News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by markus_zhang on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:34PM (#33889658)
I have been constantly harrased by accounts with pretty girl pictures on LinkedIn, wish they could do something.

Why did I know they are fake?

One, I'm not handsome, neither do I work in those high status companies, why did they reach out to me?

Two, they look more like models than software engineers. Completely bullshit.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by IIAOPSW on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:58PM (#33890145)
Lets face it. The "pretty girl profile" strategy works on a wide enough fraction of men that with probability close to 1 you can establish a legit connection to at least a few legit people at the company. Once you get that far, you can start getting recommendations for other people you "might know" and have enough of an "in" to get a glimpse at the entire org chart of the place. From there your a short jump away from being added to internal slack channels and whatever.

Not that I've ever done this. I always respect and obey the computer fraud and abuse act of 1986 vis a vis the section on unauthorized access to a computer system.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by EdwardDiego on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:17PM (#33890253)
Back in the MySpace (Bebo also maybe?) days, I met a programmer who harvested womens' profile pictures from social media for the AdultFriendFinder.com adverts on porn sites.

He didn't consider it unethical because "you'd have to be really really stupid to think that women are posting their face on a site like AFF".

I kinda thought exploiting the really stupid was still unethical, but his response was given that I worked in adtech, I wasn't really in a place to judge.

Which was hard to argue against, tbh, as I spent a lot of my time then either making popunders work again after Firefox released a new version that broke our old approach, or figuring out how to store our tracking data better.

But now that I've got a few years between me and adtech, I'm totally going to judge you hard, eug1505.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by flooo on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:53PM (#33890448)
How about the women whose profile pics he “harvested” (stole)?

Isn’t there a huge ethical issue there?

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by bee_rider on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @12:06AM (#33890812)
I think so.

> But now that I've got a few years between me and adtech, I'm totally going to judge you hard, eug1505.

I don’t want to put words in the other dude’s mouth, but I think he thinks so too.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by EdwardDiego on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:23PM (#33916596)
Fair point, I was focused more on the fraud aspect of it so didn't think of that.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by jfoster on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @06:31AM (#33893203)
How is it a "short jump" from being connected to a few people on LinkedIn, to then being added to internal slack channels? It's not impossible, but it seems like quite a leap.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by teux on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @07:24AM (#33893529)
> Two, they look more like models than software engineers. Completely bullshit.

Can I push back against this? It’s toxic as fuck. Being a woman in tech blows. You can’t be pretty or you’re considered incompetent and shallow. You can’t be ugly or you’re treated poorly for that.

It’s a loose-loose.

What does a software engineer look like to you, then?

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by edanm on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @10:32AM (#33895497)
Despite you getting some bad feedback on this comment, I think you're right and I bumped on that phrase too.

This reminds me of a billboard campaign to hire developers that ran a few years ago, and featured a few SEs, including one woman considered attractive. A lot of people said things along the lines of "this isn't what a real SE looks like", along with many... less nice things. Of course, she actually was a full stack engineer at that company. This prompted her to start a campaign (#ILookLikeAnEngineer). For more details read her blog: https://medium.com/the-coffeelicious/you-may-have-seen-my-fa...

Note to some commenters: I'm not saying that you can't tell a fake profile from a not fake profile. I'm saying that a sentence like "they look more like models than software engineers" is implicitly hinting that software engineers are not attractive females. That's the objection that I believe teux was raising, and it's a valid one.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by BlargMcLarg on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @01:42PM (#33898317)
You and GP both need to take a step back and consider the context since both of you seem to conveniently forget one very important thing: why would anyone get harrassed by software developers on LinkedIn as just another workerbee? Now multiply that by whatever factor you believe a software developer is a gorgeous woman. Maybe now it makes sense why people are skeptical.

With your line of reasoning, people would be defending phishing emails because "some representatives have bad grammar skills". Think of how lubricous that would be in a discussion on phishing.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by edanm on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @03:43PM (#33899950)
To clarify, I totally understand the context.

I'm specifically saying that saying a phrase like "they don't look like software developers" just because they're good looking women is in itself a bad (and false!) meme to circulate, which in itself is a bad thing, regardless of context.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by teux on Thursday December 08, 2022 @08:38AM (#33907739)
Yeah. That’s all I was trying to say. I’m not speaking about anything related to shitty recruiters, how hard it is to be a man online (??), or how much it sucks to be the target of sex-based scams.

