News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by brundolf on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @08:48PM (#33979004)
The flipside is that it's a lottery. Steam is overflowing with new indie games every day, and many very good ones die in obscurity. You really have to get lucky and go viral

But yeah, the entry fee for that lottery is at a historic low, which is still great (especially for hobby devs who don't care about the rest!)

Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by spaceman_2020 on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @05:42AM (#33981924)
Lottery implies its entirely luck based.

When in reality, you have a great deal of control. Marketing IS something you can control.

Sure, some streamer randomly picking up your game is beyond your control. But you can certainly create conditions that would make it easier for your game to be picked up by a streamer (build relationships with journos, streamers; get paid marketing, etc.)

Calling it a lottery is a disservice to the people who actually put in effort to create these games.

Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by pms on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @08:40AM (#33983296)
> When in reality, you have a great deal of control. Marketing IS something you can control.

If every creator does marketing, then everyone is in the same position and nobody has control. Also, check out this research paper, published in Science, showing that popularity signals like the number of downloads and ordering by popularity increases the unpredictability of a music market, which is an opposite effect to what you expect. I suspect similar effects happen for game and other cultural markets:

Salganik, M. J., Dodds, P. S., & Watts, D. J. (2006). Experimental study of inequality and unpredictability in an artificial cultural market. Science (New York, N.Y.), 311(5762), 854–856. https://www.princeton.edu/~mjs3/salganik_dodds_watts06_full....

Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by rexreed on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @07:47AM (#33982749)
Here's what I learned in life that's applicable to many areas, this being one:

Not sucking isn't enough. Even being "Great" isn't enough. And even being "amazing" just isn't good enough to be successful. You need people to notice and care and help you and carry you to success. Mediocrity with a lot of public and positive reinforcement beats quiet greatness. Truly great things die every day from lack of attention and the willingness / motivation of others to help you carry that greatness forward. No greatness succeeds on its own, despite how great it might truly be.

Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by kcartlidge on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @04:21PM (#33990777)
> Mediocrity with a lot of public and positive reinforcement beats quiet greatness.

Great point.

Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by KronisLV on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @07:03AM (#33982399)
> Calling it a lottery is a disservice to the people who actually put in effort to create these games.

I think that both for simple and complex games there are those that nobody cares about and those that end up really popular. Sometimes it's about good marketing, sometimes it's about making what people actually want to play (instead of what you want to make), sometimes it's about developing it really well, other times it's just about being at the right place at the right time.

Those aren't mutually exclusive qualities, for certain titles you might need lots of one of them, or maybe a mix of all of them. In regards to what you actually need, it can indeed be a lottery and thinking that hard work (or marketing) is all that's necessary in ample amounts (or even is a pre-requisite) might be misleading, because it's not the full story.

For an example of how any mix of those aspects can lead to failure, look at the launch of Brigador, a well made game that was a flop: https://youtu.be/qUsuusNLxik

Then contrast that (years of development) with something like Vampire Survivors. Or maybe 2048, or Flappy Bird, or Wordle for examples of even simpler projects that were also easier to make, that still were immensely popular and much more successful.

Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by fragmede on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @06:39AM (#33982235)
Except that creating games and marketing games are two separate things, so calling it a lottery is an insult to marketers, and game developers would do well to recognize that simply building a game and not marketing it should be a conscious decision to shoot themselves in the foot.
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by ambrose2 on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @03:51AM (#33981378)
Eh, I have a friend who is incredibly talented and when their indie game became iPhone game of the year it couldn’t have been anyone else I knew, the guy was just that stellar. Definitely a combination of ability and persistence and a little luck.
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by mcherm on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @09:02AM (#33983557)
> The flipside is that it's a lottery. Steam is overflowing with new indie games every day, and many very good ones die in obscurity.

Sounds to me like an opportunity. There may be a demand for a service that reviews indie games and "discovers" (promotes) little-known-but-great ones. It even has an obvious revenue source: allowing advertising by games (so long as advertisements and promoted works are VERY CLEARLY separated).

Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by nosianu on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @09:17AM (#33983745)
You just shifted the problem to a different place. Now it is the reviewer who has to get big, and has to be able to meet the expectations of their audience - over a long period. There are tons of reviewer channels on Youtube and Twitch. I don't think becoming a big enough fish as a reviewer is any easier?
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by namrog84 on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @10:09AM (#33984454)
I personally don't think youtube or twitch is the right medium for a curated reviewer store system. It doesn't scale the right way.

You need to basically be an app store but do it better than original.

Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by markus_zhang on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @08:47AM (#33983383)
I think it's more than lottery. Skills, contents and marketing are all important aspects of game production. I wonder what is the chance of getting 1,000 sales for the Nth released non-free game. It won't feed the mouth but is a good start (to convince wife). Steam probably has the data.
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by htag on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @09:19PM (#33979207)
Is it a straight lottery (random chance), or does marketing play a role along with the game itself?
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by eslaught on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @01:00AM (#33980483)
Of course it's not just a lottery, it's a lottery weighted (at least to some degree) by a variety of factors like the game itself and the marketing you put into it.

The point I think people usually mean to make is that the odds are low (really, extremely low) so it's not really a prudent financial choice unless you have other ways to support yourself and don't care about potentially throwing away the time/effort if it doesn't work out.

Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by brundolf on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @11:19PM (#33979961)
Marketing definitely has an impact, even just social media stuff, but unless you've got a AAA-sized marketing budget there will still be a significant amount of chance involved
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by dleslie on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @09:43PM (#33979395)
It's all about getting picked up by an influencer of some kind, or going for the long haul with social connectivity.
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by BoorishBears on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @03:36AM (#33981294)
Marketing matters more than the game if you're an indie, and I don't say that in a cynical way.

Unfortunately I've seen so many people pour their hearts and souls into a game thinking they can just start marketing it when it's ready: You should be engaging with your future audience well before then.

You don't have to take money from them, you don't have to make empty promises, but in the current landscape you need people to be waiting for your game, not you waiting for players, because odds are they won't come.

For every lucky game that gets the right streamer there's 10 more that are truly great games that just never get traction and die.

Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by bowsamic on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @03:57AM (#33981416)
I don't think it's lottery. I think that we don't want to admit that most people are just bad at designing and developing games. I hang about on /r/gamedev and I've seen a lot of posts complaining about low sales and not a single one of those games was compelling
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by namrog84 on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @10:12AM (#33984505)
its hard to be critical. ive never seen a great game not do well. even games that might seem pretty not doing well if you look closely enough are often still missing something.

I challenge anyone to provide a link to an actual great indie game that hasnt done well. that flew under radar.

Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by doorstuck on Saturday December 17, 2022 @08:12AM (#34027476)
"Great" and "haven't done well" would be subjective, but here's my list of amazing games that are underperforming in sales: The Hex Eliza Suzerain Know by Heart (and all Ice Pick lodge games for that matter)
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by adamnemecek on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @09:16PM (#33979188)
Is it though? Show me a good Steam game that isn't selling well.
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by larsiusprime on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @12:53AM (#33980434)
Easy: Among Us, for the many months that it toiled in nearly complete obscurity to the point of the development team nearly giving up the ghost and quitting, until one specific streamer picked it up and gave it the critical mass attention it needed to go absolutely huge. Had the developers had slightly less resources and shut down the servers before that crucial moment it would have never happened, even though clearly Among Us is a fantastic game in retrospect.

Quality is necessary but not sufficient for success.

Also: a while back, I wanted to empirically test the "any good game will succeed on steam, and if it doesn't succeed, it isn't a good game" hypothesis by setting up a little metagame called "Steam Prophet". We would track upcoming steam games and try to predict which ones would succeed BEFORE they came out. We eventually disbanded the project when we got so reliably good (but not perfect) at predictions that we got bored and quit. Turns out that just a few leading metrics were incredibly predictive of day 1 (and thus day 30, day 60, and day 90, and year 1) success -- chiefly the number of followers the game had on Steam on launch day. It is a rare game indeed that can succeed on Steam without first having banked tons of high quality wishlists (of which followers is a public proxy metric for).

