News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by johnthuss on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:49PM (#33926809)
"Drivers sits in the middle. This makes overtaking or looking ahead more difficult. But also makes it impossible to reach out of the window to pass the paperwork or to talk with the guy in the gatehouse when you enter a port or a factory or, say, a tollbooth."

This one seems like the worst one of all these criticisms.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by function_seven on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:53PM (#33926859)
My guess is that they needed to get the drag coefficient down, and did so by first raking the windshield back, then pinching the cab horizontally to get some more gains. That narrowing of the cab then led to the center-seat arrangement?

Bonus being that you don't need to configure a LHD and RHD version of this truck for different markets.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by three_seagrass on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:06PM (#33926988)
LHD/RHD swamp doesn't really matter given that the truck is probably too long for UK.

They would still need to swap out headlights anyways.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by potatochup on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:18PM (#33927138)
It's possible to have that same hardware headlight and control distribution patterns/behavior in software
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by zizee on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:48PM (#33927456)
UK is not the only country to drive on the left of the road, including Australia, India, Indonesia, and Japan.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Left-_and_right-hand_traffic

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by debesyla on Friday December 09, 2022 @08:23PM (#33928779)
...and it's unlikely that Tesla truck would be a popular choice in these countries.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by fomine3 on Friday December 09, 2022 @08:50PM (#33928953)
It may be too big also for Japan, so maybe fine only for Australia?
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by eastbound on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:03PM (#33926951)
Different markets can’t be addressed with the same truck anyway. Lights are different, mandatory equipment is different, EU trucks are limited cabin-inclusive, US trucks are cabin-exclusive, etc.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by adwww on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:07PM (#33927007)
Lots and lots of LHD trucks serve the UK making daily cross channel trips, or even just based here full time from Dutch / Eastern European shipping firms.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by ceejayoz on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:16PM (#33927771)
The UK was until very recently part of the same market, with no reason to change all their truck design rules after Brexit.

The US/Europe scenario is not the same.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by kelnos on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:09PM (#33927688)
This truck still appears to have a passenger seat on the right side, though, despite the driver being in the middle? So presumably they'd still have to reconfigure it for RHD.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by MBCook on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:25PM (#33927208)
Efficiency seemed like the reason for the tilted windshield too.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by belval on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:59PM (#33926909)
Indeed, I wonder if they will be able to address this fast enough because it does seem serious. Same goes for the mirrors that are out of reach of the driver for easy cleaning. It could be a pain point.

I guess the author wanted the pile-on a bit, but the rest feels a bit more like "this isn't how we are currently doing it so it's just wrong", especially when it comes to the shape of the truck. Being aerodynamic seems like a good way to increase the range.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by nine_k on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:51PM (#33927495)
Mirrors this big can have sweepers, like the windshield.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by danparsonson on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:00PM (#33927584)
Which can still freeze or gunk up, especially when regularly travelling tens of thousands of kilometres.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by labcomputer on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:16PM (#33927770)
> I guess the author wanted the pile-on a bit, but the rest feels a bit more like "this isn't how we are currently doing it so it's just wrong", especially when it comes to the shape of the truck.

I got that impression, too, but in more ways.

1. The interior shots I've seen show blind spot cameras (on the tablets that he doesn't like). That seems like it would address the problem with visibility from the center driver position, and probably goes a long way to addressing the mirror-cleaning issue he mentioned.

2. Why couldn't Tesla just have a little wiper-fluid squirter on each mirror to clean it off remotely? (and do we know they don't already have that?)

3. Tesla already coats their glass roofs with something that blocks lots of IR and UV, but little visible light (and makes the roof of older Teslas a very strange color when viewed from outside). I would assume they are aware of the HVAC issue and apply a similar treatment to the Semi windscreen.

