News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by rvz on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:12AM (#33878482)
One may suggest to 'learn to code', but it is not enough this time.

Perhaps now one may say, it is time to 'learn to adapt', since with the recent release of ChatGPT now gives the excuse for managers to be more motivated to hire less engineers and programmers as the cheap money has essentially evaporated.

So this time it is indeed different and I would expect less engineers to be hired and more programming jobs to become very competitive. No-one is safe; and that includes 'seniors'.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by gorbachev on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:29AM (#33878637)
ChatGPT is not going to eat all the jobs. Can we stop this nonsense, please?
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by clnq on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:46AM (#33878793)
If anything, we'll need more engineers to help GPT-3.5/ChatGPT eat most receptionist, customer support, and similar customer-facing entry level jobs. That itself could become a very healthy and large industry.
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by brookst on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:51AM (#33878851)
IMO AI code will eat entry level software eng jobs before AI eats in-person jobs like receptionist.

I would not want to be a “take this UI and add a new field” coder right now.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by clnq on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:46AM (#33880753)
I don't think so for several reasons.

First, there's the uselessness of entry-level engineers. They are hired for their growth potential (that every human has, but language models don't) and are expected to grow into mid-levels and seniors. In most of the sw industry, entry-level roles are also not terminal, which means that such an engineer must get promoted at least +1L to keep working in the company. Someone (or something) perpetually stuck at the entry level is a bad value proposition for a sw company.

Secondly, the code that language models produce is buggy. They can, on occasion, produce amazing code and even entire codebases. But this is an exception, not the rule. You can generally prototype something or get an idea for something from language models, but you can only push very little of that into production. What good is code you can't use? You still need an engineer to oversee the language model's outputs.

Overall, if some company replaced their juniors with AI, that would be incompetent management.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by a_bonobo on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:42AM (#33879523)
This feels kind of arrogant? People working in many customer-facing entry level jobs do emotional labor within organisations that no AI-training has even taken aim at. If glorified chatbots could do their work receptionists would've disappeared a long time ago.
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by clnq on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:31AM (#33880446)
Emotional labor is a problem, not a feature. A receptionist only needs to be polite with the guests. But unfortunately, receptionists are often subject to emotional abuse.

We've never had glorified chatbots like GPT-3 or GPT-3.5. I'm not just praising GPT; I've myself casually run through a few simulations with a hotel chain receptionist and an executive. The technology looks very competent, and aside from cost savings, there's also the customer service quality aspect (consistency particularly) and the element of removing staff from abuse.

The biggest challenge is integrating language models with live data. Making customer data accessible to them is not a problem technically (prepending prompts), but it could be a GDPR problem if a third party like OpenAI is involved (having to hand over data to a third party might make the AI receptionists unappealing to some customers -- maybe, needs to be tried). The other aspect is letting the AI make changes in a data model. But there are ways to solve that as well. When these obstacles are resolved - and there is a lot of incentive to fix them now - a lot of customer-facing reception-type work can be outsourced to AI.

By the way, some hotels are already very interested in chatbots for reception work. There has been a lot of talk about that in some chains since about 2020. Old-style NLP bots, too. But of course, GPT-3 capabilities are very appealing.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by roncesvalles on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @01:18PM (#33884632)
I just want to add, ordering through the McDonald's big touchscreen machine is much better than ordering through the human and that alone has elevated my affinity for McDonald's. Which other experiential leaps from replacing humans with machines remain unimplemented?
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by Rapzid on Thursday December 08, 2022 @12:31AM (#33904555)
Eh on McDonalds but I do like the self-service ordering.

Kinda amazing this has not caught on more and sooner in USA.

Much more low tech versions of this have been used in Japan forever. The noodle bars and ramen shops are case studies in efficiency.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by rvz on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:57AM (#33878910)
> ChatGPT is not going to eat all the jobs.

Of course. My comment was about 'less programmers' getting hired. Not the extreme of 'All programmers' getting replaced by ChatGPT as you read incorrectly.

Believing that programmers don't need to adapt and that managers won't need to reduce or do layoffs especially with programmers, is quite frankly a denial and delusion of what is going on with cutting costs in hiring too many of them in the first place.

Denial is the first step to acceptance and as I said before, less programmers will be hired with juniors and some seniors impacted.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by gorbachev on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:15AM (#33879137)
No, that will also not happen.

More developers will get hired, because ChatGPT will not perform the higher function tasks most developers actually spend most of their time working on.

The reason this will happen, is because ChatGPT will be more efficient in performing the lower function tasks and there will be more of a need to put all that automatically created code into actual use, integrate it with Enterprise Package FooCPT, figure out what caused the product outage at 2am at night. And on and on and on.

Not to mention that ChatGPT will not be able to talk to your users about what they want next, convince your manager that that's the right thing to do and everything else that you need to do on top of the coding part to be a good developer.

