News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by bee_rider on Saturday November 05, 2022 @05:59AM (#33479813)
Where do attack helicopters fit into modern war, out of curiosity? From my very uninformed point of view -- seems like in a world where man-portable weapons are getting more and more capable, being in a relatively (compared to jets) slowly moving, lightly (?) armored flying vehicle would be pretty terrifying.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by simonh on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:32AM (#33480048)
I think we’re in a transition period where it looks like drones will probably replace scout and attack helicopters. In the mean time a chopper like this probably still has a role, but I think they’re on the wrong side of history with this.

For now though, while western militaries can afford to hand out LAWS and MANPADS to their troops like sweets, India’s main rivals probably can’t. Yes an individual MANPAD is much cheaper than a chopper, but to defend your entire army from a few dozen choppers you’ll need to hand out a heck of a lot of MANPADS to get the coverage.

The main saving grace of a system like this is that the munitions, unguided rockets and cannon rounds, are pretty cheap. In contrast while drones are much cheaper than the chopper, they’re very expensive as munitions.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by pjc50 on Saturday November 05, 2022 @07:50AM (#33480575)
The runtime cost of helicopters is pretty terrible, though. You can easily exceed the cost of several expendable "switchblade" type drones simply taking off and flying to the target.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by le-mark on Saturday November 05, 2022 @09:00AM (#33480991)
Range and eyeballs are the elements a lot of people leave out. Helos carry the eyeballs with them long ranges. Drones require radios with enough bandwidth for real time video. Which at the range of 100s of km is very non trivial and non cheap.

That’s to say switch blades don’t have comparable range obviously, and that’s not nothing.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by KptMarchewa on Saturday November 05, 2022 @11:56AM (#33482656)
You don't need 100km ranges when your drones are standard issue at company and platoon level.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by sandworm101 on Saturday November 05, 2022 @11:37AM (#33482478)
Apples and oranges. A switchblade is only ever useful against a target. It doesn't have the firepower to suppress enemy movement, to cover an allied advance, or decimate an area of ground when you cannot pinpoint a target's exact position. A helicopter with some FFARs and a machine gun can.

If the helicopter can do something that no drone can, then it does compete regardless of the extra cost/complexity/manpower needed to deploy it.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by simonh on Saturday November 05, 2022 @03:58PM (#33485025)
Exactly this, it ludicrous to try and compare the cost of a handful of switchblade drones, which are single use with a warhead equivalent to a light mortar shell, to an entire attack helicopter deployment.

No question helps are very expensive, but the vast majority of the costs are incurred whether you deploy it or not. They can range over hundreds of miles performing a wide variety of tasks and carry far more capable sensor, communications and weapon systems than drones.

As I said I think drones are here and very capable, and they’re the future for these sorts of missions, but we’re not quite there yet.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by ch4s3 on Saturday November 05, 2022 @09:17AM (#33481154)
It seems like helicopters coupled with drones and ground forces could play a role in a rapid advance. They’re probably DOA for urban environments though, just based on what we’re seeing in Ukraine.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by closewith on Saturday November 05, 2022 @11:03AM (#33482140)
> The main saving grace of a system like this is that the munitions, unguided rockets and cannon rounds, are pretty cheap. In contrast while drones are much cheaper than the chopper, they’re very expensive as munitions.

Based on the current war in Ukraine, this isn't true at all.

Even relatively expensive loitering munitions (compare to mortars dropped from DJI drones) like the Switchblade 600 cost in the range of $10,000-20,000 per deployment, significantly cheaper than the flight costs for a rotary light attack sortie and much cheaper than even the "low-cost" missile option for the Prachand (the Thales FZ275 LGR - the high-cost option is the MBDA Mistral, which costs $300,000 per deployment).

There is no scenario in which a manned rotary craft competes with a drone on cost.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by dfc on Saturday November 05, 2022 @12:29PM (#33482996)
> There is no scenario in which a manned rotary craft competes with a drone on cost.