Tesla has been testing these things for like 5 years now, and the Semis have been seen at Pepsi warehouses for about a year. It seems unlikely that Pepsi would take delivery of a truck with such obviously fatal flaws after a year of acceptance tests... so I bet there are mitigations for most or all of the issues identified.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by ortusdux on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:09PM (#33927032)
I wonder how this cab design would affect interactions with the police. I did not realize that you enter via a corridor behind the driver seat. US officers do not respond well to people getting out of the vehicle during stops.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by mediaman on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:23PM (#33927189)
True, but I don't think police are as worried about long-haul truckers behaving well, versus someone in a civilian car. The trucker needs to keep their CDL, and they do trucking professionally.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by sudosysgen on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:05PM (#33927649)
I can assure you from personal experience there are plenty of truckers that don't act that way (they are minority but a sizeable one).
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by mediaman on Friday December 09, 2022 @07:09PM (#33928219)
Fair enough, from customer complaints I've probably hired one or two of them for deliveries...
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by avree on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:50PM (#33928089)
It's still got windows. Why would someone need to leave the vehicle to interact with police? I must be missing something.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by LegitShady on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:45PM (#33928052)
ya maybe we should check with the police before doing anything. Or not.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by NikolaNovak on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:58PM (#33926894)
As in, the most damning, or the least relevant?
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by jjulius on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:02PM (#33926938)
Most damning. The driver being able to easily lean out the window to talk to people as it passes tolls, inspection points, hell, weigh stations, is important. That all of these engineers and designers massively overlooked such a vital component of truck driving out of Tesla's own hubris is hilariously embarrassing, IMO.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by reaperducer on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:03PM (#33927611)
inspection points, hell, weigh stations, is important.

FWIW, a lot of US weigh stations are automated now.

I know very little about it, but from what I've observed, it seems that the truck drives through, and the information is transmitted from the truck to the station, and computers handle fuel tax and that sort of thing.

I don't know if this is the future, or how widespread it is, but it's at least a step in the right direction.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by macspoofing on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:29PM (#33927252)
> We can only assume they overlooked it.

I don’t think they overlooked it. I think they designed the cab to be as aerodynamic as possible, so as to squeeze out every bit of range they could … and this dictated the driver position.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by jonathankoren on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:49PM (#33927469)
So ignored key usability requirements for an arbitrary product management goal. :thumbs-up:
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by macspoofing on Friday December 09, 2022 @10:50PM (#33929703)
I think it’s more that this truck is at the edge of viability as a long haul commercial vehicle. They don’t do things like this, and this truck doesn’t exist.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by jonathankoren on Saturday December 10, 2022 @01:35AM (#33930480)
Then it shouldn’t exist.

If you want an electric semi that doesn’t suck, get a Freightliner eCascadia.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by macspoofing on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @02:55PM (#33974778)
OK - I'm personally not really torn up about it. Either this truck is viable in the market, or it isn't. If it isn't, then it won't do well.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by nine_k on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:55PM (#33927534)
A microphone and a speaker allows customers to talk to bank clerks sitting far behind thick bulletproof glass. They could implement that on a truck.

Handing papers over is harder, but I wonder if making a small window that can be opened would be really hard. The driver would need to stand up, though.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by manmal on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:40PM (#33928008)
The Semi should ship with a trash grabber to hand over papers with. It could even have the microphone built in, just point it at the checkpoint clerk.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by microtherion on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:25PM (#33927860)
Just ship an Optimus along with the truck so it can walk out with the papers and hand them over. Problem solved, more profits!
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by mortehu on Friday December 09, 2022 @07:54PM (#33928549)
How much do you think the total absence of engine noise compensates for the additional distance? Also there could be less attenuation inside the cab if there aren't many soft surfaces to absorb the sound.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by simondotau on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:12PM (#33927060)
We can only assume they overlooked it. The opinion of someone who has actually driven a Tesla Semi through a weigh station would be infinitely more relevant than anything you, I or the OP have to say.

And like most things, it's going to be a series of trade-offs. Perhaps they decided that in a big picture analysis, the disadvantages are fewer than the advantages.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by jjulius on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:19PM (#33927143)
>The opinion of someone who has actually driven a Tesla Semi through a weigh station would be infinitely more relevant than anything you, I or the OP have to say.

Thank you for quickly dismissing the opinion of someone who has experience driving semi-trucks and currently works adjacent to that industry, interacting with truck drivers on a daily basis.

I see a massive, massive flaw in this design based on my own experience but, "Nope, shut up, you haven't driven the new one, your opinion is invalid". Got it.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by simondotau on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:34PM (#33927298)
I didn't say shut up, and I didn't say your opinion is invalid. Your opinion is valid. Please stop putting words in my mouth. All I'm saying is I don't feel there's a need to come to any conclusions about the design until we've had feedback from people who have actually used the product in the real world. I can't believe anyone would consider this an unreasonable stance.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by turmeric_root on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:01PM (#33927599)
> The opinion of someone who has actually driven a Tesla Semi through a weigh station would be infinitely more relevant than anything you, I or the OP have to say.

