How does that follow? The conclusion would be that both the companies and workers suffered unnecessarily for 2 years, with no long-term benefit afterward to the layoffs. In other words, you should just ride out the downtimes instead of panicking.
After 3 years, what group would you expect to perform better financially? And if we told you it was a tie, you might ask: what did group 2 to improve their situation? Layoffs? Ok, sounds like they worked.
None of the big tech companies are in a "dire" financial situation. Indeed, some of them have just announced modest revenue increases this week. Yet they still conducted big layoffs. Did they "need" to do it? (Note in contrast that Apple announced a significant revenue decrease yet didn't panic and do layoffs.)
Did they "need" to do it?
Yes, that's the question. GP's point is that the financial situation of the companies is a confounding factor, and unfortunately the analysis does not address this. The conclusion, "Layoffs don't work", does not seem to be supported by the data/analysis that was presented.It's kind of like me having plenty of money, right now, to afford Netflix but cancelling it anyway because I feel $14/mo or whatever the price is still too much for the value it delivers in the current year, and generally worried that I might need that $14 in a year (multiplied out across a bunch of other services or habits I engage in). I'd rather save my money now, as I've decided the situation is dire or could easily become dire. Am I actually cruel and obligated to keep my Netflix subscription (gotta make sure Netflix employees make a living) because I am not, at this moment, in what others perceive to be a "dire" situation?
What if you're wrong, though, and indeed what if many people are wrong in the same way, cancelling Netflix and passing up the opportunity of enjoyment to save a little money, but in the long run it makes no difference, and only hurts them in the short-term by depriving them of the enjoyment? That's the point of the article, that layoffs are empirically self-defeating.
It's not about a mythical "obligation" to employ someone. The cruelty comes from laying off people unnecessarily, when there's no benefit.
But then they also didn’t massively increase their headcount over the previous 3 years. Steady as she goes, as always.
I would say that Apple is in the unique position of being particularly volatile since they rarely post losses. If they posted a decrease AND did layoffs, I'm sure some of their brightest would jump ship, and stocks would tumble further.
Plus they didn't really do a strong round of hire during the past few years.
Companies do layoffs all the time, even when their financial situation isn't dire.
In any case they’d still have lost two years of growth when their competitors were.
Companies layoff when they're in some sort of trouble. If you don't have the cash to support the staff, you can't will that into existence.
So it follows that companies that laid people off struggled for a bit. Because they were already struggling. It's not an instant cure, or even a guaranteed one. It's a measure to spend less so you can ride out the downtimes.
Another way of stating it is that "People who were sick with the flu seemed to tire more easily in the days that followed compared to people who weren't sick at all". It's to be expected.
No, companies layoff when they want to spend less money paying people. Being "in some sort of trouble" is only one of many reasons why they may choose that course.
You should think harder about what might drive layoffs.
In that context I was told, "Tutor this guy (a fair worker, but not exceptional). We're going to let him go if he can't step it up." We worked together and I saved his job - it remains a very proud moment for me.
The company was a leader in its field, and its merciless practice of retaining only the very best performers contributed to its success.
Capitalism at its Darwinian worst, perhaps. Or its best, depending on your perspective.
"makes no difference" != "ended up in the same place"
Recent history has shown companies also do layoffs when things aren't bad.
If the companies that lay people off are much worse off than the average comparison company, and they look the same as comparison companies after 3 years... then it sure makes sense to do it.
I'd love to see this controlled for shareholder dividends and stock buybacks. A big trend we're seeing in this round of layoffs is companies doing a lot of service for their shareholders, some posting record profits, and sacking fractions of their workforce. It doesn't tell a story of sacrifices made due to financial trouble, it looks like nothing but ruthless profiteering and class warfare.
This is somewhat counter-intuitive to me so I suspect there are other confounders (overhiring, measuring financial performance in a complicated way, etc.) but I haven't had time to run the analysis for myself yet. Maybe the data is too sparse to support a more sophisticated model.
If someone else would like to give it a shot, it looks like these people have compiled the data in a convenient format, for at least the past two years: https://fueled.com/blog/2022-fortune-1000-companies-spreadsh...
You're correct, obviously, on the general correlation aspect of companies having financial trouble and having to do layoffs.
The thing with many of these tech layoffs though, is these are in some cases companies with no trouble whatsoever. Companies with so many billions in the bank that they could continue to pay all salaries to everyone for a century without breaking a sweat. So they have zero need to reduce expenses.
> The downsized companies, however, were outperformed consistently by the nondownsized ones during the initial two years following the downsizing.
Can you think of any confounding factors in this analysis? How do you control for important factors like, say: whether the board is in enough financial trouble to downsize?