News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by csande17 on Sunday November 27, 2022 @08:45PM (#33768922)
Plastic packaging protects food from moisture and dirt. If you make the packaging out of a water-soluble material and then eat it, surely that's almost completely useless? Like, now you need some kind of additional outer wrapper to stop your edible packaging from getting contaminated.

The article mentions muffin wrappers as an alternative use case, but those are usually made of thin paper and are already compostable.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by morepork on Sunday November 27, 2022 @09:03PM (#33769050)
I think the idea is that it becomes like fruit and vegetables. You purchase them unwrapped, wash them, and eat them. This would have implications on the supply chain of course to try and keep these items clean.

It could also replace individually wrapped items, such as in a box of cereal bars the individual bars wouldn't need plastic wrap.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by WirelessGigabit on Sunday November 27, 2022 @09:23PM (#33769155)
My protein bars need individual wrap. I am not putting them 'naked' inside of my hiking backpack.

Not to mention how nasty the last one is when it takes you 2 months to finish a box... All of them exposed to air? Thanks but no thanks.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by Renaud on Sunday November 27, 2022 @09:52PM (#33769312)
That’s what tin boxes are for. They keep their content fresh and protect it.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by lazide on Monday November 28, 2022 @12:20AM (#33770081)
So a container for your wrapped product? That gets full of random lint and dust?

Meh.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by jonasdegendt on Monday November 28, 2022 @03:02AM (#33770931)
You seem quite hell-bent on denouncing containers. Yet, a good container with a plastic seal on the lid will keep your food completely clean and be pretty airtight to keep it fresh for a while.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by lazide on Monday November 28, 2022 @10:00AM (#33774424)
‘Hell-bent’? Really?

I use reusable containers for 90% of the stuff I use, especially tools, projects, etc.

I also use glass reusable containers all the time for food, as they don’t soak up weird smells and stains that can’t be cleaned out, and have bacterial problems and leeching issues like reusable plastic containers.

They aren’t practical for anywhere they’ll be exposed to impacts a lot or weight matters, like kids lunches or whatever, so I use plastic ones there.

But I’m under no illusions that any of those make any sense whatsoever for large scale food distribution, and neither should anyone else.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by ArnoVW on Monday November 28, 2022 @04:30AM (#33771450)
This is how your parents and grandparents lived. Stuff got dirty, and instead of tossing it after having used it once, they.. washed it!

When I go shopping, I:

* bring my own bag

* buy oat, rice, sugar, pasta, chocolate etc in bulk (w/ textile bags I bring)

* refill detergent containers in-shop

* buy fruit & veg without packaging

.. and I have no meaningful reduction of my living standard. I know it's difficult to make some sacrifices. But honestly, if we can't as a society be ars*d to do even that, perhaps we deserve to disappear after ecological collapse, and the geopolitical consequences of that.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by lazide on Monday November 28, 2022 @09:55AM (#33774355)
And all of them switched to the current state of affairs the moment they could. Their parents too.

Weird huh?

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by ArnoVW on Monday November 28, 2022 @10:35AM (#33774859)
Correction: the moment they thought they could
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by lazide on Monday November 28, 2022 @12:07PM (#33776176)
Pretty sure they could and did and have been for quite awhile.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by numpad0 on Monday November 28, 2022 @03:17PM (#33778936)
I've heard that there is a powder processing device called entoleter that are typically NOT used in Europe for grain and powdered food products, as ambient temperature is low enough for bugs to hatch and grow on such food in considerable likelihood.

What I'm saying is, the chance of that happening IS considerably high elsewhere, and in such elsewhere it is imperative that oat, rice, not sugar but pasta, and chocolate, must be denied of life under sterile light of an ultra processing foodstuff factory and somewhat hermetically sealed. Otherwise you wouldn't know what you'll be getting later.

