News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by extr on Thursday January 26, 2023 @06:35PM (#34540403)
Interesting to read this just as I join a new company and am using slack "professionally" for the first time (on an all-remote team). My thoughts so far have been basically the polar opposite of this post. I was previously in a FAANG where the only tool was the internal messaging platform, which in my opinion, left a lot to be desired. Slack search has been miles better, and has enabled me to get up to speed way more quickly by finding posts from months/years before I joined that are exactly relevant to what I was looking for. Nobody uses it to bug me, and in fact most of the "work" takes place off-slack in GH issues/comments, Jira, etc, but integrates with slack nicely. There is no expectation of immediate response from my manager or anyone else.

It seems like most of the article complaints are cultural, more than they are about the platform itself. Obviously it's still early days for my usage, but strictly evaluating the tool itself, it seems pretty solid. Definitely better than "unnamed but awful FAANG-specific tool".

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by chemeril on Thursday January 26, 2023 @06:53PM (#34540576)
I agree! Slack as a utilitarian tool is perfectly fine, in my experience. Not great, but fine enough to be a value-add as a communication platform for business purposes. However, I have found the working culture supported and implicitly enforced by Slack-centered organizations to be rather traumatizing to live with in the day-to-day. The availability of instantaneous, chat-like group communication has led to an expectation of instantaneous responses and giving _anyone_ in the org interrupt priority has completely destroyed my ability to do thoughtful, considerate work. This is not a Slack problem in origin, but the use of Slack is certainly loading and pointing a handgun at actual productivity in an org that uses it heavily for business.

I'm sure that there are plenty of organizations that have found ways to use Slack effectively where it fits. I have not yet found one.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by sjburt on Thursday January 26, 2023 @07:46PM (#34541057)
I treat Slack DMs like email and respond when I have time dedicated to it. Very rarely found a situation where that was not acceptable. Adding do-not-disturb times and calendar integration helps a lot too--people can tell when you are not working, in a meeting, or in a focus mode.

The big problem with Slack is when a multi-party discussion starts about a topic and you need to make immediate input or be left out. I haven't found a fix for this, but it's really the same problem as coworkers talking in the break room, so I'm not sure if the blame can be laid at Slack-type tools.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by computerdork on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:34PM (#34541382)
Yeah, agreed, using Slack's do-not-disturb to pause any notifications works really well. To be honest, not sure why the article doesn't mention this key (fairly obvious) feature to decrease distractions... Just looked, it was written in 2018, maybe Slack didn't have do not disturb back then??
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by TheCoelacanth on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:06PM (#34541598)
I've found it extremely limited. For example it only allows a single scheduled DND period per day. Also no way to do DND excluding a few specific people or specific channels.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by aphexddb on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:29PM (#34541349)
This is the way
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by guessmyname on Thursday January 26, 2023 @07:36PM (#34540955)
> I was previously in a FAANG where the only tool was the internal messaging platform, which in my opinion, left a lot to be desired.

What that Amazon and the internal messaging platform, Chime? [1][2]

[1] https://app.chime.aws

[2] https://aws.amazon.com/chime/

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by messe on Thursday January 26, 2023 @07:45PM (#34541052)
Chime has been replaced internally at Amazon with Slack as of a couple of years ago for everything but video/audio calls, at least on the AWS side.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by DiggyJohnson on Thursday January 26, 2023 @07:59PM (#34541144)
I have to use Chime about twice a month to interact with our AWA cloud (govcloud) support.