What possibly will happen is that junior developers will have even harder time getting into the industry, because clueless PHBs will see ChatGPT doing all their work "for free". A few years later they're screwed, because nobody at the company knows how their applications work. Except ChatGPT...maybe.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by rvz on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:35AM (#33879398)
> What possibly will happen is that junior developers will have even harder time getting into the industry, because clueless PHBs will see ChatGPT doing all their work "for free". A few years later they're screwed, because nobody at the company knows how their applications work. Except ChatGPT...maybe.

Reads like what I said before. Some will be affected and less programmers will be needed,. Especially in particular, juniors and some seniors getting impacted.

I don't know where I said 'All jobs' as you once again brought out as you clear read incorrectly. I only said less programmers will be hired and these software engineering jobs will be more competitive.

The best course of action is to learn to adapt and it certainly applies to programmers. Pretending that they don't need to adapt is a delusion and denial of constant change. With or without AI.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by rajin444 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:22AM (#33880243)
Who’s going to write new code to train the model? Who’s going to figure out why the code generated by the model is slightly off?

The performance gains from chatgpt are going to be amazing from a quality of life perspective but overall not a huge change (except maybe in some niche roles). Programmers are not spending much of their time figuring out code that chatgpt can generate.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by vl on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @01:49PM (#33885102)
The question is not who, but how many people are required to write code to train model?

You are like a peasant arguing about security of their job in the beginning of 20th century after seeing a tractor. Sure there are farmers now, but much fewer of them is needed.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by vl on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @01:46PM (#33885061)
You are right, but it doesn’t fit worldview of your opponents, they are just too scared to think this thoughts.

To anyone who used Copilot and ChatGPT it is obvious that in 5 years demands for entry to software dev will be much higher, and there will be less positions open, because sheer productivity increases for the already employed people will outpace the demand. It’s like peasants arguing about security of their future prospects in the beginning of 20th century after seeing a tractor.

Winter is coming, but they just can’t believe this since their income directly depends on this not being true.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by ghaff on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @04:30PM (#33887333)
No one is hiring ditch diggers because someday they may grow to become backhoe operators. No one is hiring content farm writers who can be replaced by an AI with someone a bit more senior providing some basic supervision. And no one will hire junior developers when frameworks, AIs, etc. can replace 90% of what they can do.
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by ineedausername on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:08AM (#33879967)
About that last point, imagine the horror of having the responsibility to maintain whatever the AI wrote 3 years ago. :)
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by emptyfile on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:14AM (#33879132)
ChatGPT has quite literally nothing to do with tech lay-offs.

Read a freaking newspaper once in a while.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by rvz on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:38PM (#33883983)
Yet no-one here said that for this year's tech layoffs. But I wouldn't be surprised to see less engineers being hired compared to last year which is my entire point. Bringing in ChatGPT into the mix now won't make it any easier for entry level job seekers or for several seniors. This time, it is not the same as before.

But of course. Denying it all, and not adapting sure is a great way of coping with rapid changes. /s

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by nbaugh1 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:11AM (#33879097)
I'll get scared when someone shows me an actual deployed, running, and maintained app by something like chatGPT. Solving problems with code snippets is a tiny part of the job
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by f1shy on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:10AM (#33879996)
We will be all dead and gone long before any of those points are a reality...
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by nsxwolf on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:29AM (#33881586)
I'll get scared when a chat bot can log into JIRA, take a ticket, read the requirements, say "Hmm, there's not enough details in here and a couple things seem ambiguous or contradictory..." Then it schedules a meeting with the biz dev and a QA resource and they all hash out and improve the ticket. Then it goes and implements the code and puts it out for review, addresses any comments, works with QA to clarify how to test it (maybe that's another chat bot) and deploys it.
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by htrp on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @03:37PM (#33886672)
I'll be ecstatic when that happens..... Jira is like the worst part of my day
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by nanidin on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @01:40PM (#33884958)
Not to mention, until on-prem chatGPT is available, companies that care about source code secrecy aren’t going to expose their codebase to OpenAI.

We’ll get another slew of decades long court cases once one line of Oracle or Microsoft code proprietary code comes out of chatGPT.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by throwaway71271 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:15AM (#33878504)
This is just as good as a prediction as the alternative: ChatGPT will be the new gold age of programming, all you need in any company is only programmers, all kinds of programmers, no other job will be able to do anything of value.

So everyone who knows how to do a for loop is safe.

Or the extreme, we finally have to move to post-money society, because automation is no longer creating any jobs.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by rvz on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:32AM (#33878668)
Except that my statement isn't extreme or supports either extreme. I said 'less' programmers, not 'none' or only programmers / all people being programmers.

I still stand by that no-one (including Big Tech companies) is safe, especially after the 2022 tech layoffs which happened to many and tools like ChatGPT will eventually reduce the need to hire lots of programmers like before.

It is not going to be the same as the hiring euphoria that happened last year.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by throwaway71271 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:05AM (#33879012)
I understand you disagree, but I am pointing out that you can just as well predict extremely positive outcomes instead of your pessimistic ones, which you probably convince yourself are 'realistic', but there is no such thing as 'realistic' predictions, because we live in true emergent chaos.

