It is worth speaking with an estate lawyer or accountant. There are strategies to avoid this that differ based on country, but insurance usually plays a role. It is, in my opinion, unfair that someone would be forced by taxes to sell the birthright that their parent spent a lifetime working for. Good luck.
Why is it only “cosmically inherent” as long as you don’t hurt others? Has the tiger no cosmically inherent right to his meal? The truth is he doesn’t, he must defend his kill if necessary.
The truth is you must defend what you’ve earned as well, either by force or through mutual agreement (society).
We, as a society, have agreed to grant each other exclusive rights to what we’ve earned. Of course that hasn’t always been the case throughout history. Don’t bring the cosmos into it, it happens through mutual consent, because we choose to.
Your rights are man-made, don’t take them for granted. They only exist so long as everyone agrees they do.
Another form is the right of selection -- I have one, here's another one that just become unowned, and I get dibs on choosing that over my own. If I retain my own, the other lapses to the public. If I choose the other, mine does.
Note I am not arguing that inequality is an unvarnished good or that history isn’t filled with violence and sin. However, that’s a far cry from saying simply that “birthright” doesn’t make sense at least when talking about purely physical items to be inherited.
Land in particular is a special case because more cannot be created (without absolutely massive capital projects and those require some special thinking, but they are outliers).
https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/your-book-review-progr...
https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/does-georgism-work-is-...
I think society needs property tax to perform well, or else people will horde control of land under the mistaken belief that they can sell or rent it for high prices. You need tax to bring people back to reality and force them to use it productively in the present.
This paragraph doesn’t make any sense at all either.
The reason is that there is no meaning whatsoever to the concept of earned inequality, and therefore no meaning to the idea of ‘unearned’ inequality.
Now consider a third person who also cares for their child. This person also lives frugally but instead of saving their wealth every year they buy their kid fancy cars and luxury goods. They die penniless but their kid never had to work a day in their life. Is that fair?
It would be good to reframe it with consequentialism in mind to reveal the unspoken truths of the examples.
Ten generations later, the descendants of the first person have all been able to expand their wealth purely due to the wealth that their ancestor had. None of them have had to work hard for generations, but they all vigorously defend their right to give their wealth to their kids without taxes so that they also don't have to work hard. Meanwhile, the descendants of the second person are unable to acquire wealth due to the advantage that people like the first person have in controlling capital, and they all work menial jobs for people like the first person. Is that fair?
I, personally, would have a tax of 100% on all wealth over $100m.
Your response would seem to posit a different set of questions, namely should capital be used to make decisions for society and does a concentration of capital force those without to work a lifetime of menial jobs?
I'm less interested in addressing these questions since I've heard a lot about them before and I think it will take us on a further tangent from the original discussion. But I will just say that I see no difference between a first generation person who doesn't work and a tenth generation person who doesn't work beyond perhaps an abstract greater disconnection from the rest of society and the concept of hard working. And that for capital to have influence over society it must be deployed which carries with it the risk of losing said capital.
Each table plays 10,000 games, and then the number of wins for each player are counted. Which table do you expect to have the greatest difference in the number of wins between players A and B, and which would you expect to have the least difference in wins between players A and B? I'd consider the table with the least expected difference of wins to be the most "fair", and the table with the greatest expected difference to be the least fair. My hypothesis is that table 1 would be the most fair, followed by table 3, and then table 2 would be the least fair.
Translating this to inheritance in the real world, I think being able to give an advantage to one's descendants for 10 generations is less fair than being able to give it to only one generation. In the context of something like an estate tax, I could imagine something like an implementation where accepting an inheritance incurs a higher tax rate on any money bequeathed up to the amount you inherited. For example, if I inherit $1,000,000 over my lifetime and then leave $5,000,000 to my heir, maybe the first $1,000,000 might incur an extra 10% tax, but then the remaining $4,000,000 is taxed at the regular rate. For something like this to be seriously implemented, I expect that it might need do account for more things (e.g. adjustment for inflation), but at least as far as I can see it seems like a pretty reasonable idea. It's possible that something like this already exists though!
But none of this matters because Monopoly is not real life.
The wealthy used to amass real physical resources; ores, livestock, land, people... Now we mostly have them chasing digital zeroes in a bank account. It really is much better. So some people buy a yacht every now and again? That's great! Yachtmakers have a reason to go to work every day and the world keeps spinning.
If you think there should be a cap on the total amount of zeroes anyone can hold at one time I totally get where you're coming from, but I don't get the obsession with taking a cut when someone dies beyond the normal cut we take when people just transfer wealth to eachother because a clever person will just make a plan to do this before they die and that is unfair to folks that aren't so clever.
Monopoly was just an example of a game with currency at the start; you could pick pretty much any other game with a similar mechanic.
> To strain the analogy further, why are you always transferring wins to player A? A better model is to just let both players keep whatever they have at the end of each game and use it to start the next game.
The reason I said to transfer to player A was merely to make it easier to express the inequality; think of player A not as a family line so much as "the set of people who have inheritances" versus "the set of people who don't". That's also why I don't think it matters whether the person is dead or not; my point is showing that having inheritance continue to affect games beyond the immediate one after is significantly different than limiting it to one generation.
> But none of this matters because Monopoly is not real life.
Yeah, I don't think anyone would disagree with this, but the point here is that having previous games affects later ones can give significant advantages and disadvantages, and this result is independent of the game.
> The wealthy used to amass real physical resources; ores, livestock, land, people... Now we mostly have them chasing digital zeroes in a bank account. It really is much better. So some people buy a yacht every now and again? That's great! Yachtmakers have a reason to go to work every day and the world keeps spinning.
