News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by bobsmooth on Sunday November 20, 2022 @12:07AM (#33678464)
This article does have a point. Namely, nature is way better at building machines than humans are.

Compare this bee stinger to a needle or the wings of a butterfly to the iridescent materials we can create today.

https://i.imgur.com/a7wMjlu.png

Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by gsatic on Sunday November 20, 2022 @12:10AM (#33678481)
Nature had a head start. If you give me 100 million years I can build an ant too.
Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by polishdude20 on Sunday November 20, 2022 @12:34AM (#33678614)
At that point it's not you, its nature. Because you are an extension of nature. In a way, needles built by humans are needles built by nature.
Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by k__ on Sunday November 20, 2022 @07:34AM (#33680424)
We need to be more specific here.

It's both nature, but "evolution" took millions of years to build the ant, and "humans" could probably do it I a fraction of the time.

Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by polishdude20 on Sunday November 20, 2022 @11:27AM (#33682287)
Yes but evolution took that many years to build humans. I'm zooming out here and recognizing we are just another outgrowth of nature doing its thing.
Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by ARandomerDude on Sunday November 20, 2022 @12:25AM (#33678565)
No you couldn’t.

An ant is a system within a system within a system… Only God could build this.

Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by snorrah on Sunday November 20, 2022 @12:30AM (#33678596)
incorrect
Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by manquer on Sunday November 20, 2022 @12:44AM (#33678672)
There is no discussion possible with that line of reasoning. Invoking God is terminus for any discussion independent of your beliefs.

In your frame of reference consider as though God is building it through the human.

It still make no difference, whether we could still do it through conscious design than just evolutionary pressures which was what this discussion is really about.

Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by l3uwin on Sunday November 20, 2022 @01:16AM (#33678783)
Oh, which God?
Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by ketchuptomorrow on Sunday November 20, 2022 @12:43AM (#33678663)
Relevant reddit post https://www.reddit.com/r/Damnthatsinteresting/comments/cfm1z...

The picture is of a bee stinger compared to a sewing needle.

Someone in the comment section posted another comparison https://i.imgur.com/m2m6SV2.jpg

Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by bobsmooth on Sunday November 20, 2022 @01:23AM (#33678810)
That is the post I was thinking of when I made the comparison.
Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by lozenge on Sunday November 20, 2022 @04:13AM (#33679523)
My first reaction was "sewing needles are incredibly cheap, they're made to a budget" but actually, the same can be said for bee stingers.
Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by bnralt on Sunday November 20, 2022 @12:45AM (#33678678)
That's the funny things about the article. Though it mocks the idea, in the end we can't create a machine that has the same functionality as birds. Of course, humans only use a sliver of that functionality for their own ends, but even then we still raise billions of birds for our own ends. Most people still find cats to be the best way to hunt vermin, insect the best way to pollinate plants, seeing eye dogs better guides than any robot, snails better at auto-cleaning fish tanks than any device, dogs better at tracking scents in public than any machine, etc.
Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by scaramanga on Sunday November 20, 2022 @05:01AM (#33679723)
Dijkstra said the same thing. Why bother trying to make a computer think like a human? Why not make it do something better? I tend to agree.

Or to borrow from Chomsky, why would we try to make a machine deadlift a box like a powerlifter when we can just make a fork-lift truck / front-end loader?

Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by pas on Monday November 21, 2022 @04:41PM (#33698369)
Well, function implies form in this universe to some degree. The more functions we want to put into a machine the more it's form is constrained. If we want something that does all what birds do .. we need to build a bird.

That said we already have drones. We can add a charging station, an artificial beak, a speaker and it can do bird stuff pretty well :)

What we suck at is building self-replicators.

Cats are considered better vermin hunters than simple machines, like rat traps, because they have a lot of extra benefits of being household pets. (Which rat traps don't do well. Also usually dogs are used to hunt vermin. [I wanted to find that video where dogs hunt on the field as a tractor plows it, but only found this about minks :o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MB1I7UixASY ].)

Fish tank cleaning is also a very specific problem. It's basically a niche. If we look at it as an engineering challenge it's a hard problem. Small space, hard to reach spaces, mostly mechanical work is needed (as fish tank life is very sensitive to water quality), etc. And there's also cost. It's very possible that if we were to spend a few billion dollars on the problem we could come up with a fish tank cleaner, but ... snails are provided by evolution for free.

Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by qbrass on Sunday November 20, 2022 @01:01AM (#33678727)
Nature put a barbed stinger on bees, but didn't intend for the stinger to leave the bee.

On the other hand, the risk of ripping your entrails out while using a sewing needle is quite low.

Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by bobsmooth on Sunday November 20, 2022 @01:05AM (#33678740)
> but didn't intend for the stinger to leave the bee.

Nature didn't anticipate the hairless apes to get so numerous and infiltrate every environment where bees exist.

Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by crawfordcomeaux on Sunday November 20, 2022 @01:07AM (#33678752)
I'm guessing the stinger evolved in response to most insects, not humans. Here's a video explaining how they don't necessarily always lose their stinger, even when they sting humans.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-C77ujnLZo

Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by thaumasiotes on Sunday November 20, 2022 @02:13AM (#33679004)
> Nature put a barbed stinger on bees, but didn't intend for the stinger to leave the bee.

In the sense that any natural development is intended, it's intended for the stinger to leave the bee. Compare wasps, which have reusable stingers.

Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by usrbinbash on Sunday November 20, 2022 @02:24AM (#33679055)
The stinger of bees evolved as a defense/attack mechanism against other insects, covered by a chitineous exoskeleton.

Sticking it into the elastic material that covers mammals is not it's intended use case.

Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by imhoguy on Sunday November 20, 2022 @02:44AM (#33679145)
> but didn't intend for the stinger to leave the bee

On swarm level it doesn't matter. But psychological effect on an attacker or even group of such is achieved after one event, sometimes even inherited.

Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by leobabauta on Sunday November 20, 2022 @10:36AM (#33681710)
I love the idea that nature has intentions, and that if it did, we could know what they are. Deliciously magical!
Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by unsupp0rted on Sunday November 20, 2022 @01:35AM (#33678852)
We can make a needle that’s much more svelte and efficient than a bee stinger.

Perhaps not economically at mass scale though.

But then again neither can bees.

Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by sircastor on Sunday November 20, 2022 @04:08AM (#33679491)
I think the difference is though, that nature doesn’t intend to make something. A friend of mine once described evolution as not running toward something, but rather running away from something. And there are millions of years of wrong-turns, and vestigial remnants of things that didn’t work out.
Re:Planes are still decades away from displacing most bird jobs by jillesvangurp on Sunday November 20, 2022 @07:56AM (#33680539)
Nature takes a long time to build and specialize things though. We humans for example took some time to get going. But now in the space of a few generations, we've gone from soldering together some transistors and other electronics to building software systems that can do a lot of things. Some of the people that did the soldering and early tinkering with software are still alive even.

So, we're a bit impatient but overall things are moving really quickly. I'm only 48 years old, I expect to see some amazing things in the next few decades.