Do we know the full causal factors? I'd wager not. But it is a testable hypothesis as much as "mandating helmets will save lives is." Per the evidence of this article, that hypothesis is on much shakier ground than your post would allow.
https://usa.streetsblog.org/2015/02/27/safety-in-numbers-bik...
There are so many confounding factors in there that it would be laughed out of the room at any statistician conference.
No, it's not a "testable hypothesis." Maybe you can find a "natural experiment" where two localities are exactly alike, except one has a MHL and the other doesn't: like a city where two school districts with identical demographics are divided by an artificial barrier.
Even in your article, they admit the uncertainties:
> Do more people on bikes cause cycling to become safer, or does safer infrastructure attract more people to bike? There’s no conclusive evidence either way, but the answer is probably a mix of both.
A lot of what we are getting for bike infrastructure in the US is horribly designed and often ends up being statistically more dangerous than no infrastructure at all.
A lot of our urban bike lanes, even the ones protected by barriers, fall into this trap. They make things safer in between intersections, but very few accidents happen in between intersections. But the poor design of the lanes causes increased risk AT the intersections. And the intersections were already where almost all the accidents happen. We have an epidemic of bike lanes designed by people who don't bike who have the irrational fear of being rear ended by a car as the #1 risk when that's actually one of the least common accidents.
The bad infrastructure puts more cyclists who don't really know what they are doing on the road and they don't understand the pitfalls of the lane design. So you don't see reduced bike-car collision rates.
A major point here is that the burden of proof should be on the ones proposing to make something mandatory.
Intuitively you might think that mandating helmets would improve safety. But now we've got a plausible argument that it might not. At this point there should not be a mandate unless the proponents can conclusively prove that it actually helps.
Because if helmets make things safer, people are still free to wear them in the absence of a mandate. But if they don't, and you impose the mandate anyway, you are now actively causing harm that its victims have no way to mitigate.
So, yes, lets debate the confounding factors. If you can name some factors, they should guide us in how we would build tests to explore them. I didn't claim it was easily testable, but it is certainly testable.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_experiment
So in this case, it might be "the same city, before and after MHL was enacted." Then we could graph the number of cyclists and the number of injuries, and you'd have something.
Basically, following the link in wikipedia will get you to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_control which allows for "A scientific control is an experiment or observation designed to minimize the effects of variables other than the independent variable (i.e. confounding variables)." Which is much less strongly stated than what you have. The idea is still there, of course.
For example: if Amsterdam suddenly had an MHL, that would be one. In fact, any city that instituted MHL would be a natural experiment. The number of riders, the number of accidents, the % of accidents that involve injuries -- all those things would change, while the city design and transit situation (other than bikes) presumably would not.
This is why you can have less pedestrian fatalities in cities where everyone wanders into the roads seemingly haphazardly than in cities where there are fewer pedestrians and they usually cross with the lights.
Perhaps that should be the headline then. "Mandatory Helmet Laws Make Cyclists Less Safe" implies that going helmet-free is safer than wearing a helmet. I get that there's a logical thread the writer is following re: fewer cyclists create a more dangerous environment -- we could also follow that logic when talking about rising bike prices or any number of things removed from the actual noggin-protecting benefits of helmets. Not sure I'd go so far as to call the headline "clickbait," but a more precise headline would've more accurately described the actual story (which was interesting to me, and I learned something).
But the article is interested in a different question: "If I bike, how likely am I to be injured?".
This question is very heavily influenced by the ratio of bikes to cars on the road. More bikes leads to lower chance of injury for bicyclists.
And money has to be split between all those things. A government has to provide for its people’s needs and if its people show no interest in cycling, some other more pressing problem is going to take priority
But if you have decided to bike, the article's information in no way means you should not wear a helmet.
Unfortunately, the clickbait headline mixes up these two very different things.
The article's information is useful if you are a voter or a politician trying to decide whether mandatory helmet laws will help to make your city a safe place for cyclists.
You'd never know it from the clickbait headline.
> Mandatory helmet laws are a matter of public policy, they have nothing to do with individual people making individual decisions.
Public policy doesn't do anything by itself; all it does is determine the incentives that people face when making individual decisions to do or not do things. So correctly describing the effects of a public policy is very important to individual people trying to make individual decisions.
You say that like it's not a HUGE thing. Incentives will determine the entire transport ratios of a region.
Biking on freeways is for misfits and weirdos :)
I said no such thing. Obviously incentives are important.
I'm just pointing out that incentives act on individuals making individual decisions. So to claim, as the GGP (not you) did, that public policy has nothing to do with individual decisions is simply wrong.
