News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by flandish on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:49AM (#34082195)
Every time I hear someone say “something someone else does on their property it lowers my property value”… I respond with “with investment comes risk. either your house is your house or its an investment. But that does not make ALL houses investments. If the risk is too much, pop smoke before the value is too low.”

I’m told I just “don’t get if.”

No. I don’t get it. That’s the problem. :p

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by bberenberg on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:14AM (#34082588)
Why should an investor not exercise agency to try and influence the outcome of their investment?
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by Gracana on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:42AM (#34082967)
Because of the harm they cause to the people around them, as discussed in the comments here.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by FpUser on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:44AM (#34082995)
And why should I give a fuck about what investor wishes. In my opinion bar direct / illegal actions like throwing garbage in neighbour's property we should be left alone from interference.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by flandish on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:45AM (#34083011)
Oh I think they should attempt to register their opinion, but in the end, that’s as far as it can go - if we truly “care” about a human’s right to private enjoyment of their own “property.”
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by friend_and_foe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @11:50AM (#34083077)
Now rephrase that taking into account the fact that said investor enacting his will onto another person without their consent.

If what I do with my property negatively affects your investment perhaps you should've taken that into account when conducting your risk analysis instead of throwing a fit and making your problems my problem.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by micromacrofoot on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:18PM (#34083454)
Sure but they're also enacting their will on someone through a social construct (the legal system) designed by society to enact the popular will on individuals.

If you live next to someone concerned about their investment, perhaps you should consider what mechanisms exist to prevent you from using your property in a way that would affect their investment.

This kind of argument can go on and on forever because there's no right answer. The homeowner can do what they want within the confines of the legal system on their property, and the investor can do what they want within the confines of the legal system to protect their investment.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by flandish on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:44PM (#34083853)
The only “right” answer lies in the idea that one’s home should out prioritize another’s investment.

Investment supports a class driven, divide building system.

Homes support humans.

One of the two above clearly, imho, has “right of way.”

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by renewiltord on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:54PM (#34084004)
For you. But for me, applying pressure (political or financial) to get my way without deleterious consequences to myself is the way to live.

Why shouldn't I simply arrogate to myself the right to direct all of society's resources to my own comfort? The Veil of Ignorance is nonsensical. I can condition probabilities of outcomes on my current state and choose appropriate action.

Why would I discard any power I have? That just transfers the balance of power to power of another sort that others have.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by AlexandrB on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:27PM (#34084423)
The logical conclusion of this is a panopticon, where those with more power lord over those with less in all areas of life. Sounds great for some, I guess.

Me, I like some freedom.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by renewiltord on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @10:40PM (#34089508)
Well, the problem with building such weapons is that they may be pointed at you. Price that in and the best case is lots of rules for you and few rules for me.

Which I like. Your desire for freedom is unlikely to be very deep. You'll give it up to impose rules on your neighbor, most likely.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by micromacrofoot on Friday December 23, 2022 @10:11AM (#34106648)
What if I'm using my home as an investment to fund my retirement? for which I have no savings... this is never as clear as you think it is
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by guerrilla on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:56PM (#34084023)
> Sure but they're also enacting their will on someone through a social construct (the legal system) designed by society to enact the popular will on individuals.

Your argument is premised on the law not being for sale and thus the distribution of power being extremely unequal and therefore unjust, but (at least in real life) you're wrong.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by friend_and_foe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:59PM (#34084828)
There is a right answer. "What's mine is none of your god damn business." If you're investing in property, great, don't make your problems my problem.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by flandish on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:19PM (#34085113)
Exactly. They “hedge” their investments through monied expression and bullying of others enjoying their own property.

Pretty standard sociopathic capitalist formula, to be honest.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by friend_and_foe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:42PM (#34085423)
Eh, I'm not with you on the whole anti capitalism angle to all this, I think "what's mine is mine and what's yours is yours so leave me alone and I'll leave you alone" about covers it.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by flandish on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:35PM (#34087309)
Fair point. Just consider: the only reason one investor will complain abt “value” - is because that value exists on a market that’s (purpose) built to extract as much “value” as possible with very little, often fought for, regard for humanity.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by micromacrofoot on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:49PM (#34085494)
Sorry, you live in a society so that doesn't work in theory or in practice.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by friend_and_foe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:04PM (#34086987)
"I also exist so you have to live bu my rules" it doesn't make a lot of sense when you boil it down to itst essence. Just because I live in proximity to people doesn't mean they get to dictate the terms of my life beyond whatever involvement I have with them directly.