I have no idea what this has to do with the discussion at all. Whether digital assets or physical ones are passed on via inheritance doesn't change whether or not starting with extra resources is an advantage or not. I definitely don't think that anyone is arguing that they think the problem with inheritance is that people can buy yachts?
> If you think there should be a cap on the total amount of zeroes anyone can hold at one time I totally get where you're coming from, but I don't get the obsession with taking a cut when someone dies beyond the normal cut we take when people just transfer wealth to eachother because a clever person will just make a plan to do this before they die and that is unfair to folks that aren't so clever.
We have taxes on people giving money to each other directly when alive as well. You can't just give someone $1 million while you're alive to avoid them having to pay taxes on it. If by "clever" you mean "avoiding taxes", then yes, I do think this also shouldn't be allowed, and I don't think I'd be opposed to having the tax rate be similar to the estate tax. From my perspective, the "obsession" is from people who seem to be from people _against_ allowing taxes on estates (using pejorative language like "death tax"[1] to try to derail the discussion). I don't feel the need to as strongly defend sales tax or income tax because there are far fewer people who argue that they shouldn't exist at all, but if the political will to abolish income tax reached similar levels of support to opposition to the estate tax, then I would focus more on it.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estate_tax_in_the_United_State...
When others inherit, society needs to take their wealth and redistribute it. Their situation is not like mine. These millionaires and billionaires got lucky and their kids don’t deserve to be rich for no reason.
That doesn't necessarily mean it's immoral or should be illegal, but how could you argue that it's fair that some people get free money while others don't by the luck of their birth?
A forced raffle where everyone has to join is unfair, yes. That's why we have laws, and there is (ideally) no randomness.
I don't see how it's "fair" that I was born to hardworking, financially responsible parents, while most others were less lucky though.
I think the aim of this is to avoid breaking up already poorly performing farms, and because the business tend to be low-revenue but high in assets (land, mostly). Doesn't hurt that farmers are a huge voting block here.
You can hedge crop in many ways. Give Terry Duffy a call.
1. Borrow against the land to pay the inheritance taxes.
2. Rent the land to a farmer, use the cashflow to pay off the inheritance tax loan until it’s paid off.
3. Keep renting the land to receive cash income.
If the yield on the land sucks because it’s not high quality land, sell it.
Are you aware of better strategies to do that?
...plus logistics, storage, insurance, finances, repair, markets, etc, etc. I would be interested in working with a farmer through some time of my life just to learn such a wide variety of tasks!
As said, there is a lot that goes into farming these days and almost everyone specializes in a crop or two. The folks that do it the old fashion ways without adapting are usually going under because their yields are poor / inconsistent. This will likely be you if you go at it alone, so unless you are okay with eating some losses then I would get help.
I am a farm boy. There was one night many decades ago where I said to myself: "You can either wrap your head around DiffEQ, pass the course, and graduate with an engineering degree, or go home and clean hog barns for the rest of your life." I chose option A. While this makes a good story, it is also the literal truth. The point being, I grew up in farming and understand it, but have little desire to manage a farm myself. Same goes for my wife.
Eventually with the passage of time, we inherited farm land. Our path has been to rent the land to farmer operators that we have good relationships with, and manage the leasing ourselves. If course, with the advice of an attorney and an accountant that are both local to the area where the farms are and who do a lot of farm-related practice. We feel we understand farming well enough to engage with farmer-operators and negotiate fair rents, get soil-conservation terms in our lease agreements that we desire, negotiate capital improvement projects that are mutually beneficial (some of our farm land had drainage tile installed a few years back, for example.)
If you go this path, you will want local legal and accounting advice. You should also understand enough of the "big picture" items like the ebb-and-flow of the pricing of the commodity in question, how that impacts rents, the rent models used with operators for that particular commodity, and any farming practices that you with to enforce, such as soil and water conservation, appropriate use of pesticides and herbicides, who gets the rent from pollinators if that applies, etc.
Option 2 is farm management companies. My farm land is in Iowa and Minnesota, so hardly coffee country. It is corn (maize) and soy bean country. There is a corn-belt farm management company called Hertz farm management that is one of the large, reputable farm management companies that many people in our situation use. You might be able to find an equivalent firm. This is a good option if you want something more turn-key, and don't feel that you have sufficient expertise be a landlord-with-a-clue.
300km in any direction is far enough that the rules are different.
Do you live in France by any chance?
https://turbotax.intuit.com/tax-tips/estates/what-are-inheri...
Out of scope for this comment, but there are several ways these taxs is avoided.
Making a success of a commercial farm requires deep knowledge of the crop, the land, the weather and the local pests. Gone are the days of doing things the way your forefathers did things. Moreso if you actually want to be competitive in the market that you are producing for.
Please dont make the romantic mistake of thinking you will become this farmer and it's all sunshine and success. One bad crop (which could be because of no fault of your own) can mean financial ruin.
My advice: rub shoulders with the locals in the area. Maybe theres a farmer interested in renting your land and trees. Alternatively, appoint an expert to manage and run the farm for you.
Theres a certain romanticism associated whith owning land you inherited. But you have to be honest with yourself and look at the numbers. If it's not your expertise and the financials don't make sense you'll probably be better off selling the land.
My dad and I had exactly this conversation recently. He has some land that he got from his father, that he's renting out to the farming relatives. My dad's at the age now where he needs to plan for what happens to his estate. We looked at the numbers and relaized me and my brother will be better off selling and taking the money. In my country you are liable to pay hefty taxes on inheritance. Neither of us have the reserves to pay those taxes on a piece of land we have no idea how to run or manage. You inherit an asset that you are forced to liquidate in order to afford the inheritance taxes on that asset.