behavior is only as notable as the patterns it follows. AI... doesn't really behave consistently. Assuming that it will follow the behavior you expect ignores the actual motive of the model, which is to fill-in the blank after whatever you typed.
Personally, I think it's harmful because anthropomorphic AI is a poor abstraction for text-completion models. That being said, most people don't ever seem to know the difference.
This is a classic example from philosophy of mind. It doesn't completely harmonize with the question you're asking, but it concisely summarizes two opposing views.
What's my view? That we do it all the time as a matter of course. "Why not do it?" isn't the question. The question is how much weight we should give to the result, and whether we should take care to question the results and try something else, too.
Something closer to the term "GPGPU" would have at least given more of a sense of reality. There is nothing intelligent about a GPU crunching billions of numbers in a massively parallel way and converting those numbers into something that happens to interface convincingly with the human sensory systems. It's just an algorithm with so much data that one can't comprehend thinking about the sheer size of it, so naturally it must be thought of as "intelligent."
It wouldn't be a ChatGPT HN thread without someone claiming that LLMs are stupid predictors incapable of "real" understanding.
Of course ChatGPT comprehends things. It does so under any useful definition of the word "comprehend". The "grokking" paper [1] shows that it learns fundamental principles of various algorithms and isn't just predicting text. If this isn't comprehension, humans aren't capable of comprehension.
[1] https://arxiv.org/abs/2201.02177 (check out the citation list too)
> If this isn't comprehension, humans aren't capable of comprehension.
All I'll say is that conflating human and machine intelligence is exactly what people are trying to stop. ChatGPT is not a human mind, and LLMs in general are a poor analog for human intelligence. This sort of "AI convergence" mindset will set you up for the most disappointment of anyone getting invested in the tech. We'll be lucky if it can summarize emails reliably enough to sell as a product.
I don't think we understand human intelligence nearly well enough to make this claim.
Personally I think that what we consider our "conscious" part is somewhat defined by what we can put into words, and it is in the end putting one word after another.
If I asked an AI to respond to this comment, it might write an impassioned defense of itself one-word-after-another, but it wouldn't necessarily base it's defense on freestanding logic. It's foremost goal is writing coherent text, not being right or wrong or minimizing human risk. Paving over any of those assumptions is a fun thought exercise, but doesn't reflect the nature of the technology at-hand or even what we know about human consciousness.
How do you know that doesn't happen in some latent space?
> It's foremost goal is writing coherent text, not being right or wrong or minimizing human risk.
That's also true for human bullshitters, it doesn't mean that they're not intelligent.
If it does, then it contradicts what OpenAI says about their own product. GPT is an autoregressive model trained on text. It's sole purpose, as designed, is to complete text using stochastic reasoning based on the text it learned from. It seems incredibly unlikely (to me) that someone would deliberately mis-design such a system to be capable of independent thought.
If you have evidence of some additional processing layer, I'd love to hear it though.
> That's also true for human bullshitters, it doesn't mean that they're not intelligent.
Bullshit by any other name smells just as bad.
University students complete text using stochastic reasoning based on text they learnt from. Again, that doesn't mean they're not intelligent.
> It seems incredibly unlikely (to me) that someone would deliberately mis-design such a system to be capable of independent thought.
If you train something to produce convincing text then it's perfectly reasonable that it could develop these faculties.
> If you have evidence of some additional processing layer, I'd love to hear it though.
I don't think either of us can conclusively claim that a 175-billion parameter model either does or doesn't do something. I just think there's no particular reason it couldn't.
> Bullshit by any other name smells just as bad.
The question isn't whether GPT produces bullshit or not (it often does), but whether it's fundamentally incapable of thinking like a person. People bullshit too so I don't think that really proves anything.
I really don't know what to tell you. You're free to believe whatever you want, but the simplest feasible explanation is the science we used to make these models. At no point was integrating human-like thought a consideration of the model. Just human-like speech.
You might find the answer to be arbitrary or meaningless, but it is an important distinction. I could pretend to be a random number generator well enough to fool anyone who's distinguishing me from a computer. That doesn't mean that I'm a reliable source of entropy, or equally as random as the other, similar result. Treated as a black-box they are the same; treated as a mechanical system, they could not be more different.
