News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by usrusr on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:25AM (#33421643)
Now that Falcon 9 landings have become so routine, it feels surprisingly wasteful to see that mission profile with the center booster burning up without even trying.

I wanted to write something about that lack of center booster reuse on falcon heavy feeling irrationally worse than a single F9 launch in the non-reusable profile (for a slightly higher payload iirc), but then I discovered that the non-reusable F9 profile hasn't happened in quite a while. Nice! When they started with the reuse, I was expecting the full payload profile to be a far more regular occurrence. (even if in hindsight I see that none of my reasons for that expectation make any sense)

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by BitwiseFool on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:29AM (#33421698)
>"wasteful to see that mission profile with the center booster burning up without even trying."

My understanding was that the intended orbit / mission profile means that they must fly the center core in expendable mode. Otherwise, the satellite wouldn't be able to reach the intended orbit with the intended amount of fuel for the mission's duration.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by bpodgursky on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:45AM (#33421884)
Hopefully once Starship launches, we'll never see a disposable core again.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by oconnor663 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:17AM (#33422384)
Even a reusable rocket reaches the end of its service life eventually, and at that point it can make sense for the last flight to be expendable.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by chroma on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:37AM (#33422651)
It's probably more cost-effective to keep the craft and scrap it. The structure itself is a significant amount of steel, and the engines contain expensive superalloys.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by oorza on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:44AM (#33422765)
If a spacefaring vessel lasts long enough that it needs to be decomissioned due to wear and tear, that mf'er belongs ONLY in a museum. I hope to live to the day where that isn't universally true, but it is not today.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by chroma on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @12:42PM (#33423656)
I'm sure the first couple will be preserved, but they'll quickly become as common as derelict airplanes or ships. Has SpaceX kept any of their Falcon 9 boosters besides the first one that landed? I think the old ones are disassembled for analysis, then scrapped.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by MichaelCollins on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @01:13PM (#33424113)
> I'm sure the first couple will be preserved, but they'll quickly become as common as derelict airplanes

I've always been a fan of putting such things on pedestals outside of public buildings, VFWs, etc. A bit less feasible with full rockets, but the engines at least would be fairly easy to put in parks so kids can climb on them.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by bombcar on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @01:28PM (#33424377)
You'd love Gasworks Park in Seattle: https://www.seattle.gov/parks/find/parks/gas-works-park
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by boogies on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @03:36PM (#33426324)
> TLS error [ignore]

> About

> Gas Works Park has a play area with a large play barn, and big hill popular for flying kites. Special park features include a sundial, and a beautiful view of Seattle. Access to Lake Union is restricted at Gas Works Park, as the lake sediment contains hazardous substances.

Appear that that description omits the lede! But the park does seem singularly interesting per the Wiki article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gas_Works_Park

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by bombcar on Wednesday November 02, 2022 @02:03AM (#33431875)
Yeah, the picture captures some of it, but you really have to see it (preferably with kids) as there's just giant old industrial equipment painted and ready to climb on. Some of the valves even turn!
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by TOMDM on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @12:23PM (#33423409)
Makes sense for NASA to donate, but say SpaceX could recover $10m in materials from an expended Starship, that's a steep ask.

When the time comes, I hope they choose to donate it to a museum, or if not, the funds are raised to buy it off them.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by bombcar on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @01:29PM (#33424393)
I mean it's a $10m ask/potential write-off, so there is that. The "first one" will be even more rare/valuable and NASA might make a deal for it.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by jpadkins on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @02:16PM (#33425138)
SpaceX would get considerably more than $10M in marketing / brand goodwill by donating to a museum. So for the first 1 or 2 decommissioned rockets, I think donation beats scrap ROI.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by chasd00 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @03:19PM (#33426072)
i've been to boca chica, starhopper and the older starships are quite literally parked on the side of the road. I bet if you showed up with the gear to move them they'd probably just give them to you ;)
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by verdverm on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:48AM (#33421943)
They are different classes of launch vehicles. This payload is not really a good one for starship, and conversely, starlinks will never fly on heavy
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by bryanlarsen on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:58AM (#33422103)
Yes, it's really odd to see a GEO launch rather than a GTO at launch. GTO is a geosynchronous transfer orbit with apogee at GEO and perigee at LEO that uses the satellite's thrusters to circularize to full GEO. Starship can't do a GEO directly, it would need refueling or a kick stage to do GEO.

Since we really don't know why the Space Force wanted direct GEO we can't know for sure if refueling or a kick stage would have met requirements or not. Would it be good enough as long as the satellite to stay hidden inside the fairing during refueling?

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by ErikCorry on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:11AM (#33422305)
They wanted to use it before Xmas to keep an eye on Ukraine, and they didn't want to have to wait?
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by bpodgursky on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:57AM (#33422086)
I'm pretty sure the goal with Starship is that the economics are so much better that it's used even for awkward launches. I do not believe they are targeting Falcon Heavy launches in the long-term, assuming the best-case Starship scenarios.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by nuccy on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @12:02PM (#33423090)
Likely yes. Though there may be few ways to land the core booster:

1. Expend side-boosters to save enough fuel in the core for the entry+landing burn.

2. Land side-boosters on drone ships instead of flying back to land.

First option is likely the least favorable one, since two side-boosters combined price may be higher than the single core. Even though the core itself is likely more expensive than a single side-booster, since it caries the load of the payload plus side-loads from both side-boosters. Second option may be complicated logistically due to a lack of drone-ships. Landing three (or even two) rockets in the ocean was never done before.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by elfchief on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @12:30PM (#33423504)
At one point (I don't know if it's still the case) for certain launches the US government laid claim to "100% of the thrust available from a booster" or somesuch, basically not leaving anything left over for landings. I'm not sure it was ever documented why they had this requirement.

