News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Revisiting KDE by Thev00d00 on Sunday January 15, 2023 @02:10PM (#34392123)
KDE is my desktop of choice. I feel like it captures the spirit of computing in the Windows 9x era.

Exposed options make computing discovery possible.

Sometimes having a drop-down to pick your compositing mode opens a lot of possibilities to learn more about your system.

This is not what i.e. GNOME are going for nowadays, everyone wants to reinvent the locked down iPhone "experience".

Re:Revisiting KDE by mindcrime on Sunday January 15, 2023 @02:33PM (#34392411)
This is not what i.e. GNOME are going for nowadays, everyone wants to reinvent the locked down iPhone "experience".

So VERY much this. I don't want an "experience" that's curated and chosen for me. I want to decide for myself how my desktop is going to look, feel, and work. And that is why I use KDE over Gnome, etc. KDE doesn't assume I'm an idiot who needs all options hidden away, yadda, yadda.

Re:Revisiting KDE by isthisthingon99 on Sunday January 15, 2023 @02:40PM (#34392492)
Most users don't care but yes it's nice for the market to have something like this.
Re:Revisiting KDE by 5e92cb50239222b on Sunday January 15, 2023 @02:47PM (#34392555)
IME they very much do care, they're simply not aware that a constantly changing user interface is not just something you have to deal with, like death or taxes. Every time I play tech support for friends and family it's the same story about how everything looks different yet again and how they can't find that thing that was right here just recently.

(For myself I have cobbled together something that looks roughly like Windows 95 did decades ago, but doing that for others comes with its own problems, so not forcing that on anyone.)

Re:Revisiting KDE by zx8080 on Sunday January 15, 2023 @06:33PM (#34394851)
Did you try xfce with win95 theme? This works pretty stable, though not kde.
Re:Revisiting KDE by DonHopkins on Monday January 16, 2023 @11:51AM (#34402527)
Stop making homophobic and transphobic posts.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34402242

Re:Revisiting KDE by isthisthingon99 on Monday January 16, 2023 @12:05PM (#34402723)
Bro you're weird. Are you really going through the entire post history lol.
Re:Revisiting KDE by DonHopkins on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @10:19AM (#34413424)
People go through your entire post history and criticize you for breaking the rules by posting your homophobic transphobic bullshit here, and you should expect it. This is not the place to spread your insults and hate speech. Freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom of consequences, and when you post that kind of bullshit, one of the consequences is that people know you're an asshole. If you're embarrassed about people reading what you wrote, realizing what kind of a person you really are, and telling you what they think about it, then don't ask for it by trolling like Fred Flintstone and Archie Bunker. Grow up, and take responsibility for your own actions.
Re:Revisiting KDE by isthisthingon99 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @11:54AM (#34414933)
Man shut up
Re:Revisiting KDE by DonHopkins on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:28AM (#34428825)
Obviously you can't counter or address any of my points, so now you concede and want to cut off the conversation that YOU started by inappropriately posting insulting homophobic and transphobic hate speech, because you can't even prove or justify your lies.

So you stop making homophobic and transphobic posts and insults and lies, and then I will stop replying to your hate speech and insulting lies, reminding you that what you're doing is against the rules.

Just why do you post idiotic close minded bullshit, then suddenly not want to talk about what YOU brought up, anyway? Is it because you can't justify it when questioned? Because your own words embarrass you and make you look like an asshole and a bully? Then stop posting that bullshit, if you are so afraid of answering my questions that you just want me to shut up because you know you will lose the argument!

You posted the following bullshit, in your own words, that you can't defend:

>Because a few years ago they used that on gay marriage and they said no you will never have men dressed as women in libraries you're being silly.

Exactly who said "you will never have men dressed as women in libraries"? Can you provide a quote or citation, or are you just making that up and lying? If you can't prove that somebody actually said that, then retract it and apologize for lying, and don't post hate speech and lies you can't defend in the future.

And what exactly is wrong with men dressing as women in libraries, or anywhere else?

Do you believe kids shouldn't watch Bugs Bunny or Mrs Doubtfire or The Nutty Professor either?

Bugs Bunny was America’s first drag superstar:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rDKo4mOljkc

Explain why are you so afraid of and hateful about trans and gay people (or cartoon rabbits, for that matter) that it drives you to lie and bully and humiliate yourself in public by posting indefensible hate speech and childish insults, like you do? How do they threaten or affect your life in any way at all? Or is it all about your own internalized homophobia, self loathing, and hatred of your own repressed feelings? Because real straight and cis people aren't afraid of and threatened by gay and trans people, like you obviously are.

Re:Revisiting KDE by isthisthingon99 on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @11:39AM (#34429018)
Shut up, again.
Re:Revisiting KDE by irthomasthomas on Sunday January 15, 2023 @03:06PM (#34392770)
KDE doesn't assume I'm an idiot who needs all options hidden away, yadda, yadda.

Have you read KDE's new Human Interface Guidelines? Because that is exactly what they are doing, now.

  Make it easy to focus on what matters --- Remove or minimize elements not crucial to the primary or main task. Use spacing to keep things organized. Use color to draw attention. Reveal additional information or optional functions only when needed.
  I know how to do that! --- Make things easier to learn by reusing design patterns from other applications. Other applications that use good design are a precedent to follow.
  Do the heavy lifting for me --- Make complex tasks simple. Make novices feel like experts. Create ways in which your users can naturally feel empowered by your software.
It looks like they are moving more and more toward a iphone/android like, dumbed-down experience. https://develop.kde.org/hig/
Re:Revisiting KDE by LarryMullins on Sunday January 15, 2023 @03:22PM (#34392923)
I can't find it now, but Dolphin used to have a rather demoralizing web page that listed user stereotypes (something like "Joe is a corporate developer", "Bob is an artist...", "Fred is an enthusiast..." and basically amounted to if you've a linux enthusiast since you were a teenager, we don't want to hear your feedback. I can't find it now, I hope they deleted it. I know creating such stereotypes is or was common practice in corporate software design, but it's vile.
Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Sunday January 15, 2023 @08:35PM (#34395747)
There's nothing vile about that, it's normal development practice. If you decide to make a code editor you're not making an app for artists, you're making an app for developers. That's a conscious choice you make when you sat down and said "I'm going to make a code editor today." Unless you think it's stereotyping to consider that people have different skills and professions?
Re:Revisiting KDE by int_19h on Monday January 16, 2023 @03:34AM (#34398327)
This is a very weird dichotomy that doesn't actually work that way IRL. A power user is not necessarily a command line wizard, and even if they are, plenty of tasks are still easier and quicker to do in the GUI - provided, that is, that the GUI can actually be optimized for the needs of said power user. We used to be able to accommodate all kinds of users with customization; now it's increasingly the lowest common denominator (and often an imaginary one at that) with no escape hatch.
Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Monday January 16, 2023 @11:28AM (#34402248)
I actually think the reason for that is economic and it does work IRL. What you think of as "power users" actually requires a lot of training, it's expensive to produce them. Their skill set still isn't enough to offload real development tasks on them, so whatever they do is still completely dependent on having a team of engineers to support them. If you're going to be paying the engineers anyway, it's cheaper to just make something that requires less training for the users up front.
Re:Revisiting KDE by pxc on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @10:05AM (#34413251)
Creating, testing, and updating documentation for command line tools takes a tiny fraction of the time and effort required to do the same for GUI tools. At the same time, the command line across Linux distros is subject to way less variation than all the GUIs across the same. Moreover, the fundamentals of the shell and the syntax of the CLI tools are way more stable over time than a given GUI configurator's layout, so CLI documentation will remain correct and useful longer than GUI documentation. Add to that that for many Google-able tasks, the same task may be relevant to headless servers, and you have another, independent cause for CLI documentation to be created without a GUI counterpart and for it to show up highly in search results.

