News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by ryukoposting on Thursday January 26, 2023 @07:59PM (#34541143)
Give it a couple years, you'll learn to hate it. I have dozens of channels and countless group chats with 1-5 people. I was added to those channels when the channel members needed my two cents about something, but now I'm still in these channels, months later. Do I really want to be the guy purging all his Slack channels?

Just wait until you're trying to look up a really, really important message, but you can't figure out what word (or synonym thereof) to search for that will give you the results you need. Better hope you didn't leave that channel in an effort to clean up your channels.

It sounds like your organization already has a solution, which is a combination of GH issues and Jira. Slack is fine as a supplement to more structured methods of communication, but as the main communication method, it's a disaster.

Maybe Slack is better than the "unnamed but awful FAANG tool," but by your own admission, the bar is on the floor. We can do better.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by jxramos on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:33PM (#34541378)
Yes, jumping in and out is a freedom of your choice. I do it all the time. Do it ruthlessly when channels stagnate. We have a convention of prefixing channels with wg_ to denote working group channels which are short lived projects of limited duration. They get archived once the objectives are met. By all means leave fruitless channels, wait until someone pings you with an @ or they add you back to a channel. You can also mute channels that are too noisy but require your membership.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by ethbr0 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:34PM (#34541765)
Agreed. If anyone feels some kind of way about you leaving a Slack channel, parent's company is using it wrong.

I'd kinda guess parent's corporate culture also tends to accrete huge email CC lists? As that's the same human problem: add, but never remove.

And also, Slack search by default is global: you don't have to be in a channel to get a search hit.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by akdor1154 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:34PM (#34541383)
> Do I really want to be the guy purging all his Slack channels?

Yeah I think you do, if it's an endemic issue then there are probably loads of people in the same boat, who would like to see a first mover to do something about it.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by chrisbolt on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:09PM (#34541216)
> Do I really want to be the guy purging all his Slack channels?

Why not?

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by slotrans on Thursday January 26, 2023 @08:55PM (#34541522)
It screams "I'm about to quit"
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by progman32 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:24PM (#34541722)
This is group culture dependent. For us, people popped in and out as needed. We cheered when someone said "I need a slack break" and signed out for a day, and were glad when we saw people clean up their channels because we knew they'd be able to get more actual work done. We got there because people just decided to purge one day, despite maybe looking bad. This normalized the behavior over time. It's just like walking out of a meeting saying "y'all got this, I'm not going to be of help". It can seem rude to some, but it can also seem rude to stick around just to for looks.
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by robertlagrant on Friday January 27, 2023 @05:52AM (#34544671)
> It's just like walking out of a meeting saying "y'all got this, I'm not going to be of help". It can seem rude to some, but it can also seem rude to stick around just to for looks.

Rude or not, sticking around in meetings you can't add/receive value to/from is a great way to get nothing done.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by carlivar on Thursday January 26, 2023 @11:29PM (#34542484)
You've never witnessed a communications existential crisis?
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by 4ndrewl on Friday January 27, 2023 @02:58AM (#34543721)
It screams "I'm organised and capable of planning"
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by progman32 on Thursday January 26, 2023 @09:18PM (#34541668)
For many years at an old gig it was either a) almost zero docs or b) meager docs in the form of Slack archives. A terrible situation no matter the choice of A or B, but we chose B and at the end of the day we had something to show. Did it prolong our dysfunction? Hard to say. When I left the culture was shifting a bit towards expecting slack convos to be rewritten as formal documentation after the immediate question is resolved, which is much better. If nothing else it lit a fire under me to improve my technical writing. Seeing someone use your doc to breeze through a challenge is a special feeling. A good manager will notice that.

By analogy, chat tools are the coal-fired plant to more formal documentation's solar. Coal is comparatively easy and will get you bootstrapped, but it will wreck your environment. Use it to get to solar and things will be OK.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by ryukoposting on Friday January 27, 2023 @07:55AM (#34545455)
> When I left the culture was shifting a bit towards expecting slack convos to be rewritten as formal documentation after the immediate question is resolved

I am suddenly grateful that I work in an industry with heavily regulated documentation requirements.

Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by type-r on Friday January 27, 2023 @12:11AM (#34542725)
why does it matter what channels you're in? i just mute all channels except for the ones that i actually care about. my channel list is probably in the low hundreds but i hide it anyway and just use stars to show the ones i often navigate to
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by ryukoposting on Friday January 27, 2023 @07:56AM (#34545460)
Why aren't channels muted by default?
Re:Slack is the opposite of organizational memory (2018) by hello2023 on Friday January 27, 2023 @03:03AM (#34543755)
In my team when someone asks me to look at some issues, my very first question is always where they see the alert. Because there are a huge number of "alert" channels. And I am very "happy" spending most of my days doing nothing much than searching and looking up things lolz