News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by Aunche on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:05PM (#34456131)
For well developed industries, I agree that employee representation is a good thing.

On the other hand, America's friendliness to capital has lead to funding companies that end up competing for software engineers. This is part of the reason why developer jobs in the US tend to pay twice as well as those in Europe.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by virtualritz on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:19PM (#34456365)
Do they? And what does that money buy you?

I was on a wedding in NYC last summer. One of the guests I talked to was a junior dev. He was making 120k/y. He had to flat share. With 120k?

With 60k/y you do not have to flat share in Berlin.

And this goes the other way around too. When I worked for a multinational in Berlin a few years ago we had lots of Ukrainians that we hired at externals through a subcontracting company in that country.

Quite a few of the better developers applied directly and we happily took them on. The main reason was that they would make twice as much in Berlin.

But that was on paper. After paying taxes in Germany their net salary was less than what they had made net in Ukraine. Most of them went back.

Just saying.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by Aunche on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:47PM (#34456797)
>One of the guests I talked to was a junior dev. He was making 120k/y. He had to flat share. With 120k?

For one, every city with a lot of career options for young professionals is actively hostile towards housing development, except maybe Seattle.

$120k should be enough to live in apartment anywhere in the US though. However, with how high rents are, it makes much more sense to spend that somewhere else like an early retirement in a much cheaper city.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by ender341341 on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:45PM (#34457735)
Seattle is pretty actively hostile to housing development (it seems to be swinging a bit more friendly but it's also a "I'll believe it when I see it.").
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by AlgorithmicTime on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:02PM (#34457032)
>I was on a wedding in NYC last summer. One of the guests I talked to was a junior dev. He was making 120k/y. He had to flat share. With 120k?

Ok well the problem there is he's living in the most expensive place he possibly could. Live in the suburbs and you won't have to share a flat on $120k.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by astrange on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:17PM (#34458271)
That's bad for society because living in NYC uses less real resources (especially energy) and is much less carbon intensive than living in a suburb. The only reason it's more expensive is they're bad at governing themselves.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by tracker1 on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:18PM (#34459224)
Much of the property in NYC is just parking money into fixed assets... doesn't even have to be income property. I'm not sure the govt is capable of fixing the issue, short of separating corporations from personal liberties legally (via national legislation) and legislating usage requirements for corporate owned land/property. Both of which would be VERY hard to do legislatively.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by astrange on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:28PM (#34459385)
If there's no height limits, someone owning an empty condo shouldn't stop other people from living in the same building. They're paying property tax too.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by drstewart on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:14PM (#34457217)
Why compare NYC and Berlin instead of NYC and London, or Houston and Berlin?
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by Apocryphon on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:20PM (#34457337)
Berlin is a major European tech hub, is it not?
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by JumpCrisscross on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:26PM (#34457436)
> Berlin is a major European tech hub

Yes, between Tel Aviv and Shanghai [1]. Though on a VC metric, it’s a minor player [2].

[1] https://about.crunchbase.com/blog/top-startup-ecosystems-in-...

[2] https://startupsusa.org/global-startup-cities/

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by moonchrome on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:20PM (#34459252)
More like wannabe tech hub - salaries reflecting competitiveness.

Reality is SW engineering barely 2x median income in Germany untill you're talking like senior/lead roles. Meanwhile in the US grads start 2x.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by ivan_gammel on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:35PM (#34460273)
Local CTO chat in Berlin has over 200 members and it's just fraction of all companies that work here. I'd say it is indeed a tech hub with very dynamic startup ecosystem, with its own Zalando etc mafias.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by smcl on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:03PM (#34458041)
Presumably because that's where the junior programmer and the commenter in question are from?
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by skizm on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:48PM (#34457801)
On 120k you can get your own apartment in NYC outside of Manhattan and the expensive parts of Brooklyn easily. Plus that is for a new grad / jr engineer. They’ll be making north of $200k in 5 years most likely.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by justsocrateasin on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:03PM (#34458035)
Yeah but outside of (Manhattan and the expensive parts of Brooklyn) leaves like... not much of NYC? Most new grads do not choose to live in Queens, the Bronx, or Bed-stuy.