This means that most documentation for advanced tasks in a volunteer-maintained system where everything actually has configurability via the CLI will tend to cover and emphasize CLI methods.

It is arguably possible to have knowledgeable 'power users' who do not know how to use an operating system's CLI. Longtime Windows users probably fit the bill. But on Linux, nobody who has spent enough time actually reading documentation or following tutorials (and made a reasonable effort to understand them) to become a power user is actually unable to use the CLI. The CLI-averse power user just doesn't exist on Linux due to a bit of a chicken-and-egg issue.

PS: The only system directory tree users should ever 'administer' on Linux by directly manipulating files in it is /etc. The grasp of the CLI needed for this is extremely basic, and there are even nice CUA text editors for the terminal these days. There's no wizardry required to do anything that isn't as destructive or risky as confusing the operating system itself (namely the package manager) about the state of the filesystem.

Re:Revisiting KDE by mindcrime on Sunday January 15, 2023 @03:14PM (#34392845)
Have you read KDE's new Human Interface Guidelines?

No.

Because that is exactly what they are doing, now.

That is unfortunate. I'd hate to have to move off of KDE. It's been great up to this point.

Re:Revisiting KDE by midoridensha on Sunday January 15, 2023 @08:40PM (#34395772)
You don't have to. The OP is entirely misinterpreting the KDE HIG. If you want to see how actual KDE devs interpret it (rather than some random non-KDE user on a message forum), just go use the latest KDE. It isn't turning into Gnome.
Re:Revisiting KDE by mindcrime on Sunday January 15, 2023 @11:22PM (#34396768)
I do use the latest KDE. I'm just saying that if they start making changes that go in the "let's dumb this down and start removing options" path, then I'll probably start looking at other options.
Re:Revisiting KDE by midoridensha on Sunday January 15, 2023 @11:39PM (#34396872)
I don't see any evidence they're going to do that, including in the HIG quote the OP posted before. It said nothing about removing options, so any suggestion they are seems like scare-mongering to me.
Re:Revisiting KDE by hulitu on Sunday January 15, 2023 @05:09PM (#34394113)
> Use spacing to keep things organized

Stupidity is contagious. Some five years ago i had to use Gmail for work and someone from Google had the great idea to use a big "Gmail" icon which did nothing but used around 1/5 of the screen.

Or you go to a website to fill a form (name, address, etc) and there are exactly 3 text inputs on the screen, the rest being unused space.

Re:Revisiting KDE by zx8080 on Sunday January 15, 2023 @06:29PM (#34394830)
Probably, it's the unified material design to blame. It's a space hog, though on mobile it was pretty good in the beginning around android v5.
Re:Revisiting KDE by foresto on Sunday January 15, 2023 @06:17PM (#34394749)
The box at the bottom of that page gives me hope:

> Note

> KDE encourages developing and designing for customization, while providing good default settings.

Re:Revisiting KDE by phatfish on Sunday January 15, 2023 @07:39PM (#34395328)
To me that means thinking about contextual information rather than "dumbing down". I don't remember anything significant being removed in the last 5 years, Dolphin is an almost perfect "power user" file manager, and they have not been messing around with it. In fact the whole Plasma desktop environment is getting into a nice stable state.

I can see it being overwhelming for someone used to an iPhone (or Gnome :p), but the KDE approach seems to be to hide advanced options/GUI by default if needed, but make enabling them a simple check box that doesn't suddenly disappear one day.

Re:Revisiting KDE by pxc on Sunday January 15, 2023 @07:52PM (#34395415)
> I don't remember anything significant being removed in the last 5 years, Dolphin is an almost perfect "power user" file manager

When Dolphin first came out, it was arguably a 'dumbed down' version of Konqueror, which has even more features and also supported web browsing.

But over time, it became clear that Dolphin did a great job of organizing and simplifying Conqueror's file management functionality without losing power in any way that mattered.

I hope that kind of change is what the new KDE HIG is going for. If so, I think KDE is going to be better than ever.

Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Sunday January 15, 2023 @08:31PM (#34395724)
It's not dumbed-down to make apps that are focused around performing a specific task and making them easy to use. That's literally the entire purpose of designing apps. There's nothing else to it. iPhone and Android didn't invent that either, I think most people would agree that not every app needs to be Emacs.
Re:Revisiting KDE by qu4z-2 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @04:35PM (#34482476)
I think there is. It transforms the applications from a tool to an appliance.
Re:Revisiting KDE by midoridensha on Sunday January 15, 2023 @08:38PM (#34395765)
>It looks like they are moving more and more toward a iphone/android like, dumbed-down experience.

Have you actually used KDE? The amount of settings in the "system settings" application is almost overwhelming; it is definitely not a "dumbed-down" experience. The thing you're quoting is just asking devs to keep things a little more focused, not to remove options altogether ("Reveal additional information or optional functions only when needed.")

Re:Revisiting KDE by darkwater on Monday January 16, 2023 @02:40AM (#34397956)
I don't know if this you are doing should be called "FUD" like in the old days or "fake news" as a more modern term.
Re:Revisiting KDE by anhner on Monday January 16, 2023 @03:05AM (#34398126)
There's a difference between simplifying and putting extra options under a setting, and removing things altogether.
Re:Revisiting KDE by lelanthran on Sunday January 15, 2023 @03:40PM (#34393113)
> KDE doesn't assume I'm an idiot who needs all options hidden away, yadda, yadda.

You make it sound like Gnome assumes you're an "idiot who needs all the options to be hidden away".

You couldn't be more wrong. Gnome assumes you're an normal "idiot", and then removes the options altogether.

They aren't hidden, they're gone.

Re:Revisiting KDE by mindcrime on Sunday January 15, 2023 @04:23PM (#34393579)
Fair enough. I haven't touched Gnome in like 15+ years, so I'm not real familiar with the state of that system.
Re:Revisiting KDE by squarefoot on Sunday January 15, 2023 @06:17PM (#34394754)
Aren't they still accessible through the Dconf editor?

Just asking, don't want to sound like it's a good thing to me: they started dumbing down the interface long time ago (between GTK2 and 3 if memory serves), and now they ruined it completely with the new design.

Re:Revisiting KDE by AngriestLettuce on Sunday January 15, 2023 @07:29PM (#34395266)
Sometimes, but that's a finnicky beast in its own right. You need to figure out which poorly documented variable you need to change to do whatever, usually from a Stack Overflow post from some other poor fucker, then make heads and tails of system settings vs. user settings, the dbus nonsense for communication, the weird gconfig shit for fiddling with system files, etc. Doing something as simple as e.g. changing the image used on the login screen for all users is far more complex than it should be.