Just because you want it to be that way doesn't mean it will be, and me and others like me will keep pushing to be left alone by people who get a hard on looking to exert power over us.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by micromacrofoot on Thursday December 22, 2022 @12:03PM (#34095590)
> Just because I live in proximity to people doesn't mean they get to dictate the terms of my life beyond whatever involvement I have with them directly.

They do though, always have and always will. Society can't function unless they do. You keep the noise down, don't play with noxious materials, you can't put a shooting range in your yard facing their house, can't build a building too close to their property, can't operate a business with customers without certain permitting, have to maintain a certain level of cleanliness... I could come up with dozens of things you have to do for the sake of your neighbors.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by davidgay on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:02PM (#34083255)
So clearly, I can start a toxic chemicals factory in my basement, next to your house? (I'll move elsewhere of course)

Or, absolute principles are rarely absolutely applicable.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by friend_and_foe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:11PM (#34083379)
There's a clear distinction here: risk to other people and their property. There's a reason people who make arguments for controlling other people's behavior have to come up with over the top, ridiculous scenarios with obvious answers. If you're trying to find an answer, find the principles and work from there and you'll find absolute principles are fine. There's no risk to you or your property if I decide to have a car with the hood up parked in my driveway.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by noduerme on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:33PM (#34083688)
What if you have a different car with its hood up on your property every day? What if you're painting them and venting it out of your garage? Toxic chemicals is not a wild scenario, it's the logical next step.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:40PM (#34083795)
If toxic chemicals is the problem, legislate that.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by flandish on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:46PM (#34083894)
We already have laws re environment - STOP EMBOLDENING THE SUPPORT FOR THE INVESTMENT OWNING CLASS by pretending those laws don’t already exist.

No example given isn’t already covered by a law that already exists.

Except in the correlation to a “market” that this “investment” will be expected to perform on.

It puts capital and profit over humans and is deplorable behavior.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by friend_and_foe on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:36PM (#34084529)
So legislate the next step then. "No dumping or releasing toxic chemicals" it's not that hard, and the fact that that's not what's legislated, but it's what is used as an excuse for totally different sets of rules tells me that's not the motivation here.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by flandish on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:16PM (#34085071)
Regarding your edit: the ire comes from (at least in my reply) the idea that your logic or example is so shallow as to “by default” support the class of people who can afford to treat homes like investments.

There are entire cohorts of people who cannot. Who own one home, barely, or are beholden to a landlord’s (sometimes corporate) whims.

Saying “what if they leak oil from junk cars” - resolved via environment law already.

“Noise complaint.” - resolved via law already.

Too many cars, too much blight? - laws already.

Every single example provided couches this as a potential harm to someone else’s investment, and strengthens the divide in class between those who can afford to “invest” and those who cannot and strive to simply exist.

Yes, people DO worry about investment. I do. I own my home. My only home. It’s paid off, largely speaking.

But it’s my home. I have NO desire or assumption that its value will go to my children or provide retirement income.

Because it’s a home.

And I look at my fellow working class neighbors in the same way.

If someone complains my home needing paint (it does) will affect (effect? I always forget) their investment - I will happily let them paint my house or they can f off.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by noduerme on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:29PM (#34085258)
From the article:

>> it's believed that the code is intended to prevent small independent repair shops from popping up in someone's backyard

While other laws may cover each of the potential negative secondary effects of a backyard auto shop on the neighbors, that doesn't mean the group of behavior leading to violation of those laws should remain undefined.

Again, to me this has nothing to do with keeping value on an investment. My experience with this was renting... I now own (one) house, and my problem with what the neighbors do has to do with how it affects my health and quality of life.

Claiming every possible negative effect is covered by law makes no sense. Leaking chemicals? Could take years to be discovered in the water table. Noise? Not really enforced anywhere... especially not if the activity in question is otherwise legal / doesn't require a license.