Just something which reason isn't immediately obvious sometimes.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by morepork on Sunday November 27, 2022 @10:16PM (#33769444)
The bars wouldn't be exposed to air, that's what edible wraps like what is described in the article are for.

For backpacks and the like you will need something else to keep it clean, same as you would for an apple. May I present to you the lunch box, already used by 100s of millions.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by seer on Sunday November 27, 2022 @10:26PM (#33769496)
But would you put an apple “naked”? A cucumber? A tomato?

At least for me - when I hike I usually have a box and put all of those items there “raw” - the box protects them from mechanical forces but I don’t need to individually wrap my apples inside that box. Having other edible things have such an edible covering would be amazing actually.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by King-Aaron on Sunday November 27, 2022 @11:40PM (#33769878)
Fruits and vegetables tend to have their own inbuilt wrapping that protects them from dirt, moisture, etc. Whereas an oat bar or protein bar is often quite porous and would get impregnated with dirt and stuff very quickly. It's an absurd comparison to make.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by bee_rider on Monday November 28, 2022 @12:42AM (#33770186)
This thread was kicked off by discussion of an edible plastic-like wrapper (which would be analogous to the fruit skin).
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by gen220 on Sunday November 27, 2022 @11:57PM (#33769962)
FWIW, if you're curious about the insights from somebody who's crusty enough to make their own protein bars :)

If you care about avoiding "processed foods" in other domains and are consuming shrink-wrapped bars with a shelf life of 2+ months: here be dragons!

I store ours in a glass container the refrigerator, where they're individually wrapped in butcher paper. I'd consider them good outside of the fridge (in the paper) for 32 hours, inside the fridge for a week or two. Making a batch takes about 10 minutes + overnight refrigeration, and the recipe is trivial to scale-up/down in size.

They're certainly not as convenient or robust as shrink-wrapped lara bars, but we're not frequently in situations where the diff disappoints, ymmv.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by humanrebar on Monday November 28, 2022 @12:01AM (#33769995)
I find most "protein" bars, processed or unprocessed, are relatively low in protein and function more like energy bars, meal replacement bars, or even weight gainers.

I expect the ones made without processed ingredients like protein powders to be especially in that category. Not that there's anything necessarily bad about that, but it does bug me when folk label products as "high" in protein when all the protein comes from nuts, legumes, etc.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by bee_rider on Monday November 28, 2022 @12:44AM (#33770200)
Some granola bars would probably be better considered candy bars dressed up to trick you into thinking they are healthy.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by robertlagrant on Monday November 28, 2022 @06:18AM (#33772235)
Here is your 6-monthly reminder to read the No S Diet[0] and learn its lessons on why health snacks exist.

[0] http://nosdiet.com

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by gen220 on Monday November 28, 2022 @09:59AM (#33774408)
As I understand it, there's disagreement on how efficiently the body absorbs/digests the protein latent in protein powder. Especially when it's in a "dry" form most commonly found in protein bars.

I totally agree re the disappointing macro-nutritional composition of most protein bars. Especially disappointing (to me) is the sugar content and its source (typically rice syrup or corn syrup).

After computing the macros for homemade bars, it's hard to feel like you're getting much bang for the buck with those bars -- it feels like you're better off eating some dried and mixed nuts.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by colordrops on Monday November 28, 2022 @12:12AM (#33770040)
You gonna let us in on the recipe?
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by gen220 on Monday November 28, 2022 @09:49AM (#33774268)
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by jhatax on Monday November 28, 2022 @04:05AM (#33771303)
Recipe, please? These sound easy to make, easy to store, and healthy. That’s the trifecta! If they are delicious too, billions!
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by gen220 on Monday November 28, 2022 @09:48AM (#33774259)
You can make them with or without protein powder.

But the main ingredients are creamy natural peanut butter, one of either local honey or local maple syrup, and "old-fashioned" rolled oats.

Stir until combined 200g PB, 135g honey/maple syrup, 5g vanilla extract, 3g sea salt.

