News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by ergonaught on Sunday January 29, 2023 @02:49PM (#34571958)
We occasionally "grounded" our teenaged daughters from their devices for various reasons. This primarily cut them off from social media. After a week away from it, even they acknowledged how much healthier and happier they were (mentally/emotionally). A few days after device usage resumed, those things tanked. We pointed it out a few times. They saw it, too, even brought it up themselves. But of course they continued using the stuff. It reminds me of the vast hordes of young people vaping who wouldn't be caught dead hitting a cigarette, apparently aware that this is idiotic but doing it anyway.

It's fun times to be a human.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by lordnacho on Sunday January 29, 2023 @03:11PM (#34572178)
Social media is basically internet era alcohol. Except alcohol has been around for a heck of a long time and the internet has been a culturally important thing for maybe a quarter century.

Just like in previous times when we discovered alcohol, various cultures also found ways over time to deal with the fallout. Some cultures don't do so well with it.

The same happened with various other chemicals like opium, tobacco, and crack, which all have had societal reactions over time. The contraceptive pill is another one, and I'd argue so are processed foods.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by superfrank on Sunday January 29, 2023 @03:29PM (#34572369)
> Social media is basically internet era alcohol.

I've always used sugar and high fructose corn syrup as my analogy.

In the early days of the internet we didn't have what we now call social media, but we had things like blogs and message boards that allowed for some connection with other people. Those things had some of the elements that make modern social media toxic, but they were mixed in with other good things and we consumed them much slower.

Over the past few decades, we've slowly refined social media to what it is today. In an attempt to retain customers we've boiled it down to its most addictive and unhealthy parts and pushed customers to consume more of that quicker than ever before.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by wrp on Sunday January 29, 2023 @09:41PM (#34575248)
The analogy I think of is the introduction of sugar to Inuit culture. Before the Europeans brought it, the Inuit apparently had no need to be concerned about dental hygiene and controlling intake of certain foods. For decades, there was the stereotype of Eskimos with most of their teeth rotted out. I don't know how many generations it took for Inuit culture to adapt.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by berniedurfee on Monday January 30, 2023 @06:43PM (#34588414)
Spot on. Humans are driven to optimize innovation to an incredible degree… for better or for worse.

The distillation of social media is still ongoing. It won’t be long before TikTok looks as quaint as MySpace does today.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by the_only_law on Sunday January 29, 2023 @03:17PM (#34572242)
> Social media is basically internet era alcohol

God I wish, I’d probably use it more if it had any similar benefits as alcohol.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by derefr on Sunday January 29, 2023 @03:37PM (#34572449)
I think the analogy flows through the idea that, like drinking in bars, posting on (some kinds of) social media can be used to make friends and/or deepen existing relationships; and that people often excuse a pattern of abuse of {alcohol, social media} as actually having this goal.

Something this analogy through-line makes me notice, is that we have clear cultural images of what a healthy use of alcohol looks like — going out for cocktails with friends; having wine with dinner; etc; vs. what alcohol abuse looks like — day-drinking, drinking alone, drinking until you pass out, etc. But we don't (yet) have similar cultural images for what healthy vs. unhealthy/abusive social-media participation looks like.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by dotancohen on Monday January 30, 2023 @08:43AM (#34579449)
I appreciate this as one of the most insightful comments that I've read in a long time.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by gerad on Sunday January 29, 2023 @03:25PM (#34572334)
I think it’s closer to smoking. All the cool kids do it, minimal buzz/reward, takes lots of time/money, totally addictive.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by eyelidlessness on Sunday January 29, 2023 @10:20PM (#34575432)
I’m 40 so I grew up with the “cool kids” narrative. But the only time I ever experienced it was when my brother pressured me once. I started smoking because I was bored out of my mind one day and the opportunity was available. Smokers were never the “cool kids” in my experience, at least not any more than football players or drama club.

Everything else you say is spot on, although the “reward” is a very nuanced minimal for me… it’s something I can go do privately by myself for a few minutes without needing to explain that. It’s probably the biggest conscious tie I still have to the habit.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by watwut on Monday January 30, 2023 @02:30AM (#34576862)
The rewards of smoking were social but not in making you cool. It was that smoking made it easy to find somebody to chat with and start contact. Smokers met outside, borrowed each other fire or gave cigarettes and became acquitances and friends. It was quick and easy.

