Just don't care about it that much, really. My main account has been at https://functional.cafe for years now, but I'm posting about pretty much everything there: programming, music, art, politics, current events, shitposting.
> and also isn’t run by someone whose (perhaps currently unespoused) views I’d find problematic?
Ask someone from your friend circle who's already on Fediverse, but also see the above point.
But I think that's the important point. Right now, there's nothing wrong with Mastodon. Mastodon is working fine. A couple of servers that people commonly encounter first are having growth issues. But those servers aren't Mastodon any more than Gmail is email.
I would further say there's a marketing problem that Mastodon advocates keep saying this situation is normal, expected and it's working fine, which is obviously quite offputting.
And that's what a lot of tech people don't get, to normies actually Gmail does equal Email and such. You're not going to get the bulk of everyday people on these platforms until you think in their shoes and provide features (and don't have downtime on your main servers) that fit their experiences.
I'd love to hear of some evidence for that. I've never encountered anyone assuming that the bit after the @ has to be gmail.com, or being unclear and uncertain if they can communicate between their work Outlook account and their home Gmail account. This feels very much like someone's taken the idea "to most people, the internet just is the web" and run wild with it.
GMail was invite only for a very long time at the beginning fwiw
And in the end, people (who left willingly) ended up back on twitter anyway just because people kept sharing things from there. But also because the alternative services could not keep up with the momentum, resulting in degraded service. So everyone seemed to collectively go "meh" and returned to twitter.
I predict everyone will be back on twitter once all this blows over, and especially if alternatives can't keep up. Uptime and reliability seem to be more important than features, freedom, or just about anything else.
I remember the failwhale days, but this is different.
Twitter is a VC-backed company that had the resources to build out their infrastructure.
Mastodon is a bunch of volunteer-run servers and it looks pretty obvious they aren’t going to be able to handle the infusion of new users… unless there’s an infusion of resources.
I’m on mastodon.social and it has slowed to a crawl, compared to what I was used to 6 months ago.
Also the UI/UX isn’t great. Say what you will about Twitter, but they’ve built a pretty slick web application and native apps. People used to the simplicity of Twitter are going to struggle, if the complaints on my Twitter timeline are any indication.
It's very transparent, which I like -- "we got a bunch of new users, the server bill is going up $2k a month overall so if you can pitch in please do" is extremely clear and seems to work effectively. An individual server seems like it should be able to charge for hosting your account like with email if it needed to be operated like a business.
So far it doesn't really seem like it needs to operate like a business, it just takes longer for collectives of humans to respond to changes in needs than a giant enormously wealthy company that knew what would happen in advance. I'm sure it will equilibrate, it has the last two times this happened.
Edit: And a few minutes after posting this, a wiki link showed up in my Masto stream with numerous suggestions and tips:
<https://joinfediverse.wiki/How_to_host_your_own_Fediverse_in...>
What I’m worried about is my reputation - what the server I’m associated with tells others about me (the argument that those others are wrong in making assumptions doesn’t comfort me).
These hazards are probably very unlikely, of course, but the alternative of ‘how about I just avoid all these hazards’ is the one my lizard brain is picking.
It was a very unfortunate and frightening view into what can quickly happen with the fediverse.
Unlike Twitter, you can leave a Mastodon server for another one and take your follows and followers with you.
If you want assurances that a server owner will never act against your will, you need to take the same action you would to mitigate a landlord acting against your will. Buy your own place.
In a decentralized universe you have to start thinking of servers as real estate. Nothing is free but if your goal is to get someone chooses to share with you what they paid for for free, you take what you can get. Or buy your own server for only yourself, or share with others.
This is what the world looks like without tracking and advertizing trying to make everything seem free.
I eventually chose fosstodon.org which seems like about the most vanilla thing that's open to new users and where I have a decent claim to being the right kind of person. I suspect a lot of people will look at the long list of furry-centric instances and conclude Mastodon is not for them. IDK, maybe that's considered a feature.
Just pick one that feels right. Maybe you are French or Korean and like a server in French or Korean, or maybe you feel very strong about politics: the make that a parameter. Otherwise just go for any "general" server.
Just like with email, people will generally just pick Hotmail, AOL, xs4all.nl, yahoo or email, without much thought. This is fine.
You can easily move later if you ever find a community that you wish to be part of.
That's exactly what I tried, and failed, to do. As far as I was able to discover, including via the site being discussed here, there are no such servers currently available for new signups.
So this is temporary, and certainly not a fundamental issue.
But as numerous people replied, many alternatives are ready or wip. Many of them make hosting really easy. Since that thread I tried several. Gotosocial being my favorite, now.
So this too isn't fundamental. Because 'mastodon' is about much more than this one piece of software. It's a network, the fediverse. And you can easily host a near 1-1 mastodon alternative today on a cheap, VPS.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33120136&p=2#33120419
I don't want to think about what server I'm on. I want the whole thing to just work. The fact that there is only one Twitter and only one Facebook are actually advantages in the marketplace for those services.
Think of it like your phone number, it's a service and you need a provider. Choose one by location https://umap.openstreetmap.fr/en/map/mastodon-near-me_828094 makes no difference, they all talk to each other and you can move servers at any time
And it's curated for servers that are open for registration so hopefully no dead ends
This is especially true now that there is an official system to change/move servers.