Just. Saying it sucks to be a woman in tech and statements and sentiments like this are part of the reason why.

Still no one answered my question: “What does a software engineer look like then?”

I think it was a combination of me being not explicit enough and touching on an obviously sore subject for others. But I don’t have the energy to unravel it or debate.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by 3pt14159 on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @07:36AM (#33893619)
Are you a woman in tech?

The reason that I ask is that your account is pretty new and this seems a little bit like stowing up discord on social media.

Regardless. There is a difference between a beautiful woman that can code (these are actually getting more and more prevalent) and the trashy looking profile picture that all of us instantly know is some kind of spammer or scammer in our DMs or our inbox.

The fact that they're portrayed as woman has more to do with the loneliness of many men in tech than anything else and pretending that this type of behaviour is non-existent is childish when it's clear that places like LinkedIn and Twitter could do a lot more to detect it and prevent it.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by teux on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @08:16AM (#33893986)
Yes? I just migrated from reddit.

Read my comments. I have been discussing my job in Europe and my work with vectorised optimisations.

Seems like a lot of work for sowing discord, but you make the call.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by 3pt14159 on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @08:43AM (#33894219)
Well I'll take you at your word then. Be aware that new accounts or accounts without much comment history are treated with more suspicion on HN when they discuss hot button issues like gender or politics.

> It’s toxic as fuck. Being a woman in tech blows. You can’t be pretty or you’re considered incompetent and shallow. You can’t be ugly or you’re treated poorly for that.

One of the best programmers I've ever worked with was a woman. Former Google. I'd prefer not to discuss how attractive she is because it doesn't matter to me. I'm sorry you're having a rough time in Scandinavia and, from your comment history, formerly the USA. I've worked with non-aggressive teams from different places, but I've also observed women being mistreated in both Canada and the USA as well.

That said, I've seen ASD men mistreated as well. Unfortunately there are jerks out there and we can all try to do better.

[dead]
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by dang on Thursday December 08, 2022 @07:46PM (#33915963)
Hey, please don't be a jerk to newcomers, even if they're not following the rules yet. We don't want HN to be that kind of place.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by mnky9800n on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @07:31AM (#33893588)
can i push back on that? as a guy, girls texting you randomly on any platform is almost always a bot, scammer, <insert something other than what it appears to be>.

i completely agree with you, a software engineer looks like a person who writes software. but that doesn't change the online experience that i have had as a man, which is namely, if a girl texts you, she's not a girl, and she certainly isn't your friend.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by BlargMcLarg on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @07:37AM (#33893628)
The average woman is fairly well treated and not at all like the average LinkedIn stalker, let alone a model. You're trying to bridge two related but different contexts
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by xwolfi on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @07:52AM (#33893753)
ok but do you really need to look like a model on Linkedin ? You can be pretty, but is being ultra sexy really that important there ?

He didnt say they were random girls like we meet every day, he said model. When men contact me on linkedin for insurance products and they look like Calvin Klein underweare models, Im like "hum" too.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by markus_zhang on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @02:46PM (#33899246)
Yes you can push back.

Of course woman in tech can be pretty. Grace Hopper is 100x more pretty than any model in the world.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by commandlinefan on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @01:41PM (#33898303)
> You can’t be pretty or you’re considered incompetent and shallow

That's not a gendered stereotype, though, that's all technology people.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by dijit on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:55PM (#33890129)
I have noticed that a lot of tech recruiters are conventionally attractive women.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @02:16AM (#33891581)
Because sex sells. Where you not aware of this by now? This has been proven to death by now.

And by sex I don't mean the copulation act, but just seeing very handsome and attractive people that trigger your primal mating desires, works in advertising when trying to convince people to buy something from you or give you something (a product, a service, an idea, their time, their money, their attention, their assistance, etc.)

It's why many recruiters, especially in tech, tend to be the attractive female type as it works well enough on the majority male demographic this career attracts.

And why most successful sales people, and to a large degree, managers who managed to climb 'the ladder', tend to be on the tall, athletic, attractive side.

