https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6del%27s_Loophole#Backgr...
This is mentioned in the article. It's a pretty standard way to overthrow democracies — it subverts the system, using the system.
And my delayed response likewise agitated the Mr 202 area code spec agent.
No need to prosecute for expulsion if there were lies on the immigration form; it becomes just an administrative matter.
But, hey, there might be a true believer on the T-side! God says you're not supposed to lie, so it's a real Catch-22 - 'Render unto Caesar the evidence he deserves.'
Disclaimer: not legal advice, for entertainment value only.
There's already precedent that having a state medical marijuana card already makes one ineligible, and using as an ID when trying to purchase a firearm is grounds for automatic denial by the seller. Hawaii, which requires all firearms to be registered, went even further, proactively cross-referencing their gun registry with the medical marijuana one (https://www.leafly.com/news/politics/surrender-your-guns-pol...).
It's not really surprising that the law is so broad, given that it was written in 1968 when anti-drug craze was still ramping up. The reason why it doesn't get amended is, I think, because it manages to touch two third rails at once: Republicans don't want to be perceived as "soft on drugs" by their base, while Democrats are afraid of being seeing as not sufficiently aggressive wrt "gun violence". And so, here we are.
On the other hand for someone pumped up on coke it would be a big worry. Though I guess if the US had medical coke cards they would be banned as well :)
So Marijuana with a widely accepted medical benefit is considered a more dangerous drug than coke which is much more addictive and makes (some) people total pumped up jerks?
I really can't imagine that, it should be the other way around. This is what I don't understand about the US federal drug policy. Most countries define marijuana as a "soft drug".
I wonder how this came to be.. It sounds a bit like a 'war on hippies' thing from the 70s still lingering around the law books or something.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_J._Anslinger
As to why, the guy had many purported horror stories to tell about weed - collecting such was his hobby. Often, although not always, they boiled down to overt or covert racism. Some choice examples:
“There are 100,000 total marijuana smokers in the U.S., and most are Negroes, Hispanics, Filipinos and entertainers. Their Satanic music, jazz and swing result from marijuana use. This marijuana causes white women to seek sexual relations with Negroes, entertainers and any others.”
“I think the traffic has increased in marihuana, and unfortunately particularly among the young people. We have been running into a lot of traffic among these jazz musicians, and I am not speaking about the good musicians, but the jazz type.”
“Colored students at the Univ. of Minn, partying with female students (white) smoking and getting their sympathy with stories of racial persecution. Result: pregnancy.”
Additionally it creates a condition of jeopardy, because now you've made an official statement, and if it's false you're now potentially chargeable for perjury or making false official statements. So if you're a super-slick spy type and they can't pin something on you conclusively, but are sure you're up to something (in the same way they could only get Al Capone for tax evasion), then at least it gives them a pretext to take action and charge or deport you.
On the other hand, if you answer yes to this question they will probably don't let you into the country... But I can't say for sure.
:D
I would have ask if they were a judge. At least they are tasked with weighing the facts and deciding and not fighting for one point of view
But then in the US it still wouldn't matter unless they are your judge.
They might not be a terrorist, in which case they weren't lying.
In a civil case, it's likely to be about the preponderance of evidence and in front of some non-court administrative body there may be no particular standard of evidence at all.
Their evidentiary standards are closer to “nonexistent” than to preponderance of evidence.
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_Judge_(United_St...
So maybe an expulsion tribunal is 50.1% too?
- If you answer "No": That's what they expect everyone will say, but having it in writing may still come in handy in international disputes. Say you're considered a terrorist in another country. The form, AFAIK, doesn't define by whose standards you are a terrorist, so it might be grounds to kick you out if the US isn't specifically interested in keeping you in.
- If you answer "Yes": You most likely have mental issues. Entry denied.
- If you stress too much over it: Entry denied, possibly notify relevant law enforcement.