I don't think it was a shallow objection... and I believe you're reading it through a classist lens of "what if some rich investment owner next door told me what to do on my property" without considering the other side, e.g. someone renting next door to people who do noxious stuff.

[edit] also, I can see from your point of view as a homeowner myself who's surrounded by creeping investment properties and Airbnb's... and certainly if they were telling me how to paint my house they could f off too. But that's aesthetic and about their investment value. I guess what I'm saying when you get down to it is the aesthetics of auto repair aren't the part that bothers me, it's living next door to the noise and pollution.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by flandish on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:42PM (#34085433)
I do appreciate your replies and can see where you are coming from as it pertains to the article. Zoning is what zoning is - and that’s to be covered by the auto shop or pet store or etc etc.

What “triggers” me is this idea that the default state is “consider investment” and not “does it harm one’s ability to enjoy their home.”

Sure you cab define “enjoy” as “watch value go up” but that’s clearly not what I mean.

The whole “and it harm none, do as you please”, imho, does not consider the wallet.

Which, when thinking about investments, is thinking about class divide and puts $ over people.

My neighborhood is largely renters. I’m a 1 family across from another 1 family. On my sides are multi families. Renters. Owned by corporations but not kept up. Some in pretty crappy disrepair.

If I wanted to claim they affected my prop value, I could. But those corps have MUCH more money to defend and hit back (my house needs paint, etc) … just the same. (That’s not my style though as said earlier)

Anyway. I’m tired and rambling. I do appreciate the replies and I do hope I’ve helped some bit to look at anything that comes out of the gate thinking $ before people - is widening the gap and harming people.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ajkjk on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:09PM (#34083355)
I feel like your argument undermined itself? There is a clear argument against your neighbor having a toxic chemical factory that has nothing to do with investment values, such as "it makes my home an unsafe place to live". The whole point here is that the point of homes is to be homes, not investments.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by AlexandrB on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:21PM (#34084343)
Ironically, people do this all the time - it's called a fire pit[1]. But people rarely complain because it's not "icky".

[1] https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/wondering-what...

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by thecosas on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:41PM (#34084593)
I know some people do outdoor burning in rural settings to address debris, etc. Curious now if there is a cleaner way to burn that debris other than an open fire.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by AlexandrB on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:46PM (#34084656)
The article actually mentions that hotter fires are (generally) cleaner, so adding oxygen/air would improve things.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by shanebellone on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:56PM (#34084027)
I mostly agree with this, but I'd slightly adjust the phrasing.

No investor is owed a profit (unless contractually stipulated).

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by jjulius on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:02PM (#34083250)
Because this is my home, not your investment. Invest in something else if people living their lives on their own property seems like too much of a risk to your "investment".
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by chasd00 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:31PM (#34084471)
my property my rules is a slippery slope. For example, many cities require you to purchase a permit to have a garage sale because neighbors don't want you running a flea market out of your yard.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by kaesar14 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:04PM (#34083281)
This is how we got to a housing crisis.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by Nifty3929 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:12PM (#34083392)
They should - and they should fail. It should not surprise us that people try to use the force of government to achieve their personal goals. But we should be mad at ourselves for voting for politicians and legislators that allow the government to wield this power in the first place.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by jonfw on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:08PM (#34084179)
I'd expect them to consider the implications of our actions towards others before exercising their agency. Nobody is excused from ethics just because money is at stake
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by api on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:30PM (#34083651)
"Housing cannot be simultaneously affordable and a good investment."

Housing as an investment first and a place to live second is a disease. It penalizes the poor, new arrivals, and the young, transferring wealth from these groups to people who bought homes back before the disease took hold. This is not wealth earned by working hard or creating value. Instead it's wealth extracted by obstructing value creation to collect rent from a captive audience.

Most of those benefiting from this condition would never have been able to buy in today, but "I've got mine, fuck you."

Any place dominated by this dynamic has zero claim to any kind of liberal or progressive title. This includes the supposed liberal bastion of the San Francisco Bay Area, a massively distorted housing market that creates one of the widest divisions between rich and poor anywhere in the US. Places like Texas, Georgia, and South Carolina are more progressive than San Francisco because a working class person can afford a home.

Most of the country has this disease to some extent, but obviously there are a few hot spots that are particularly bad. I picked on SF because it's among the worst and also among the most sanctimonious, continuously holding itself up as some kind of progressive bastion while implementing what amounts to red lining on a massive scale.

