People can and do spam Uniswap with fake tokens, because it is wide open and anyone can interact with it. That doesn't necessarily mean that people are losing large percentages of their net worth, or that large amounts are being lost trading these tokens. I don't know the numbers myself, but if 99% percent of Uniswap trades are WBTC, ETH, LINK, USDC, USDT, DAI, and other big-name tokens, and 1% are scams, then the scale of the problem is not at all what is implied by the headline.
This matters from a policy perspective because headlines like this disparage one of the best things to emerge from crypto in recent years: DeFi.
DeFi apps like Uniswap are safer than centralized exchanges because you can see everything that is happening on-chain, and maintain custody of your own tokens. Most people who were relying of FTX have been screwed by the exchange itself, regardless of the market value of the token that you thought you owned. If you lose money on Uniswap it's not because the exchange did something wrong, but because the issuer of the token did something wrong, or simply because the token you purchased fell in value.
It's preposterous to call a marketplace where less then 3% of the offerings are "legit" a safe market to use.
Its a digital marketplace. The digital space is full of attempted scams that never come to fruition, and their presence is no indication of engagement. Is that really that hard to wrap your head around?
I’m sure the AOL walled garden had much higher quality content than the internet at large.
[1] or whatever they are using now
What they'll conclude reading this is "wow, crypto is full of scams" and be right.
Email and Uniswap are both useful tools that are safe to use for even non-technical users. In fact Uniswap is safer as spam filters aren't 100% reliable but Uniswap's lists nearly are.
> “97% of the tokens are scams so Uniswap is unsafe to use"
People are likely to draw the unsafe assumption.
Sargos attempted to clarify that some safety is created with filtering via a trusted list.
My conclusion reading it was, crypto tokens are 98% scams. Uniswap is an exchange. It's a utility, using an open protocol. It's makeup reflects the makeup of the domain.
I told you.
If there's 100 tokens listed on the front page, and one of them is a scam, that may be near 0%, but it's equally near to 2%.
I'd be pretty confident that there's a >1% chance of being scammed on a platform like this. FTT wasn't thought to be a scam until it was proven to be.
Unless a token issuer does so with fully audited accounting with real assets backing their tokens, why should any token not be default assumed to be a scam, instead of default assumed to be valid?
Popularity and usage doesn't change this point. USDT may be incredibly popular, but it also lacks credibility.
Disclaimer: I still remain long BTC (lol@myself)
Ignoring anything else you might have gotten wrong, the comment you are responding to didn't say a 2.3% chance of being scammed, it said a 2.3% chance of NOT being scammed, which is nowhere near 0% or 2%, as it comes from abusing the 97.7% figure from the paper.
I think the majority of those top 100 tokens are not properly audited with tangible assets backing them.
FTT remains the most recent glowing example.
To fix your analogy, it's like a payment processor having thousands of fake storefronts able to accept payment. If 97% of their volume was to those fake entities then definitely shut them down but most of the volume would be Amazon and Walmart and the fake storefronts wouldn't even be a rounding error.
Volume info: https://info.uniswap.org/
Reminds me of "it either works or it doesn't, so there's a 50/50 chance"
And excluding users who haven't gone through that education hardly seems like the democratization of finance that these services advertise.
So uneducated users would really have to go out of their way to get scammed through there. Like having to go out of their way to follow up on a solicitation from something caught in a Gmail spam filter.
There's also the obvious case of the scammers getting a user to actually buy the token (perhaps through spam email or "pump groups" that give explicit instructions on how to perform the swap) which I'm not saying has never happened but I do claim is more rare. Even the obviously silly scam emails do have the occasional person click on them and lose their money. The upside is that getting scammed on Uniswap is actually harder as you need to manually bypass safety features.
It looks at transactions and attempts to classify coins as scam or not.
It doesn’t make any claims about the volume in scam coins. That’s more a clickbait headline and HN thread thing.
It’s most trying to contribute an algorithm for identifying scam coins.
See the appendix for features from the transactions that they used for their algorithm.
Uniswap filters the tokens available the same modern email providers filters email. If you go looking in the spam folder and fall pray to a scam there, it is your fault, not the fault of the email provider.
I am mainly wondering about Uniswap being described as safe.
If you want to trade an unlisted token by adding the contract address manually, sure you can do that. But then it’s on you if you get scammed, like if you follow through on a solicitation from a spam email.
I don't know anything about the space, but it sounds like a fact and statistic that should be front and centre in peoples face all the time.