---

> I didn't say shut up, and I didn't say your opinion is invalid. Your opinion is valid.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by simondotau on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:17PM (#33927790)
Yes, that's what I said. Do I seriously need to explain words?
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by NegativeK on Friday December 09, 2022 @07:18PM (#33928288)
I think you need to reexamine the phrasing you're using, because it's coming off as extremely dismissive of people with significant knowledge of the industry.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by meragrin_ on Friday December 09, 2022 @07:33PM (#33928405)
> it's coming off as extremely dismissive of people with significant knowledge of the industry.

Nah, it's coming off as dismissive of people who haven't used a product.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by turmeric_root on Friday December 09, 2022 @07:21PM (#33928310)
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by Alupis on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:18PM (#33927130)
If you want industry buy-in, you generally need the industry to be on-board with what you are doing.

Building some product in a dark warehouse, then thrusting it onto the industry is a recipe for rejection and failure.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by newsclues on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:22PM (#33927177)
All of these factors can have the infrastructure updated to the 21st century. We don't need coins for tolls, or paperwork.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by mediaman on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:27PM (#33927237)
That's hilarious. Okay, go tell every warehouse and factory with a loading dock out there that their systems are out of date and they need to use RFID for everything. And if they don't -- well, we won't send this truck to your facility!

A little bit of humility when it comes to appreciating how sectors of the economy you have zero experience with would go a long way.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by labcomputer on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:39PM (#33927355)
Maybe, but trucking is a low-margin industry. If the "fuel" savings are even half as big as Tesla claims, there is going to be a strong incentive to switch to this truck.

Suddenly, the warehouses that refuse to switch are paying more for shipping via ICE truck... that is their choice of course, but I don't want to hear any whining about how unfair it is.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by rsynnott on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:43PM (#33927397)
That only really works if Tesla has a monopoly on electric trucks, though. They do not.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by newsclues on Saturday December 10, 2022 @02:58PM (#33936205)
It's not that I don't understand the challenge of changing not just infrastructure but the way people do things, but it can be done.

Either climate change is a real problem and society is going to have to fundamentally shift and do lots of little things like change how warehouses and factory loading docks work for increased efficiency. Don't you think these challenges will be solved before we have robo trucks on the roads, which will need the same changes?

I wasn't a trucker, but I did do LTL shipping in addition to FedEx, so I've signed enough manifests to know that having a good excuse to update the industry wouldn't be resisted as much as you think, because the costs would pay for themselves eventually.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by rsynnott on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:42PM (#33927385)
"This design is fine provided that you change all the infrastructure in the world" isn't a _great_ argument, honestly.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by jjulius on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:28PM (#33927242)
Coins and paperwork will not be gone by the time this truck is on the market, just as coins and paperwork aren't the only reasons the seat placement is flawed.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by Alupis on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:04PM (#33926960)
The most damning in that they obviously didn't consult any real truck drivers or truck manufacturing companies to figure out why things are the way they are, before setting out to try improving them.

We see this a lot with smart inexperienced developers taking on entire industries with hopes of "disruption" - but lack even the most basic understanding of that industry and it's problems. The hubris necessary to assume everyone in the industry are dumb and just haven't thought about these novel improvements is very high...

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by jsight on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:24PM (#33927193)
The project was originally lead by the former lead of the Cascadia program.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by Alupis on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:59PM (#33927575)
Perhaps you are talking about Feightliner's eCascadia truck? If so, I think we're only making this case stronger. The eCascadia is a traditional semi, but electric and technology improvements here and there. It's not a "throw everything out and start from scratch" thing. Perhaps there's a reason he is the former lead...

The Tesla Semi is a fantasy semi that no one asked for and I suspect no one will buy. There's plenty of electric semi's already available...

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by jsight on Friday December 09, 2022 @07:56PM (#33928559)
I'm not sure that I understand your point here. He was there for the Cascadia program almost 20 years ago. It had plenty of problems on its own, but I don't think there's doubt that he worked with a traditional trucking company. They had plenty of relevant experience on hand.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by Alupis on Friday December 09, 2022 @08:12PM (#33928682)
You should probably be more clear in what specifically you are talking about. Names and links would be helpful...