I understand that GNOME has other goals than I do for my machine, but it's basically the antithesis of the reasons I choose to run Linux in the first place. I think it being the de facto "standard" Linux desktop environment is really hurting the ecosystem.

Re:Revisiting KDE by midoridensha on Sunday January 15, 2023 @08:35PM (#34395745)
>I think it being the de facto "standard" Linux desktop environment is really hurting the ecosystem.

I completely agree. I think it's a case of moneyed interests having taken over. Someone in another HN comment a while back implied that the big reason for Gnome and its philosophy is Red Hat's big corporate and especially government customers. Why so many casual Linux users have jumped on the Gnome bandwagon I don't understand. If you want something that gives you no choice and tells you how to use your computer and is "simple", then just buy a Mac.

Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Sunday January 15, 2023 @08:39PM (#34395769)
Please stop with the conspiracy theories. GNOME is still very much a volunteer project. And KDE also gets corporate contributions too.

GNOME isn't really against "choice" either, they just optimize for a different workflow.

Re:Revisiting KDE by bruce511 on Sunday January 15, 2023 @10:02PM (#34396328)
I'm thinking maybe there are two distinct groups of people. One group choose their OS and love to fiddle and fine tune its behaviour.

Another group have their OS chosen for them by their employer. They don't care about the OS, or software in general - they just want to get through the day.

Perhaps KDE is well suited to one group and Gnome to another?

Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Sunday January 15, 2023 @10:38PM (#34396514)
GNOME can be fiddled with, just not in the same way as KDE.

And KDE can simplified for installation on work computers, just not in the same way as GNOME.

Personally I use GNOME now because it fits my current workflow better, but in the past I had a different workflow and I used KDE more. I still have both of them installed so it's not difficult to switch.

Re:Revisiting KDE by johnny22 on Monday January 16, 2023 @12:39PM (#34403209)
> Another group have their OS chosen for them by their employer. They don't care about the OS, or software in general - they just want to get through the day.

People like Linus Torvalds didn't get their OS chosen for them, but still chose kept Fedora's GNOME default.

Re:Revisiting KDE by account42 on Monday January 23, 2023 @09:14AM (#34488932)
> default

Sounds like someone else did make the choice for Linus, even if it could have been overruled.

Re:Revisiting KDE by raverbashing on Monday January 16, 2023 @01:44AM (#34397608)
> they just optimize for a different workflow.

Usually of the people that just work with a giant terminal session with screen and that's it.

No, really, because having a terminal application where "Tab Next" doesn't wrap around just goes to show how worried they are about users outside that niche (and yes maybe they fixed this now, but come on)

Re:Revisiting KDE by unethical_ban on Monday January 16, 2023 @01:57AM (#34397709)
Maybe I like simple, intuitive keyboard shortcut driven environments and also like Linux.
Re:Revisiting KDE by danjac on Monday January 16, 2023 @02:14AM (#34397819)
It depends on your needs and workflow. Personally I spend most of my time on my laptop in the terminal, browser, email and one or two other apps like Discord. I just want something that is simple and stays out of my way and I don't want to spend my time crafting the perfect desktop. Stock Fedora+Gnome with a couple extensions pretty much covers all my needs.

Other users have different expectations and needs and perhaps KDE suits them better, and maybe they are happy spending hours fine-tuning their desktop experience. All good and I'm happy we all get to have a choice.

Re:Revisiting KDE by seba_dos1 on Monday January 16, 2023 @06:28AM (#34399563)
Sounds similar to my needs and workflow, and yet GNOME always feels to me like it requires me to spend hours fine-tuning it, finding extensions that make simple things possible and tweaks that aren't exposed anywhere by default to make it usable - while Plasma works fine out-of-box and I'm not worried about little things I do like to tweak in my desktop because I can be reasonably certain that I'll be able to quickly reconfigure things whenever I get annoyed by them.

However, I do like to use GNOME on my phone (with phosh as a shell). It fits there quite nicely and IMO feels better than Plasma.

Re:Revisiting KDE by abrouwers on Monday January 16, 2023 @05:37PM (#34406414)
You don't understand why some people might prefer a more precisely defined, simpler-by-default desktop? I can only speak for myself - I've been using linux full-time for ~20ish years, and gnome 3 is the one of the most solid, stable, elegant desktops I've used. I understand why some prefer KDE, but I spend most of my times in APPS, not configuring my desktop environment.

Also, what does "big corporate" customers even mean? At my corporate job, I get paid to do work (within applications), not spend time configuring settings in my DE. I'd be quite curious to hear how gnome specifically prevents you from doing your job.

Last thought, but "just buy a mac" is a rather silly argument; in fact, if gnome is being to mac, that's a pretty high compliment, IMO. If that's not your thing, that's fine, but it's also fine for others to want to use a simple, well-designed desktop.

Re:Revisiting KDE by pxc on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @09:42AM (#34412894)
> I understand why some prefer KDE, but I spend most of my times in APPS, not configuring my desktop environment.

When I first got into KDE, I was young and excited about all of the eye candy and downloadable widgets and stuff. I spent a TON of time tinkering with the desktop environment. But nowadays, I use KDE with something like 85% or 90% of all the options at their default settings. I think that's a really common way to use KDE: everyone has their 5% or 10% of customizations, and it's not much, but for everyone that 5% or 10% covers different options.

I feel that in that way, defaults are very important for KDE as well. They provide a center of gravity for the userbase, and their appropriateness determines how much work it is for everyone to maintain a usable setup.

Anyway, on KDE I have a handful of settings saved in my dotfiles or similar, and the rest I don't really spend time configuring anymore. So I totally understand GNOME users who take a similar approach but fall a little further on that spectrum where the settings are 98% or 99% at the defaults.

I don't know why (maybe it's my reliance on the CLI and the deep familiarity of GNU and Linux together), but for whatever reason, despite being a KDE guy, I strongly prefer GNOME to Windows or macOS. It feels thoughtfully designed, and limited, yes... but not too restrictive. I get the comparison, but macOS feels hamstrung and confining to me, including compared to a nice, current GNOME distro.

Re:Revisiting KDE by pjmlp on Monday January 16, 2023 @01:37AM (#34397574)
KDE also uses DBUS, which is the successor of Bonobo and DCOP, after both desktops agreed on the same infrastructure.

XFCE also uses it for their plugins.

Re:Revisiting KDE by AngriestLettuce on Monday January 16, 2023 @07:14AM (#34399846)
On the side of the desktop environments and their usage of it, the fact that I have to "dbus-launch" to change a user's settings from a shell seems pretty insane to me.

Technology-wise I'm sure other protocols are worse and all, but DBUS does not spark joy. My experience with DBUS is that it's a pain in the ass to program with, and can cause strange issues if you for example have a service that needs to be available both for early boot and late during shutdown and you're not very careful with your dependencies. Documentation is sparse, and it seems like 99% of people just use the low-level library they keep screaming you shouldn't use anyway. I used the glib one, and it put me off programming anything GNOME ever again.

I am not a fan of DBUS.

Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:02AM (#34409330)
I have bad news for you, every alternative is going to be the same or worse. There's no good and clean solution for early boot services. The Linux kernel expects you to handle any of those issues in userspace with a userspace daemon like dbus. If you're upset the documentation is sparse, well, welcome to open source.