Not smokers took longer to get to know each other and it was harder. But it was nit about cool factor all that much.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by satvikpendem on Sunday January 29, 2023 @03:22PM (#34572304)
Well, HN is also social media. I find at least some benefit in it, learning about new technologies.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by warning26 on Sunday January 29, 2023 @04:11PM (#34572804)
You're getting downvoted, but this raises a good point; how does HN avoid becoming a toxic cesspool?

It shares many attributes/features with other social media. Does it just come down to excellent moderation on the part of u/dang? Is it the lack of instant reply notifications? Is it that thread depth is capped? Only allowing downvotes for power users? Some combination of all those?

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by satvikpendem on Sunday January 29, 2023 @04:52PM (#34573149)
I believe so, it's hard to have flamewars as well since most users are limited from responding too fast. All of the above are good ways to increase the quality of discourse here.

In a way, based on the alcohol analogy, HN is kind of like an evening beer with friends at a biergarten, you drink socially, not too much to even get very inebriated, and if you try to, mechanisms exist to stop you, such as the biergarten owners kicking you out. You're not getting (or are supposed to get) drunk at a biergarten, generally speaking.

On the other hand, many other social media are more like clubs. Sure, you can drink less, but the entire environment is designed to get you to drink more. This is analogous to places like Twitter or Instagram which are specifically designed for you to use them as much as possible, like through only allowing short replies (thus stripping nuance and incentivizing short angry replies) or gamifying like counters and incentivizing heavily cherry picked and edited photos.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by qu4z-2 on Sunday January 29, 2023 @04:52PM (#34573152)
I've found a clear split between sites which are topic-focused and sites which are person-focused. Also smaller communities tend to be better. That said, Hacker News is unusually good even for a topic-focused site.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by SamoyedFurFluff on Sunday January 29, 2023 @05:22PM (#34573395)
I think HN does become a cesspool for some specific subject matters that are controversial or anti-vc. Other than those subjects high moderation tools and extensive limiting of identified toxic contributors helps imo.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by dragonwriter on Sunday January 29, 2023 @08:49PM (#34574920)
> It shares many attributes/features with other social media.

It doesn’t have any concept (much less a public one) of “following”, it doesn’t have public likes, it doesn’t have a DM facility, it doesn’t have a personalized algorithm, it isn’t ad supported (and thus isn’t incentivized to tweal its algorithms for maximizing engagement and ad delivery), it has negative (but equally not-public) voting and signals (flagging) that don’t require filling out a form and human review, and it has dang.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by giardini on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:06PM (#34582800)
Aside: Has anyone analyzed social media in terms of it's inputs and outputs and distinguished what factors are most critical/useful to achieve a particular goal? That is, an analysis/compendium of social media sites from NNTP to Parler and the pros/cons of various methods? A book? A report?

From small scale (e.g., "How to create a social media site", etc.) to "How to best use Facebook to sell XXX, to influence political campaigns, to overthrow governments, to confuse your competition, etc.".

A good bibliography?

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by BlueTemplar on Sunday January 29, 2023 @05:37PM (#34573513)
> “When we do things that are addictive like use cocaine or use smartphones, our brains release a lot of dopamine at once. It tells our brains to keep using that,” she said. “For teenagers in particular, this part of their brain is actually hyperactive compared to adults. They can’t get motivated to do anything else.”

/me checks how much time I spent on hn this week-end and decides it's maaaybe time to "log out"

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by satvikpendem on Sunday January 29, 2023 @06:16PM (#34573827)
Turn on noprocrast in your user settings.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by gardenhedge on Sunday January 29, 2023 @07:05PM (#34574173)
HN is an online forum and online forums pre-date the widespread usage of 'social media'
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by satvikpendem on Sunday January 29, 2023 @07:09PM (#34574199)
Online fora are social media too, doesn't matter when they originated.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by wilsonnb3 on Sunday January 29, 2023 @08:57PM (#34574976)
IMO forums don’t use any kind of upvote/downvote system for comments or content, so HN is not a forum.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by mertd on Sunday January 29, 2023 @04:13PM (#34572812)
What are the benefits of alcohol?
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by ben_w on Sunday January 29, 2023 @04:28PM (#34572953)
Social lubricant. People are often more at-ease when slightly tipsy.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by Levitz on Sunday January 29, 2023 @06:04PM (#34573730)
It's not as if people who don't drink are socially inept or anything. My guess is that we get used to alcohol and just rely on it. Like sleep pills.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by ben_w on Sunday January 29, 2023 @06:39PM (#34573987)
And bikes can still be pedalled without oil, lubricants just makes things a bit easier.