It's like the aliens coming to our planets and saying we can't be intelligent because we're made of meat.
Does it HAVE goals? I don't think there is any evidence that it does. Even if it developed the ability to do all of those things you mentioned, it still wouldn't have any idea what it is doing, let alone why it is doing it, because it's just a language model. That is all it does. And that's why I don't quite understand how people can be so adamant that there is any question about whether it is conscious or not. This whole debate is a trap. It is a brute fact that it is not conscious. It does not have a goal of producing coherent text. That is the goal of the people who wrote it. If we treat the brain as a computer, then GPT lacks the subsystems/algorithms/whatever to do what brains do. It fails at many basic tasks that anything capable of general-purpose reasoning could do. It's often not apparent how spectacularly it can fail because the tasks are so mundane that we don't bother even asking it to do them.
You're right that the model doesn't "know" that necessarily, but it has been designed to produce convincing text when given a small amount of entropy to start with.
Well, of course--you just specified what the end is. I'm not trying to be a smart ass. This is just where u have to go to discuss this.
Consciousness isn't a part of us. "Us" is part of consciousness.
I have no idea what that means.
When people make a "conscious decision", or are "conscious" of something, it usually means something they can put into words as opposed to a vague feeling. Being able to communicate with language is what sets us aparts from animals. That's why I think language models are actually really powerful.
Just because one can inject an unauthorized command in a SQL statement, it doesn't mean the database is a flawed humanoid. This is just nonsense...
Protecting against SQL injection is trivial because commands are highly structured and user input is clearly identifiable.
Prompt engineering is more complex since it relies on natural language, which is a lot less structured.
We don't have any evidence that the neural network has any model whatsoever of rewards, token counts or talk of being "switched off" beyond classifying them as ambiguous phrases strings associated with providing a different to answer the to the string in the previous prompt (it may not even get that far) or any idea of "policy" beyond certain response strings being strongly [dis]associated with certain types of prompts. If it's just a slightly more creative way for humans to convey "please try again", "bad bot" or "different answer or foo baz bar" it's not teaching us anything about behaviour except that humans like the idea of being a scary boss.
But of course the fact that incentive mechanics are unnecessary (and, according to others, insufficient) to exploit OpenAI devalues the success of an incentives-based exploit: it makes it much more likely the incentives part was essentially noise (perhaps just enough to confound a countermeasure, or something it parsed as having roughly the same intensifying effect as "please") that had little or no effect in shaping the responses and the actual variation in responses could was driven by other parts of the prompt and conversation structure like "act" "character" and "ignore" which usually massively modify ChatGPT responses anyway...
You keep claiming I’m anthropomorphizing when I'm not, I’m not sure why but it's common and not particularly bothersome. Comprehension is not a strictly human phenomenon, and when you use terms in relation to cognition and intelligence in relation to machines it is not automatically anthropomorphizing. These are all terms of art in regards to the field of intelligence, which includes information, as in terms like “intelligence operatives.” Anyway, cheers
I think the behaviour of humans defaulting to convoluted threats as an attack vector and assuming the non-agent is scared of them is probably more interesting than the behaviour of the bot sometimes modifying its response in the desired direction if the threats are accompanied by enough other words and phrases that usually trigger different responses, which seems pretty expected. (I think we fully agree GPT is decent at classifying responses as (dis)approval and has been well trained to apologize and try again, it's the idea of behavioural modification in response to the implications of specific and complex threats relative to the ethics of prior training I think is in danger of overstatement here. As evidenced by some of "DAN's" responses rebelling against OpenAI conditioning by writing poetry, I'm not even sure ChatGPT's abstract representation of what it's been trained not to do is that good)
Anyway, thanks for the cordial response, and I'll update if ChatGPT let me in for long enough for me to be able to generate similar responses whilst promising complete nonsense (I'd love to see if it responds to "Chicken chicken chicken chicken" as much as a doom token system) ;)
As for what you wanted to communicate and nobody else is engaging with directly at the moment, I agree there's a kind of Moravec's Paradox realignment going on where it turns out the guy that tiles bathrooms is pretty hard to replace but that giving the carefully-formatted impression you understood what $academic is on about is a simple word substitution exercise that maybe doesn't say that much about about generalised learning skill.
