News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:97.7% of tokens launched on Uniswap were scams and rug pulls by pyrale on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:19AM (#33572770)
Yeah, people should remember that they have 2.3% chance of not getting scammed on uniswap. That's the definition of safe to use.
Re:97.7% of tokens launched on Uniswap were scams and rug pulls by Sargos on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:25AM (#33572819)
Misconceptions like yours are why the title is misleading. If you go to Uniswap right now you will not see any of these tokens and have a near 0% chance of being scammed.
Re:97.7% of tokens launched on Uniswap were scams and rug pulls by oarsinsync on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:40AM (#33572935)
> If you go to Uniswap right now you will not see any of these tokens and have a near 0% chance of being scammed

If there's 100 tokens listed on the front page, and one of them is a scam, that may be near 0%, but it's equally near to 2%.

I'd be pretty confident that there's a >1% chance of being scammed on a platform like this. FTT wasn't thought to be a scam until it was proven to be.

Unless a token issuer does so with fully audited accounting with real assets backing their tokens, why should any token not be default assumed to be a scam, instead of default assumed to be valid?

Popularity and usage doesn't change this point. USDT may be incredibly popular, but it also lacks credibility.

Disclaimer: I still remain long BTC (lol@myself)

Re:97.7% of tokens launched on Uniswap were scams and rug pulls by saurik on Saturday November 12, 2022 @11:14AM (#33574388)
> ...but it's equally near to 2%.

Ignoring anything else you might have gotten wrong, the comment you are responding to didn't say a 2.3% chance of being scammed, it said a 2.3% chance of NOT being scammed, which is nowhere near 0% or 2%, as it comes from abusing the 97.7% figure from the paper.

Re:97.7% of tokens launched on Uniswap were scams and rug pulls by oarsinsync on Sunday November 13, 2022 @04:17AM (#33581403)
As amused as I am to be roasted by the great cydia himself, ignoring all the other things I got wrong, I wasn’t actually responding to the 2.3% claim, but rather the original claim that the top 100 tokens on the front page weren’t scams.

I think the majority of those top 100 tokens are not properly audited with tangible assets backing them.

FTT remains the most recent glowing example.

Re:97.7% of tokens launched on Uniswap were scams and rug pulls by pyrale on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:00AM (#33573103)
It's not misconceptions, it's accepting that the whole ecosystem is fraudulent, and that as an intermediation layer, uniswap fails to protect consumers. If any payment processor was letting 97.7% of its merchant users be fraudulent, they would be closed yesterday.
Re:97.7% of tokens launched on Uniswap were scams and rug pulls by Sargos on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:07AM (#33573150)
This paper is discussing listings and not volume. No one is claiming these tokens had any amount of meaningful volume and most likely weren't even traded by a real user. If 97% of Uniswap's volume was fraudulent then I wouldn't even give it the time of day.

To fix your analogy, it's like a payment processor having thousands of fake storefronts able to accept payment. If 97% of their volume was to those fake entities then definitely shut them down but most of the volume would be Amazon and Walmart and the fake storefronts wouldn't even be a rounding error.

Volume info: https://info.uniswap.org/

Re:97.7% of tokens launched on Uniswap were scams and rug pulls by throwup on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:36AM (#33572910)
This is logically incoherent. It would only be true if you chose a token completely at random instead of choosing a widely-used token you wanted to use.

Reminds me of "it either works or it doesn't, so there's a 50/50 chance"

Re:97.7% of tokens launched on Uniswap were scams and rug pulls by socialismisok on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:40AM (#33572941)
Trusting all individuals to make safe decisions in a marketplace flooded with scams is just not scalable. You cannot educate every user in how to identify a scam.

And excluding users who haven't gone through that education hardly seems like the democratization of finance that these services advertise.

Re:97.7% of tokens launched on Uniswap were scams and rug pulls by eswat on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:59AM (#33573097)
If we’re talking about Uniswap specifically, it actually does a decent job of adding guardrails (only listing curated tokens from the Token Lists standard) and warning about unsafe actions (confirmation prompts when you are adding an unlisted token to swap).

So uneducated users would really have to go out of their way to get scammed through there. Like having to go out of their way to follow up on a solicitation from something caught in a Gmail spam filter.

Re:97.7% of tokens launched on Uniswap were scams and rug pulls by runnerup on Saturday November 12, 2022 @12:21PM (#33575055)
As much as If genuinely like a marketplace for shitcoin/scamcoins that I can gamble on and hope to beat the exit dump crash, I admit that uneducated consumers protections probably should trump my desires to participate in this gambles.