The spirit of Steam Prophet lives on today in the form of Simon Carless' Game Discover Co newsletter, which obsessively follows upcoming and newly released Steam Games: https://gamediscover.co/

Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by Mikeb85 on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @02:09AM (#33980863)
The problem with Among Us is that it's an online game. Meaning you need a certain amount of actual people playing it before it's fun. So it's a chicken or egg problem; it's not fun without players, players won't join if it's not fun.

Most good single player games do well.

Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by anon84873628 on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @03:19AM (#33981199)
In other words it's a game dependent on network effects, which definitely makes for an uphill battle. You _have_ to go viral.
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by spaceman_2020 on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @05:51AM (#33981977)
What was Among Us' marketing strategy like?

Most developers have very little understanding of marketing, and are very hesitatnt to pay for good marketing services.

Here's something most people won't tell you: the majority of online marketing is paid, either explicitly (i.e. you pay Google) or covertly (i.e. you "bribe" an editor at Forbes to feature your article).

Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by kibbi on Thursday December 15, 2022 @10:03PM (#34009326)
If you got that good at predictions, doesn't that show that for most games, it's usually not a lottery at all?

Aside from rare cases like Flappy Bird, and aside from the usual vagaries of commercial, technological and artistic projects. And aside from special challenges like the minimum playerbase size required for an online game like Among Us.

During development, developers could set up a Steam page, release one or two trailers as soon as possible (with mocked-up gameplay if necessary), and try to predict the audience's interest by the increase of followers/wishlists (compared to other games). In case of a lukewarm reception, they could decide to drop this game and start developing another one.

Did you write about the leading metrics and your insights somewhere, aside from this article, which seems to be from the beginning of your "Steam Prophet" project?

https://www.gamedeveloper.com/business/what-i-learned-playin...

Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by stolenmerch on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @09:57PM (#33979483)
That's difficult to evaluate since "good" is subjective. So is "selling well", to be honest. I assume you mean a game that is reasonably finished and polished and not simply shovelware, but still not getting the sales to be profitable. There are tons. 30 games drop on Steam everyday. Just sort by new and see all the games that any little indie studio would be proud to release but have few sales.
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by ancapsfascists on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @10:32PM (#33979688)
Hellion.
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by cridenour on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @12:51AM (#33980420)
This game?

https://store.steampowered.com/app/588210/HELLION/

Looks like it sold incredibly well and was abandoned by the developers and is no longer for sale.

A weird example.

Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by ancapsfascists on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @02:13AM (#33980884)
It failed to sell well enough to recoup expenses.
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by 0xRolex on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @11:03AM (#33985432)
It IS subjective. For a game of its kind it can have sold realy well yet not have sold enough to make up for a poor management and way too big of a debt. It wouldn't change the reality of "it sold well" but still validate "it didn't sell well enough"
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by mach1ne on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @09:21AM (#33983806)
4,000 reviews suggests sales numbers of 400,000, which is huge.
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by ancapsfascists on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @10:21AM (#33984665)
They sent out a notification that development had stopped, but they were still selling the game for half price. This resulted in huge review bombing.
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by MichaelZuo on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @10:44AM (#33985062)
Even 40 000 sales is still decent for an indie game?
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @07:56AM (#33982809)
I've seen many. Wuppo didn't sell well until it was called out by an algorithm as the most underrated game on Steam or something like that. Of course, "good" is very subjective. I personally don't think the most popular games are any good.
Re:After 20 years the Dwarf Fortress devs have to get used t... by glonq on Wednesday December 14, 2022 @02:35PM (#33988916)
Every time I see a new-ish game released for free on the epic games store or indiegala, I think "bummer, I guess it's still mac and cheese in mom's basement for these guys.