What headline are you seeing? At the time of this comment, the clickbait headline is:
> > Mandatory helmet laws make cyclists less safe
Which is clearly relevant for:
> a voter or a politician trying to decide whether mandatory helmet laws will help to make your city a safe place for cyclists.
and not clearly relevant for individual people making individual decisions, whether about biking at all, or about wearing a helmet when they do. (It's obviously possible (even likely) that relevant information might show up, but the clickbait headline isn't actually claiming that.)
But my initial reaction on reading the headline was: "Huh? They're saying wearing a helmet makes you less safe? That doesn't make sense! A helmet protects your head." I suspect I'm not alone (at least one other poster in this discussion has called the headline "deliberately deceptive clickbait", which is an even stronger claim than just "clickbait").
You can change your decision of whether to bike or not based on information about the effects of mandatory helmet laws. Some people might choose not to bike any more based on that information.
But if, taking the effects of those laws into account, you still decide to bike, the article says nothing to contradict the obvious common sense that you'll still be better off wearing a helmet than not.
This simply doesn't indicate that wearing a helmet makes cycling less safe. Perhaps someone might misread it that way, but that would be a mistake in terms of both logic and rhetoric.
https://www.bicyclelawyer.com/cycling-law-blog/study-shows-c...
I bet that people also drive with a bit more risk tolerance when they are wearing a helmet than otherwise, and of course more likely to get that helmet for a fast, risky, fun ride than a quick trip to the grocery store.
Interestingly, if you are seeking to reduce your personal odds of dying, it is a no brainer to bike. The cardiovascular health benefits outweigh the chance for getting hit by a car.
Edit: add the link
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-2031394/Cycling-w...
There are multiple aspects that lead to mandatory helmet laws causing in lower safety for cyclists.(many laws have a side-effect of making some group of people less safe)
Read the title three times and tell me where it says that helmets make cyclists less safe?
MHLs could increase my overall risk of cycling accident enough to offset any gain from wearing the helmet.
There are studies that show drivers go faster and closer to cyclists wearing helmets (vs those without helmets). That alone could increase the risk of deadly car-bike interaction enough to offset the gains from wearing the helmet.
https://www.bicycling.com/news/a25358099/drivers-give-helmet...
Edit - either way, I'm all for separate, protecetetd bicycle and pedestrian infrastructure. That's the "real" solution here - get bikes and cars onto different roads and what drivers do or don't do ceases to be a problem (almost, we still get drunken idiots driving down our protected bike paths outside DC).
I'm not claiming you're wrong, just that it's not a home-run "of course": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Risk_compensation
> Safety in Numbers is a straightforward concept: More people on bikes creates safer conditions on our streets. The National Association of City Transportation Officials (NACTO), which represents professional planners from 81 cities from around the United States, pointed this out in their own pushback on NTSB’s recommendations.
If you follow the links in the article you'll come to some actual research about the topic https://www.bmj.com/content/332/7543/722.2.
Wear a helmet. Your skull doesn't care about this study.
And titles like could lead to people to thinking that they won't need one. Which is unsafe for cyclists.
It would help if you ack that the article encourages helmets. They are not trying to say to not wear them. They are arguing that the practicalities of how "mandates" work out cause more issues than they solve.
I, for one, fully accept that "more studies" would be good. I also always wear a helmet. I don't think either of those are good rebuttals. And any blanket statement of "I don't care what evidence there is," is almost certainly the wrong foot to be on.
A more accurate description would be "I don't waste my time with bad science and sealioning."
Take the "dropped precipitously" link from the article. Does it link to an article about the before-and-after effects of the helmet mandates in Sydney in Melbourne? No. Does it talk about a drop in bicycle usage, irrespective of any relation to the mandates? Also no. It's an uninstrumented observational article about the lack of adoption (specifically) of bike share programs in several Australian cities, with no meaningful analysis of policy-based or temporal factors (outside of the changing coverage areas of the bikeshare companies). That study has zero relation to the claim for which the posted article cites it. Trying to pass it off as if it does is entirely in bad faith.
Articles like the one linked in the OP are a dime a dozen, and disregarding them based on simple heuristics is a good use of everyone's time. If one has a bold scientific claim to make, they should either present the data alongside the article in which they make the statement, or accompany it with a peer-reviewed article that does.
Following a few links from the main article easily gets to https://www.seattlebikeblog.com/2017/09/01/missing-the-fores..., which has https://usa.streetsblog.org/2014/06/13/wapo-is-wrong-head-in..., and ultimately points to there being something with just getting more folks on bikes. Especially for short trips that are likely the norm for bike share systems.
There is some intuitive sense to this. Is why short bus rides don't require seatbelts. (Though, I confess I can't remember the rules for cross state busses. https://www.cga.ct.gov/2016/rpt/2016-R-0318.htm has some info on school busses, but I'm not entirely clear that is applicable here. Except in as much as it is clear that comparing helmet laws to seatbelt ones is... dubious.)