Assuming you pay $200/month in healthcare, ~$1800 a month to max out your 401k, your take home pay is about $5,000 after taxes. In Manhattan and the expensive parts of Brooklyn, your own place is realistically a minimum of $2,500, possibly as much as $3,000. Outside of those places, still $2,000.

Source: I literally just went through this process, as a new grad, making slightly above $120k about 3 months ago.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by skizm on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:22PM (#34458341)
$1,800 is a lot to save relative to your income. 50/30/20 rule says you should be saving <$1,300ish and spending around $3,200 on needs, so maybe like $2700 on housing and $500 on utilities, groceries, etc. $3k / mo for an apartment on $120k salary is completely reasonable.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by refurb on Saturday January 21, 2023 @02:28AM (#34464619)
I went through the same thing and had no problem getting a place of my own.

Plus with junior devs the salary increase is pretty steep in the first few years.

I think the argument “he has to live in a share flat otherwise would need to compromise on maxing out with 401k” isn’t as convincing an argument as the OP thinks.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by jen20 on Saturday January 21, 2023 @08:09AM (#34466200)
> outside of (Manhattan and the expensive parts of Brooklyn) leaves like... not much of NYC?

What about the cheaper parts of Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx or Staten Island...? Not even to mention Jersey City.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by geodel on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:38PM (#34458576)
Well, I wouldn't know he had to or he preferred to. In my case I had that salary but I always lived shared house/apartment as long I was single. It wasn't like I had to spend more because I earned more. IMO living in shared accommodation at decent income level can be a lifestyle choice rather than a forced condition.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by tracker1 on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:15PM (#34459174)
I would suggest sticking it out for a year or two to get more experience, then get a job with a company working remote for similar/higher salary and moving to a city with a lower cost of living. The past couple years have really opened the job market for software development nationwide, and in most of this country (US) someone can live relatively comfortably at $120k/yr. Though the cost of food, and current interest rates make it harder.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by throwaway2037 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @04:39AM (#34475788)

    After paying taxes in Germany their net salary was less than what they had made net in Ukraine. Most of them went back.
This is insane. It overlooks quality of life: stable democracy, low perceived corruption (police, gov't, biz, etc.), economic stability, personal safety, food safety, social safety net (physical and mental healthcare, national pension, etc.), (industrial, economic, financial and environmental) regulation, quality of public education, quality of public transportation infrastructure, quality of publicly funded arts, income inequality gap, etc.

Income tax in Ukraine is about 20%. I used to live in Hongkong. Max tax rate was about 15%. Overall quality of life was terrible compared to advanced economies with 2x/3x tax rates. Sure, you might be "rich" on paper, but you pay a lot for privitised versions of these quality of life services. I always say: "If you pay little [in taxes], you get little [in gov't services]."

Another way to think about it: Look at countries that are not corrupt but it is very hard to get rich. Usually, those countries have excellent quality of life.

And maybe they went back for cultural reasons (food, family, education, etc.). I have observed that pattern many times.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by gavinhoward on Friday January 20, 2023 @12:21PM (#34456378)
Probably unpopular opinion here on HN, but I'd love to see developer salaries come down and other workers' salaries go up.

I'd rather live in a place where everyone is comfortable than a place where only people like me are, even if I'd be somewhat wealthy.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by thorncorona on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:46PM (#34457755)
Yeah it's a ridiculous opinion when those holding our leashes make billions.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by rayiner on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:08PM (#34458117)
It’s not “ridiculous.” The median American simply has more money under the American system. The OECD collects detailed data on this: https://data.oecd.org/hha/household-disposable-income.htm. Look at the dataset “gross incl. social transfers in kind” which looks at disposable income accounting for universal healthcare, etc. America is head and shoulders ahead of EU countries like Germany.