Maybe I’m the exception but for me almost without exception the answer is that I want to run my own instance.
What’s the point of leaving a centralized system for a decentralized one if you still let someone else own your data?
Opine:
The "tell me what to think" motivation is frustrating from multiple perspectives:
- overt bias of the Tellers is rife with unethical potential
- low engagement of the Users is a part of communication, it's reality and why the style of Exciting Content (insert emojis) has become popular in modern communication vs the 'respectably formatted and spell-checked' of yesteryear
This is what freedom looks like, vs going to a defacto centralized megacorp and having them tell you where to live so that they can most efficiently manipulate and spy on you for profit.
Everyone has become far too accustomed with exploitative corpos telling them what to do on the internet. Choices are harder, but healthier.
Just make a choice, and you can make a different one later.
This, to me, is the central problem in the Fediverse.
You use the built-in[0] migration feature. Create an account on your new instance, point it at your old one. Then point your old account to your new one.
[0] Built in to Mastodon, anyway. YMMV with other Fediverse software.
Yes, of course. That involves a mortgage, location, the logistics of moving...
Yes! Doesn’t everyone to some degree? That’s a huge decision that takes me days to decide.
Just make a choice, and you can make a different one later.
If we’re going with a housing analogy, this is pretty terrible advice. But I don’t think the housing analogy really applies. Where someone lives says (in my mind) a lot less about them - but is also a much more important personal decision.
You’ve implied a few times in this thread that complaints about Mastodon are because people are somehow accustomed to being told what to do by corporations. That is quite hyperbolic, and I also don’t really think it’s true.
I don’t see how caring about what a public choice appears to say about me has anything to do with that.
That is indeed something I've applied to buying an apartment in the past. I bought an apartment and ended up not liking it too much, so I sold it and bought a different one a few years later. Now I'm thinking about selling it again and buying something in a different part of the world. I don't see why making a choice and making a different one later is bad advice here.
Of course, there are choices that are difficult to reverse. Then some hesitation makes sense in my opinion.
Mastodon could probably use a directory service independent of the network service.
It is a bit like snail mail forwarding address.
I agree a directory server is probably a good call. It proved to be useful in Matrix.
When I was ready to buy a home, I looked at one, made an offer, and bought it.
Life is a lot easier when you know your practical success criteria and are decisive when something meets it.
I truly think most people today are too accustomed to letting algorithms live their lives for them.
It is not that much different from choosing an email provider.
The analysis paralysis this induces is incredible.
That’s not true though, is it?
Aren’t you able to consume content from anywhere else in the fediverse?
Now Blockbuster is gone and there are a pile of other ways to obtain movies out there and you are complaining that choosing one is hard. It is entertainment and they all have access to the same movies so it is not that important of a choice.
Just do it!
I will note that for you "as a content producer" the uniformly reverse chronological presentation on Mastodon highly penalizes older posts (even a day old!) to an extent that is pretty rough to get used to, and that makes those older posts pretty irrelevant to move over. This is much like Twitter before its engagement-maximization algorithm days, though.
I searched for managed mastodon and found plenty of options.
https://elest.io/open-source/mastodon
https://federation.spacebear.ee/software/mastodon
I expect many more will emerge now that demand is increasing.
- move your account to a different server
- use your account as a sign-on for other ActivityPub based services
- easily discover content that your server doesn't already know about
I've been on Mastodon since 2016. I've switched instances twice, once when the instance was shut down (the maintainer gave several months' notice), once when instance ownership changed.
The first time was early enough that profile migration didn't exist ... and it still wasn't much of a deal. I follow a few hundred profiles, and am followed by about 2,000. It turns out that it's pretty easy to re-associate, at least for individuals. (Commercial / brand profiles with large follow/follower lists would have a different experience.) We reconnected pretty easily.
The more recent switch used profile migration. This brings along your followers / following lists, as well as block and mute lists, and is straightforward. Toots are not migrated, but for the most part Mastodon "lives in the present", and the back-catalogue isn't particularly significant. (I care more about this than most, and ... it's still not that big a deal.)
I actually have several active profiles, though all are forwarded to my primary active one: <https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius>. Again, if I need to fallback to another instance, I can.
Larger instances tend to be fairly anodyne. Smaller instances tend to fit niches, of both specific interests and policies. Pick something that looks reasonable. If you decide you want to change at a later date, it's not a big deal.
There doesn't seem to be many general servers that:
1. I can trust won't just shut down in a week.
2. Are accepting signups
3. And won't end up having a negative stigma a in year when the creator goes off a deep end. I know I can just switch to another instance, but I really don't want to have to do that frequently.
Matrix at least solves this by just having an official Matrix home-server. Matrix is still federated, but if you just want to just sign-up and join a chat room, you're not forced to pick a home-server that's specific to you or worry about the factors above.
How do I find a server that ‘matches’ me but doesn’t make me seem like an over-enthusiastic single-issue or single-hobby dedicant - and also isn’t run by someone whose (perhaps currently unespoused) views I’d find problematic?
Maybe I should just join what seems to be the default (because of its friendly domain?) of http://mastodon.social. But that seems defeat the purpose of decentralization - and (without evidence) I don’t really trust that mastodon.social is set up to handle the huge influx of users at the moment…