News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by pocketarc on Thursday December 01, 2022 @12:56PM (#33819905)
Ads seem to be a modern virus that infects everything. Everyone who claims "no ads", eventually turns their back on that once they get big enough, even companies with more than enough money from their own products (e.g. Apple, Netflix). I've never seen anything so powerful. I guess it comes down to "no business would say no to free money", but it really is incredible.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by squarefoot on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:09PM (#33820099)
The market eventually became saturated with products and services; today there are a lot more of them than pockets that can or will purchase them, therefore they fight to occupy the spots where people can notice them first, knowing that whoever comes after won't sell. This is a train wreck waiting to happen since there are no signs that it could self-limit in the immediate future; products and services sellers will eventually fight for every possible still free space to put ads into and win potential users attention; it will simply become worse and worse, unless someone invents consumerism with some limits built in, which in today's culture is deeply frowned upon.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by spaniard89277 on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:04PM (#33820026)
They have a paid option. It's paying or ads. Running a search engine is not free. Somebody has to pay for it.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by rabuse on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:06PM (#33820061)
That's not the problem. The problem is they sold their service as one thing, and then completely switch on the users down the line, instead of being honest upfront.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by trs8080 on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:09PM (#33820102)
It was free, so they never sold it and nobody ever bought it. Companies often times need to pivot or introduce pricing to their products to survive. Would rather pay a modest fee to ensure that Brave continues as an alternative to the major browsers vs them running out of money and shutting down.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by jjulius on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:28PM (#33820390)
>It was free, so they never sold it and nobody ever bought it.

I mean, OP's not wrong. The phrase doesn't have to specifically mean an exchange of goods for money - can sell you on an idea, for instance. They "sold you" on the idea of using Brave by being very anti-ad. Now that you "bought it" and are hooked, they'd like some money.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by soundnote on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:43PM (#33820636)
They've been very upfront that Brave Search will have ads one day in my experience.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by puchatek on Thursday December 01, 2022 @02:08PM (#33821057)
And what was the thing you thought you were buying?
Re:Brave launches private search ads by kleer001 on Thursday December 01, 2022 @12:59PM (#33819958)
And, from what I understand, Ads don't really "work" inasmuch as they're very high output to very low return.

Small motile cells in many species are used in a reproductive strategy very much like ads.

Tee-hee.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by glitchc on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:35PM (#33820513)
Companies throw a lot of money at ads. Far more than individual consumers can muster. It's the difference between grass-roots donations and institutional funding.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by paulcole on Thursday December 01, 2022 @12:59PM (#33819950)
Did Apple or Brave ever say “no ads”?

In the case of Brave (and every business), somebody’s got to hand money to someone in order to keep the lights on.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by derefr on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:08PM (#33820077)
Brave (the browser) has a built-in ad-blocker, the existence of which could be taken as an implicit stance by its creators on how they feel about ads.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by Semaphor on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:13PM (#33820157)
The browser also has a built-in ad-replacer which tells you even more about how they feel about ads.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by hunterb123 on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:30PM (#33820441)
No they don't. They don't replace ads, that's a lie, stop repeating it here please.

The Brave rewards are system OS text notifications that you can OPT IN to.

In no way do they replace banner ads on websites.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by skinnymuch on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:52PM (#33820781)
They could have meant when Brave swapped affiliate links before the backlash had them backtrack. Which was a wild thing to do. Blocking ads in your browser while charging to not show ads is also pretty wild. Why doesn’t their ad blocker block their ads?
Re:Brave launches private search ads by hunterb123 on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:57PM (#33820880)
I doubt that. They said replace ads, not add affiliates, those are different words entirely. The "ad replacing" is a common lie.

Just don't use Brave search, the separate product. Or you know, add the blocking rules yourself to the ad blocker, that works. Or you know, pay the $3 dollars to support the thing you use.

Most of the people complaining here don't actually care about this. This is all just a proxy war to go against Eich for his beliefs. It happens every Brave thread, pretty transparent and pathetic.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by Semaphor on Thursday December 01, 2022 @11:08PM (#33826662)
> This is all just a proxy war to go against Eich for his beliefs.

Of course. Just like I war against your beliefs, whatever they may be. I war against all the beliefs.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by soundnote on Thursday December 01, 2022 @07:47PM (#33825296)
They didn't replace affiliate links. They had a feature similar to Firefox Suggest or whatever's in Chrome/Edge nowadays I think. They had a deal with eg. Binance, and if you typed Binance in the address bar, their Binance promo would show up as one of the results.

They had a bug in it where if you typed a valid URL (eg. binance.us) it'd still give the sponsored link as an autocomplete which it shouldn't have. That bug stood for one day, if memory serves, and the feature was turned off by default.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by BrendanEich on Friday December 02, 2022 @06:23PM (#33838336)
You're wrong on "refgate", see https://twitter.com/BrendanEich/status/1360780527100338177.

We do block our own search ads if Brave Shields is set to Aggressive mode, same as with other search engines and UGC social platforms.

What else you got?

Re:Brave launches private search ads by skinnymuch on Sunday December 04, 2022 @01:20AM (#33851147)
Oh wow. So much time had passed since that. I remember seeing the details after I had made the negative connection between Brave and “refgate”. Especially the HN thread at the time was chaotic. That negative connotation never left.

