Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work
by tablespoon on Friday February 03, 2023 @12:44PM
(#34644817)
> Companies layoff when they're in some sort of trouble. If you don't have the cash to support the staff, you can't will that into existence.
No, companies layoff when they want to spend less money paying people. Being "in some sort of trouble" is only one of many reasons why they may choose that course.
You’re missing a number of critical factors. One of them is that companies have largely abdicated performance management and managing out underperformers, and layoffs are a primary means to get this done. Another issue is that larger companies have incentives problem when headcount justifies manager-track promotions. Layoffs are a way to force them to address dead weight headcount.
You should think harder about what might drive layoffs.
Re:Layoffs Are Cruel and Don't Work
by cheese_van on Friday February 03, 2023 @02:18PM
(#34646456)
Yes, I experienced this. About every year and a half, my company instructed each office to layoff a certain number. Low performers were targeted. If an office didn't have low performers, good performers were let go, and only the very best were retained. It cruelly encouraged and enforced exceptional output. It was heartbreaking, actually. But the pay was very good and we accepted it.
In that context I was told, "Tutor this guy (a fair worker, but not exceptional). We're going to let him go if he can't step it up." We worked together and I saved his job - it remains a very proud moment for me.
The company was a leader in its field, and its merciless practice of retaining only the very best performers contributed to its success.
Capitalism at its Darwinian worst, perhaps. Or its best, depending on your perspective.
Companies layoff when they're in some sort of trouble. If you don't have the cash to support the staff, you can't will that into existence.
So it follows that companies that laid people off struggled for a bit. Because they were already struggling. It's not an instant cure, or even a guaranteed one. It's a measure to spend less so you can ride out the downtimes.
Another way of stating it is that "People who were sick with the flu seemed to tire more easily in the days that followed compared to people who weren't sick at all". It's to be expected.