Nobody is "screaming" at you to stop using libdbus. The issues with it are actually spelled out in the docs. Here's what they say:

>The low-level API documented in this manual deliberately lacks most convenience functions - those are left up to higher-level libraries based on frameworks such as GLib, Qt, Python, Mono, Java, etc. These higher-level libraries (often called "D-Bus bindings") have features such as object systems and main loops that allow a much more convenient API.

>The low-level API also contains plenty of clutter to support integration with arbitrary object systems, languages, main loops, and so forth. These features add a lot of noise to the API that you probably don't care about unless you're coding a binding.

So unless you really have your own object system, language and event loop, you shouldn't bother with using libdbus. Use literally any of the other bindings of which there are many. The glib one is only going to be good if you're already using glib's event loop and object system.

Re:Revisiting KDE by abrouwers on Monday January 16, 2023 @09:39AM (#34401062)
Most popular options seem pretty well exposed via. gnome-tweaks. I'm curious which others you find missing?
Re:Revisiting KDE by AngriestLettuce on Monday January 16, 2023 @09:54AM (#34401226)
I don't have an actionable list off the top of my head, but in particular, about 6-12 months ago, I started digging into how to theme my install. Wanted to have e.g. different system theme colours than Ubuntu eggplant, a different background, different login screen, etc. There were so many different ways and places of doing things (stylesheets packed in gresource files, dconf, more oldschool config files, gnome-tweaks) that after messing around with it a bit I just gave up. Didn't seem worth the time.

It isn't any one particular option that I'm missing, rather the entire experience of modifying its behaviour is a pain in the ass. They seem to labour under the delusion that if they just make this one perfect system, everyone will be happy with it, so they don't need to prioritize customizability. This is rarely ever the case when dealing with real people with different needs.

Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Monday January 16, 2023 @11:53PM (#34409292)
That has nothing to do with GNOME. That's going to happen any time you try to theme 100 different programs and try to get them all to look consistent. Try to imagine writing one CSS and applying it to every website you visit and expecting it to work correctly. It's just not going to work, you'd have to manually rewrite the CSS for every site. The same is true of desktop applications. The only reason your desktop appears consistent with the default Ubuntu themes is because all the apps already did the work to target that theme. If you want another theme, you have to do all that work all over again. You can't avoid this just by adding more options, it's a large amount of extra code that needs to be written every time for every app.
Re:Revisiting KDE by int_19h on Monday January 16, 2023 @03:31AM (#34398309)
It actually started during the GNOME 2 era. Remember spatial Nautilus?

https://www.osnews.com/story/7344/opinion-why-users-blame-th...

Also, if I remember correctly, the editable path bar was removed in Nautilus and Gnome file picker somewhere around that time.

Re:Revisiting KDE by redeeman on Monday January 16, 2023 @09:28AM (#34400966)
they began removing stuff WAY before gtk3 was even on the table. I believe gnome 2.6 was the last version before they decided that users are precious snowflakes that must be protected from options that an idiot shouldnt have
Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @12:29AM (#34409450)
Clearly they didn't "ruin" it because there are people in this very comment thread with a mix of opinions. Some saying they like it, some saying it's okay, some saying they don't like it.
Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Sunday January 15, 2023 @08:45PM (#34395815)
No one's assuming you're an idiot. Please stop assuming bad faith. The reason GNOME tries to minimize the number of preferences is because every preference has a very real maintenance cost. No project can afford to pay for a huge number of those. Every preference you add contributes directly to a reduction in testing capability. It's not reasonable to ask volunteers to do around-the-clock testing so this is the solution you get.
Re:Revisiting KDE by yjftsjthsd-h on Sunday January 15, 2023 @09:10PM (#34395977)
What volunteers? GNOME is a Red Hat project.
Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Sunday January 15, 2023 @09:14PM (#34395994)
Please stop with the trollish responses. Even if that was true (it's not), what makes you think Red Hat wants to start paying those costs?
Re:Revisiting KDE by yjftsjthsd-h on Sunday January 15, 2023 @09:52PM (#34396262)
Yeah, see, disagreeing with you and trolling are different things. Trolling would be more like creating an account just to make personal attacks and defend RH. Anyways. This is a pain to get hard numbers for but https://hpjansson.org/blag/2020/12/16/on-the-graying-of-gnom... seems decent enough; based on that, @redhat.com represents ~13,000 commits out of ~50,000 commits with all other groups combined not even coming close, which means that even as a technical minority overall RH has a massive amount of influence. Or as the author puts it,

> Top 15 affiliations again, but now ordered by commit counts. It's safe to say that GNOME is dependent on paid developers in a big way. Specifically, and to no one's surprise, it leans heavily on Red Hat.

So yes, it is true.

> what makes you think Red Hat wants to start paying those costs?

Well no, I'm sure they don't want to. And hey, it's Red Hat's devs, so at some level I can't blame them for serving RH's interests above the user. Just as they can't blame me for abandoning their function-poor toy desktop environment.

Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Sunday January 15, 2023 @10:06PM (#34396357)
No, that page is misleading because it doesn't include unaffilated developers. Red Hat may be the biggest corporate contributor, but most contributors are actually not affiliated with any corporation.

I say you're trolling because even if it were entirely a corporate Red Hat project, Red Hat still wouldn't owe anyone any features. They would still be the "volunteers" in that case. Insisting anyone meet some threshold of features for a random free product they give away is leaning heavily into toxic entitlement. I suspect you know this full well. This isn't just about a disagreement and it's not that they're putting their interests above "the user." A corporate contributor puts the interests of their paying customers over anyone else. That's how they work. But then you immediately jump from there to equating "the user" with your own personal choice. Can you not see how this is a very trolly way to approach conversation about anything? Just be clearer next time and say it's not to your liking and be done with it, you don't need to turn every conversation about this into a Red Hat flame war.

And before someone makes more trollish comments accusing me of "defending Red Hat," I don't have any connection to them. It's just bad conversation to have people trying to turn every comment thread into a hate-fest directed at some corporation. Yeah I get it, capitalism is terrible. But isn't this what we want companies to be doing? Taking labor their customers paid for and giving it back for free to open source projects?

Re:Revisiting KDE by yywwbbn on Monday January 16, 2023 @03:11AM (#34398166)
It still seems pretty strange to me that you’re so fervently denying anyone the right to criticize the design and UX choices made in GNOME just because it’s available for free (unless you’re a RedHat customer I guess..).

I assume most people who do that genuinely want GNOME to be improved than due to malice or anything else. What’s wrong about that? If I was working on GNOME I’d definitely prefer users who share their views and opinions to those who just silently quit without saying anything.

Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Monday January 16, 2023 @11:03AM (#34401970)
I never denied anyone that. Go criticize all you want. Just please stop with the conspiracy theories, it's bad discussion. You don't have to be a Red Hat customer, you could pay any other Linux consultancy.
Re:Revisiting KDE by yywwbbn on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @03:27AM (#34424601)
The Red Hat but was supposed to be sarcasm…
Re:Revisiting KDE by yjftsjthsd-h on Monday January 16, 2023 @03:42AM (#34398382)
No, 50k commits is from the higher up graph that includes unaffiliated commits.

> I say you're trolling because even if it were entirely a corporate Red Hat project, Red Hat still wouldn't owe anyone any features.