I’m not usually the type to be so opinionated about software I don’t power-use, but: it’s awful.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by scubbo on Thursday January 26, 2023 @07:56PM (#34541129)
In the CDO business I left earlier this year, Slack was making inroads to A/V calls as well (though Chime was still dominant)
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by a_e_k on Thursday January 26, 2023 @07:57PM (#34541131)
It was the same on the Consumer side organization I was in when I was there.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by Krastan on Thursday January 26, 2023 @07:54PM (#34541115)
Google uses Chat
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by brazzledazzle on Thursday January 26, 2023 @07:40PM (#34540998)
Slack search isn't perfect but it's surprisingly good. I use it frequently to get up to speed on something I'm being brought in on. We used to use some crappy Microsoft instant messenger and I can't imagine going back. Slack, Confluence, issue search and code search make such a huge difference that I don't think I could comfortably live without them or some equivalents.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by zelphirkalt on Thursday January 26, 2023 @07:53PM (#34541105)
Compared to existing and free software chat solutions[1], Slack however looks like such a kindergarten tool. It has a terrible performance. Every time one switches a channel, it basically burns a CPU. The loading of messages when scrolling down a channel with many message is not working well, not pre-loading enough messages to make scrolling a smooth experience. Instead one has to wait half a second or so until the next 20 messages or so are loaded, then scroll, then wait again, then scroll ...

And the "markdown" text input oh my. Rarely have I seen a worse markdown input than in Slack. Maybe on Bitbucket or Confluence it is worse. It is as if they have decided to not use any existing and perfectly well working markdown parsers, but instead get an incapable team of engineers to reimplement a bug-ridden one with missing features. One cannot even insert an image at any place in the message, but only at the bottom. That means one needs to refer to the image in the message, when otherwise one could have simply had the picture in that place where it is relevant. It is such a headache for anyone more familiar with markdown. At this point just give me a plain text input, that has any normal off the mill markdown parser to properly translate my text into a message.

Oh and they still have not managed to implement voice chat according to standards properly, so that it works in all modern browsers. While other more feature full chat programs like Discord had this solved for years ago, Slack is still the same old shit. Now I have to start ungoogled-chromium every time I want to enter a "Huddle" and navigate to their website, where they will bug me with their incessant popup asking me to use their desktop app, which I have to decline every. single. time. because chromium does not remember to block such popups from websites.

So basically Slack is quite crap.

[1]: https://github.com/zulip/zulip

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by selykg on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:22PM (#34541311)
Go use Microsoft Teams for awhile and then tell me "Slack is quite crap."

I'm stuck using Teams right now and it is an abysmal experience. There are definitely complaints to have about Slack, but it can be miles worse.

Just today I was looking for a prior conversation to document it for the future. I selected a portion of the conversation so that I could paste it into another tool I use for documenting. I selected the text once and it deselected a good chunk of it. Repeat. Okay, clearly not working well. I had to copy and paste 5 times to get ~15 lines of text because if you scrolled at all it somehow deselected some portion of the text.

I mean, honestly, what tool doesn't even let you easily copy the conversation? Teams is that tool. That's just one of the many issues I have run into today.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by beebmam on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:50PM (#34541492)
I couldn't disagree more with this post. Teams offers such a better solution than Slack for virtually everything, in my opinion. Slack's voice/video chat is a toy, and it's unbelievably slow and unreliable. I am so glad I don't work for a company that uses Slack anymore.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by TideAd on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:26PM (#34541735)
I liked the Teams video calls.

But did you ever try to search for a message in a conversation, and have it give you just the message you wanted, without any surrounding context? Or have you ever tried to scroll through chat history, only for it to lazy-load 10 messages at a time, making you spend 5 minutes scrolling constantly to find a conversation from a few months ago?

Teams would even lose my messages completely from time to time. It was honestly hard to believe how janky it was.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by jodrellblank on Saturday January 28, 2023 @06:00PM (#34562910)
> But did you ever try to search for a message in a conversation, and have it give you just the message you wanted, without any surrounding context?