Americans might be selfish but they’re not irrational. Much of my family immigrated to Australia and Canada. My mom just got back from a long trip there, and was complaining about how small and close together the houses are, and how doctors can’t really get rich there. If you care more about the square footage of your house or the number of cars you have (and Americans do, and continually import immigrants who have similar values) than about health care for poor people, then the specific trade-offs made in America economic policy are totally rational.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by thorncorona on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:11PM (#34460765)
I think you're switchtracking me.

I'm saying that governmental policies have allied the poor and the ultra wealthy to the detriment of the middle class. GP was saying American dev salaries are too high, when really they are not the issue compared to how many tax breaks 10MM+ individuals have gotten.

Investors have bought up 40% of the real estate in some counties in the US. That's ridiculous.

When the government allows for predatory behavior by companies and the ultra wealthy that lowers their responsibility to society that is not a burden for the middle class to bear.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by CraigJPerry on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:49PM (#34457818)
I don’t understand why more people don’t think like this. Even from a selfish point of view - you get to live in a place with less violent crime, you get to experience living in a “happier” community, etc etc

I feel like this is the opposite of what’s happened here in the UK and the timescales are not that long but the collective amnesia is staggering. Even just as far back at the mid 00’s seems to have fallen out of the memory of a large proportion of the population.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by arcturus17 on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:19PM (#34458305)
Why are the people saying this not donating half of their 200k salaries? Is the only way to re-distribute your personal wealth by being compelled by market conditions or by the state?
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by teawrecks on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:40PM (#34458625)
Because they don't want to selflessly give away $100k for nothing. Rather they selfishly want to live in a healthier society. You're proposing they trade something for nothing, and that's misguided in the best case, or disingenuous in the worst.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by lordfrito on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:55PM (#34459818)
I think the point being made is that it's trivially easy to make armchair moral/ethical arguments about spending money in other peoples wallets. And that the arguments would be taken more seriously if the person arguing has actually demonstrated that they have skin in the game, staked their own wallet.

Isn't that what the complaints about NIMBYism are all about? Yeah, I'm all for having other people solving the problems of the poor workers. I don't have to do anything until they do. While we're at it, lets have the software developers clothe and house them as well. They can clearly afford it. It's only fair. Am I a good person now?

Talk is cheap. Do something first before complaining about what others aren't doing.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by whoknew1122 on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:28PM (#34460193)
It's a silly argument. Me donating half my salary, today, doesn't make any sense because it won't materially impact anything.

If there were a stronger social safety net and everyone had to pay a bit more in tax, then that would actually impact something.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by refurb on Saturday January 21, 2023 @02:24AM (#34464595)
Won’t materially impact anything?

Go and give $20k each to 5 people making minimum wage. That would have a huge impact.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by ricardobeat on Saturday January 21, 2023 @07:54AM (#34466104)
I bet a dollar if he went and did that, you'd turn around and call it virtue-signaling.

You're just looking for an excuse to invalidate their beliefs, so you can excuse yours. Not a healthy debate.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by refurb on Saturday January 21, 2023 @09:07AM (#34466485)
That wouldn’t be virtual signaling in the least. Virtual signaling is putting no effort behind your words.

Redistributing your own income is putting your money (literally) where your mouth is.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by teawrecks on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:51PM (#34460476)
Again, the goal is not selflessness, it's selfishness. The selfish want to form a more perfect union. No one is saying they want to give away half their salary for nothing, no one is expecting anyone else to do so either.

It's effectively a bunch of people who want a crowd funding campaign for a product to exist, and everyone else saying "if you want to throw your money away, here's a trash can". That's entirely missing the point and completely unhelpful. The goal is to make a collective investment and get something in return.