- If you start to ask questions about it, like precisely what is meant by this question and why: You either have mental issues, or are up to something. Either way, entry denied.
If you lie on your immigration form, you gained entry under false pretenses. Nothing complicated or grey about that.
I feel bad for him that he got caught up in local politics. I understand those normal people ate up the rich guy foreign ploy. What they missed was their rights were being trampled on while the rest of the world opened up and they were distracted by a fake booeyman.
I'm not Australian, but did follow the story with some interest as I do like professional tennis.
I thought it reflected much more poorly on Djokovic than on Australia. They set the visa rules, Djokovic violated those rules (and not subtly either).
It was too bad that he was unable to play at the AO last year, but that was (AFAIK) specifically due to his actions in violation of Australian law.
Those actions being lying on visa forms. And he did so regarding something that could be easily checked and confirmed/debunked.
Had he not lied, he probably would have gotten his visa.
If I'm a visitor to the country and say the same thing having signed an affirmation that I'm not going to advocate for violent overthrow of the US government it's not a first amendment case, it's a lying-on-immigration-forms case and out I do.
"Brandenburg was convicted of violating a criminal law that prohibited speech that advocates crime, sabotage, violence, and other similar acts after he spoke at a KKK rally. The Supreme Court found that the law infringed on Brandenburg's First Amendment rights, and created the imminent lawless action test. In order for speech to fall out of First Amendment protection, it must 1) be directed at producing imminent lawless action and 2) it is likely to produce such action."
I think there is an exception for ones made against certain public officials, which IMO are likely unconstitutional, but no one is really excited about challenging those.
That paragraph is not much different from what you'll find from self-described stocastic terrorist LibsofTikTok.
And, you know, I certainly agree that this kind of speech is terrible! But just as the US first amendment has protected, for example, supplying lists of doctors providing women with healthcare, showing crosshairs over them, putting red crosses over ones who have been murdered, and so on, the US has decided over the years that you have to issue very direct threats, or very clear instructions, to be held liable for speech that could incite harm.
Even advocating for violence is constitutionally protected.
A credible threat would, generally consist of specific actions that the person would have means to carry out.
Part of it is liability (tho I like to think they send the most reliable parts on sample orders), but also ITAR.
The point of this is not to get people to admit their plans.
Its to convert having those inchoate plans into a crime (fraud against the government) that can be prosecuted if discovered without any criminal act after entry (and can be used, with a reduced proof threshold compared to prosecuting crime, as a basis to withdraw status and deny any future application.)
(I had never been convicted of any crimes, so admittedly I could have just said "no" without causing a scene.)
Such a tragic, disgusting euphemism for the murder of millions, without them getting to devour their corpses.
Just rhetorically, using inflammatory terminology isn't going to convert anyone to vegetarianism / veganism. For those of us who've lost friends and relatives to murder (including myself unfortunately), it's profoundly distasteful.
Surely this is not as easy as just pointing out the 'correct' definition of words. The difference between "execution", various other forms of killing you mention, and murder can't be so clear that you can easily say "it doesn't apply in this case".
> not useful
More than rhetoric and saying what is useful, sometimes I just feel like I should be saying what I find to be truth. After billions and trillions of 'killings', with people saying 'useful', definitinly correct things in response, I just want to say the truth, sometimes.
It's exclusively asked as a, "turns out you lied, that's perjury" question to make deportation easier in criminal cases.
The article you link suggests that the quarantine area is the region from which it's illegal to bring fruit out.
The wikipedia article also does something interesting where it describes a mature fly as being an "apple maggot". I would have thought that the term "maggot" referred exclusively to the larval form.
It is illegal to bring homegrown fruit into eastern Washington, regardless of terminology.
Also the entry form they give you on your flight deserves a mention. This one has "did you handle livestock in the last X months" repeated like 3 times in different phrasing. Not as stupid as the first one, but... why? Why is that question that important in the first place? Pest control?