What drone competes with a manned MH-74 on cost? It seems like the traditional drone advantages disappear when the payload is humans.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by sitkack on Saturday November 05, 2022 @12:41PM (#33483084)
Goal posts have now crossed state lines.

And to actually the thread, drones ARE being worked on that can go do search and rescue, bringing back the victim. Safer for crew, better coverage and can get into places a traditional rotor craft can't.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by MichaelCollins on Saturday November 05, 2022 @01:36PM (#33483641)
It's not a moved goalpost. Remember that Hind type helicopters are used in both transport and attack roles. There aren't yet any comparable drones, nor even any drones with a comparable transport lift capability. A drone which can lift a guy on a stretcher can only do a small fraction of what transport helicopters do.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by dfc on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:16PM (#33484090)
"There is no scenario" encompasses all the goal posts.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by sitkack on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @06:34PM (#33525724)
This whole thread was a great example of how internet forum debates go off the rails. No true scotsman can fit through the eye of needle carrying a coconut.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by closewith on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:54PM (#33484456)
Every drone competes favourably with Chinook on cost.

What you are comparing is capability, not cost, and by definition you cannot have an unmanned helicopter with pax.

To be honest, your reply is so disingenuous that I wonder if you're trolling?

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by bee_rider on Saturday November 05, 2022 @03:50PM (#33484937)
> Every drone competes favourably with Chinook on cost.

Technically the space shuttle had limited autopilot capabilities so you could see it as a drone carrying humans, one of which happens to be a pilot who will control it at other times, but that's just a coincidence. And it was way expensive. You fool, you absolute fool.

And anyway, what is a fly-by-wire system, but a drone that is piloted remotely... for very small definitions of "remote."

I dunno. I don't think there's any productive discussion possible with people who are (for some reason) willing to ignore context and widen your claims so you can be wrong.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by closewith on Saturday November 05, 2022 @03:53PM (#33484969)
> I dunno. I don't think there's any productive discussion possible with people who are (for some reason) willing to ignore context and widen your claims so you can be wrong.

I feel like you may be in need of some introspection.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by bee_rider on Saturday November 05, 2022 @03:55PM (#33484996)
I agree with you, my comments were sarcastic :)
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by closewith on Saturday November 05, 2022 @04:31PM (#33485342)
:O Oh, boy, my apologies! I fell hard to Poe's Law there...
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by bee_rider on Saturday November 05, 2022 @05:47PM (#33486189)
It was a pretty good response anyway, haha. "May be in need for some introspection" is always a classic.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by unity1001 on Saturday November 05, 2022 @02:00PM (#33483927)
> western militaries can afford to hand out LAWS and MANPADS to their troops like sweets

They can't. These are expensive in the West due to the privatized defense industry racking up prices. Russia and China can. And countries like India, who buy from them cheap, can.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by Sakos on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:32AM (#33480049)
Manpads really aren't all that effective against helicopters. I don't think anything has fundamentally changed in the past 40ish years in regards to the ubiquitousness of manpads or how they work. Helicopters are comparatively cheap, effective, flexible and difficult to shoot down without proper AA, but that's what combined arms is for, or a lot of luck. Only about 40 helicopters were lost to hostile fire in Iraq from 2004-2009. I'd say the flexibility is the main reason why you can't get rid of helicopters in modern armies. There are just things that planes can't do without protected airspace or a controlled airfield.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by T-zex on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:50AM (#33480182)
Manpads were a game changer in the Ukraine. orcs failed to establish air superiority partly due to the effectiveness of the manpads.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by baxtr on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:57AM (#33480237)
I am very much pro Ukraine and all that. But please let’s keep having respect for other humans. No matter how much we hate them. That’s also part of our value system we’re defending over there.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by causi on Saturday November 05, 2022 @07:18AM (#33480376)
"Orcs" is an incredibly gentle term, but fair enough, they're not literally orcs. "The Russian invaders who rape infants and then throw them in mass graves with their parents failed to establish air superiority partly due to the effectiveness of the manpads."
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by pxmpxm on Saturday November 05, 2022 @07:48AM (#33480565)
Oooh, do America/Iraq next
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by KingOfCoders on Saturday November 05, 2022 @08:35AM (#33480817)
Look up Phoenix program for wild things. Not to take any Iraqi victims lightly, but Vietnam had much more atrocities.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by pxmpxm on Saturday November 05, 2022 @09:33AM (#33481303)
I think you're collectively missing my point; the two parents in this thread are phenomenal example of https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/newsfeed/002/355/607/670

