> Lawyers tell Axios the main criminal risk Bankman-Fried faces is an indictment on charges of fraud — one of the more common charges in white-collar prosecutions. But to convict, prosecutors must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that someone had knowledge or intent to commit fraud, which can be tricky, they say.
> That’s why the defense against such charges typically centers on something like, "It wasn't fraud, I was just really bad at my job."
> "Typically, in a fraud case, the person at the top argues that he was inattentive, delegated to others, and wasn’t focused on the details," Mariotti tells Axios. "The point is to argue that he was sloppy or inattentive, not a fraudster."
>The point is to argue that he was sloppy or inattentive, not a fraudster.
If that's going to be his strategy there's still a lot of laughs to have at his expense.
If only it were that easy, "oh I didn't knew I was crossing the border with a hundred pounds of cocaine in my car", like, how come they never thought of THAT? LOL
That said if it is some random retired couple with zero idea what is going on and 10 kilos of coke in their spare tire, as long as they co-operate, most gov’ts wouldn’t prosecute them.
If you can plausibly convince everyone, for instance, that you legitimately thought that the car you got into and drove away was your car, then you didn’t commit car theft.
Good luck with that 99.9% of the time of course.
This is in comparison to strict liability crimes, like drug possession or statutory rape that don’t require knowledge or intent.
Fraud requires that you knew you were lying (essentially), or should have known, to be fraud.
You can’t accidentally commit fraud.
Near as I can tell, SBF would have to somehow convince everyone he had been brain dead while collecting billions of dollars to pull that off here, but hey - defense attorneys have to try something I guess?
It doesn’t requiring knowing what you’re doing is against some law.
It requires knowing what you’re doing (which is against a law).
If what you did is very different from what you thought you were doing because of a legitimate mistake of fact (aka you thought it was your car, but it was not), then you’re not guilty of the crime, because you didn’t realize what you were doing was the thing that was a crime.
It’s roughy why not guilty by reason of insanity is a legitimate defense in some cases.
If someone is so insane they can’t understand what they were actually doing, or the thing they legitimately thought they were doing isn’t a crime, they weren’t committing the crime. That does mean they are probably such a danger to themselves or others they need to be locked up somewhere though.
As with the car defense, it is a very difficult thing to prove in most cases, and for good reasons
Many analysts did DCF modeling and $22 per FTT looked reasonable.
And we are yet to see whether they throw the book at her.
There is a paper/tweet trail a mile long that SBF was trying to cover up malfeasance that pretty clearly shows mens rea in my opinion.
Knowingly driving a car someone else stole is illegal, even if you don't actually know it's a crime to drive a car someone else stole (after all you didn't steal it, maybe you bought it from the person). Driving a car that was stolen that you didn't know was stolen is not illegal.
The system also reported small amounts ($400m) last time I checked.
This misrepresentation is fraud.
Could be legit, he's literally digging, admitting to blatant criminal behaviour like it's normal stuff.
> like, "oh FTX doesn't have a bank account, I guess people can wire to Alameda's to get money on FTX" > ..3 years later.. > 'oh fuck it looks like people wired $8b to Alameda and oh god we basically forgot about the stub account that corresponded to that and so it was never delivered to FTX'
I'm not trying to defend his actions him and I think he should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law, but honestly, I kind of get what he's saying. I've worked at enough start ups where everything is always chaos and speed and scrappiness are valued above all else, that I feel like I've seen this multiple times. It's like, someone makes a dumb choice and everyone goes, "we'll that's not great, but it's working and it's not that bad, so I don't want to make it my problem" and eventually that dumb decision is just how things are. Eventually, new people join the company and don't realize things aren't this way intentionally and eventually one of them adds another dumb decision on top of that and the same cycle plays out again.
After a few years, you end up with multiple of your processes or parts of your infrastructure based on these chains of bad choices and the one of them collapses. When you're close to the problem, each of the decisions on their own don't look too bad, but when you step back and summarize it in one sentence, it's clear how fucked up things are.
It's funny because he smugly spends the start of this article arguing about how pointless regulators are, but I feel like if there was actually regulation in the space, there's a good chance they would have slowed things down enough to catch these bad decision chains.
I don't think he intentionally lost peoples' money, but I think he was intentionally reckless and for that reason he should be prosecuted.
How do you suppose they took a directional bet, with customer funds, and lost, unintentionally?
SBF's claim is that FTX customers sent money to Alameda and nobody remembered to categorize it as FTX client money.
This is about as believable as my 11yo saying he didn't realize he had to pay for the $50 worth of Pokemon cards he took from Wawa. (This was after he originally claimed the cards were a gift from a friend at camp -- a friend whom he could neither name nor describe to us.)
I’m still trying to understand why investors would entrust their money with them. Why did the press fawn all over him? He talked a big game, but so have literally hundreds of others!
Like, if you are releasing financial documents and a large entry is "HIDDEN POORLY INTERNALLY LABELED ACCOUNT.", it is hard to explain that without getting into outright malice or negligence so extreme that it is difficult to differentiate from malice. Even rudimentary reviews of their finances would have highlighted stuff like this, and they clearly had money to pay people to help them do it.
No one was doing things like that intentionally, but as the company started to grow, so did peoples' egos and they people begin to confuse being reckless with being innovative.
No, it's media damage control. Gets you to think about unverifiable stuff like personal motivation instead of what his company actually did.
It revelatory that VOX interviews him instead of investigating him.
> more careful accounting
Maybe it's just me being cynical. Maybe benefit of hindsight. Maybe a little of both. And talking with my partner, who is working towards a CPA and absolutely loves forensic accounting.
"Careful accounting" doesn't in any way mean "doing the right thing financially", though it is certainly meant to imply that.
"Careful accounting" is "hiding where the bodies/cash is buried".
Really not so different from archilego/ hwang or London metals exchange fiasco or gilt fiasco or oil going negative or cds fiasco or LTCM.
I mean this is like nested layers of stupidity. You'd be stupid to do this, you'd be stupid to think it's not a major crime, you'd be stupid to think that this was in any way acts as a defense of your crime and you'd be stupid to actually tell people that this is what you did thinking that it's a defense for the crime you committed.
Guy literally though that Ponzi schemes would be legal if only the perpetrators on the way to court wrote on a document "I hereby lend myself all the money I misappropriated"?