This is completely anecdotal, but I've never ever seen conventionally short males in upper management in any company I worked at so far. It's as if it was a 'jocks club' and you needed the right physique to join.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by karmakurtisaani on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @02:55AM (#33891806)
A funny observation: I've had the best response rate and relationships with recruiters who are regular looking men. The attractive female recruiters mostly just send a message with the job info, but completely bail when you ask for a salary range and remote work policy. Maybe they get such a large number of replies that they don't need to bother with the ones asking difficult questions.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by texasbigdata on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @04:37AM (#33892424)
There was an academic paper about this recently; we’re aware of “Asian” as a bias but not “physically attractive” and disproportionately favor the more pleasing individuals.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @06:30AM (#33893200)
What's the "Asian" bias? That sounds like an US thing.

It it the stereotype that Asians are good at STEM?

[dead]
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by jollofricepeas on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:12PM (#33890541)
Whoa there buddy.

Your statement is both downright offensive and untrue.

1. Great recruiters work long hours around others’ schedules

2. Recruiters deal with tons of rejection that most developers don’t have the stomach for

3. Female recruiters are often overworked, harassed, mansplained to and disrespected in our industry as they deal with fragile male egos, imposter syndrome, interview anxiety, etc

To build a real career as a realtor or recruiter requires perseverance in the face of rejection, work and networking skills. They are worthy of our respect.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by csomar on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:30PM (#33890636)
Are you sure we are getting contacted by the same recruiters? I'm pretty sure most recruiters are not like that; and we would be better without them. Recruiters exists because companies wants to save on $$ (it would make more sense to let developers do the recruiting, and not someone with no technical knowledge). Of course, this has the opposite result which is why the hiring market is such a sh*t-show.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by Consultant32452 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:58PM (#33890774)
I'm a whore and the recruiters are my pimps. They only like me because the johns hire me. The world makes more sense through that lens.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by dijit on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @12:09AM (#33890828)
This whole thread is shameful.

Recruiters do a valuable job; I don't pity them and I do not envy them.

The number of bad recruiters I've interacted with are high, but that's largely selection bias: the ones that reach me are not paying attention enough to realise that I'm not going to move.

I've worked closely with recruiters and their job is tiring and thankless; in the end though they can go home peacefully and it's easier to plan their day.

I can't speak to the reason I noticed this phenomena (of conventionally attractive women being overrepresented in recruiting), but I could believe that it's possible that men are more likely to respond to pretty women reaching out to them with kind words and making them feel wanted and valued; thus conventionally attractive women tend to be more successful in the industry, and thus we sort of have some kind of survivorship bias at play.

I don't know if that's true, but I could believe it quite comfortably.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by Consultant32452 on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @11:20AM (#33896178)
Pimps serve a purpose. Sometimes they are good and hook me up with johns so I make good money. Sometimes they protect me from bad johns. Sometimes they abuse me by sending me to johns they know will hurt me and then take all the money.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by nigerianbrince on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @01:18AM (#33891238)
I know it's against the guidelines but:

bruh

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by MikePlacid on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @12:12AM (#33890850)
My son worked as a summer job at a small recruiting setup in Silicon Valley. He was actually doing the interviews.

- Oh, but doesn't it require a lot of technical knowledge?

- Not exactly, we are just checking a) if he has at least 5 years of experience, b) that he graduated from one of the top 10 schools.

>perseverance in the face of rejection

The only rejection this company was facing was when their software pipeline for dumping resumes at Google and others was broken for a week. So no money was incoming.

- Oh, I can look at it if they want.

- See, this thing is written by a friend of the owner. They live at the same dorm room, actually. So it's politically incorrect for me to even suggest that something is wrong.

And so they persevered, indeed.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by dehrmann on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:45PM (#33890410)
> they look more like models than software engineers

I worked with someone (she was on the sales team) who looked like a model. Her mom was a model--go figure. So while unlikely, it does happen.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by stevenwoo on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @01:23AM (#33891267)
I remember filtering programmer resumes about 20 years ago and one listed modelling as a prior job and her packet included a headshot. We flew her out and interviewed her and she aced the written test and interviews; we made her an offer but she had multiple to choose from and our starting salary was not competitive.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @04:02AM (#33892212)
> one listed modelling as a prior job

We had the near opposite experience. We were looking to hire a "Modelling and simulation developer" for Matlab. And some ladies would somehow only see the "modelling experience desired" part and ignore the other technical requirements and flood us with their portfolios of various photo shoots.