So, you have a choice how to look at the world.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by joshribakoff on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:18AM (#33878526)
I don’t get the nexus between the release of chatGPT and rising interest rates. Are you implying the former somehow caused the latter?
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by ackbar03 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:21AM (#33878561)
My guess would be either chatGPT convinced JPowell to raise rates, or a large chunk of the world's money supply was spent training chatGPT
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by joxel on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:25AM (#33878596)
I like to the the original comment is written by an older NLP model
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by robertlagrant on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:17AM (#33878518)
> since with the recent release of ChatGPT now gives the excuse for managers to be inclined to hire less engineers and programmers as the cheap money has essentially evaporated

I don't understand the relevance of ChatGPT to this.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by base698 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:25AM (#33878600)
I assume because I've seen ChatGPT successfully:

- write a Gitlab ci job that tests python code and outputs a junit test report.

- can you add code coverage?

- write a sql table that has users, age, and a biography

- write python that parses the above output from the table

- now use a lexer and parser

- create a unit test to verify it's correct.

- write a perl one liner that parses a list of users and phone numbers

It completed all of them. I was already impressed with OpenAI when it generated an argument for why Britney Spears should become president and a test for a third grader about Socrates which I then answered incorrectly and had it grade it.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by hansjan on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:35AM (#33878689)
Have you tried doing this yourself? On Twitter etc. you see some really cool cherry-picked examples that are quite easy to break when replicating them yourself.

It is often confidently incorrect. Which is easy to spot if you know the subject matter, but nearly impossible if you are not familiar with the subject.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by paulcole on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:46AM (#33878791)
> It is often confidently incorrect.

My god, it truly can replace computer programmers.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by brookst on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:54AM (#33878878)
As a lifelong product manager, I’ve always considered my specs to be prompt engineering for incredibly impressive but sometimes misguided intelligences.
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by fvdessen on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:50AM (#33878837)
I've tried it and it works. It sometimes makes mistakes which it corrects when pointed out. And it's going to make less and less mistakes as the technology improves. It also can do many things I am not able to do. It's incredible.
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by tobyhinloopen on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:52AM (#33878857)
I found the same thing! I asked multiple questions and a lot of things were “confidently incorrect”. It was the exact term I thought of seeing these answers.

I found it funny because it made it more human-like as well.

(Example: “what’s the difference between timestamp and timestamptz in postgresql?” will answer that timestamptz will store the time zone and takes more space, which is both incorrect!)

I also asked it general, abstract programming advice and it gave pretty well-reasoned arguments mentioning maintainability and readability.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by LeeroyWasHere on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:05AM (#33879004)
It can barely spell out the correct ingredients of certain dishes, wouldn't trust it.

Garbage in, Garbage out.

GPT3 is as good and reliable as a Tesla autopilot.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by base698 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:18AM (#33880169)
These were all examples I tried myself.
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by UncleMeat on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:31AM (#33878659)
Okay. If there is somebody out there where the hardest part of their job is those tasks then that's not good for them.
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by bigDinosaur on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:35AM (#33878694)
There are a lot of people for whom those kinds of tasks are the most difficult programming tasks they'll be doing (more or less) per feature. It's just their job will often involve a lot more than just that (and if it doesn't, goodbye job...)
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by UncleMeat on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:43AM (#33878760)
Right. I don't understand the concern even for people working on small crud apps using widely used frameworks and little specialized business domain modeling. The act of writing code isn't the hard bit.
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by robertlagrant on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:14AM (#33879134)
I agree. People think coding is the hard bit, when for most jobs it isn't.
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by andy_ppp on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:20AM (#33879209)
On being able to replace a real programmer I'd say ChatGPT is about the same distance lane assist is from FSD.

Why you ask? Well it's because most of what a programmer does is more complex than the AI can handle right now. For example my job involves the following:

a) multiple interacting systems and management of the relationships between them

b) > 90% of my work does not involve writing new code

c) the programming part is mostly about changing existing code

d) or debugging (and sometimes setting up a debugger and running code)

e) reading hundreds of articles to figure out why the trivial example these systems are good at doesn't work (sometimes on someone else's machine or staging only)

f) taking product requirements and making small alterations to allow them to become reality (and knowing when to tell people about the decisions you made and when not to)

g) talking to people who might know more about the specific problem you are facing and when to battle through

h) sharing ideas on how to do things with the wider team

i) fighting the good fight and sneaking in refactoring when people are not looking

I don't think we are yet anywhere near these things yet.

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by f1shy on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:14AM (#33880067)
The most important, I think, is talking to the customer, and understanding what they want... even when they do not know it...
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by f6v on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:51AM (#33878844)
How don’t you get it? Singularity is around the corner. This time for sure.
Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by f6v on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:50AM (#33878830)
GPT took our jaaaawbs!

proceeds to building a time machine to get a job in 2015

Re:Ask HN: How is the job search coming along for people who... by amelius on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @08:09AM (#33879072)
Don't forget to patent the transformer algorithm.