If someone's OKR is based on quarterly revenue from App store, they aren't going to care until regulation is literally at their doorstep. That's next quarter, not this quarter. Next quarter that person could retire or quit.
There is something we're not being told here. Because the reasons all these commenters are throwing out make zero sense.
You're assuming the existence of a 'need'. Part of my point is that there doesn't have to be any 'need' for additional revenue beyond the revenue itself.
It also seems like you may be assuming that the person or people responsible for this and other similar decisions are incentivized to consider all of Apple's revenue as opposed to a specific subset of it, which I suspect is unlikely.
Fiscal 2022 Services revenue is 77 million and iPhone revenue is 220 million, so it's not there yet, but it's beating iPad (29 million) and Mac (40 million) combined which is nothing to sneeze at.
I don't think that Apple discloses App Store revenue separate from Services revenue
https://sixcolors.com/post/2022/11/apples-fiscal-2022-in-cha...
For anyone interested in the antitrust space, this is a pretty good (though excessively optimistic imho) newsletter:
They claim they gave devs ~$64Bn in 2021. That means they collected about $27Bn in revenue in 2021, and most of that is basically money for free and almost entirely profit.
It's probably about 10-12% of their profit and grows without them having to do much at all.
What will be a massive problem is if the government says "App Stores can only have at max a 20% fee", and then to enforce this law they only allow two app stores, or it increases the barrier of entry for small players even more.
If anything, I suspect that Coinbase intentionally violated the rules with this update so that it can sign on with Epic and Twitter in the fight against Apple.
Exactly, the dumb/risky thing to do would be to make a special exception for Coinbase. This is no different from a consumer buying Robux to spend on a 3rd-party game.
This is more like your stock broker app letting you buy a stock, although "cryptocurrencies aren't securities, they're speculative assets". So maybe more like buying art via an app.
https://web.archive.org/web/20221030193939/https://developer... (search for NFT in the page).
Apple was never going to allow the blockchain to remove their 30% cut on these purely digital items, as much as crypto folks preached that the blockchain would remove us from the shackles of App Store IAP payments.
yeah arguably if apple wanted to say "you're doing a forex trade in app, TD Ameritrade makes $10 in fees on that $20k transaction, we deserve $3 of that, and it needs to be paid via our IAP scheme" that's a consistent application of their rules at least.
again though, coinbase's PR department is doing what PR departments do, they've got you talking like coinbase would be charged 30% of the whole transaction and that's not actually what Apple is saying here... just like it turns out Qualcomm may not have been entirely honest about ARM's licensing changes and many of the specifics of EVGA's complaints are highly misleading or specific to their (atypical) business model, despite a generally-correct thrust.
Like, kinda funny that grown-ass adults don't understand that a literal PR department might not always be presenting the situation entirely fairly... and this is a business community we're discussing that in, no less. You need to apply critical thinking about why someone might be saying things now, and why they're saying them in that particular way... they're happy to lead you into a wrongful conclusion even if they themselves haven't said anything technically wrong, that is the conclusion they intended for you to draw and you consumed the information uncritically and you did draw that conclusion. They walked you right down the garden path there, give that PR guy a raise.
Just like Sony can argue for app-store openness on Apple's platforms but argue they shouldn't have to open their own platform to competitors too... they want to keep their 30% cut but force their competitors to give up theirs. And no, consoles are not sold at a loss anymore, PS5 hit hardware profitability around 6 months after launch...
edit: for those paying a broker fee, does Apple even take 30% of that?
For anyone who understands how NFTs and blockchains work, this is clearly not possible. Apple’s proprietary In-App Purchase system does not support crypto so we couldn’t comply even if we tried.
This is akin to Apple trying to take a cut of fees for every email that gets sent over open Internet protocols.
No, only the ones sent using their hardware. And I think there’s no law or regulation that would forbid them from doing that.
Similarly, if, currently, the App Store model doesn’t support what Coinbase wants to do, they shouldn’t have made an app.