To this mixture, add 100g rolled oats, 80g whey, ~200g nuts and seeds (can be crushed or whole, although partially-crushed is a bit easier). I use pecans, pepitas, walnuts, almonds, cashews. Whatever is in the pantry.

Transfer + compress to an appropriate-sized casserole dish (above is good for 8x8) with a large spoon, I usually line it first with paper to make later transfer easier.

Cover + chill for at least 1 hour, then slice with a sharp instrument (I use a pizza slicer, but a chef's knife is great). These proportions yield 12-ish bars. But you can compute the macronutrients for yourself to decide how big a serving should be.

In short, it's pretty similar to granola. Only without baking and without oil. I've found the flavor to vary widely depending on the honey/pb/whey used.

Sometimes, they taste like peanut butter cups. :)

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by 9wzYQbTYsAIc on Sunday November 27, 2022 @09:19PM (#33769133)
From the article: “The cranberry film can work as a replacement for film plastic, protecting fruits and vegetables with delicate skins, such as English cucumbers.”
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by jimmiebtlr on Sunday November 27, 2022 @08:51PM (#33768978)
Edible packaging would also be biodegradable and a big plus, agreed that trying to eat it would pretty much defeat the purpose.

Could make some interesting food items with an edible film though.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by WirelessGigabit on Sunday November 27, 2022 @09:22PM (#33769150)
Edible doesn't make sense, because then we need a removeable layer around it to protect the edible part.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by csande17 on Sunday November 27, 2022 @09:25PM (#33769168)
I think the parent comment is suggesting using it as a food ingredient, not as packaging. Like dumplings, or like how people make fancy desserts with edible gold leaf.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by 9wzYQbTYsAIc on Sunday November 27, 2022 @09:25PM (#33769169)
The article describes how this edible part is also anti-microbial, if it were to be consumed instead of just thrown in a composter.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by bee_rider on Monday November 28, 2022 @12:46AM (#33770208)
I wonder if it would be possible to design a wrapper that wild animals would happily eat. Hypothetically at least this would cut down on the effects of littering.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by amluto on Sunday November 27, 2022 @10:06PM (#33769380)
Muffin liners actually make more sense to me. It’s often hard to get a muffin liner off of the muffin without losing a lot of muffin. An edible liner that has a good texture might have some actual value.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by sockaddr on Sunday November 27, 2022 @11:53PM (#33769948)
Or you could just sit and try to scrape the residual muffin off with your teeth getting little crumbs all over you and sticky crap all over your fingers like a normal person. Don’t try to play god with your edible wrapper technology. This is the way it’s meant to be.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by robertlagrant on Monday November 28, 2022 @06:16AM (#33772221)
The scientists were so intent on seeing if they could improve muffins. They never stopped to consider if they should.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by fy20 on Monday November 28, 2022 @12:36AM (#33770156)
There are already edible materials that would work like waffle (as in ice cream cones) or rice paper. You could even call it something different to advertise it's green properties, like wuffin or ruffin.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by h4waii on Monday November 28, 2022 @01:15AM (#33770332)
I feel like "nuffin" makes good sense, nuffin' but edible muffin when you use nuffin wraps.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by alistairSH on Monday November 28, 2022 @09:32AM (#33774024)
I cooking muffins with liners the norm? We don't use them. A healthy smear of olive oil in the pan and the muffins come out just fine.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by irjustin on Sunday November 27, 2022 @10:25PM (#33769487)
water-soluable packaging would be impossible in high humidity environments.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by RajT88 on Monday November 28, 2022 @12:16AM (#33770069)
Yeah, this specific bio-material probably doesn't make sense for moisture and dirt.

However, the bio-plastics made from shellfish leftovers (think: crab, lobster, shrimp) would be appropriate for this.

The problem with petroleum based products (Styrofoam, plastics) is that they are crazy cheap due to our oil based economy. At some point the economics of that industry will change, and with it the prevailing winds on using plastics as building materials.