Regardless, just because he was part of some team at some truck manufacturer doesn't mean he knows what he's doing. The Tesla Semi isn't a "Trucker's Truck" by any stretch of the imagination. It was designed to look cool and get good PR...

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by MisterTea on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:16PM (#33927774)
I'd say one of the worst things about this truck is you cant bail out of the thing as the door is behind the seat. Ever see that video where the tow truck driver bails out after the truck he is towing slides off the icy road and down a steep hill and takes the tow truck with it? You don't have time to walk around the seat.

The driver sitting in the middle makes it clear no on at Tesla ever drove a truck. I have and the driver sitting in the middle does will not help with visibility. You want to be able to stick your head out and look right down the side of the truck. This is important as you cant see everything from the mirrors and in addition they can be broken, missing, iced up, fogged, etc. Same with cameras in case you thought they are solutions.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by three_seagrass on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:59PM (#33926908)
I dunno. I get annoyed just having to unbuckle and get out of my seat for parking tickets that are out of reach.

I can't imagine having to do repeatedly do this while maneuvering a big rig around a stockyard. Or did you mean it was one of the most valid criticisms?

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by Simon_O_Rourke on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:13PM (#33927073)
I highly doubt it, but unless it's some crafty scheme to sell the same cabs to both the UK/Australia/Japan and the USA without modification.

Doubt it though, the simplest explanation in this case is probably design ignorance.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by KaiserPro on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:08PM (#33927017)
Its not a problem in the states, but in the EU/country with cyclists, you'll never see the 20/30 of them that are sneaking down the inside of you at a junction.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by eecc on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:13PM (#33927741)
Look, here in the EU we have plenty cyclists getting killed daily by trucks of the current “benchmark” design. Just the other week https://www.adnkronos.com/e-morto-davide-rebellin-ex-ciclist... so meh, these arguments about dead spots are just pearl clutching. The truck has more cameras than a bank, it’ll probably do better than what we have today
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by feifan on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:14PM (#33927090)
The displays have downward-facing cameras covering what looks like the blind spots next to the cab
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by TheLoafOfBread on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:04PM (#33927638)
A narrowing tool fixing what bending tool has screwed up...
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by feifan on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:29PM (#33927901)
I understand and partly agree with your sentiment, but "offsetting" technologies/components are all over the place. E.g. combustion engines also need mufflers, catalytic converters, etc.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by bamboozled on Friday December 09, 2022 @07:14PM (#33928261)
It's because in the future, you won't talk to anyone, it will be Teslsa botz doing everything! Duh?
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by JustSomeNobody on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:11PM (#33927056)
It's almost as if Musk and his "designers" have never seen a weigh/inspection station.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by pastor_bob on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:00PM (#33926925)
Do these front windows even roll down? Might be a moot point
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by rightbyte on Friday December 09, 2022 @07:05PM (#33928203)
Ye. Looking around the corner when cornering is the main problem with centre seat. Not opening gates with a keypad.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by raldi on Friday December 09, 2022 @04:56PM (#33926876)
Worst as in most salient or least?
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by meragrin_ on Friday December 09, 2022 @07:42PM (#33928464)
> "Drivers sits in the middle. This makes overtaking or looking ahead more difficult.

> This one seems like the worst one of all these criticisms.

Seems like it would be a feature if the driver couldn't see over cars and trucks. Maybe they would actually keep to a safer distance.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by lamontcg on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:18PM (#33927127)
> This one seems like the worst one of all these criticisms.

Weird that so many people can't figure out what was meant here.

I know the literal English is ambiguous but it should be obvious what was the intended reading.

Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by newsclues on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:21PM (#33927164)
Good, we can go paperless and minimize human contact and viral exposure with digital paperwork and authorization systems and intercoms. No need to roll down the windows and let the climate controlled air get dirty and hot/cold.
Re:The Tesla Semi cab from the practical POV of someone who ... by greedo on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:35PM (#33927313)
You do realize that there are literally thousands of weigh stations in the US that would need to be upgraded? They're run individually by the states, who will have minimal incentive to cooperate.