If we're being real, this group, myself included, is only one step removed from a NIMBY, but it is what it is. If you want to suggest I abandon the little leverage I have to put towards creating a better society for myself and the people around me, I would say: you first. Oh, not interested? Welcome to the club. Now let's work together to make this place we live better.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by novok on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:28PM (#34460184)
Violent crime & affordability issues in cities is a choice set by policy makers to make some politically connected people richer, it is not an attribute of cities. Poverty stricken rural places are just as bad, or even worse in many cases.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by arcturus17 on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:51PM (#34457845)
In Europe, even in the wealthiest countries, average programmer salaries are about 10% higher than the national salary at best. This would mean probably cutting your salary in half, instead of talking about it. It would be interesting to see you face that reality. Words are cheap.

And besides if you think that's an economically feasible zero-sum calculus, I don't even know what to tell you.

But if you really think you earn too much, you can donate 40-50% of your salary and truly transform another person's life or make an astonishing impact in a charity of your choice. I hope you are being coherent with your words and are already doing this.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by teawrecks on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:24PM (#34458382)
> I hope you are being coherent with your words and are already doing this.

How do you feel about people who say to protestors, "if you don't like it here, move"?

You're peddling the same logical fallacy that conservative billionaires have convinced the lower-middle class of for a century.

OP proposes a trade: their high salary for a society that prioritizes the wellbeing of everyone over the wellbeing of the luckiest few. In response, you suggest that OP should give away half their salary to another individual, and they've solved their problem.

The fallacy here is that you assume assume OP's goal is to be purely selfless; that is not the case. OP very selfishly wants to live in a healthier, more sustainable society than they currently do. In response, you disingenuously suggest that they take all of the negatives of their the trade with none of the positives.

Hopefully you see why that's not helpful to anyone.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by jkubicek on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:15PM (#34459169)
This is very well put, you said it better than I ever have myself.

One thing I'd add is that, even if I were able to give away enough of my income to make a difference in my community, everyone in the community would benefit, but I would be the only one paying for it. I find this intensely unfair and distasteful.

This is similar to how I felt during the height of the bay area mask mandates when most people were masked and one or two families were not. Those folks were reaping all the benefits of widespread vaccinations and masking, yet bearing none of the burden. I despised those people probably more than was healthy.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by qwytw on Friday January 20, 2023 @07:41PM (#34462437)
> even in the wealthiest countries, average programmer salaries are about 10% higher than the national salary at best

I'm not sure 'even' is the right word here. The gap between developer and median salaries goes down the richer the country is. e.g. in many Eastern European countries the average salary for a software developer can be up to 2x or more higher than the national average.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by giantg2 on Friday January 20, 2023 @01:54PM (#34457904)
I would like others' salaries to go up. I'd rather not have mine come down. I mean, the median is $115k or so in the US. I make under that.

Now this is a really unpopular opinion on here... I think the real issue is centralization of high capital tech work, and really the density of people in general. The cost of living in places like NYC, northern VA, and Silicon Valley are all hugely above the median. It's like a vicious cycle of groupthink instead of evenly distributing those jobs (companies) throughout cheaper, less populous areas. I'd love to see someone from a depressed area start a big name company in that area to help being jobs and prosperity to their neighbors. Perhaps that's just my deluded fantasy.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by hobs on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:40PM (#34458607)
$54,132 per year is the median in the united states, not 115k.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by teawrecks on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:44PM (#34458677)
A quick google search shows varying numbers between 74k and 120k for median software developer salaries in the US. 54k seems quite low, where'd you see this?
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by spondyl on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:22PM (#34459299)
I believe $54k is for salaries in general across all industries. Mercedes is not a tech company so no reason to assume the discussion is about software salaries
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by teawrecks on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:32PM (#34459456)
If you scroll up for context, this thread of comments was referring specifically to sw dev salaries coming down, not all salaries in general.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by thfuran on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:00PM (#34459872)
Dev salaries going down and all the rest going up.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by giantg2 on Friday January 20, 2023 @06:41PM (#34461807)
Median as a dev is about $115k, is what I meant. Sorry.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by notfromhere on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:31PM (#34458486)
Good place to start would be in college towns where you could easily siphon off new grads.