I'm sure the hiring guys hated it.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by stevenwoo on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @10:48AM (#33895703)
I distinctly remember thinking - this is odd, but whatever, we had to look at so many resumes we had to concentrate on looking at grades and outside projects and anything else to distinguish between candidates to get to the phone screen stage, it was just me and a senior producer (might be called product manager nowadays), I cannot remember everything but we were looking at new grads for a couple of years to expand a little.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by kbelder on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @01:58PM (#33898582)
Reminds me of an incident twenty+ years ago when a magazine looking to recruit models temporarily rented office space above the local comic book shop.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by 998244353 on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @09:39AM (#33894788)
Sounds like people applying to thousands of positions based on only keywords to stay competitive.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by jwhiles on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @07:11AM (#33893434)
If you work at somewhat prestigious companies, you've probably worked with ex or part time models. Not many people make enough money off of modelling that they won't need another career, but being model material makes everything else in life, such as job interviews, easier.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by mbg721 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:39PM (#33889703)
Those are just the auditors; the audit firms send charismatic and attractive people around so that the people whose work they're checking will let their guard down.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by markus_zhang on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:50PM (#33889784)
Not really, the title is usually something like a tech consultant with completely BS educational and career experience. But I do agree it could be red team but they are annoying as hell. Actually lemme show you one:

https://www.linkedin.com/mwlite/in/ellie-fang-411900257

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by papercrane on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:57PM (#33890140)
That headshot is of a Taiwanese actress. You'd think they'd at least use a more believable headshot.

https://ent.ltn.com.tw/news/breakingnews/2357875

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by 998244353 on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @02:51AM (#33891775)
One common explanation to such things is that it is a filter: if a person doesn't notice something like that, there's a good chance they won't become suspicious later either.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by winReInstall on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @05:40AM (#33892830)
Low effort pig butchering scams for lonely workaholics..
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by maerF0x0 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:44PM (#33889743)
Also pen test teams will use halo effect when it's an option.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by cwkoss on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:00PM (#33889835)
Linkedin+Glassdoor lets you target marks based on approximate salary.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by markus_zhang on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:03PM (#33889850)
Oh that's nice to know...but to what end?
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by pixl97 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:08PM (#33889893)
So you don't waste time targeting the poors?
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @02:34AM (#33891658)
Bingo. For example, if you watch Youtube from a very poor country, you might not see any ads.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by checkyoursudo on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @06:15AM (#33893077)
"Buy our vpn service in $low_income_country and ditch your youtube subscription!" arbitrage opportunity for someone?
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by dmurray on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @08:16AM (#33893983)
This is definitely going on already.

Here's a VPN company advertising "a VPN server located in a region that offers cheaper games, in-app purchases, products, etc." and if other VPN providers don't explicitly advertise this benefit, they know some of their customers are using their product for that reason.

https://www.vpnunlimited.com/help/solutions/saving-with-regi...

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by cwkoss on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:09PM (#33889897)
I'd imagine they're trying to monetize your eyeballs in all of the ways spam usually does: mostly scams and advertising.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by dopidopHN on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @07:29AM (#33893575)
One of my coworker looks like a barbie doll. Also for some reason she looks 30 when she’s mid 40.

She also really, really good at her job.

Her profile on LinkedIn looks like what you describe.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by danwee on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @06:49AM (#33893315)
You mean female recruiters? For some reason, all the female recruiters I know (on Linkedin) are rather attractive. Maybe there is some logic behind it.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by walthamstow on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @07:48AM (#33893710)
My brother and his girlfriend are tech recruiters here in London.

They are both very conventionally attractive people, but it's not their image that makes them good at their jobs per se, IMO it's having the confidence and charm of a person who has gone through life always being attractive.

If a less attractive person had that confidence, charm, charisma, whatever you call it - and some do - they would also be successful.

Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by danwee on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @08:26AM (#33894065)
I wasn't talking about been successfull or not, but I agree with your statement indeed.
Re:Beware of the perfect gentleman by walthamstow on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @09:45AM (#33894865)
Ah, yes, apologies, I had merged your post with another sibling post in my head