85% of all email is spam[1]. But that's not a value judgment on the technology--Humanity can still get value from email.
Sturgeon's law says 90% of everything is crap. If you deal with other humans, you need a way to sift through that crap. In the case of email, that means use a spam filter. In the case of crypto, it means don't buy shitcoins.
This is their marketing message "Put your crypto to work. With Gemini Earn, you can receive up to 8.05% APY on your cryptocurrency." This is done by buying and holding stablecoins. Just curious how do you suppose they return such high APY on stablecoins without doing the exact same scam as FTX?
[1]https://www.bbb.org/us/ny/new-york/profile/cryptocurrency-ex... [2]https://www.trustpilot.com/review/gemini.com
The only scams possible in the _logic_ of Uniswap are those which would be considered bugs in the code.
Obviously, as this article points out — that’s not a panacea for _all_ scams. But I am surprised that people on a forum about hacking can’t see why eliminating an entire class of bugs could be useful.
No true crypto enthusiasts would use a centralized exchange. If they’re using an exchange, they must not be a true crypto enthusiast.
To say that centralized exchanges whom you trust to keep your assets in their custody run counter to the spirit of a system conceived with trustlessness as the defining feature is not rhetorical voodoo or fallacious reasoning.
Is there a “Every Man a Scotsman” saying?
The comment didn’t say “you’re not a crypto enthusiast _unless_ you believe X”. It just made an assertion (which, for what it’s worth, I think is incorrect) that the majority have a certain belief.
It really doesn’t matter to the meaning of my comment whether the first sentence exists or not. You can simply remove it if you like, the rest of the comment is still comprehensible. And, most importantly, its main point - to differentiate between the kind of exchange the gp was referencing and the kind the post is about, still stands.
This is all just a case of nitpicking some small detail that is so common and annoying. It’s the “your battery is dying” to a screenshot.
Even disregarding that, are we really posting wikipedia links to No True Scotsman in 2022? Has anyone not heard of NTS? It just comes across as pedantic.
Finally, you’re all hung up on the definition of “crypto enthusiast” — but it doesn’t even have meaning in the specific context. It’s just an attempt to shorten a much longer comment (like this one).
In my head, crypto enthusiast was just the 15 character version of “that group of people who are very interested in the programming and theory of decentralized economies. They tend to attend crypto conferences, program solidity or other smart contract dsls, and use phrases like ‘not your keys, not your crypto’”.
In that context the statement was mostly tautological stage setting for the rest of the comment, so for the whole thing to get derailed by low effort, kind of rude, attempts “but it’s an almost, but not quite logical fallacy (well, NTS isn’t actually a logical fallacy, but I am going to snarkily imply it is one)” sniping is not only wasted space … it’s boring.
Not addressing the argument, but pointing out a fallacy on Wikipedia.
I hope this irony was intended!
It's just neutral infrastructure. Trying to think of an analogy, I thought... "It would be like saying 98% of transactions in $USD are scams, that wouldn't mean $USD are unsafe to use."
But once i said that in my head... it would definitely say something about a traditional currency if 98% of transactions were scams. (I know uniswap isn't a currency, that just came out of my attempt at an analogy). Something not good. About something. Maybe it doesn't mean uniswap is unsafe to use, but wow, it means something is a mess.
If it just means that there are a crazy ton of people trying scams with tokens, that sure seems like something to be aware of.
If 98% of Uniswap trades were scams then I definitely wouldn't be here discussing it.
The same applies to your USD analogy. It doesn't matter if 98% of transactions are scams if these 98% are worth a few dollars only. A scammer could make a million transaction worth a cent each. That's very different from a trillion dollars being used in a few big scam transactions.
Finally, somewhere I can sell my slaves easily!
Users do not see these tokens unless they actively search them out. Uniswap uses the TokenList standard (https://tokenlists.org/) and by default users only see tokens such as the top 100 projects on CoinGecko. There are many lists created by reputable players such as Aave and Gemini which cover the entire gamut of projects users want to trade without exposing end users to scam tokens.
I believe this is a good system and has worked well as having any kind of listing process or even a DAO introduces subjectivity and provides points of capture for bad actors. With an open listing process and standards like TokenLists we can say that Uniswap is truly a public good and will be around as long as we need it which provides a guaranteed way to swap any asset for any other asset no matter who created it or how controversial it is which is a good primitive for humanity to be able to rely on.