Again, if you have legit complaints, make them. If you feel safer wearing safety gear at a personal level, you are correct. If you think that safety gear at a society level is a no brainer, I challenge you on that assertion.
It's clear from even the short HN title that we're talking about making helmets mandatory by law, not whether you should wear them.
THIS is the real difference.
Why not? Shouldn't we want to increase cyclist safety? Wearing helmets does that, both the data and common-sense concur here. But article was making a different claim. We shouldn't have laws MANDATING helmet use due to unintended side-effects actually producing more net-harm than the whatever deterrence impact the laws have in increasing helmet use. This is really not an obvious conclusion and requires reviewing the empiric data - but I suspect it is right.
> And titles like could lead to people to thinking that they won't need one.
Yes - the title is badly phrased. They are trying to present a subtle, nuanced argument that is not-obvious to a casual reader scanning headlines or even an article summary.
Multiple things can be true at once. MHL hurt cyclists, and having a helmet on makes your head hurt less when you fall.
Cyclist safety is _not_ an individual responsibility. It's a collective one. Mandatory helmets promote a state of affairs where cycling is considered a leisure opt-in activity, a fig leaf for shameless victim blaming when drivers do run into a cyclist (should have worn a helmet har har). The collective psychology of drivers, - reckless, inconsiderate, entitled - combined with a street design that actively encourages speeding and reptile-brain fueled jostling for position is what is hurting cyclists. This is why mandatory helmet laws are harmful, they are actively nurture a deadly collective mindset.
Plus, we are not making drivers where helmets. In a crash, having their head packaged inside a helmet will benefit drivers too. So maybe let's start there.
1) Everybody SHOULD, for their own benefit, wear a helmet.
2) Nobody should be REQUIRED BY LAW to wear a helmet
There is no paradox, unless you assume that every good thing thing should be mandated by law and every bad thing regulated. I was actually surprised to read this article and discover the arguments against the helmet law mandates. Usually the argument is something like: "yes mandates save lives, but freedom is more import." But this argument was different -- do to complex system interactions removing the mandate saves lives on net. So, with or without laws most regular riders are going to wear helmets. However, just one example from the article, with the laws there are fewer people riding which makes the roads less safe for bikers. Lots of bikers promotes awareness of bikers by drivers, and encourages infrastructure investment, and prevents thus prevents accidents. We have data that shows this happens in practice. It also encourages both helmet and non-helmet wearing bikeshare adoptees, which in-turn also creates ridership, and a culture of bikeriders, which in turn reduces accidents. So even while you have more non-helmet wearing riders (which is a small fraction of riders) it reduces the _conditions_ that cause accidents sufficiently that there are on-net fewer accidents.
https://www.google.com/search?q=dutch+cyclists+don%27t+wear+...
Your argument that you're safer with a helmet might be true but you're probably being hypocritical in that there are plenty of things you do in life where you'd be safer with a helmet were you don't personally wear a helmet. Apparently you'd be ok if the government forced you to where a helmet at all times except sleeping because by the same argument, it's safer to walk with a helmet than without therefore there should be a law requiring it
Basically, the only reason that bicycling is unsafe is cars. Cars are only a threat to cyclists when they share the same roads, which is only a problem because not enough people bike. The best way to ensure safety for cyclists is for there to be dedicated bike infrastructure that is completely separated from car infrastructure, and that's only going to happen once enough people switch to biking.
>None of them say that a cyclist wearing a helmet is just as likely, or more likely, to get injured.
That is not said or implied by the headline.
> The goal is to protect people who already ARE cycling.
If that's true, it's an idiotic and shortsighted goal. We have to do better than that- the goal should be to promote bicycling as a safe and accessible alternative to driving for everyone. 8-year-old children should be free to bike to school unsupervised without the risk of getting hit by a car. Mandatory helmet laws don't solve the problem, they make it worse.
How is that true? I fall off my bike and hit my helmet on pavement once every couple of years or so. I am quite thankful I wear a helmet regularly.
Bicycling is of course much safer with less cars.
That seems extremely unusual. Are you MTBing / using skateparks / etc?
No, just riding around streets. Typically from a large stone or something in the walkway, or I try to jump a curb and miss it by a bit.
I don't have the best balance in the world.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
> That seems extremely unusual. Are you MTBing / using skateparks / etc?
As someone who commutes exclusively by bicycle and who goes on 80+ mile rides on the weekend, I used to hit the pavement about once a year. I now ride with elbow pads in addition to a helmet, and I think I've developed a pretty good instinct for what could go sideways. I don't have control over every factor, and being a normal animal that gets tired or distracted, I expect falls to happen again in the future.