Problem is getting money to a place like that. Investors hate travel if its not to the same 3 cities

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by layer8 on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:05PM (#34458082)
The parent is probably talking about $200K+ salaries.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by giantg2 on Friday January 20, 2023 @02:40PM (#34458611)
Sure, but if you take those $200k people and make them $100k people, then I assume I'll lose my job to them all day long. Employers will pay me lower because I comparatively suck.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by tracker1 on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:10PM (#34459113)
Even then... for many companies the past couple years have opened up competition nation-wide. I'm able to compete for higher salaries with companies used to paying that along with what was only local talent before, while living in an area with comparatively lower cost of living and would like to move with that in mind (locked in until interest rates improve).

The same works in the other direction, and it kind of sucks for companies in areas where income isn't as high having to compete for talent against others with much deeper pockets. It's been interesting to say the least.

Unfortunately, I've seen the govt operating against unions... looking at the railway and airlines and think they're really on the wrong side of this, as much as I don't want to be more inconvenienced from strikes, they should be able to do so. I feel the govt does more harm than good in the US and would prefer a little less picking winners and losers in the mix. On the same note, I don't think they're playing their hands well at all to establish domestic production and security fia application of tariffs and FDA requirements.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by robotresearcher on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:01PM (#34459891)
Locality has natural efficiencies, which is why cities and caches are so powerful. That can't really be fought head-on in the short term. But over a longer period the increasing costs of a white-hot locale will cause other places to be more appealing. And new tech can find a new natural place to land with costs as part of that.

This is happening all the time. A hundred years ago the Santa Clara (Silicon) Valley was orchards. Detroit was getting rich on the latest tech wave.

A hundred years before that, the North of England was making fortunes in the Industrial Revolution.

In our lifetimes China has changed incredibly. Foxconn is now a big name company that employs over a million people and moved a lot of money into the places they operate.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by novok on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:25PM (#34460140)
HCOL cities is a policy choice that is somewhat independent of city density, that seem to be the worst in english speaking countries, pointing to a potential flaw in the culture or shared legal systems. There are many high density cities that are more livable than the USA and significantly more affordable. Cities managed efficiently are the most economically and environmentally sustainable places to have humanity live in by far.
Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by jollofricepeas on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:35PM (#34460287)
Good point.

1. Inflation - Though I will not expound here because I’m not an expert.

2. Salaries in the US have been stagnant since the 70s which correlates to the start of the weakening of Big Labor by corporate and government interests.

Left-leaning source:

https://www.epi.org/publication/charting-wage-stagnation/

Right leaning source:

https://www.aei.org/articles/have-wages-stagnated-for-decade...

Brookings Institute coverage of both left and right sources:

https://www.brookings.edu/blog/up-front/2019/09/10/are-wages...

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by berniedurfee on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:30AM (#34489138)
StickerMule is an example. Check out where they setup shop in Amsterdam, NY. It’s in a rundown mostly abandoned former factory area.

They’ve been slowly expanding operations and bringing new tech jobs and opportunities to a pretty bleak area. Very cool and inspiring to see.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by ynx on Friday January 20, 2023 @05:10PM (#34460748)
I agree with the general idea but disagree strongly with the execution.

Highly paid tech workers are still workers, albeit ones that tend to lack class consciousness because they think they're on top (until they get fired en masse to save profits).

Management earning wildly disproportionate salaries should share first. Management is worthless without labor, yet is responsible for choking workers from their fair share.

Re:Mercedes-Benz workforce to receive record profit-sharing ... by m_ke on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:15PM (#34459182)
They pay so much more because US is the largest english speaking country, which is why most companies that plan to go international start there first. Starting a company in Italy and expanding to other regions is a lot harder than going from US to Canada, UK, Australia and rest of the world with english only product.