Related, but it's pretty eye opening to see left-leaning people being marketed and fully sold a war. I can only surmise this latest rehash of "support of troops" is about the best chance/narrative that team donkey has for the upcoming elections. Cognitive dissonance banalities(1) notwithstanding.

(1)https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/oct/25/democrats-jo...

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by baxtr on Saturday November 05, 2022 @11:37AM (#33482485)
Nice graphic. I have been thinking about this a bit.

I think a good way to say on which side you are is to ask: Could I protest here freely?

Most democratic systems will allow protests, no matter what the official/government position on the topic is.

Protesting and speaking your mind will get you in serious trouble elsewhere.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by KingOfCoders on Saturday November 05, 2022 @12:48PM (#33483160)
Yes I missed your point and thinking about it I don't know what's your point when you've said "Oooh, do America/Iraq next"

I thought it was about the relativity of a standpoint and mirror positions. For that I've replied "use Vietnam", because in the atrocities of the US Iraq is relativly moderate and not very interesting to do a "The American ..." but the Phoenix program is much more so.

But I didn't get it.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by causi on Saturday November 05, 2022 @07:54AM (#33480604)
That is also awful, and the way American leadership covered for those monsters nauseates me.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by lnsru on Saturday November 05, 2022 @09:02AM (#33481007)
I don’t think, that politics is a topic for HN. But orcs is too nice word for the beasts who put the corpses of men in the city center and force the little crying kids to identify their dead parents. And then shoot whole families as a punishment for resistance. And the western countries are very worried again.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by Sakos on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:52AM (#33480202)
This is HN. Can we not use derogatory terms here?
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by aliswe on Saturday November 05, 2022 @07:21AM (#33480400)
I thought he meant orcas, but I'm only basing this off CnC. Orcs as the fantasy creature? Thats just silly.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by tokamak on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:58AM (#33480238)
That's what he did. I can think of much worse.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by sandworm101 on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:53AM (#33480205)
Manpads have changed massively. There are still 30+yo systems in the field, which gives a false impression of the tech, but there are also very sophisticated new systems too.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by _kbh_ on Saturday November 05, 2022 @07:09AM (#33480310)
> Only about 40 helicopters were lost to hostile fire in Iraq from 2004-2009

Russia has lost that many helicopters in about 9 months in Ukraine, id say the effectiveness of helicopters is largely dependent on the capabilities of your opponent and whether or not you can gain air superiority.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by Sakos on Saturday November 05, 2022 @07:13AM (#33480335)
Russia has made a lot of mistakes that have nothing to do with Ukraine. I find it difficult to draw any accurate or useful conclusions from the war that translate to the US or Western armies other than don't repeat Russia's mistakes.

I certainly wouldn't base any opinion on the effectiveness of helicopters in general on Russian performance in the current war.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by _kbh_ on Saturday November 05, 2022 @08:07AM (#33480678)
> I certainly wouldn't base any opinion on the effectiveness of helicopters in general on Russian performance in the current war.

Sure but (and I could be wrong here) isn't this the first time that modern Russia helicopters has gone up against modern MANPADS in a near peer type of conflict?.

