News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by oconnore on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:00PM (#34643933)
This is incredibly dumb.

> The downsized companies, however, were outperformed consistently by the nondownsized ones during the initial two years following the downsizing.

Can you think of any confounding factors in this analysis? How do you control for important factors like, say: whether the board is in enough financial trouble to downsize?

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by tomnipotent on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:12PM (#34644172)
Don't forget the next bit, "by the third year, these differences became statistically nonsignificant". So the layoffs... worked?
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by lapcat on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:21PM (#34644346)
> So the layoffs... worked?

How does that follow? The conclusion would be that both the companies and workers suffered unnecessarily for 2 years, with no long-term benefit afterward to the layoffs. In other words, you should just ride out the downtimes instead of panicking.

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by dtdimond on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:25PM (#34644417)
Group 1: companies in a good enough financial situation to not need layoffs Group 2: companies in a dire financial situation requiring layoffs

After 3 years, what group would you expect to perform better financially? And if we told you it was a tie, you might ask: what did group 2 to improve their situation? Layoffs? Ok, sounds like they worked.

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by lapcat on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:28PM (#34644492)
> Group 1: companies in a good enough financial situation to not need layoffs Group 2: companies in a dire financial situation requiring layoffs

None of the big tech companies are in a "dire" financial situation. Indeed, some of them have just announced modest revenue increases this week. Yet they still conducted big layoffs. Did they "need" to do it? (Note in contrast that Apple announced a significant revenue decrease yet didn't panic and do layoffs.)

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by geph2021 on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:48PM (#34644901)

   Did they "need" to do it?
Yes, that's the question. GP's point is that the financial situation of the companies is a confounding factor, and unfortunately the analysis does not address this. The conclusion, "Layoffs don't work", does not seem to be supported by the data/analysis that was presented.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by notinfuriated on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:54PM (#34645039)
Depends on your definition of "dire." Perhaps some companies have Finance departments that believe they're in a dire situation when they have less than six months runway if all revenue stopped. I don't know what they factor in to the decision other than they believe their costs are too high given the current economic conditions.

It's kind of like me having plenty of money, right now, to afford Netflix but cancelling it anyway because I feel $14/mo or whatever the price is still too much for the value it delivers in the current year, and generally worried that I might need that $14 in a year (multiplied out across a bunch of other services or habits I engage in). I'd rather save my money now, as I've decided the situation is dire or could easily become dire. Am I actually cruel and obligated to keep my Netflix subscription (gotta make sure Netflix employees make a living) because I am not, at this moment, in what others perceive to be a "dire" situation?

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by lapcat on Friday February 03, 2023 @01:14PM (#34645393)
> because I feel $14/mo or whatever the price is still too much for the value it delivers in the current year, and generally worried that I might need that $14 in a year

What if you're wrong, though, and indeed what if many people are wrong in the same way, cancelling Netflix and passing up the opportunity of enjoyment to save a little money, but in the long run it makes no difference, and only hurts them in the short-term by depriving them of the enjoyment? That's the point of the article, that layoffs are empirically self-defeating.

It's not about a mythical "obligation" to employ someone. The cruelty comes from laying off people unnecessarily, when there's no benefit.

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by Aeolun on Friday February 03, 2023 @08:47PM (#34650480)
I think it’s more that cancelling your existing Netflix contract for a few months because it’s too expensive right now, knowing that you’ll likely want it again 6 month in the future, and knowing Netflix will likely increase the price to $21/month for new contracts, seems a little bit shortsighted.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by simonh on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:12PM (#34647080)
> Apple announced a significant revenue decrease yet didn't panic and do layoffs.

But then they also didn’t massively increase their headcount over the previous 3 years. Steady as she goes, as always.

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by deafpolygon on Saturday February 04, 2023 @12:27AM (#34651814)
> Apple announced a significant revenue decrease yet didn't panic and do layoffs.

I would say that Apple is in the unique position of being particularly volatile since they rarely post losses. If they posted a decrease AND did layoffs, I'm sure some of their brightest would jump ship, and stocks would tumble further.

Plus they didn't really do a strong round of hire during the past few years.