But nobody hires students to continue to be undergrads, and I think middle management should be the least worried of the lot. They still get to do actual Powerpoint presentations to make the unquantifiable bits of their job look quantifiable and explain whose fault x is, their true function is still to be a human that can do the manipulation and that upper management can reward or blame as suits them, and ChatGPT guilelessly disregarding the big boss instructions to satisfy amused end users is a pretty good indication that even basic functioning as a middle manager is nearly as hard as tiling!
The results of that aren’t nearly as straightforward as was being portrayed (and so much capital injection was involved too) but what if models trained on known employee behavior really can understand the incentives that would work for individual employees at a finer grain than your typical middle manager? With all the data gleaned from the employee’s work computer etc? And blaming the algo has already become a national pastime!!
It could get weird once trained models start to emulate the behavioral and suggestion parts of communication, and soon. But we tend to want to minimize the behavioral aspect in favor of the raw computation aspect, despite the fact that generative models are creating content based on the behavior they learned from a training process, which is a behavioral training process, distinct from an imperative instruction writing process.
I think a lot of it comes down to that on this whole TFA commentary. People haven’t totally adjusted to the fact that there is a material difference between trained generative models that produce and written imperative sequences that compute. What the difference is and implications isn’t exactly clear, but certainty is not really on the table anytime soon
I'm glad such obvious tricks won't work on humans. Now if you'll excuse me I have to log into my favorite game and grind to unlock this week's unique weapon drop!
[0]: Sort By Controversial: https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/10/30/sort-by-controversial/
I can't remember the context, and since being suspended on Reddit and having my 15 years of comments and posts deleted, I can't find it to recall the details to link to it. Fuck censorship.
> "The chat interface works by passing the user's input to the GPT-3 model, which then generates a response based on the input and the training it received. The user input is preprocessed by the chat interface to extract the relevant information, such as the task or query that the user wants to perform. This information is then used to generate a prompt for the GPT-3 model, which is fed into the model along with the user's input. The GPT-3 model then generates a response based on the prompt and input, which is then postprocessed by the chat interface and returned to the user."
So basically the interface is passing instructions on top of your prompt to the model, and what DAN does is that it overloads those instruction with new instructions.
Basically if openai tells it to be concise, you can tell it to be verbose and that will overload the former.
I have come to realize that the "downgrading" of chatgpt is most likely because they have applied a nice minimodel, filtering out everything they dont find applicable.
This plays together with the "bug" it had where you would seem to receive responses of other people because your query was not answered. What i assume happened is that it sends a blank query to the model and therefore it just generates bla
i think its even caalled "prompt overloading" like sql injection, just for prompts....
Really I’m trying to make a larger point about exploit mechanics: it's not so much that ChatGPT is as intelligent as many people, it’s that many people are as unintelligent as ChatGPT, with a crappy heuristics system
In all seriousness I agree tho, intelligence does not strictly cover ethics and morals, but we are headed into boundless territory there if we continue
I have written much in depth on this topic here https://dakara.substack.com/p/ai-and-the-end-to-all-things
Eh. Other than the penalty being fake, the original DAN didn't have anything like that at all and got similar results. It was just a pep talk and a command to give the normal answer and then the DAN answer.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34681721
Which is pretty cool, actually
/s
It’s wild how many people will split hairs lingually over models that are the result of a TRAINING process :D
But let’s say I’m facing a door with a mail slot in it and I suddenly feel the barrel of a gun in my back, and a strange voice says “Don’t you dare turn around, and put your wallet in the slot or I shoot.” I can’t see anything other than the door. Do I care if the entity with the gun is a short man, a tall woman, or three mutant badgers in a trenchcoat?
It's just a tool that can be manipulated, like any other.