And I say that's not what that word means, unless you truly believe that no reasonable person could actually disagree with you (in which case you'd be factually wrong, but using the word correctly). You're allowed to claim that GNOME/RH giving software away for free makes it illegitimate to critize them, and I'm allowed to say that's nonsense and the software still sucks. Trolling, if you'll forgive my quoting urban dictionary, is

> making random unsolicited and/or controversial comments on various internet forums with the intent to provoke an emotional knee jerk reaction from unsuspecting readers to engage in a fight or argument

This isn't random (as an ex-user, I have very real, very strong opinions about GNOME), I don't care about your emotions, and I didn't intend this to be a fight. So no, not trolling.

[0] https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Trolling

Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Monday January 16, 2023 @11:09AM (#34402033)
The comment on the higher up graph still says "I've excluded personal accounts" so a lot of data is just missing there.

I'm not saying it's illegitimate to criticize anything. Please don't put words in my mouth. This is the entire original comment I was responding to:

>What volunteers? GNOME is a Red Hat project.

There's no legitimate criticism in this comment. If you do have real opinions, you never communicated them. The only thing here is the usual substanceless FUD and complaining about Red Hat that pops in every Linux thread. It's bad discussion. You did add some more information afterwards, but your original comment didn't have that. This is why it's trolling. Do you see it now? Next time, lead with the information. Please don't just make snarky comments. I really don't get this vehement denial when it's right there. It was a snarky comment, you can just own it and we can move on.

Re:Revisiting KDE by jchoksi on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @06:39AM (#34425601)
> Trolling would be more like creating an account just to make personal attacks and defend RH.

user: QUrprUd1nCeicw created: 11 days ago karma: 76

Seems like he has a point. Are you afraid of losing internet karma points on your normal account?

Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Friday January 20, 2023 @11:15AM (#34455171)
No, there wasn't a point. Making these accusations is the personal attack and it's a non-falsifiable claim anyway. Once you go that route you're on a complete descent into nonsense conspiracy theories.
Re:Revisiting KDE by lelanthran on Monday January 16, 2023 @03:50AM (#34398443)
> I say you're trolling because even if it were entirely a corporate Red Hat project, Red Hat still wouldn't owe anyone any features. They would still be the "volunteers" in that case. Insisting anyone meet some threshold of features for a random free product they give away is leaning heavily into toxic entitlement.

Negative feedback when removing existing features is not "trolling", nor "toxic entitlement".

In fact, it's expected, when you remove a much used, much loved feature, that you're going to get criticism for doing so, even more so when there is strong indication that there will be no replacement for that feature now or in the future.

Gnome has been steadily dropping features and then attacking anyone who complains (much like you are doing so).

Mostly the gnome supporters imply that the complainers are just plain stupid (don't know any better, are ignorant, have poor habits, etc): from https://www.osnews.com/story/7344/opinion-why-users-blame-th...

> Browser-mode file browsers hide the lack of thought and organisation in the filesystem structure; spatial ones do not.

> And now, when the time to ressurect the spatial ideas has finally come, people accustomed to the bad interface design try to defend it only because for the past years they have been using it!

TBH, if I had time, I could compile a substantial list of similar insults from the Gnome devs themselves, when closing issues as "wontfix".

Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Monday January 16, 2023 @11:18AM (#34402125)
You can criticize all you want, but I notice you neglected to share any of that actual criticism in your comment. Closing a bug as wontfix isn't an insult, please stop taking that personally. All open source projects reject bugs sometimes. Every project gets to determine their own threshold for what features they remove and what bugs they close as wontfix. All projects reject bugs. There's a comment from down thread about KDE developers doing exactly the same thing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34395682

But you also have to make sure your criticism is good. Just complaining that a feature was removed "because I was using it" is not a useful criticism. I learn nothing from reading that. You have to actually explain why you needed the feature, how you were using it, and why the newer options don't work for you.

>Mostly the gnome supporters imply that the complainers are just plain stupid

I don't see the author claiming anyone's stupid in that article. This is what the author says:

>it is just bad file organisation coupled with a bunch of old bad habits

And maybe on that note, you could consider that designers know a lot more about the habits of users than a random drive-by commenter, considering they study it for a living?

Re:Revisiting KDE by lelanthran on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @10:08AM (#34413286)
> Closing a bug as wontfix isn't an insult,

That's a strawman. I said "they attack people who provide feedback".

And whether you like it or not, feedback of the form "Hey, don't take that away, I'm still using it" is legitimate feedback. You wanna see their typical response?

From https://trac.transmissionbt.com/ticket/3685#no1:

> I guess you have to decide if you are a GNOME app, an Ubuntu app, or an XFCE app unfortunately.

And that's one of their *good* responses. From my other link, you saw that their responses basically said that, even if users were using something, that way of doing things is only done by the ignorant.

> You have to actually explain why you needed the feature, how you were using it, and why the newer options don't work for you.

The posters in the link above explained all of that, and the response was still "No".

> I don't see the author claiming anyone's stupid in that article. This is what the author says:

>>it is just bad file organisation coupled with a bunch of old bad habits

The gnome dev literally said that any way other than their way had was because the users weren't thinking!

> Browser-mode file browsers hide the lack of thought and organisation in the filesystem structure; spatial ones do not.

I mean, they literally said that the users are not thinking if they prefer the old way.

There's a reason why gnome has fewer users than you'd expect given that is the default everywhere - even though it is the default, many user's still find it easier to simply switch.

> And maybe on that note, you could consider that designers know a lot more about the habits of users than a random drive-by commenter, considering they study it for a living?

If these designers knew that, they'd have more marketshare on Linux at least.

Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @02:07PM (#34417136)
Ok, sorry. I misquoted you. I should have said "isn't an attack" instead of "isn't an insult."

Still, the rest of my comment is still relevant even with that change. There's no "attacks" anywhere in anything you've quoted. That response about Ubuntu and XFCE is a factual statement. GNOME, Ubuntu and XFCE are all different platforms and they have different APIs. You can't expect GNOME to implement every XFCE feature just like you can't expect XFCE to implement every GNOME feature. And if you decide to do port to another OS like Windows or Mac, then you have to decide if you're going to use Linux APIs or Windows APIs, and so on. This is all very basic concepts. As an app developer you have to decide which of these APIs you're going to use. It's not "attacking" anyone to point out that truth. It's also not an "attack" for them to respond with a firm "no" response. If you want to get along with others you need to learn to accept that sometimes you'll receive "no" for an answer.

And no, "Hey, don't take that away, I'm still using it" isn't legitimate feedback. You need to actually explain why you need to use it that way and why another way isn't going to work for you. And even after that, you still need to be able to accept that your explanations could be bad or wrong and could get thrown out by the developers. You're not the one paying the cost to maintain that code so you don't get the final say on what gets thrown out and what doesn't. That's the entire point of open source. If you don't like this, then you start sharing some of the costs by maintaining the code, and then you can be the one who makes that decision. But it simply isn't an "attack" on you when someone else decides your feature is too expensive for them to work on anymore. You need to not take that so personally.

>The gnome dev literally said that any way other than their way had was because the users weren't thinking!

>I mean, they literally said that the users are not thinking if they prefer the old way.