Unfortunately I can't think of any solution to this problem that isn't painful. Either we inflate the rest of the economy until a loaf of bread is $15 but housing is reasonable again or we let housing collapse.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by xwdv on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:38PM (#34083767)
I’d be careful calling this a disease.

The fact is, for many people having a home that they build equity in is the closest they’ll ever get to some kind of “savings” account. When the home is paid off in 30 years they no longer need money saved up to buy a retirement home because they will have full equity of their house which may have gone up substantially in value. They could then sell this property and downsize and continue to live off the proceeds from the equity they sold.

If homes weren’t investments, it means people would have to be a lot more serious about saving and investing money for the future, and frankly that just isn’t going to happen at scale given human behavior.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by api on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:42PM (#34083832)
That's the disease: the use of housing as one's primary source of savings and retirement funding.

There are alternatives like pensions, improving social security and medicare/medicaid, etc. The de-prioritization and gutting of these has probably contributed to housing taking their place.

But housing isn't a sustainable answer. It's basically done. Current generations can never see the kind of housing appreciation their parents did. Prices simply can't go up much more except in areas that are undervalued and never saw a run-up in previous decades. New buyers today risk the opposite: straining to buy into overvalued markets only to see them crash and leave them underwater. Housing as a source of retirement funding is a one-generation-and-done phenomenon.

Personally I would not touch real estate in overvalued metros today unless I were rich and could afford to lose 25-50% of the value of the home. If interest rates don't come back down to near-zero and/or if the trend toward telework and geographic decentralization continues, these areas could very well crash.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by xwdv on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:46PM (#34083904)
Pensions, social security, and Medicare/Medicaid can all be wiped out with the stroke of a pen. A hard asset such as a home is not so simple. I think there is still room for housing to be the best investment a person could make in their life.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mattmanser on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:31PM (#34084466)
A stroke of a pen can make your home someone else's too, so not sure what's your point?
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by mindslight on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:34PM (#34084506)
This myopic "but government" fearmongering is itself a cause of the disease.

The "hard asset" value of a house is a very small component of its total value. The majority of the value directly relies on the government policy of overwhelming monetary inflation dumped into the financial industry. That policy can be changed much easier than bona fide entitlement policies, and perhaps it has even started changing already.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by api on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:58PM (#34084049)
> I think there is still room for housing to be the best investment a person could make in their life.

If so, only at the expense of the next generation who will find it even harder to afford a place to live. When housing prices go up it means the next generation will find it that much harder to afford a place to live.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by saint_fiasco on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:00PM (#34084841)
Apparently, someone repairing a car in their own garage can significantly reduce the value of this so called hard asset.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by Ekaros on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:24PM (#34084380)
Delta of moving to smaller or cheaper is entirely reasonable case. But the appreciation is bullshit and massive extraction of wealth from those that can least afford it.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by jasonhansel on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:54PM (#34084771)
Housing is a good investment because it is a place you live in. When you own (and live in) a house, you ideally make both a short-term profit (by having a place to live) and a long-term one (from reselling it later). These aren't mutually exclusive.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by marcus_holmes on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:25PM (#34086600)
Renting is short-term cheaper than owning, though (depending on local markets). I've rented a bunch of properties way out of my mortgage price range.

And I think gp's point was that if housing prices rise (so that they're a good investment) then they become unaffordable (as we're seeing). One or the other, not both.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by andrewjl on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @04:23PM (#34166170)
> Unfortunately I can't think of any solution to this problem that isn't painful. Either we inflate the rest of the economy until a loaf of bread is $15 but housing is reasonable again or we let housing collapse.

Or we could build more housing?

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by danudey on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:45PM (#34083889)
Please lower my property value so that my property taxes go down, thanks.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by nonameiguess on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:57PM (#34084041)
It's unfortunate but telling that the code site has this wording, but there is a steelman version of this type of sentiment. Sufficient neighborhood blight can have a direct impact on the quality of life of the people living in the neighborhood, even if they don't plan to ever sell their house and don't care about resale value. I would argue this is far more the case with things like ostentatious lighting, noise violations, and bad smells than with something like non-functional cars being visible in driveways, and this doesn't personally bother me. I do my own repairs and my next-door neighbor has been working on a project RV for nearly two years now, which I'm also fine with.