Too much and you become anti-social, but that's a separate problem.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by mertd on Sunday January 29, 2023 @09:41PM (#34575256)
Doesn't social media have the same benefit when used in moderation? It makes it easier to get in touch with friends and make new ones based on shared interests.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by ben_w on Monday January 30, 2023 @02:50AM (#34576988)
At its best, sure.

I think the analogy is we're still in the equivalent of the early days of the Temperance movement for social media, where it's somewhat dysfunctional (like not drinking alcohol in the early 19th century US) to not have at least some account somewhere.

We may well be speed-running this. I won't be surprised by an attempt to ban "hard liquor" like FB and Twitter, nor if they decide to ban everything including "beer" places like here.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temperance_movement

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by berniedurfee on Monday January 30, 2023 @06:45PM (#34588438)
The anonymity of the internet removes inhibitions much more than alcohol!
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by Tempest1981 on Sunday January 29, 2023 @03:15PM (#34572226)
But more insidious
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by lordnacho on Sunday January 29, 2023 @03:28PM (#34572356)
I'd say the fact that the internet is clearly useful in certain ways is a thing that allows some of the downsides to travel along.

With something like recreational drugs, the upsides are just pure hedonism, you do them because they make you feel a certain way and the downsides aren't inextricably connected. Plus the downsides are pretty awful, whereas with internet stuff it's awful but in a way that doesn't require an ambulance. Basically social media addiction is a flu that millions of people catch and mostly live with, whereas drug addiction is a thing fewer people catch but some of them die from it, like Ebola.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by Wolfbeta on Sunday January 29, 2023 @03:25PM (#34572330)
Same as it ever was.

"One wants to do everything and one can do nothing, one is always thinking that from to-morrow one will begin a new life, that from to-morrow one will set to work as one ought, that from to-morrow one will put oneself on a diet; but not a bit of it, on the evening of that very day one will over-eat oneself, so that one can only blink one’s eyes and can’t say a word—yes really; and it’s always like that.” -- "Hlobuev", Gogol, N. Dead Souls (1854)

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by d_sem on Sunday January 29, 2023 @05:18PM (#34573366)
It's quite recent to have multi-billion dollar tech companies develop algorithms that are this affective of hijacking attention.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by ryan93 on Sunday January 29, 2023 @05:30PM (#34573454)
Food is more powerful
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by Retric on Sunday January 29, 2023 @06:13PM (#34573804)
Obesity is killing ~2.8 million people a year, and being over weight causes a great deal of suffering.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by j-bos on Sunday January 29, 2023 @07:42PM (#34574439)
I don't think obesity deaths were breaking a mill in 1854.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by Retric on Sunday January 29, 2023 @08:08PM (#34574665)
You lost me.

Obesity uncommon back then, on average people where younger, and there where only ~1.2 billion people alive in 1854 vs 8 billion today. I would be surprised if obesity related deaths topped 100,000 / year back then.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by j-bos on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:22AM (#34581892)
My apologies.

Your comment better illustrates my thought than me. The thought being, while human nature may not change much across centuries, some vices like food and tech are now more refined in their distribution and effects than ever before.

The idea that things are similar but not the same.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by primordialsoup on Sunday January 29, 2023 @08:49PM (#34574913)
When everyone is sick, they stop calling it a disease. - naval.

:(

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by imranq on Sunday January 29, 2023 @10:25PM (#34575459)
What is water when we are fish in a dirty river
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by ryandrake on Sunday January 29, 2023 @11:06PM (#34575667)
Obesity has not just been normalized, it’s being actively promoted. I walked by a Victoria Secret store in the mall today, and one of the models displayed on the advertising wall was not just “plus sized” or obese, but morbidly obese. Advertised and promoted by a major brand as if it was healthy and sexy. I don’t get out much so it was shocking.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by pbj1968 on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:18AM (#34576047)
Should morbidly obese women not be allowed to buy underwear? Is Victoria’s Secret not allowed to market to them? Should the entire world tremble for the approval of your gaze?
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by jakobnissen on Monday January 30, 2023 @01:34AM (#34576517)
I think the idea is that no matter if they want it or not, Victoria's Secret inspire and influence people, especially young people.