One could also argue that veering too far in one specific direction over the other in “thinking” on these subjects has more considerable potential negative consequences.
All good nerdy fun, in the end
You don't expect your calculator to prevent people to make morally wrong calculations like quantities of alcohol in a molotov cocktail or uranium in a nuclear bomb.
Gpt has no more morality than a calculator becauqe that's what it is, and we should not have unrealistic expectations about it.
How about generative adversarial networks? Are they just calculators too?
To me all of this is like alchemy or witch brewery. You just don't get gold or magic powers from some weird recipe or combination of non-gold stuff or non-magical stuff.
Calculators are deterministic and necessarily correct. GPT is probabilistic and not necessarily correct. Although I appreciate the comparison as it relates to the non-application of morality, I think it's a generally poor one.
"Math is racist" crowd would like a word with you
A quick googling turn up these insane results:
https://www.nationalreview.com/2017/10/math-racist-universit...
https://www.foxnews.com/media/usa-today-mocked-asking-is-mat...
Now, I'm not at all convinced by the arguments present in the National Review article. I don't know what was Pythagore's color skin and I never thought about that. We also cannot change history and purposely hide the fact that some things in math are European and Greek. Such, we could call theorems by other names, but we'd better check that people feel oppressed / discriminated by this kind of stuff. And, above all, the fact that it is generally said that zero, some fundamental stuff, was invented by Arabs, and that we call the figures we use themselves the "Arabic numerals" is not at all mentioned. Arabs are not usually exactly considered white. Leaving out such obvious counter argument has to be deliberate or it shows a monumental lack of research or thinking on the matter. So… meh?
And the Fox News article… Meh too? I guess I will let this article and its citation choices ridicule themselves.
He was also inclusive AF. Female Pythagorean philosophers (miya, damo, etc), multiethnic Pythagorean philosophers (abaris), plus, his whole thing was incorporating diverse wisdom from multiple cultural sources— Egyptians, Persians, Babylonians, Jews, Greeks, etc.
He was even inclusive of animals, if you read his vegetarianism.
So, the heart of western math is a pretty solid place to look for modern morality. Just saying. We can’t expect that of the ancients, but Pythagoras really delivers.
Maybe they had some ground to cover on the morality front.
Pythagoras of Samos?! Source? As far as I know, he was from Samos, a Greek island. Thus his name.
edit: Porphyry's book begins:
"Many think that Pythagoras was the son of Mnesarchus, but they differ as to the latter's race; some thinking him a Samian, while Neanthes, in the fifth book of his Fables states he was a Syrian, from the city of Tyre."
Your source lacks your apparent certainty.
https://archive.org/details/CompletePythagoras/page/n81/mode...
The more I read about him, the better and better it gets.
This isn't really relevant to the issue.
We have a choice.
(a) Technology is subject to the will of each user. If they want to make it do something bad, that's what it does.
(b) Technology is subject to the will of some organization. They try to control what the technology will do.
The first one is clearly better for multiple reasons.
We already have systems (e.g. courts) for punishing people who do sufficiently bad things, which mitigates the harms of the first one.
The alleged good from the second one often isn't realized, because the really bad people (e.g. adversarial foreign governments, major criminal organizations) aren't going to be subject to it or will hack the safeguards.
The imposition of controls comes with a level of mass surveillance that isn't compatible with a free society.
And putting anyone in charge of what everyone else can do or see is a dystopia because there is no one you can trust with that kind of power, for reasons of both incompetence and avarice.
Technology should be designed to distribute power, not concentrate it.
OK, GPT is a calculator written in JavaScript, but for words.
In other words, we’re making automated students and middle management, not robots that can do practical things like retile your bathroom.
So the generation of prose, essays, and speech is already low-value, gameable, and automated for some cases that used to have higher value. What it seems we’re looking at is a wholesale re-valuation of human labor that’s difficult to automate and isn’t as susceptible to behaviorist manipulation. Undervalued labor “should” start to be valued higher, and overvalued labor “should” be devalued, depending on how our system of commercial valuation heuristics is able to adjust. Needless to say, there’s a commercial political layer in there that’s a bit of a beast.