(this isn’t a statement about the desirability of the current situation)
Apologies if I'm misunderstanding, but are you saying my iPhone belongs to Apple?
(I may be confused by how you mean "their hardware".)
> No, only the ones sent using [an app distributed via Apple's App Store].
I don't want to speak for anyone, but that's (probably) more accurate to the intended meaning.
They're lucky that the US has the particular form of "democracy" that they do, because I suspect the current regulations aren't exactly "the will of the people".
Oh, wait, they can just pay in dollars. I don't think that Coinbase has their problem solving hat on :)
Trading volume has been falling 30-44% every quarter:
https://s27.q4cdn.com/397450999/files/doc_financials/2022/q3...
https://s27.q4cdn.com/397450999/files/doc_financials/2022/q2...
https://s27.q4cdn.com/397450999/files/doc_financials/2022/q1...
so I'm thinking they don't have a product and they know it. This NFT product was supposed to be so hot their servers couldn't take it!
https://www.gfinityesports.com/cryptocurrency/coinbase-nft-w...
so what gives? I think someone is lying here. Maybe even bad enough someone could get fired if this doesn't get turned around. And if that's the case, it seems plausible to me that someone looked at 30% of "their" revenue going to Apple and just said fuck it.
This is not an in app purchase, IMO.
https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#goo...
It isn't an in app purchase. It doesn't pay a cut to Apple.
Apple is asking for 30% of fees charged, not amounts exchanged. It’s like if a bank app charged you $1 to deposit $100; Apple would want $0.30, not $30.
Still debatable and I’ve got no sympathy for Apple, but this kind of OMG they want to take 30% of all cash flows response is exactly the misleading PR people are trying to gin up.
EDIT: here is what Coinbase themselves say:
Apple’s claim is that the gas fees required to send NFTs need to be paid through their In-App Purchase system
I'm not supporting Coinbase here, though, and I wouldn't be mad if this policy were actually just a tacit way to ban cryptocurrency transactions in the App Store. But your analogy doesn't fit.
I can't fathom why this decision was made.
People will still support them, as long they can have the fastest phones/laptops. I started on a mac clone in the mid 90s (they almost went under), but I finally moved away last year, though I still have an iphone. The Linux desktop works great for developing.
Its a societal and network effect problem. This isn't new. We've been warned. We've chosen to ignore.
However, it would be so contrary to the spirit, if not the letter, of the law that I expect any such attempts would quickly gain antitrust scrutiny and new legislation declaring that APIs and software included in a device may only be monetized at point-of-sale (with the exception of subscription plans marketed toward consumers). It is possible that a court would even see it as such a violation of the law's intended effect that they would step in.
A good analogy would be me making a new control panel for a mechanical machine, where the panel has metal arms and rods that connect to the machine's original mechanisms to bring about a certain result that the machine itself would be incapable of bringing on its own.
You wouldn't say I can't distribute that new panel I made because the original machine is patented, right?
Disagree with it or not, were I Apple Legal, I would never in a million years allow a concession without a fight.
Knowing when to lose is quite valuable. Microsoft learned that the hard way last time.
Its hilarious to see the difference between apple, google and microsofts reactions. Two of them went we will fight tooth and nail, microsoft who tried that last time instantly went we are dropping the fees instantly, unless you want more? and will work with regulators to make open access ...
This is not the time to be strengthening the rules. You've got the Digital Markets Act already entering force in Europe which is going to most likely break App Store dominance over there in just a year or two. The US has senators eyeing the Open App Markets Act again after Elon's threat (and if it doesn't pass now, when senators see an open Europe and a closed US, what about then?). You've got antitrust investigations opened in the UK. This is time to be giving concessions hoping to keep power - not doubling down!
Edit: If Apple's claims about it being "privacy and security" are true, here's how to keep power. Drop the 30% cut, make a $25-$50 fee every time a new version comes out for a quality app review from a 3rd party independent board, drop some of the more onerous restrictions, and maybe then regulators would be willing to allow the App Store to remain. Instead...