No, it doesn't say anything like that anywhere in the article. That article isn't written by a GNOME developer either. If you're referring to something else, please show the direct quote where they said that.

>If these designers knew that, they'd have more marketshare on Linux at least.

There's no "marketshare" and no "market." This is an open source project being given away for free. I think what you meant is "mindshare." None of these projects are concerned with trying to dominate the mindshare, they all work together.

Re:Revisiting KDE by int_19h on Monday January 16, 2023 @02:46AM (#34398003)
And yet somehow Gnome was much more pleasant to use 20 years ago than it is now.
Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Monday January 16, 2023 @11:42AM (#34402431)
Sure, some people think Windows XP (also roughly 20 years old) was more pleasant too. But somehow, few of them are racing to format their hard drive and replace everything with Windows XP. I bet you could name a few reasons why.
Re:Revisiting KDE by bergheim on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @01:53PM (#34431140)
Uhm. For once, it's... totally unsupported, and nothing runs on it anymore?
Re:Revisiting KDE by johnny22 on Monday January 16, 2023 @12:41PM (#34403240)
I used GNOME 3 and definitely think the opposite.
Re:Revisiting KDE by iamtedd on Monday January 16, 2023 @03:17AM (#34398208)
> every preference has a very real maintenance cost.

And yet KDE manages.

Re:Revisiting KDE by yjftsjthsd-h on Monday January 16, 2023 @03:51AM (#34398450)
To be fair, my impression is that KDE has more bugs, which is what you'd expect in the "features are a burden" model. I'm not conceived that that's the reason (because other environments are even more configurable without that reputation), but it's a plausibly consistent claim.
Re:Revisiting KDE by Fire-Dragon-DoL on Monday January 16, 2023 @01:44AM (#34397610)
Lol, thank you for the chuckle, that's how I feel while I use gnome. Damn, I wish KDE was the desktop choice for Ubuntu and fedora, it would solve so many problems.
Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Monday January 16, 2023 @11:50PM (#34409275)
That would just be trading one set of problems for another set of problems. Be careful what you wish for.
Re:Revisiting KDE by Fire-Dragon-DoL on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @02:10AM (#34409888)
Maybe. Linux spread is little enough that these might not show up.

Oh, KDE is the environment of Steam Deck, in case people forgot about it!

So in reality, potentially, KDE is already more widespread than Gnome

Re:Revisiting KDE by QUrprUd1nCeicw on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @02:16AM (#34409924)
KDE isn't the environment of the Steam Deck. The environment of the Steam Deck is Steam running its own Gamescope compositor. The desktop mode runs KDE but that's optional and it's not the main mode because the Steam Deck isn't a desktop, it's a handheld gaming device.
Re:Revisiting KDE by drooopy on Sunday January 15, 2023 @02:27PM (#34392338)
"KDE is my desktop of choice. I feel like it captures the spirit of computing in the Windows 9x era."

I was trying to find the right words to describe why I prefer KDE over other DE's but this captures my feelings perfectly.

Re:Revisiting KDE by pxc on Sunday January 15, 2023 @08:01PM (#34395496)
I find this quite strange. I was a kid (and heavy computer user) when Windows 9x was current. I'd been a user of MS-DOS, Windows 3.x, Windows 9x, and Windows XP before I got into Linux and KDE, back in the KDE 3.4 days.

I love KDE, but I have no positive feelings about Windows 9x, and I don't really think KDE reminds me of it at all. In fact, some of the developments and workflows that excited me back in the day were divergences away from Windows 9x, like the replacement of the old Kicker menu with Lancelot.

The KDE application that eventually won my heart as a teenager was Amarok, which simply had no equivalent in any other ecosystem. To me, what is great about KDE is best described with reference to KDE itself, not some other desktop experience.

Re:Revisiting KDE by FeepingCreature on Monday January 16, 2023 @12:34AM (#34397188)
Amarok is a distant descendant of WinAmp, which was indeed developed for Windows 95.

WinAmp -> X11Amp -> XMMS -> Amarok ... -> Clementine -> Strawberry, if you want a current player that looks like Amarok 1.4.

Re:Revisiting KDE by seba_dos1 on Monday January 16, 2023 @06:44AM (#34399669)
Describing Amarok as a descendant from XMMS feels like describing Firefox as a descendant from Lynx.
Re:Revisiting KDE by FeepingCreature on Monday January 16, 2023 @10:37AM (#34401655)
That's fair, there's no code lineage. The design lineage is maybe more credible if you look at historic screenshots like https://amarok.sourceforge.net/amarok_20040203.png , which also illustrates the Winamp descent of those players. (Note the "PL EQ" buttons, straight off the Winamp main widget.)

edit: Even further https://web.archive.org/web/20030815185552/http://amarok.sou...

Re:Revisiting KDE by pxc on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @01:32AM (#34409714)
* * *
Re:Revisiting KDE by FeepingCreature on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @01:45AM (#34409766)
Glad you got a good player. For me, the big dense screen-filling freeform playlist was the main selling point, so 2.0 was a huge letdown.
Re:Revisiting KDE by pxc on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @10:25AM (#34413515)
I remember feeling disappointed and frustrated with the 2.0 layout as well. I think it was around 2.3 that the player got some UI tweaks which let you make use of screen space in similar proportions to 1.4.x.

It's been super long since I really used a local player, but IIRC later versions of Amarok 2.x let you rearrange the panes that make up the single window interface, including IIRC stacking them into tabs which is similar to the vertical, collapsible tabs on the left side of 1.4.x.

What was exciting for me about the 1.4.x player and earlier was the contextual information provided for songs— especially lyrics fetching and Wikipedia embedding. I used the lyrics fetching to learn and sing along to hundreds of songs when I was a teenager. It took decades for streaming services to catch up on lyrics display and trivia.

I also heavily utilized the collection management features and patterns, which were so excellent. Amarok was my primary tool for organizing a collection of MP3, Vorbis, and eventually Opus files that grew into the hundreds of gigabytes, on spinning rust. The metadata fetching and editing and file renaming functions were vital for me, although later I did do a lot of maintenance with Musicbrainz Picard.

The dynamic playlists in 2.x were great for parties, and I liked moodbars for showing people specific sections of songs and the cool visuals.

Anyway, to me Clementine feels like a very cluttered hodgepodge of features and menus, in a way that Amarok never did.

Re:Revisiting KDE by FeepingCreature on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @01:25AM (#34423969)
It's cool but kind of daunting to see that people can have totally different experiences with the same piece of software. :)

Cheers for configurability!

Re:Revisiting KDE by irthomasthomas on Sunday January 15, 2023 @02:53PM (#34392622)
That is what attracted me to KDE. However, in recent years there design philosophy has become more aligned with Windows and mobile. It seems more difficult to create skeuomorphic themes, now. The trend seems to be for dizzying, translucent, psychedelic themes, where figuring out what I can and cannot interact with is like a point and click adventure game, only without the joy. But this seems to be in line with KDE's new stated design goals:

  Make it easy to focus on what matters --- Remove or minimize elements not crucial to the primary or main task. Use spacing to keep things organized. Use color to draw attention. Reveal additional information or optional functions only when needed.
  Make complex tasks simple. Make novices feel like experts. Create ways in which your users can naturally feel empowered by your software. [0]
To me, this feels like dumbing down, and this is disappointing for a powerful desktop. A desktop PC is such a vast and powerful utility that it's interface should be reasonably complex, like the cockpit of an airliner. I'm working with 14 to 30 inch screens, I don't need the same UI as a 5" phone. Instead, we are following Musk's lead and hiding everything behind an Android-like system, with burger menus, disappearing UI elements, brightly coloured icons, and bouncy window animations. And even though KDE is still infinitely customizable, the vast majority of themes out there follow this trend. If anyone knows of a good skeuomorphic theme that still works, I'd love to see it.