Yes; they seem to have fixed that now, I don’t know when but I was surprised when it took me to the conversation with context suddenly.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by progman32 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:03PM (#34541571)
It's very interesting how different people's experiences are. I worked for a company that used both Slack and Teams, and Teams always caused issues, was unstable, and had many video problems. Slack worked much more reliably for us. Perhaps it's a platform issue? Nobody in our workplace used Windows, everyone was either Linux or OSX.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by superfrank on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:36PM (#34541774)
I'm with you, man. I went Skype -> Hipchat -> Slack -> Hipchat -> Teams -> Slack and feel Slack is the superior tool.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by nivenkos on Friday January 27, 2023 @03:10AM (#34543803)
Yeah, Hipchat and Flowdock were reasonable Slack alternatives but Teams is a complete nightmare.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by version_five on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:12PM (#34541631)
I've found teams > slack for video and stability on OSX, but slack has a better UI. Both have been mostly unusable for me on linux though I think it may also be machine dependent (I had an XPS13). I've never tried them with windows
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by progman32 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:29PM (#34541749)
I think the Linux thing is machine dependent. I used a Dell Latitude something-or-other (7490? idk) for about 3 years, but it was the version that shipped with Ubuntu. Rock solid on Slack, and Teams mostly just had company-wide issues for us. But my colleague with the same model laptop and same Ubuntu version had no end to trouble with both Slack and Teams - turns out, the Windows version of the laptop had different internals and it struggled mightily. It was mostly GPU issues. Just thought that was interesting, mine is probably not a useful anecdote.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by ethbr0 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:29PM (#34541748)
The biggest problem with Teams is everything outside of chat/video that it tries to do.

Did you know Teams had apps? Inside of it?!

90% of the problems I encounter with Teams (bad UX, crashing, freezing, corrupted sessions) would be removed if they deleted every feature outside of chat/video and more loosely coupled themselves to Office365/Exchange.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by happymellon on Friday January 27, 2023 @02:57AM (#34543713)
Teams complains that my driver is out of date, but will only do it when I go to share my screen.

Do I stop my presentation so that I update my driver, or do I wait until next time I want to share my screen and interrupt then?

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by progman32 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:01PM (#34541562)
I believe this is a rendering optimization leaking through to UX. It's a bit of a pattern in recent MS UI, especially their "productivity" web apps. Another example I saw a couple years ago: Ctrl-A in Outlook Web Access only selects the visible messages + a small number above and below the visible messages, because the selection logic only has access to the currently-rendered items. That's my guess, anyway. I've implemented controls with this so-called "virtualized rendering" technique and it was a nightmare to retrofit to existing controls.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by webo on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:51PM (#34541883)
Somebody described Slack vs Teams this way:

- Slack is so easy and fun to use that we use it for things we shouldn't be (fun channels, fun integrations). It creates too much noise and hard to extract signal. It ends up being distracting past 100+ people company.

- Teams is so bad that people try not to use it. It forces you to use it minimally because everything is terrible. It actually ends up being more productive than Slack.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by robjan on Thursday January 26, 2023 @11:21PM (#34542441)
Teams creates knowledge siloes which is worse than Slack. Every company I have used ends up with people creating various "Teams" and channels under them, then everyone just creates group chats all the time because it's easier.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by patmcc on Friday January 27, 2023 @12:03AM (#34542688)
Here's my problem with Teams: the search is terrible. I know I had a conversation with someone (but maybe I don't remember if it was just them, them and a few others, or a meeting chat, or a team chat), I know what it was about, I know a few words from it...and I can't reliably search for it. Useless.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by matesz on Friday January 27, 2023 @02:33AM (#34543586)
Teams are much cheaper though - $4 vs $7.25 per user per month for a roughly equivalent plan.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by Jcowell on Friday January 27, 2023 @08:20AM (#34545623)
Honestly the (last I used) inability to go back to a conversation months ago via search is a much higher cost.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by patmcc on Friday January 27, 2023 @12:09PM (#34548545)
It's cheaper yah, but each time I lose ten minutes it costs me more than that.

That was part of the pitch at work - "oh, over 3 years our total savings is $200k" or something. Great, but if each dev loses 10 minutes a month, or is frustrated and less efficient for an hour, that costs us 5x that.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by jkmcf on Saturday January 28, 2023 @11:23AM (#34558870)
Unsure if it still is, but if you had a MS office contract it was free, which describes a lot of the defense industry.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by happymellon on Friday January 27, 2023 @02:55AM (#34543693)
And that fucking card UI absolute abomination.