Some of the ways I've hit the ground include hitting a patch of icy road after 3 days of 50+F temps because that spot happened to be covered by shadow no matter where the sun was that time of year, hitting a small wet metal grate at the entrance to my employer's parking garage where the bike cage is, and the driver of a truck passing too close and hitting my hand which was out signaling my intention to turn.
Speaking nothing of the hundreds of times I've identified a hazard and avoided it by adjusting my road position, slowing down, bunny hopping, or sometimes even stopping and dismounting when I'm in the middle of the stroad (once when I found myself in a mess of overlapping streetcar tracks all around me). But even with a 99.9% success rate at responding to hazards correctly in the moment, I can expect to fail once every 1,000 hazards or so. That's why I wear protective gear.
Speed matters a lot. There's a good reason why most bike racers wear helmets, while most regular city bikers or leisurely bikers do not.
Mind you, I've fallen a couple of times too (usually in icy or otherwise slippery conditions I wasn't properly accounting for at the time). But never hit my head. Worst I think was when I scraped my hands as a kid.
There's a hill near my house where I used to regularly hit 70kph. There's a super-sketchy cross street right at the bottom of that hill with motorists always trying to white-knuckle gun it into traffic, so I've stopped doing that.
For all of my crashes I was going at or under 15kph. Which is probably why I'm still here to tell you all about it.
(I think it was here [0], though I don't remember crossing that raised sidewalk; maybe they changed that since then, or I misremember.)
[0] https://www.google.com/maps/@52.3507984,4.854121,3a,75y,108....
It's also possible to have mandatory helmet laws and still have lots of cyclists. Vancouver Canada is a good example. Lots of cyclists. Good cycling infrastructure. Mandatory helmets. They do get black ice.
Maybe we should just make helmets mandatory for drivers. Then perhaps they'll hop on a bicycle instead.
But without a helmet, it really doesn't require much energy for a head strike to be a fatal or life-changing injury. If riders face a baseline risk from non-car collisions, there's a strong case to be made for mandatory helmets, even if it means the risk from car collisions increase.
EDIT: Evidence: https://road.cc/content/news/268605-wearing-cycle-helmet-may...
Do you mean "more injuries overall" or "more injuries per cyclist"? Or something else entirely?
"The new paper from Walker also re-affirms that wearing a helmet was indeed associated with more “close” passes when you take into consideration that in some places, the law dictates more than one meter of room."
and any increase in accidents, let alone injury accidents.
The real goal is often to reduce the number of people biking. This is why there is strong correlation between supporting mandatory helmet laws (and bicycle taxes, license plates and mandatory training) and opposing safe infrastructure such as segregated bike lanes.
Where is the evidence of that intention? This seems more like the case of unintended side-effects to me.
*supporting mandatory helmet laws, mandatory insurance on bicycles, other bicycle taxes, license plates on bicycles and applying car-related legal requirements in general, requiring driving license to use bicycle, ban on cycling by children, opposing safe infrastructure such as segregated bike lanes, opposing any bicycle infrastructure, wanting to ban cycling on roads, wanting to remove cycleways.
Less overall cyclists means less visibility and less awareness by motorists (ie. if you encounter less bikes, you're less likely to watch out for them)
if you have 4x as many people on bikes, the cyclists with helmets are safer due to the "safety in numbers" effect. If you've done any urban bike riding you'd see this is obviously true.
* More bikes means less cars, and cars are dangerous. Less cars means less danger.
* More bikes means car drivers are more used to seeing bikes, more likely to expect and consider bikes, and will take bike traffic more seriously.
* More bikes also makes bike-specific infrastructure more attractive to invest in. The city isn't going to build a separate bike path for a single biker, but for a thousand, they might.
Countries with the highest bike safety don't have mandatory helmet laws. Of course that's partially because those mandatory helmet laws are simply less necessary there, but also because they've found more effective ways to make bikes safer, while stimulating instead of discouraging bike use.
By forcing them to either abandon cycling or become criminals?
We increasingly see dangerous substances being made legal while still pushing for the criminalization of getting from A to B.
I hope they make you wear a helmet on the sidewalk too. I only want you to be protected.
They have a third option: suck it up and comply with the law.
1. A reduction in the number of cyclists on streets;
2. Financial struggle for popular bike sharing systems; and
3. More exposure among vulnerable populations to unnecessary interactions with police.
NONE of these support the clickbait headline. #1 and #2 say that MHLs reduce the number of cyclists. And #3 fails to control for "percent of populations who ride without helmets."
None of them say that a cyclist wearing a helmet is just as likely, or more likely, to get injured.
> The unfortunate truth is mandatory helmet laws simply don’t lead to their purported goal, which is to make streets safer.
No, that's never been the "purported goal." The goal is to protect people who already ARE cycling.