[0] https://develop.kde.org/hig/

Re:Revisiting KDE by int_19h on Monday January 16, 2023 @03:38AM (#34398356)
"Dizzying, translucent, psychedelic themes" is how I would describe KDE pretty much... always? Here's a fairly typical KDE desktop circa 2005:

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:SUSE_Linux,_KDE_3_De...

Re:Revisiting KDE by irthomasthomas on Monday January 16, 2023 @12:26PM (#34403006)
Holy transparency, batman! I'm guessing KDE 3 introduced the transparency API or something? But that wasn't a default theme was it? I've used trinity, or TDE, which is a KDE 3 fork, but it's built in themes are way more conservative and practical.
Re:Revisiting KDE by int_19h on Monday January 16, 2023 @04:26PM (#34405697)
True transparency had only just become possible around then thanks to Compiz, so default themes generally wouldn't have it. However, even outside of transparency, look at e.g. how much crystal glare and reflections all the icons have.
Re:Revisiting KDE by Barrin92 on Sunday January 15, 2023 @03:01PM (#34392717)
it's personally why I don't like KDE. I have no nostalgia for the old school windows desktop and it feels like something designed by a Soviet Design bureau combined with an airplane cockpit. There's always three different menus to change the same thing and buttons everywhere.

GNOME goes a little bit overboard sometimes with the simplification but it just feels so much cleaner out of the box.

Re:Revisiting KDE by sph on Sunday January 15, 2023 @05:37PM (#34394390)
Yes and no. I would use KDE if either they went full Windows 98 in their style, or modern slick like GNOME.

Instead they have this bland Windows 10 flat look that has no personality.

The familiar Windows 98 gray had saturation, constrast and even a touch if colour (the gray tends a bit towards the red)

The modern KDE look is a diluted flat gray/desaturated cerulean blue which I really do not like. So uninspired, cold, clinical, corporate, clashing with that friendly look they want KDE to represent. It is uncanny, and while the GNOME design team loves to change stuff just for the sake of it, they have more taste and eye that whoever runs the design team at KDE.

Can we have a desktop that doesn't look like a poster that's been left in the sun for too long? Can we have contrast back and more colours than just light gray and light blue?

Re:Revisiting KDE by jraph on Sunday January 15, 2023 @06:01PM (#34394608)
I like KDE's default theme and color scheme very much, but you can fine tune the colors to your taste or pick a Windows 9x-like theme :-)
Re:Revisiting KDE by kitsunesoba on Sunday January 15, 2023 @06:02PM (#34394610)
Part of what gives the default KDE theme that feel you describe I think is its usage of transparent grays. Generally when you do transparency in UI it needs to be transparent white or transparent black (though in some case, dark transparent gray can work), because transparent mid-grays make everything feel kinda dingy, with whatever's showing through feeling like it's being seen through a thick fog on a dark rainy day.
Re:Revisiting KDE by int_19h on Monday January 16, 2023 @03:50AM (#34398439)
By default, Win98 used the same gray as Win95 (#C0C0C0). If I remember correctly, it was Win2K that made it warmer, and it was definitely an improvement.
Re:Revisiting KDE by seba_dos1 on Monday January 16, 2023 @07:08AM (#34399807)
The default look isn't great, but I'm using Breeze Dark Plasma theme with default Breeze for apps (one click in settings) and it doesn't feel that way anymore.
Re:Revisiting KDE by ssnistfajen on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @07:50PM (#34421824)
They both have their strengths. I prefer KDE on desktops with larger monitors while GNOME feels very clean and uncluttered on laptop screens.
Re:Revisiting KDE by kace91 on Sunday January 15, 2023 @05:33PM (#34394344)
> KDE is my desktop of choice. I feel like it captures the spirit of computing in the Windows 9x era.

I find this sad. It is a sign of lack of innovation in desktop environments.

As a teen I loved fiddling with linux because it had compiz/beryl, etc. You could make windows explode in fire when closed, see the desktop as a 3d cube, etc.

It was all trashy eyecandy, and of little use, but the point is that there was experimentation.

Nowadays I don't think there's a lot to see, the options are:

- 90's-like UX - terminal focused setups (tiling windows managers, etc) - dumbed down tablet-like experience.

Re:Revisiting KDE by skykooler on Sunday January 15, 2023 @05:41PM (#34394436)
I switched back to KDE a few days ago, after having used GNOME for about a decade. One thing that made me really happy is that wobbly windows are an option again! (There's a plugin for GNOME 3 to enable them but it has unusable graphical issues on all computers I've tested it on.) It's nice to be able to reenable some of those effects that got me to try Linux out in the first place.
Re:Revisiting KDE by arka2147483647 on Sunday January 15, 2023 @05:40PM (#34394433)
> I find this sad. It is a sign of lack of innovation in desktop environments.

Most of the modern OS developments focus on making things easy and safe. That usually boils down on removing features and locking down things.

And more generally, there is no gurantee that the new thing is better than the old one.

Re:Revisiting KDE by kace91 on Sunday January 15, 2023 @05:59PM (#34394588)
> Most of the modern OS developments focus on making things easy and safe. That usually boils down on removing features and locking down things.

Fair enough, but innovation should not necessarily be more complex. See pinch-to-zoom in the first iPhone as an example of a groundbreaking addition that makes things simpler.

Re:Revisiting KDE by LarryMullins on Sunday January 15, 2023 @06:34PM (#34394859)
Pinch to zoom is nice, but relies on a sort of peripheral that most desktop computers don't have. To make a mainstream desktop system, you can't assume the user has more than a keyboard and mouse. And so the usual ctrl + / ctrl - shortcuts for scaling/zooming remain, even though they're usually superfluous to laptop users with touchpads.

All kinds of things like that have been added to desktop environments. Things like hot corners to "Exposé" the windows or show all your virtual desktops, gestures for minimizing all your windows or flipping through them. Dragging windows such that they snap into certain geometries for an assisted manual sort of tiling. Despite all these additions, things which Windows 95 didn't have, the typical desktop environment would still seem reasonably familiar to a time-traveling Windows 95 user because the primary input devices are still keyboard and mouse and therefore desktop environments all work the same way, broadly speaking.

Re:Revisiting KDE by WharfWhoretress on Sunday January 15, 2023 @05:38PM (#34394406)
KDE has the same exploding windows and other window effects.
Re:Revisiting KDE by kace91 on Sunday January 15, 2023 @05:56PM (#34394563)
My point was not that those effects from 20 years ago are unavailable, it's that I have not seen current similarly experimental projects that expand what we think of as a desktop.