And now they have just flipped the interface so you scroll up for new and not down. With no warning and no notification so for the first day no one could find any current conversations.

And the terrible "Teams documents" so we can lock away documents behind a specific chat. If anyone should be having layoffs, it is their UX folks.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by Sakos on Friday January 27, 2023 @03:42AM (#34543980)
I can't believe how bad the search is. Every time I need to find something we talked about days or weeks ago, it's torture.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by dylan604 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @10:04PM (#34541969)
Just because MS Teams is an even worse train wreck does not automatically make Slack brilliant. The whataboutism when people criticize a program that they happen to like is wild. The complaints in the GP are exact complaints I have. I'd even add having to type a space before using a slash character when all you want to do is type a path to something.

Yes, MS Teams might actually suck worse, but don't try to diminish valid complaints about something else that also sucks

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by bayindirh on Friday January 27, 2023 @03:52AM (#34544034)
Just because Teams is bad, and it's bad, make no mistake, it doesn't make Slack a good tool. Slack is just a resource hog which creates too much noise.

Neither are good tools.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by hot_gril on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:15PM (#34541259)
I've used Discord for work chat before. It's not designed for that, but it does a better job than Slack, MS Teams, or Google Chat.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by class4behavior on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:10PM (#34541608)
Well, if you have the opportunity to choose, it's a bad choice to surrender your communications to a commercial globally centralized black box both professionally and privately. Moving to Zulip, RocketChat, Matrix/Jitsi, etc. instead of Slack, Discord or even Signal/Whatsapp should be the long-term goal for everyone.

Adobe has already started to feed its customers' data to its AI. Who says, other providers won't take advantage of broad contracts and terms in order to avoid informing their clients.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by hot_gril on Friday January 27, 2023 @04:02PM (#34551808)
One big hurdle to this is how there's no widely-used open standard. Many corps don't want to commit to something niche that might lose support, but if there were many interchangeable services for the same kind of chat, it'd be a different story. The standard used to be XMPP, but I used to work with that closely and can rant for an hour about every reason it failed, and maybe any new standard would have similar problems.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by KyeRussell on Friday January 27, 2023 @06:01AM (#34544731)
Part of my criteria for a work IM tool is something that non-techies can actually use. I wouldn’t wish Discord on my worst enemy, with all its weird gamer marketing language. And I certainly don’t want to work in a team where I’m that far removed from reality.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by hot_gril on Friday January 27, 2023 @12:52PM (#34549291)
I'm looking at the Discord UI now and don't see any gamer lingo except for the "welcome" messages. I can see how the UI could be overwhelming with features, and my older family members couldn't figure out how to use it the one time they tried, but Slack is even worse in that way too. And MS Teams was so bad that I couldn't figure out how to even log in.

If it weren't for the security and reliance implications, I'd run a company chat over Facebook Messenger. Simple as.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by jxramos on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:29PM (#34541352)
I’m pretty sure it’s a simplified pared down md.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by folkrav on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:40PM (#34541803)
Looking at Slack's own documentation on formatting messages, they don't even mention Markdown. I agree it's Markdown-like, but they at least aren't pretending it is.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by jt2190 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @10:01PM (#34541947)
Not sure if your threads contain a lot of images/media, but I find that having images collapsed by default improves performance immensely.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by dylan604 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @10:07PM (#34541988)
one company i worked with was horrible with the amount of GIFs littered throughout the threads. it was like a light shining down from heaven with a chorus of angels when i found the disable anims feature.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by marmetio on Friday January 27, 2023 @12:13AM (#34542745)
I was surprised when it nearly froze because people used too many of those reaction emoji gif things on a comment. How is a tiny cartoon more important than than being able to use the app? It's ridiculous that they apparently didn't prioritize tasks.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by sacnoradhq on Friday January 27, 2023 @02:14AM (#34543492)
Others that came through:

- HipChat, Campfire (Basecamp) clone

- FlowDock, which was superior to Basecamp and Slack

- Textual

- IRC

And now there's Discord, albeit for different purposes.