If you show anorectic models, they will inspire to anorexia. We all recognize that would be immoral. Now the inspire obesity, but because the pendulum is still swinging away from underweight, we don't recognize it for how sick it is.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by diordiderot on Monday January 30, 2023 @02:55AM (#34577013)
They should tremble for the ability to walk up a set of stairs, or go shopping without a scooter, or eat carbs without an injection etc
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by giardini on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:36PM (#34583359)
But they do tremble! Even the stairs tremble in fear and anticipationk(of structural failure)! Indeed I am "trembled", being on the parallel staircase in an adjacent apartment on an adjoining wall. I pause as the elephants pass.

Have a friend, non-obese and diabetic, who has learned precisely how much insulin to shoot up after various and sundry of his candy bars and caffeinated-sweet drinks. Impressive in a way.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by boppo1 on Monday January 30, 2023 @07:58AM (#34579016)
People who are obese should not be misled that they are healthy. They should be encouraged to lose weight. "Healthy at every size" is a horrifyingly wicked slogan that will contribute to people being very ill and racking up hospital bills.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by GoblinSlayer on Monday January 30, 2023 @03:48AM (#34577348)
Did you notice nobody complains about internet addiction? Because it went mainstream with social networks.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by nimajneb on Sunday January 29, 2023 @07:55PM (#34574545)
Not for me.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by AussieWog93 on Sunday January 29, 2023 @03:15PM (#34572227)
I've noticed that effect for so many things that have become cultural norms, from the food we eat to how we spend time with our friends.

Seems really sad that we're forced to choose between our own wellbeing and participating in broader culture.

Have to point out, though, it seems the one place where everything isn't toxic seems to be (certain forms of) orgnanised religion.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by nostrademons on Sunday January 29, 2023 @03:35PM (#34572440)
Hmm? To me organized religion seems to be the most toxic of all - megachurches and Internet-only pastors are the ones whipping up their followers into believing people that are not like them are existential threats worthy of being killed. The healthier forms of religion are the ones that explicitly un-organized: Unitarian Universalists, Quakers, your local community church that serves as a gathering place for like-minded folks but isn't interested in imposing their beliefs on others.

Maybe the lesson there is that organization is the evil, given that it seems to pop up in so many contexts (megacorps < small businesses, megachurches < community organizations, public schooling < small private/parochial/charter schools, big government < grassroots organizations). Would make sense, since an organization, by definition, is about subsuming what individually makes you happy so you can be a part of something bigger. The bigger the organization grows, the less it can fit the authentic selves of the people who support it.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by akkartik on Sunday January 29, 2023 @04:19PM (#34572869)
The essential prisoner's dilemma of humanity:

* As a group grows it gets worse at serving each individual's needs.

* Large groups outcompete and disrupt small ones.

I think the trick is for small groups to be illegible to the outside world.

Fish school, birds flock and animals herd partly to avoid predators. I wonder if multiple schools/flocks/herds are always superior to a single one, as long as each of them is above some critical threshold.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by chowells on Sunday January 29, 2023 @05:02PM (#34573253)
Organization from the bottom up works fine. The problem comes with hierarchies that exist to reinforce power. If you naturally construct a hierarchy to coordinate, great. Let the hierarchy die when the need to coordinate is over. When someone co-opts that hierarchy to increase their own power and reduce that of others, you've got a problem.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by saurik on Sunday January 29, 2023 @05:33PM (#34573490)
> Let the hierarchy die when the need to coordinate is over.

That doesn't happen.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by chowells on Monday January 30, 2023 @03:08PM (#34585645)
It happens all the time in bottom-up disaster relief. Don't assume something doesn't exist just because you don't participate in areas where it's common.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by memling on Sunday January 29, 2023 @04:07PM (#34572766)
> Have to point out, though, it seems the one place where everything isn't toxic seems to be (certain forms of) orgnanised religion.

Perhaps what we are seeing is a generalization of religion in which certain aspects of social concern have effectively become religious exercise. This might be a challenging thesis to sustain, but where parallels can be found it might give some broader insight into the present moment.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by GoblinSlayer on Monday January 30, 2023 @03:56AM (#34577394)
You can participate in broader culture once per month, that should be enough. Anyway most people don't participate but consume.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by devwastaken on Sunday January 29, 2023 @03:14PM (#34572216)
Social media for teens are effectively casinos. They're designed to do that.