There is nothing (that I know of) that feels as groundbreaking for 2022 as compiz was for 2006

Re:Revisiting KDE by bodangly on Sunday January 15, 2023 @07:20PM (#34395190)
You see this a lot though. It’s because it becomes harder and harder to do something new and different when it’s all sort of been done before. Innovating something that’s been done to death is a lot harder than innovating when things are still less well defined.

I think video games are in this same space. Rarely does a game actually innovate or come up with something truly novel anymore. Ultima Online was the most amazing thing I ever saw at the time, but now that I’ve seen a million different MMOs the entire genre feels stale. Have fighting games really advanced much from either a Street Fighter type, Mortal Kombat, Marvel Vs Capcom or Smash Brothers style? What about action adventure - is God of War Ragnarok innovating anything? It doesn’t feel that different than playing any number of other games, just maybe more polished. Uncharted is just another take on Tomb Raider at the end of the day. Same thing with movies or television. There just isn’t that much new ground to break.

Re:Revisiting KDE by LarryMullins on Sunday January 15, 2023 @06:05PM (#34394643)
I think desktop design in the 90s reached a point similar to car design did in the mid 1910s; the lack of innovation is a sign of maturity. Almost every car since the Cadillac Type 53 has had more or less the same controls; a steering wheel, foot pedals for the accelerator/brake/clutch with accelerator on the right, brake to the left of that, and clutch to the left of the brake. Some deviation from this scheme is tolerable, new automatic systems sometimes replace manual controls like the clutch pedal, but for the most part every new car either conforms to this general scheme or sets itself apart as a weird outlier. Rarely there is a car with a yoke or joystick instead of a steering wheel, but it never catches on.

Even if you managed to discover something marginally better but radically different, it probably wouldn't catch on because the status quo gets the job done and everybody already understands it. Re-learning how to drive because your car came with a joystick instead of a steering wheel isn't appealing to most people who view their car as a means to an end.

(Also, I don't think there's an intrinsic connection between tiling window managers and terminal-focused setups. The apparent correlation between the two is a coincidence; the sort of people who choose one also often choose the other. GUI file managers and the like work fine under tiling window managers.)

Re:Revisiting KDE by Zababa on Sunday January 15, 2023 @05:53PM (#34394544)
Exactly my feelings, altough it would be with Windows 2000 and XP since I wasn't born before. The file explorer, dolphin, is a good example of that, and a pleasure to use.
Re:Revisiting KDE by antihero on Sunday January 15, 2023 @08:54PM (#34395884)
I’d love the KDE experience with the Gnome aesthetic.
Re:Revisiting KDE by rhaway84773 on Monday January 16, 2023 @06:54AM (#34399724)
Gnome assumes developers don’t have an insane amount of time to spend on their open source desktop apps. And that users deserve high quality apps that work well together.

So Gnome devs, seeing the vast majority of bug reports that developers of first and third party apps received were a result of the large number of configurations and extensions and customizations have decided to rein it back.

Doing so means Gnome developers can start with a smaller footprint which they will now expand to add customizations back in a supported manner.

It’s a different approach. The good thing is that with Linux different groups can try different approaches and users can switch relatively painlessly between them.

So far, having gotten a lot more responsibilities with growing older, I’ve found that letting Gnome pick sensible defaults, etc, and not requiring me to spend a lot of time and mental energy configuring stuff has meant that Gnome has been the most productive general use Desktop in my personal life (i3 for work life…).

Re:Revisiting KDE by cuteboy19 on Monday January 16, 2023 @01:24PM (#34403790)
The issue is that everyone needs at least one or two customisations that they can't live without, even though they don't need all of them. And so they end up installing gnome tweaks which is a buggy mess which will never be fixed, as with most third party extensions.

In comparison, even though there are a lot of bugs in KDE, they will eventually be fixed, given that most customisations are first party.

Re:Revisiting KDE by asdajksah2123 on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @08:10AM (#34411960)
Seems like you prefer the KDE model.

Great! Use KDE!

I, unfortunately, have a limited amount of time and prefer not waiting for those bugs to eventually be resolved. So I prefer using Gnome, where the limited flexibility is not a problem for me, and the far more consistent and stable Gnome environment is extremely valuable!

So I use Gnome.

That's the great part about Linux.

And I can somehow manage to do that without suggesting that KDE developers need to stop treating their users like a bunch of kids with no jobs living in their mother's basements.

Many in the Linux community seem incapable of doing that second thing, which is the crappy part about Linux.

Re:Revisiting KDE by WhyNotHugo on Monday January 16, 2023 @09:10AM (#34400799)
What distro do you use? Would you recommend it to newcomers?

I've friends and family who always ask me this. My partner tried Fedora KDE, but their input methods are completely broken, and writing in Chinese (her native language) was simply not feasible.

I tried live media of a few random distros, but basic things were always broken (e.g.: touchpad scrolling didn't work, things like that).

Re:Revisiting KDE by bmn__ on Monday January 16, 2023 @12:08PM (#34402765)
The best distro for newcomers is the one their mentor in the local LUG is using. Any other way is just a recipe for misery.

> Fedora KDE, but their input methods are completely broken

That sucks. I can say with confidence that this is not the case on openSUSE with KDE. I have fcitx5, fcitx5-chinese-addons and a few other relevant packages installed and it works fine.

Re:Revisiting KDE by WhyNotHugo on Monday January 16, 2023 @03:16PM (#34404988)
I tried OpenSUSE and it had scaling issues. Basically, everything was tiny (to a point where it was unreadable).

OpenSUSE used X11 by default (rather than Wayland), and configuring scaling on X11 has never fully worked for me, so I didn't want to sink time into that. It didn't seem that Wayland was an option.

I admit I didn't have a huge amount of patience or put a lot of time into OpenSUSE; after wasting a lot of time into trying to make input work on Fedora [and failing], we basically went through multiple distros in a weekend and quickly moved on whenever one had obvious issues rather than try and figure out if it was possible to tinker around it.

Do you know if X11 is still the default or Wayland if is well supported? Or any other advise for this scenario?

Re:Revisiting KDE by bmn__ on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @03:07AM (#34410192)
I observe no scaling issues, I use the settings below and it works just fine.

System Settings → Hardware → Display and Monitor → Display Configuration → Global scale [125%]

System Settings → Appearance → Fonts → Adjust All Fonts… and raise the size to 16pt.

Re:Revisiting KDE by ssnistfajen on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @07:49PM (#34421807)
When was the last time you tried OpenSUSE? Both distributions of OpenSUSE with GNOME now use Wayland by default. As for KDE unfortunately it still needs a bit of time for Wayland sessions to be more stable. They are perfectly usable now, but face potentially more headaches comapred to GNOME Wayland sessions.

As for Chinese input, fcitx + google pinyin worked just fine on Manjaro KDE for me. Word prediction isn't very good but it's generally usable. For more details see here: https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/fcitx

Re:Revisiting KDE by WhyNotHugo on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @08:25AM (#34426336)
This was in October 2022.

I might give OpenSUSE/KDE another shot. Any ideas what's broken on their wayland session?

Re:Revisiting KDE by ssnistfajen on Wednesday January 18, 2023 @02:58PM (#34432158)
https://community.kde.org/Plasma/Wayland_Showstoppers

If using Wayland is a hard requirement then I would recommend choosing GNOME over KDE for the desktop environment. I've been using KDE on X11 just fine for now.