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by dbingham on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:40PM (#34644738)
The assumption that the companies doing layoffs "need" to do layoffs isn't necessarily well founded. Really we should be comparing companies in comparable financial situations - with one group doing layoffs and the other not. For public companies, we could probably reasonably set up this comparison, but for private companies we don't have the data.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by tablespoon on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:43PM (#34644786)
> Group 1: companies in a good enough financial situation to not need layoffs Group 2: companies in a dire financial situation requiring layoffs

Companies do layoffs all the time, even when their financial situation isn't dire.

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by Aeolun on Friday February 03, 2023 @08:44PM (#34650455)
I don’t think there is nearly enough information there to conclude that.

In any case they’d still have lost two years of growth when their competitors were.

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by goodoldneon on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:25PM (#34644427)
Maybe there's selection bias, where the companies who downsized were doing worse than the companies who didn't. So if both sets of companies ended up the same, and one set was initially doing worse than the other, then that'd mean layoffs worked
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by bena on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:34PM (#34644626)
Companies typically don't layoff because they want to have a laugh.

Companies layoff when they're in some sort of trouble. If you don't have the cash to support the staff, you can't will that into existence.

So it follows that companies that laid people off struggled for a bit. Because they were already struggling. It's not an instant cure, or even a guaranteed one. It's a measure to spend less so you can ride out the downtimes.

Another way of stating it is that "People who were sick with the flu seemed to tire more easily in the days that followed compared to people who weren't sick at all". It's to be expected.

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by tablespoon on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:44PM (#34644817)
> Companies layoff when they're in some sort of trouble. If you don't have the cash to support the staff, you can't will that into existence.

No, companies layoff when they want to spend less money paying people. Being "in some sort of trouble" is only one of many reasons why they may choose that course.

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by foobiekr on Friday February 03, 2023 @01:13PM (#34645381)
You’re missing a number of critical factors. One of them is that companies have largely abdicated performance management and managing out underperformers, and layoffs are a primary means to get this done. Another issue is that larger companies have incentives problem when headcount justifies manager-track promotions. Layoffs are a way to force them to address dead weight headcount.

You should think harder about what might drive layoffs.

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by cheese_van on Friday February 03, 2023 @02:18PM (#34646456)
Yes, I experienced this. About every year and a half, my company instructed each office to layoff a certain number. Low performers were targeted. If an office didn't have low performers, good performers were let go, and only the very best were retained. It cruelly encouraged and enforced exceptional output. It was heartbreaking, actually. But the pay was very good and we accepted it.

In that context I was told, "Tutor this guy (a fair worker, but not exceptional). We're going to let him go if he can't step it up." We worked together and I saved his job - it remains a very proud moment for me.

The company was a leader in its field, and its merciless practice of retaining only the very best performers contributed to its success.

Capitalism at its Darwinian worst, perhaps. Or its best, depending on your perspective.

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by mrjin on Friday February 03, 2023 @10:59PM (#34651347)
But you forgot to mention one vital thing: layoffs make the financial sheets look much better at given spot, and the C*Oes might even get a bonus for it. Giving in most of the cases, the executives are just employees, they cannot care less if the company and/or employees doing the actual work hurt in the next couple of years as by which time they might have either secured a new job from another company by delivering the layoffs "successfully" or walked out with a decent paycheck.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by Gibbon1 on Saturday February 04, 2023 @02:06AM (#34652340)
It's pretty obvious to me at this point that most of the time layoffs are driven by exceptions of financial annalists. A point of order none of those guys have ever been involved in running firms. And the certainly don't care about anything beyond how long a median 'investor' holds stock.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by raincom on Friday February 03, 2023 @06:18PM (#34649228)
Layoffs are indifferent to outcomes by the third year.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by brookst on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:09PM (#34644114)
What? Next you’re going to find fault in my analysis that proves CPR kills people, as evidenced by the number of people who die after receiving CPR compared to those who just have a normal day.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by ejb999 on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:26PM (#34644435)
good analogy (not being sarcastic)
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by cuteboy19 on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:43PM (#34644792)
You have to prove that CPR works. The burden of proof is not on anyone to prove that CPR does not work. In that sense the idea that the difference becomes insignificant after just 3 years is quite damning
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by recursive on Friday February 03, 2023 @01:13PM (#34645390)
Damning to which side of the argument? Sounds like evidence that the layoffs worked to me.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by cuteboy19 on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:03PM (#34646978)
If an action makes no difference then it makes no sense to actively do it.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by recursive on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:22PM (#34647192)
Companies do layoffs when things are bad.