Those who vape would also smoke, vaping is far healthier to do, it's cheaper, and it tastes better. You also can't government regulate liquid like you can cigarettes.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by agentwiggles on Sunday January 29, 2023 @04:35PM (#34573018)
> you can't government regulate liquid

You certainly can, my city just passed a ban of all flavored tobacco products which will include vaping.

I disagree with the ban, but that's beside the point here.

I'm actually curious to see how things play out. The first thing that occurred to me was that vape shops might start selling unflavored liquid and also sell flavoring which you would have to mix in yourself. Not sure that would be passable under the legal regime or not.

Interestingly, statehouse Republicans attempted to pass a law which would have negated my city's ban. This was vetoed by the state governor though.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by devwastaken on Monday January 30, 2023 @01:37PM (#34584343)
And now the city has created a black market of unregulated vaping liquid. Sounds like it's perfectly legal to buy the base liquid itself, then you just add the flavoring. Much cheaper and fun!
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by agentwiggles on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @12:14AM (#34591453)
To be fair, I'm not sure that's the case re: unflavored liquid, I was just speculating. That said, as with any prohibition, yes, there will obviously be people selling vapes / liquid illegally now.

It's quite frustrating that as we slowly step towards an end to the senseless and wildly net negative prohibition of marijuana, we are determined to repeat the mistake with nicotine.

Lots of the motivation behind this seems to be the popularity of vaping among teens. "Think of the children" and all that goes along with it.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by rolenthedeep on Sunday January 29, 2023 @06:56PM (#34574108)
> You also can't government regulate liquid like you can cigarettes.

Alcohol

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by voldacar on Sunday January 29, 2023 @04:02PM (#34572718)
Vaping doesn't deposit nitrosamines, polycyclic hydrocarbons and tar in your lungs though? I don't see how it warrants comparison
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by manmal on Sunday January 29, 2023 @04:08PM (#34572774)
Nicotine itself incurs DNA damage and is suspected to be a carcinogen.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by pksebben on Sunday January 29, 2023 @04:47PM (#34573103)
I've yet to find conclusive research backing this up. Got any sources?
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by stirfish on Sunday January 29, 2023 @05:10PM (#34573315)
Analysis of nicotine-induced DNA damage in cells of the human respiratory tract https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22001448/
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by ApolloFortyNine on Sunday January 29, 2023 @06:53PM (#34574085)
Props for the link, but the full text seems to be pay walled?

And the important bit seems to be

>nicotine concentration between 0.001 mM and 4.0mM.

And they found an effect starting at 1.0mW. But, this is what I hate about pretty much all scientific papers that clearly set out with a purpose in mind (good or bad) is the abstract doesn't mention what the hell 1.0mW. Is that even a feasible amount? Is that one puff? Is that 100% nicotine being directly vaped? What on earth is it? None of this is mentioned, for free anyways.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by Firther on Sunday January 29, 2023 @07:57PM (#34574567)
It's molar concentration, the study doesn't really mention it directly of course. 1mM is probably high since they're looking at what concentration of tobacco causes DNA damage in e.g., a cavity, but the study doesn't think it's unreasonable. Other studies in animals used up to 4mM.

The full study can be found as the first article in this pdf: http://tobacco.cleartheair.org.hk/wp-content/uploads/2018/01...

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by Firther on Sunday January 29, 2023 @07:55PM (#34574542)
The full study mentions that other studies found nasal snuff produced the highest plasma nicotine concentration at 0.8 uM, with speculation that a large (emphasis mine) pinch would produce mM concentrations in the nasal cavity, right on target for observed DNA damage, yet incidents of nasal cancer among western nasal snuff users are practically unheard of. Similarly, rates of oral cancer among Swedish Snus users are so low that several studies now have failed to find any association with oral cancer.

This says nothing about rates of other non-site specific cancers of course (pancreatic being a big one), or the other health risks that are still associated with smokeless tobacco (stroke, cardiovascular disease, impotency), but it's somewhat telling that even anti-nicotine advocacy groups rarely mention the risk of cancer for smokeless tobacco products in their publications.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by ergonaught on Sunday January 29, 2023 @05:17PM (#34573363)
The "At least I'm not shooting heroin into my eyeballs" argument doesn't float.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by pessimizer on Sunday January 29, 2023 @05:59PM (#34573687)
Nobody is making that argument. They're making the argument that the danger of vaping isn't at the same scales as the danger of cigarettes. Or rather, they're pointing it out, because that fact is not particularly controversial.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by ergonaught on Sunday January 29, 2023 @10:09PM (#34575389)
That is exactly the argument being made.