However, I am absolutely not fine with the party house AirBNB next door to me on the other side that is constantly hosting bachelor and bachelorette parties with DJs and strippers playing loud music on Sunday night when I need to get up early in the morning to work on Monday, also filling up the entire street with vehicles and leaving nowhere to park for people who actually live here. So yeah, that I'll complain about.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by jandrese on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @12:59PM (#34084063)
"Property value" is the biggest cop out. When someone says that what they really mean is "I don't like the look of that", but they can't just say that, it has to have a vague monetary penalty for them to be taken seriously.

Whenever someone hits you with that make sure you get them to document the reduction in their property value in dollars, including methodology. It's not possible, houses sell for whatever someone buys it for and you can't know the mind of buyers. Maybe the fact that your door is off-tan instead of off-medium-tan will make some buyer reduce their offer on a house 5 doors down by $20,000, but there's no way to prove that.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by jakogut on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:10PM (#34084220)
I learned in my home buying process that values are mostly meaningless, and completely subject to what buyers will offer.

When you buy a house, the bank orders an appraisal to ensure the property is worth the offered price, in case of foreclosure. What's the first thing the appraiser looks at to determine value? Comparables, which is an industry term for similar houses/properties in similar areas and what they sold for. What's the best comparable? The offer you made on the property you're attempting to buy. It's cyclical.

I agree that people should not be penalized for living in and using their homes. If I buy a house with a garage, you shouldn't get mad that I work on my car and even gasp make some noise during the day while I do it.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by jandrese on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:19PM (#34084319)
The entire appraisal industry is largely a scam IMHO. At most they can tell a bank if an offer is outside the realm of reason for the neighborhood, but that's basically just a search of recent sale prices. They won't even send someone out to look at a property.

Last time I went to sell my house the market was in a fairly volatile state and I didn't have a good idea of what a fair price for my house would be. So I called multiple appraisal companies asking if they could give me a fair market value figure I could use for the listing. Not one of them would do it. That's not their business they told me. They basically exist as one of many dubious middlemen that takes a cut out of each home sale while offering little value.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by conductr on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:16PM (#34086510)
I wouldn’t disagree with you except to point out that they do exactly what they’re intended to do. Protecting the lender. Even then, it’s just one of the many checks in the underwriting process.

They do however tend to thwart rapid price surges in the market. Depending on if you’re buying or selling will change your opinion on if that is good or bad.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by telotortium on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @07:41PM (#34088290)
My mortgage lender's appraisal involved an in-person evaluation both times on my house (first house purchase - initial mortgage followed by a refinance). In SF Bay Area, so maybe things are done differently where you are?

I'll grant that they largely rubber-stamp the offer price, but if the property has hidden defects it might be good for the bank to try to find that out before lending.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:15PM (#34084277)
It's terrifying that public education lets someone graduate high school without the most basic understanding of how pricing works.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by josephcsible on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:10PM (#34084223)
> When someone says that what they really mean is "I don't like the look of that"

No, they mean "people who are in the market for a house like mine tend to not like the look of that."

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by jandrese on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:14PM (#34084271)
Again, how do they know the mind of buyers? Are they in telepathic communication with current home buyers?
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by tharkun__ on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:33PM (#34084500)
I think you are both onto something there.

Of course nobody in telepathically able to figure out what goes on in some buyers' minds. I don't know if/how many buyers would really consider it in a "let's bid $20.000 below asking because the neighbour three doors down has a broken car in his driveway" or "because the lawn isn't a golf-green" way.

What I do think many buyers will consider is whether to buy at all. Many buyers will not even consider to buy your house, if the neighbour's yard is overgrown. Like the difference between this being your neighbor: https://i.ytimg.com/vi/PGgOiHH_4Sk/maxresdefault.jpg vs. this https://fthmb.tqn.com/bUupIggP7-_Duha--avqVcXqLqc=/960x0/fil...

Now both are overgrown but one screams neglected, possibly even abandoned. The other, while not everyone's cup of tea, seems intentional and lively.