I would welcome more products being made as sturdy as they used to be. Take for example, pooper scoopers. It's actually quite difficult to buy a scissor-style one made of any kind of metal (there's one which is 80ish USD and made of steel - sort of a vanity product). They're all plastic. They all break, some sooner than others. The one I picked up from my parents' house recently was used from about 1990 to 2003 (and left outdoors since), and performs better than any of the plastic ones we used. It's wood and aluminum, and probably was no more expensive than the plastic ones on offer today. We broke a 25 dollar scooper within a month, and the scooper we inherited will likely outlive yet another dog.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday November 28, 2022 @12:23AM (#33770097)
> At some point the economics of that industry will change, and with it the prevailing winds on using plastics as building materials.

KSA can pump oil at current rates for 40 years at $20 per barrel.

That'll definitely be enough for global plastic consumption.

Economics itself isn't going to phase out plastics in my lifetime.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by labster on Monday November 28, 2022 @01:03AM (#33770275)
If oil demand decreases enough, it should get more expensive. It seems counterintuitive, but so much of the supply chain depends on moving large amounts of oil, refineries selling different grades of molecules to different customers, and oil companies not having to pay to shut down old wells. Heh, just kidding on the last one, oil firms never pay to shut down wells, they just sell to small firms which can go bankrupt instead.

But the big complicated supply chain for petrochemicals can break at lower scale. Compare how freaked out the markets have gotten at Meta and Netflix for losing users while still being profitable, and you can see how financing could dry up before the wells do.

I doubt it’s enough to phase out plastics, but it might make alternatives more economically viable.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday November 28, 2022 @09:02AM (#33773732)
None of this applies to KSA's oil - which is more than enough oil to meet plastic consumption for 100 years.

At $20 per barrel - the economics alone will be tough to beat with some other material.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by labster on Monday November 28, 2022 @08:04PM (#33782303)
Wow, I didn’t know that refining, shipping, and access to global capital didn’t apply to KSA. Such a magical country.

They’re going to need that magic when the primary export collapses — or if it doesn’t, wet bulb temperatures in the Gulf make it literally unlivable. The $20 a barrel will be even harder to sustain in a protracted civil war, which is where they are headed if they don’t diversify enough.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday November 28, 2022 @11:57PM (#33783859)
> Wow, I didn’t know that refining, shipping, and access to global capital didn’t apply to KSA. Such a magical country.

KSA refines all its own oil.

KSA doesn't need capital. It's a money printing machine - even at $30 per barrel.

Shipping will have some impact. ~40% of global shipping cargo is fossil fuels.

However, my guess is, fossil fuel shipping would get even cheaper, not more expensive.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by tylergetsay on Monday November 28, 2022 @12:28AM (#33770121)
From my understanding the shellfish bioplastic will trigger allergies so its not suitable for food wraps but can be okay things like straws
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by RajT88 on Monday November 28, 2022 @12:33AM (#33770139)
Huh. I don't see how those two things can both be true but OK.

Anyways. I am sure the boffins are working on the shellfish allergy angle.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by rocqua on Monday November 28, 2022 @04:12AM (#33771341)
Food wraps make the food completely unedible, whilst an allergic person could avoid the straw but still consume the drink??

Best argument I could come up with.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by friendlyHornet on Monday November 28, 2022 @05:20AM (#33771812)
Thanks for mentioning this; I have shellfish allergies and this was my first thought when I saw the parent comment mention shellfish-based wrapping
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by Grimburger on Monday November 28, 2022 @01:13AM (#33770320)
> shellfish leftovers

There's nowhere near enough of that and it's a natural resource we are already plundering at brutal levels.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by TylerE on Monday November 28, 2022 @03:17AM (#33771034)
It’s not like if throw the shell back in it’s gonna grow a new crab.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by jakewins on Monday November 28, 2022 @04:05AM (#33771308)
Additional sources of revenue for fisheries will increase the scope of which stocks are financially viable to destroy.