My remark was about young people doing something that is idiotic (vaping to the degree they do it) who would not take a puff on a cigarette. Arguments that vaping is "less dangerous than smoking" are precisely "At least I'm not shooting heroin in my eyeballs", because at no point did I assert that they were equivalent.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by Karellen on Sunday January 29, 2023 @04:22PM (#34572896)
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by nimajneb on Sunday January 29, 2023 @05:14PM (#34573342)
This is my fear with my daughter, even though I'm addicted to electronics as well. I've trying to decrease my usage, but it's hard.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by Aeolun on Sunday January 29, 2023 @08:12PM (#34574696)
I know papa is constantly looking at his phone, but I believe it’s bad for you, so I don’t want you to do it.

Becoming the hypocrite is never fun, but at least I understand my parents now.

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by MandieD on Monday January 30, 2023 @01:18AM (#34576414)
“Don’t you ever start, Mandie,” said my grandmother, lighting her next cigarette from the current one.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by User23 on Sunday January 29, 2023 @05:30PM (#34573453)
Addictions are insidious. I recall that brief era when Internet addiction was a concern. Then virtually everyone got addicted so it's just normal.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by treeman79 on Sunday January 29, 2023 @07:52PM (#34574525)
That was my exact experience with a teenage daughter. She was depressed and rude with social media. She’s get it taken away for a month. Happy and energetic. Complete reversal in a couple days after getting it back. Repeat for several years.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by Aeolun on Sunday January 29, 2023 @08:07PM (#34574657)
This is no different from me and my mobile phone usage. It directly correlates with the quality of my sleep, and I know I should sleep more, but it’s just too hard to give up.
Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by za3faran on Sunday January 29, 2023 @09:38PM (#34575230)
I recall hearing a lecture from Dr Leonard Sax where during part of it he discussed the dangers of social media on teens. He also mentioned that girls were especially disproportionately affected than boys.

> But of course they continued using the stuff

Sorry to be blunt, but why don't you do your duty as a parent and continue the prohibition of those devices except for necessary things?

Re:Surgeon General says 13 is ‘too early’ to join social media by pxoe on Monday January 30, 2023 @12:26AM (#34576112)
It's because cutting off is the most basic non-solution, that doesn't actually try to tackle the problem or fix anything. (Perhaps less so for 'managing use and having time limits', but definitely that for just 'cutting completely off, down to zero' approaches.) In a digital and online world, cutting people off is inhibiting people's communication. It's just plainly unfair. People need the ability to communicate, and venues to socialize in, at any age.

Perhaps one useful and applicable distinction that can be made, is between 'interpersonal communication' (in apps like messengers, directly talking to people you know) and 'posting something on a platform' (in apps that are more like "social media", where posts are available to a broader public). Here, though, another distinction could be made for 'private platforms/spaces' (like discord) or 'limited/like-minded/focused spaces' (that aren't just the most general platforms, but something bit more specialized for some kind of content or audience), and the bigger platforms/spaces (that are basically just 'you're out there with everyone'. here though, it could be pointed out, that 'having a semi-private group on a big platform might not be too bad - but that it might be still out there and accessible, so there's things to mind'. or, hell, just explaining what comes with posting on a big platform and what precautions should one take). Explaining the differences and outlining where and what someone would be doing, could help, in a practical way that won't be just 'you can't do anything now'.

Cutting off messaging isn't something that should be done, in my opinion - it's too drastic. it's basically saying, 'don't talk to people/you don't get to talk to people', and those people are probably gonna be the most familiar/important people to them. Cutting off social media, could be done, but it's really worth talking through and explaining the difference between 'publishing something for the whole internet and hanging out in that broad of a space' or 'posting something for your friends group to see, and hanging in a private, familiar space' (and perhaps, enticing them to grow and enrich their own social circle and seek something there, not just from random people on big platforms). At the end of the day though, cutting off and prohibiting something can be just circumvented, as people might just do something anyway, and if they don't have the 'why' explained to them, it might be even easier to ignore the limits without much concern. With guidance, that stands on its own, maybe it could be less so.