Id say it shows at least the effectiveness of different MANPADS against specific countermeasures no?.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by Sakos on Saturday November 05, 2022 @08:10AM (#33480691)
If the conclusions you want to draw are about Russia, fine. But it's simply not comparable to how Western armies function. I don't see how you're going to remove all the noise from the data like lack of maintenance, bad training, lack of readiness, outdated hardware, bad doctrine execution, bad leadership, etc.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by rjsw on Saturday November 05, 2022 @10:05AM (#33481584)
I think there will be statistics for the performance of Russian helicopters against western MANPADS from Afghanistan during the 80s. I'm not expecting that the MANPADS will have got worse since then.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by zaphirplane on Saturday November 05, 2022 @09:56AM (#33481523)
> I find it difficult to draw any accurate or useful conclusions from the war

How about the side that can out produce and outspend (or has friends that do) will come out on top. Same lesson from ww2 . The tricky bit it to stay standing till then

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by patentatt on Saturday November 05, 2022 @10:07AM (#33481603)
Same lesson that every RTS or 4x game has ever taught me! Just need to have the generals play more command and conquer.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by bee_rider on Saturday November 05, 2022 @01:02PM (#33483281)
Maybe they were playing Total War Warhammer instead, that would explain why they put their leaders so close to the front line...
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by bee_rider on Saturday November 05, 2022 @01:05PM (#33483306)
It seems hard to generalize lessons about wars. I remember commenters who thought the couple day timeline was realistic, presumably because they were used to the way the US invades countries. Most armies aren't Russia, most aren't the US...

I dunno, maybe we need to get, like, France and the UK to duke it out again? (kidding obviously).

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by sorokod on Saturday November 05, 2022 @07:56AM (#33480621)
My understanding is that many helicopters are not equipped with the necessary countermeasure systems. The Russians send out a mix of machines, some with and some without the necessary gear. These groups ore often ovewhelmed by multiple manpads fired at the same time.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by Spooky23 on Saturday November 05, 2022 @08:46AM (#33480887)
The Russians are a tough counter example because they are operating really poorly and seem unable to coordinate or train operators well.

Their use of tanks is a great example. Russian losses are huge, mostly because they aren’t coordinating with infantry and artillery fires.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by dfc on Saturday November 05, 2022 @12:41PM (#33483086)
Russian helicopters have had a rough time because of Stingers in Afghanistan and they do not seem to be fairing a lot better in Ukraine.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by chrisseaton on Saturday November 05, 2022 @06:07AM (#33479869)
Attack helicopters are designed for anti-tank, and some anti-infantry and escort. Yes they’re vulnerable. You’re trading off that risk with being able to being able to move extremely quickly and long distance compared to the tanks they’re fighting.

If you want to be very safe you can sit static encased in a metre thick steel shell, but you won’t achieve anything.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by rippercushions on Saturday November 05, 2022 @10:23AM (#33481740)
In an army, there is a perennial unsolved debate between the tank and the anti-tank corps. The tank guys think you'd be crazy to be on a battlefield if you're not protected by a solid meter of steel and capable of pulverizing anything you point your turret at, while the anti-tank guys think you're crazy if you're sitting trapped in the highly visible steel cage everybody is shooting at.
Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by blamazon on Saturday November 05, 2022 @07:15AM (#33480355)
Via the wiki article for this heli:

> The impetus for the development of the LCH Prachand came in the form of the Kargil War, a conflict fought between India and neighbouring Pakistan in 1999, which revealed the Indian armed forces lacked a suitable armed rotorcraft capable of operating unrestricted in the high-altitude theatre.

In that conflict, Pakistan downed more than one Indian MiG with a man-pad, so I presume this scenario is not lost on India w.r.t. development of this aircraft.

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by lm28469 on Saturday November 05, 2022 @08:58AM (#33480977)
I mean, nothing fits into modern war when cheap portable anti tank and air defense system exist.

It's always been the same, I think people are confused because for decades the US has been attacking AK47 wielding farmers with $$$ cutting edge technology but wars between relatively equivalent forces is always a blood bath, everything you can come up with has a cheaper counter measure

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by stickfigure on Saturday November 05, 2022 @09:24AM (#33481235)
Perun made a video about this:

End of the Helicopter? (no) - MANPADS and helicopter losses in Ukraine

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnoKpXvj41A

The TL;DR is "It's complicated".

Re:Indian Air Force inducts natively developed light combat ... by rg111 on Saturday November 05, 2022 @12:18PM (#33482880)
India has terrains and fronts, and enemies where such equipment will prove valuable.