Wish I could edit or delete my post. Sorry.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by asadotzler on Thursday December 01, 2022 @07:49PM (#33825306)
Replacement doesn't imply a reuse of a specific location. Taking an ad out your browser and placing a different ad on your desktop is still replacement. Do you really not understand that advertising isn't about space in physical world, but about space in your mind? What brave does is absolutely replacement. They replace a bit of light that was emanating from one part of your device's screen to invade your attention to make some other party money with a bit of light that emanates from a different part of your device's screen to invade your attention to make them money. How in the world is that not "replacement"?
Re:Brave launches private search ads by hunterb123 on Thursday December 01, 2022 @10:15PM (#33826307)
Brave has a built in adblocker for the user that is on by default.

Brave also has a rewards program the user can opt-in to get scheduled text notifications on their system.

I could see your point somewhat if their rewards system was opt-out or tied to whether the adblocker was on, but it's not.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by BrendanEich on Friday December 02, 2022 @03:49PM (#33836686)
Hi Asa, macOS dictionary says

re·place /rəˈplās/

verb

1. take the place of. "Ian's smile was replaced by a frown" 2. put (something) back in a previous place or position. "he drained his glass and replaced it on the bar"

Notice the use of place and position. If you say we "replace ads", I think you are misusing the word replace. I hope you won't from here on, because we definitely still get smeared with the lie that we replace ads in-situ in publisher pages.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by Semaphor on Thursday December 01, 2022 @11:14PM (#33826695)
Maybe they never activated it, but they certainly planned to do so: https://brave.com/braves-response-to-the-naa-a-better-deal-f...

I didn’t follow up on details on this, so I guess they changed their plans, that still tells me what they think about ads.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by smt88 on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:09PM (#33820104)
> an implicit stance by its creators on how they feel about ads

Like Apple and AdBlock, the stance is that they want to sell their own ads in the spaces where they're blocking other people's

Re:Brave launches private search ads by paulcole on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:24PM (#33820324)
I’m not asking how you think the creators feel about ads. Did Brave as a company ever say that their product would be free of ads? If so, what was their plan for not going out of business?
Re:Brave launches private search ads by soundnote on Thursday December 01, 2022 @07:44PM (#33825275)
They've been in the ad serving business for ages and have been upfront about funding or intending to fund their services with privacy respecting ads.

The blocking system is a stance against privacy invasions, not advertising itself.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by Apocryphon on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:15PM (#33820203)
What 15 years of ZIRP does to a mfer
Re:Brave launches private search ads by twhb on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:47PM (#33820706)
I felt this way for a while, but I’d like to offer another angle: maybe it’s like saying “Every company eventually hires tall people. Some have no tall people, but it’s just a matter of time. Tall people are really an unstoppable force.” The missing piece is also observing short people (ad-free offerings), which you’d notice are not being eliminated, are also prevalent, and also “infect” everything. I think the unstoppable force being felt here is just statistics: ads are often an option, companies make a lot of decisions, it’s statistically inevitable that some of those will be ads, unless the company has some strong aversion to ads, which most don’t.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by zagrebian on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:53PM (#33820803)
Modern? When I grew up in the ’90s, ads were everywhere: in the magazines I was reading, on TV, on billboards, in the mail. How can you call ads a modern virus?
Re:Brave launches private search ads by autoexec on Thursday December 01, 2022 @05:26PM (#33823858)
Ads aren't a new thing, but the it's been allowed to spread unchecked and unregulated in ways that were simply not possible in the 90s causing new problems.
Re:Brave launches private search ads by ramesh31 on Thursday December 01, 2022 @02:40PM (#33821568)
>Ads seem to be a modern virus that infects everything. Everyone who claims "no ads", eventually turns their back on that once they get big enough, even companies with more than enough money from their own products (e.g. Apple, Netflix).

TBF at least it's better than the status quo of the late 90's to early 2000s, when the revenue model was malware and actual viruses rather than ad supported.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by autoexec on Thursday December 01, 2022 @05:35PM (#33823952)
> TBF at least it's better than the status quo of the late 90's to early 2000s, when the revenue model was malware and actual viruses rather than ad supported.

Back then we called software that phoned home to check for updates spyware and it was to be avoided. The idea that a random program on my system would know when I was connected to the internet, and would be collecting my IP address was unacceptable. Now it's standard practice.

The revenue model back then was shareware. You get the software, it mostly works, and you send a check to some PO box to get a full version. It wasn't terrible. I don't remember too many companies shipping malware and when they did people were rightly pissed off (Sony's rootkit for example)

What we had were lots of ad filled websites hosting shareware and it was often the ads that were infecting people, although some sites did inject malware into the downloads.

Re:Brave launches private search ads by t0bia_s on Saturday December 03, 2022 @06:47PM (#33848794)
But you need money. Without money, whole businesses is pointless. With financial crisis and ridiculous inflation, who cares about ads?

Well... If they try sell you a product, it is harmless. But with selling an ideas and manipulation of masses, that is diferent story. I guess propaganda is a right definition.