Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work
by brookst on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:09PM
(#34644114)
What? Next you’re going to find fault in my analysis that proves CPR kills people, as evidenced by the number of people who die after receiving CPR compared to those who just have a normal day.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
good analogy (not being sarcastic)
You have to prove that CPR works. The burden of proof is not on anyone to prove that CPR does not work. In that sense the idea that the difference becomes insignificant after just 3 years is quite damning
Damning to which side of the argument? Sounds like evidence that the layoffs worked to me.
If an action makes no difference then it makes no sense to actively do it.
Companies do layoffs when things are bad.
"makes no difference" != "ended up in the same place"
>Companies do layoffs when things are bad.
Recent history has shown companies also do layoffs when things aren't bad.
Assuming the companies that layoff are in equivalent situation to those that didn't.
If the companies that lay people off are much worse off than the average comparison company, and they look the same as comparison companies after 3 years... then it sure makes sense to do it.