Workplace is an everything platform.

The problem with each tends to be distractions, discoverability, bookmarking, an app/browser performance. You really have to have a strong culture of netiquette to use any of them AND access to video conferencing to have quick meetings, because trying to do everything over chat doesn't work.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by happymellon on Friday January 27, 2023 @02:46AM (#34543656)
> And the "markdown" text input oh my. Rarely have I seen a worse markdown input than in Slack

Let me introduce you to Teams.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by robertlagrant on Friday January 27, 2023 @05:37AM (#34544600)
> Rarely have I seen a worse markdown input than in Slack

Try writing code in Microsoft Teams. Slack is very decent.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by ryukoposting on Thursday January 26, 2023 @07:59PM (#34541143)
Give it a couple years, you'll learn to hate it. I have dozens of channels and countless group chats with 1-5 people. I was added to those channels when the channel members needed my two cents about something, but now I'm still in these channels, months later. Do I really want to be the guy purging all his Slack channels?

Just wait until you're trying to look up a really, really important message, but you can't figure out what word (or synonym thereof) to search for that will give you the results you need. Better hope you didn't leave that channel in an effort to clean up your channels.

It sounds like your organization already has a solution, which is a combination of GH issues and Jira. Slack is fine as a supplement to more structured methods of communication, but as the main communication method, it's a disaster.

Maybe Slack is better than the "unnamed but awful FAANG tool," but by your own admission, the bar is on the floor. We can do better.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by jxramos on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:33PM (#34541378)
Yes, jumping in and out is a freedom of your choice. I do it all the time. Do it ruthlessly when channels stagnate. We have a convention of prefixing channels with wg_ to denote working group channels which are short lived projects of limited duration. They get archived once the objectives are met. By all means leave fruitless channels, wait until someone pings you with an @ or they add you back to a channel. You can also mute channels that are too noisy but require your membership.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by ethbr0 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:34PM (#34541765)
Agreed. If anyone feels some kind of way about you leaving a Slack channel, parent's company is using it wrong.

I'd kinda guess parent's corporate culture also tends to accrete huge email CC lists? As that's the same human problem: add, but never remove.

And also, Slack search by default is global: you don't have to be in a channel to get a search hit.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by akdor1154 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:34PM (#34541383)
> Do I really want to be the guy purging all his Slack channels?

Yeah I think you do, if it's an endemic issue then there are probably loads of people in the same boat, who would like to see a first mover to do something about it.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by chrisbolt on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:09PM (#34541216)
> Do I really want to be the guy purging all his Slack channels?

Why not?

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by slotrans on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:55PM (#34541522)
It screams "I'm about to quit"
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by progman32 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:24PM (#34541722)
This is group culture dependent. For us, people popped in and out as needed. We cheered when someone said "I need a slack break" and signed out for a day, and were glad when we saw people clean up their channels because we knew they'd be able to get more actual work done. We got there because people just decided to purge one day, despite maybe looking bad. This normalized the behavior over time. It's just like walking out of a meeting saying "y'all got this, I'm not going to be of help". It can seem rude to some, but it can also seem rude to stick around just to for looks.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by robertlagrant on Friday January 27, 2023 @05:52AM (#34544671)
> It's just like walking out of a meeting saying "y'all got this, I'm not going to be of help". It can seem rude to some, but it can also seem rude to stick around just to for looks.

Rude or not, sticking around in meetings you can't add/receive value to/from is a great way to get nothing done.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by carlivar on Thursday January 26, 2023 @11:29PM (#34542484)
You've never witnessed a communications existential crisis?
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by 4ndrewl on Friday January 27, 2023 @02:58AM (#34543721)
It screams "I'm organised and capable of planning"
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by progman32 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:18PM (#34541668)
For many years at an old gig it was either a) almost zero docs or b) meager docs in the form of Slack archives. A terrible situation no matter the choice of A or B, but we chose B and at the end of the day we had something to show. Did it prolong our dysfunction? Hard to say. When I left the culture was shifting a bit towards expecting slack convos to be rewritten as formal documentation after the immediate question is resolved, which is much better. If nothing else it lit a fire under me to improve my technical writing. Seeing someone use your doc to breeze through a challenge is a special feeling. A good manager will notice that.