If world fisheries had shown that it was possible to control extraction such that we did not destroy stocks, then this would be a great way to meet a significant (~10%, it seems?) portion of world packaging plastics needs. However, it seems pretty clear that the fishing industry as a whole has any interest in ensuring sustainable production.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by yourapostasy on Monday November 28, 2022 @09:12AM (#33773818)
That's not sufficient macroeconomic justification to push the shellfish remains biofilm forward. See Cobra Effect [1].

This is reflexivity in action [2]. In the first year you start manufacturing this biofilm, your sentiment is true, it is using waste stream. In the Nth year, fisheries are collapsing shrimp stocks, flooding markets with shrimp to extract what used to be a waste stream to eke out ever decreasing margins in a vicious cycle.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reflexivity_(social_theory)

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by shalmanese on Monday November 28, 2022 @09:34AM (#33774057)
Or you just consume the entirety of the waste stream and then stop because it's a low value marginal add on product that doesn't drive an industry. It's not like the demand for cow manure is driving us to create brand new herds simply to output more manure.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by yourapostasy on Monday November 28, 2022 @10:19AM (#33774664)
Right now what saves us from the cobra effect with such a biofilm is hydrocarbon-based plastics are cheaper than it and the distribution and manufacturing networks are built around them. I'd be perfectly content with no concerns if there are no subsidies tampering with such biofilms; let them organically develop their own markets, manufacturing networks and supply chains, and I completely agree with you that they will naturally stop.

If well-intentioned government subsidies aggressively push for using the waste stream however (about the only way I see such a biofilm ever ramping up beyond niche markets), then it is very difficult to conceive those policy makers calibrating to the same homeostatic outcome. That's not how the plastics industry works. The demand scale is on such a bonkers level that distorts normal incentives.

I always worry about such reflexivity when these breathless articles come out about alternative production-side solutions to our current plastics production-consumption matrix. It's way more complex and large than most people understand outside that industry.

Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by shalmanese on Monday November 28, 2022 @11:53AM (#33775968)
If you compare the price/lb of shellfish vs the price/lb of plastic packaging, it's very hard to imagine any level of subsidy that would result in the tail wagging the dog.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by fullstop on Monday November 28, 2022 @10:10AM (#33774549)
I don't think that this is feasible, but shellfish molt quite frequently. They generally consume the molted shell, though.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by sn41 on Monday November 28, 2022 @01:28AM (#33770393)
Another point to add: rodents. This is an issue in large warehouses, in humid climates. Plastic is more resilient against rodents, since it is not edible.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by thombat on Monday November 28, 2022 @03:47AM (#33771208)
Cling film does nothing to keep pests out: beetles & weevils go through plastic bags and I've had a persistent rat chew through 2mm of hard plastic box. More important would be retaining the protective atmosphere that perishables are commonly packed with.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by numpad0 on Monday November 28, 2022 @05:04AM (#33771711)
Mites and liquids are issues too. Existing aluminized plastic packaging serves purposes to protect food against those.
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by taylorius on Monday November 28, 2022 @07:20AM (#33772711)
"since it is not edible". As of this time, but I wouldn't put it past them to evolve an ability to eat plastic somehow. (Though if they did, a new rat-based eco industry would be born)
Re:Could Dissolvable Cranberry Film Replace Plastic Packagin... by conorcleary on Monday November 28, 2022 @09:58AM (#33774399)
For rats, cats, raccoons, skunks, squirrels, chipmunks, and mice (standard warehouse dwellers) the digesting part of plastic isn't the main issue. The plastic may attract them, but the edible content in the plastic bags is often the target. Plastic of nearly any make is easily torn through (chewing, clawing, knawing, etc.) but the shear amount of plastic either as bag or pallet-wrap is the real issue, all over the world.

We need to at least start replacing the pallet-wrap with non-petroleum material.