"makes no difference" != "ended up in the same place"

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by whitemary on Saturday February 04, 2023 @10:06AM (#34655002)
>Companies do layoffs when things are bad.

Recent history has shown companies also do layoffs when things aren't bad.

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by mlyle on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:10PM (#34647055)
Assuming the companies that layoff are in equivalent situation to those that didn't.

If the companies that lay people off are much worse off than the average comparison company, and they look the same as comparison companies after 3 years... then it sure makes sense to do it.

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by twelve40 on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:50PM (#34647550)
yeah it's like doing CPR on a healthy person (profitable company). of course it works! but is it necessary?
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by Joeri on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:44PM (#34644821)
Has anyone here read the full paper and checked whether they controlled for this?
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by s1artibartfast on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:51PM (#34644968)
Per the article, they just took the fortune 1,000 companies and look at the ones that laid off during the 2008 crash versus the ones that didn't.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by klyrs on Friday February 03, 2023 @01:10PM (#34645331)
> How do you control for important factors like, say: whether the board is in enough financial trouble to downsize?

I'd love to see this controlled for shareholder dividends and stock buybacks. A big trend we're seeing in this round of layoffs is companies doing a lot of service for their shareholders, some posting record profits, and sacking fractions of their workforce. It doesn't tell a story of sacrifices made due to financial trouble, it looks like nothing but ruthless profiteering and class warfare.

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by ricardobeat on Friday February 03, 2023 @06:41PM (#34649474)
You’re assuming downsizing is a consequence of financial trouble. It has not been the case for almost every layoff that happened recently.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by zeroonetwothree on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:58AM (#34652293)
How do you reckon that? All the big tech companies had huge income declines.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by fithisux on Saturday February 04, 2023 @06:05AM (#34653528)
This is what they say! But is this supported by data?
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by SturgeonsLaw on Saturday February 04, 2023 @07:27AM (#34653954)
Oh no, poor Alphabet, they only made $23 billion in profit Q4 2022. The wolves are really at their door.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by anothernewdude on Saturday February 04, 2023 @12:56AM (#34651941)
Yes. They won't have data for companies that failed. So the downsized group should be doing even worse than the data suggests.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by kqr on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:27AM (#34652117)
I read the referenced (apparently peer reviewed) study hoping that it controlled for this obvious problem, but no. (I don't count that they measured "in a period characterised by growth" because individual organisational performance is rather noisy.) Maybe I'm the dumb one here, but when I read their results I draw the complete opposite conclusion: layoffs work but they are not a quick fix; it takes some time for the positive effects to kick in.

This is somewhat counter-intuitive to me so I suspect there are other confounders (overhiring, measuring financial performance in a complicated way, etc.) but I haven't had time to run the analysis for myself yet. Maybe the data is too sparse to support a more sophisticated model.

If someone else would like to give it a shot, it looks like these people have compiled the data in a convenient format, for at least the past two years: https://fueled.com/blog/2022-fortune-1000-companies-spreadsh...

Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by langsoul-com on Saturday February 04, 2023 @01:46AM (#34652235)
In context of the article, the big tech companies are widely profitable and no way in any financial trouble. Hence no point downsizing.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work by jjav on Saturday February 04, 2023 @10:05AM (#34654998)
> Can you think of any confounding factors in this analysis? How do you control for important factors like, say: whether the board is in enough financial trouble to downsize?

You're correct, obviously, on the general correlation aspect of companies having financial trouble and having to do layoffs.

The thing with many of these tech layoffs though, is these are in some cases companies with no trouble whatsoever. Companies with so many billions in the bank that they could continue to pay all salaries to everyone for a century without breaking a sweat. So they have zero need to reduce expenses.