By analogy, chat tools are the coal-fired plant to more formal documentation's solar. Coal is comparatively easy and will get you bootstrapped, but it will wreck your environment. Use it to get to solar and things will be OK.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by ryukoposting on Friday January 27, 2023 @07:55AM (#34545455)
> When I left the culture was shifting a bit towards expecting slack convos to be rewritten as formal documentation after the immediate question is resolved

I am suddenly grateful that I work in an industry with heavily regulated documentation requirements.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by type-r on Friday January 27, 2023 @12:11AM (#34542725)
why does it matter what channels you're in? i just mute all channels except for the ones that i actually care about. my channel list is probably in the low hundreds but i hide it anyway and just use stars to show the ones i often navigate to
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by ryukoposting on Friday January 27, 2023 @07:56AM (#34545460)
Why aren't channels muted by default?
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by hello2023 on Friday January 27, 2023 @03:03AM (#34543755)
In my team when someone asks me to look at some issues, my very first question is always where they see the alert. Because there are a huge number of "alert" channels. And I am very "happy" spending most of my days doing nothing much than searching and looking up things lolz
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by superfrank on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:04PM (#34541185)
> I join a new company and am using slack "professionally" for the first time

I think this is the difference. Slack is great when you need information from other people, it's terrible when people need information from you. You, like most new hires, need a lot and have little to give. Once that balance starts to shift you'll start to feel the pain points.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by ethbr0 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:40PM (#34541807)
> it's terrible when people need information from you

I'd challenge this.

IMHO, Slack is pretty decent if one instills 3 rules in corporate culture.

#1 - No DMs. Talk about all work in an open channel. Radical transparency will also make you a better company.

#2 - Keep replies on the same topic in threads. I.e. don't use it like IRC.

#3 - Post-back end solutions/resolutions. A thread should NEVER end with "I'll DM you" or "Let's talk about this offline"

If these are followed, at some point you reach critical mass, where "question someone wants to ask you" is discoverable in your history.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by swader999 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @10:57PM (#34542271)
Navigating the threaded replies in slack is quite tedius. I agree it makes sense to reply this way.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by uglygoblin on Thursday January 26, 2023 @11:03PM (#34542304)
I've been pushing my org to open channel discussions using the thread feature and periodically will hear somebody say they found what they needed in an previous discussion. This is the way.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by superfrank on Thursday January 26, 2023 @11:31PM (#34542495)
I agree with #2 and #3, but I absolutely despise the radical transparency mindset. In my experience, it often leads to people pulling threads off topic and creates an atmosphere where who ever is willing to argue for the longest wins. It often feels like the same problem Stack Overflow has where you go "Bob, how do I do X" and someone who is not Bob will chime in and go "Why are you doing X? You should be doing Y." and you end up spending 10 explaining that you're not an idiot, you know what you're talking about, and you just need an answer to your question.

I think in smaller companies where people can set their egos aside, it's possible to make it work, but once you hit more than a few hundred people you're bound to have a few people who are constantly trying to prove how smart they are and they ruin it.

I've said it before, but I also feels very micromanage-y to me. Like, we're all adults, why don't you trust me to use my best judgement on Slack? No one has issues if I book 1:1 meetings, no one makes rules about who needs to be on email thread, what makes Slack different?

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by snovv_crash on Friday January 27, 2023 @03:23AM (#34543867)
If there are people like that they will spoil any culture, including in-person meetings.

If the culture is bad then Slack doesn't hide it, if it's micromanagey already then Slack will exacerbate that, I agree.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by superfrank on Friday January 27, 2023 @12:20PM (#34548751)
Yeah, that's my point though. Once a company hits a certain size, those people will exist no matter what you do. It's just a personality that a certain percent of people have. If it's just one or two people you can probably correct that but when you have hundreds or thousands of employees, it's unreasonable to think you can get everyone to see the problems they are causing.