Or to take cars. This to me looks ugly and abandoned. Don't want to live next to that person: https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-ub_p4acppHE/TWv_24yosLI/A... but this is awesome https://i.pinimg.com/originals/c9/81/97/c98197ac689cdef00eb5... and that tractor definitely needs repairs from time to time.

The problem comes in when trying to do something about one without affecting the other. I don't know if that's possible via a law at all as there's so much nuance and personal opinion and aesthetics in it. I bet in this large HN crowd you'll find someone that even disagrees w/ my opinion that the second yard I linked to looks awesome. I'd buy that house!

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by ghaff on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:30PM (#34085281)
I think that's exactly right.

A lot of people will look and think at least somewhat subconsciously "If a neighborhood tolerates that sort of thing, what else do they tolerate" and just keep driving by.

And I say that as someone who let some stuff around my property get a bit out of control (but mostly out back) over COVID but I have a fairly large property and my neighbors have even larger ones and I'm well off the road.

But my messy country garden is just a messy country garden that pretty much no one but me needs to look at. Neighbors might reasonably think differently in a neat upscale suburban neighborhood.

I strongly lean to the live and let live side but there's a, to me, distressing about of Screw my neighbors, I'll do whatever I want on this thread.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by chasd00 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:28PM (#34084443)
i don't think it's a cop out, I certainly wouldn't buy a house on a street with a bunch of broken down cars on it.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by lrvick on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:57PM (#34084803)
And that is why people do it.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by marcus_holmes on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:21PM (#34086566)
Standard house-buying advice is to buy "the worst house on the best street".

So having some broken-down cars on your property may make it "the worst house" on your street and therefore more saleable.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @04:26PM (#34086605)
> Standard house-buying advice is to buy "the worst house on the best street".

“Worst” here really meaning selling for the lowest value compared to what is implied by size and neighborhood.

> So having some broken-down cars on your property may make it "the worst house" on your street and therefore more saleable.

It may signal that it is likely to be underpriced and get people to check it out, but that’s about it.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by antasvara on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:25PM (#34085206)
Let's say a house is actively burning down next door. If you were to sell right at that moment, the value of that home would be decreased due to the fire risk. However, there isn't any sensible methodology for predicting the exact amount that house would decrease in value.

The point I'm making there is that for some changes, price will most definitely be affected negatively. However, it would also be impossible to quantify how much the price would decrease with any degree of accuracy.

Now, is something like "door color" going to have this clear of a negative impact? No. We should ignore those requests as largely absurd. But there are definitely activities that would have clear negative impacts on price, even if that can't be quantified in an accurate manner whatsoever.

Does this mean we should legislate changes to help maintain property values? No. But it's certainly a valid claim in some circumstances.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by willcipriano on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:44PM (#34085453)
If I build a shed on my property that my neighbor doesn't like they could come with their hand out.

If I bulldoze my house and build a beautiful park, they'll never send me a check.

In my view this has to go both ways or neither.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by CivBase on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:08PM (#34084173)
I don't think it's unreasonable for laws to enforce some level of risk mitigation for consumers making purchases as significant as houses. But a line has to be drawn somewhere and I firmly believe that fining neighbors for having ugly cars in their driveway is far beyond any reasonable line.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by wizofaus on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @05:48PM (#34087408)
But if a politician gets elected with such a policy being a key election promise - i.e. indicating a majority of residents do agree there should be such a policy - is it still 'far beyond any reasonable line'? Why should you personally get to decide where the reasonable line is? (FWIW, I do actually agree with you, but your and my opinions are just that - opinions).
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by btilly on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:26PM (#34084409)
I value being able to do what I want with my house.

I'm willing to pay a premium for that value.

I am only willing to consider an HOA if it comes with a steep discount.

The more people there are out there who think like I do, the less it makes sense for people to try to tell their neighbors how to live.

Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by godshatter on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @01:59PM (#34084813)
If for example, a derelict car sitting on my property is causing them monetary distress because it's affecting their property values, I'd suggest they make me an offer for the car. Otherwise, I would advise them to leave my property. Their "investment" is not my worry.
Re:Repairing Your Car in Your Own Garage Is Considered Illeg... by tcmart14 on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:19PM (#34085114)
Thats my line of thinking. My property is my property and I will do what I damn well please on it. You don't like it? Sounds like a you problem and not a me problem.