The way to avoid letting those people interfere is to let me direct message the people I need to talk to. Why are you taking that away from me?

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by ethbr0 on Friday January 27, 2023 @02:59PM (#34550982)
I mean, you can also just pretend they don't exist. Not going to lie, I've seen that happen in Slack threads when someone random is inserting themselves in an unhelpful way.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by superfrank on Friday January 27, 2023 @03:55PM (#34551721)
I think it's a bit rude to just pretend the person doesn't exist and I feel like it would make the problem even worse. This person who didn't need to be in the conversation is now feeling ignored, so you've now got hurt feelings layered on top of what ever other problem you're trying to solve.

Also, I can't control everyone else in the thread. Even if I ignore the person that doesn't mean other people will. All it takes is one person engaging and it pulls the thread off topic.

It just seems weird to me... I hear people complain so often about how meetings (especially big meetings) are useless because they get off topic and it's super easy for a few loud voices to take over, but then we want radical transparency on Slack.

Also, also, I think it's funny that we're still pushing this idea of radical transparency when it turned out to be a total sham at one of the poster child companies for it ("Away"). It ended up being massively toxic and radical transparency was really just a way for management to ensure they could have an opinion on everything and leadership didn't hold themselves to the same rules. https://www.theverge.com/2019/12/5/20995453/away-luggage-ceo...

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by c23gooey on Friday January 27, 2023 @12:14AM (#34542756)
We follow #1 and #2 in our company. I like #1 because it definitely helps create a more open information environment. It often takes a little while when a new employee starts to train them into this. Quite often they will come in and ask all their questions in DM, I'll always politely push them to ask the questions in the appropiate channel.

I like #2 because it keeps the channels quieter when conversations are had within threads.

Something we've done recently is cut down the number of channels. We essentially just use #general and #random now. We're only a small company (<20 employees) so it facilitates a better information flow if everything is in the one place. One thing we also do, is if a thread contains valuable information we will transcribe this into our documentation system (currently confluence)

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by ethbr0 on Friday January 27, 2023 @10:57AM (#34547453)
To me, the biggest use of channels is "One place I would ask a question about {major category}"

F.ex. at my company we have #help-{product} channels where engineers from each product team hang out and answer questions once a day or so

I guess the primary utility is roughly grouping queries and distinguishing question from general.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by treeman79 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:19PM (#34541293)
Wait until they put a 30-90 day retention policy on slack messages.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by noobermin on Thursday January 26, 2023 @11:05PM (#34542322)
You're right that culture is a big part of the gripe, but chat apps in general do enable that micromanagement, constant distractions culture.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by Dave3of5 on Friday January 27, 2023 @04:17AM (#34544174)
> It seems like most of the article complaints are cultural, more than they are about the platform itself

I've heard this argument before. If you read again they say:

"slack empowers your worst people to overwhelm your best"

This isn't a culture thing it's a property of the entire industry. No company can stop employees doing this, not even in office. Slack on the other hand is a tool that actually promotes these interruptions.

It's like a table saw without the guard. Just because I haven't cut my fingers off doesn't make it safe, it just makes me lucky.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by tremon on Friday January 27, 2023 @05:45AM (#34544641)
I'm not sure I agree entirely. Yes, Slack can be a table saw without guard. But the guard solution for Slack is company culture: each team needs to have a proper front-desk process, and the manager needs to (viciously) defend his team members that are not on front-desk duty (if at all -- a good organization has a central front-desk process for all its teams).

There are organizations that get this right.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by Dave3of5 on Friday January 27, 2023 @10:54AM (#34547397)
None of that actually solves the distractions problem really. The fact is that using slack makes it worse.

I've actually tried a lot of the solutions talked about here and none of them actually work.

Software like slack is literally designed to make people interrupt you and pull you away from productive tasks.