What surprised -me- was that all three boosters were brand new, rather than, say, expending a booster that's already flown half a dozen times or such.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by xeromal on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @12:52PM (#33423809)
Just guessing but maybe 100% of thrust available = statistically safer or something like that?
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by bombcar on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @01:27PM (#33424356)
Or gives them more lee-way for maneuvering or - makes it a tiny bit harder for spies to figure out what orbit they're going to place the satellite before the launch.

Or because someone asked "how high" and got back "as high as you can go".

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by snovv_crash on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @02:22PM (#33425236)
It could be something with a large fuel tank that can be adjusted in capacity so that it will be 100% of whatever Falcon can offer for the target orbit.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by Denvercoder9 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @01:45PM (#33424663)
> What surprised -me- was that all three boosters were brand new, rather than, say, expending a booster that's already flown half a dozen times or such.

Using new boosters was probably a contract requirement, but even if it wasn't, the Falcon Heavy center core isn't interchangeable with regular Falcon 9 cores, as it has to be strengthened to handle the additional load the side boosters put on it.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by mensetmanusman on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:30AM (#33421701)
Have to consider overall risk mitigation waste impact. E.g. if the additional complexity of adding a center booster increases risk of full mission failure, then, integrated over time, it can be a more wasteful decision if the goal isn’t to test that. Especially considering the satellite that would get destroyed and all the impact of having to rebuild that across the global supply chain.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by mercurywells on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:30AM (#33421700)
It doesn't have enough spare fuel for the descent/landing burns when lifting such a large payload.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by wiredfool on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:29AM (#33421696)
The booster was going 12km/sec at MECO, which is more than escape velocity. What they're doing with the second boost, they're not telling anyone.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by cecilpl2 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:38AM (#33421817)
No, it was going 14,240km/hr according to the video, which is about 4km/sec. Not near escape velocity.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by xcskier56 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:35AM (#33421772)
The booster was doing 14,000km/h at MECO which is about 3.8km/s. Orbital velocity is 7-7.5km/s depending on altitude and escape velocity is even higher, so no, it was not at escape velocity or anywhere near it.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by s1artibartfast on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:47AM (#33421924)
Isn't orbit tracking trivial? Also, orbital velocity depends on altitude, so perhaps they are just going to a higher orbit.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by wumpus on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @02:14PM (#33425092)
> What they're doing with the second boost, they're not telling anyone.

This is a direct-to-GEO launch, and some of the payloads are public.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by dotnet00 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:45AM (#33421892)
I think that due to how much F9 has managed to eat into FH's market, FH flights we see are more likely to only happen when the payload is heavy enough to need the center core to be expended.

For example, for a GTO insertion, an expended F9 can do 8.3t while a completely reusable FH can do 8t, but the expended F9 is going to be cheaper overall. Thus FH is only worth using when the payload is heavy enough to require at least the center core to be spent. This might be different for Lunar payloads though.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by bryanlarsen on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:52AM (#33421985)
Do you have any source for this? I would expect that a FH launch that reuses all 3 first stage cores would be cheaper than an expended F9. A few hundred thousand extra in fuel costs for the side boosters is cheaper than the few million dollars that the 9 expended engines would cost.

But I still believe you -- the infrequency of an FH launch probably increases the ancillary costs. I'd just like to see your source.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by dotnet00 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:16AM (#33422377)
My payload numbers are from the FH Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_Heavy#Capabilities

As for the price, the official numbers are $67m for a new F9 and $97m for a reusable FH (from their respective Wikipedia pages).

Additionally, my reasoning is (as you mention) related to cadence. FH flies very infrequently and requires more ground expenses to prepare, recover and then refurbish 3 boosters. Additionally there's the opportunity cost of keeping a center core on standby (as it's purpose built for FH [1]) and the opportunity cost of keeping the side boosters either on standby or converting them to F9s.

Elon has previously mentioned that with Falcon rockets the main costs per flight are the second stage (~$10m, expended), fairings (~$3-4m, reusable), refurbishment (~$1m) and fixed ground costs, which can be reduced by increasing cadence [2]. In the case of FH the second stage and fairing costs are the same, the refurb costs are tripled and due to much lower cadence the ground costs are higher. Meanwhile, F9 flies frequently, so it has lower ground costs per launch and the booster's cost can be more easily amortized via several flights before the expendable launch.

Additionally, [2] mentions that the marginal cost of building an F9 booster is ~$15m, so all the extra costs of FH only need to be greater than $15m to make it worth just using an expendable F9.

[1] https://spaceflightnow.com/2022/01/27/spacex-gives-converted...

[2] https://www.inverse.com/innovation/spacex-elon-musk-falcon-9...

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by bryanlarsen on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:38AM (#33422667)
The $67M price is for a reusable F9, though. The price of an expendable F9 used to be $90M, but public SpaceX prices have since gone up ~10%.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by dotnet00 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @12:09PM (#33423192)
Hmm yeah, digging around it seems that Wikipedia is probably incorrect with the expendable pricing. Seems like there aren't really any recent numbers available for expendable F9s as the last intentionally expended F9 was 3 years ago.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by usrusr on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @01:37PM (#33424532)
When I skipped through the video to the point where they explain that this was a mission without center reuse I was surprised to hear that they actually do seem to offer a three booster reuse profile. Perhaps my surprise was from confusing "no second stage reuse" with "no center booster reuse"?

But if it's a wash (as you say) between non-reusable F9 and 3x reusable FH I'd probably go for a single EOL core anyways, for the lower total count of failure modes alone. Even more so if launches in that weight class are sufficiently rare to be served from "organic" churn of reusable F9 launches (they clearly are).

In any case, my mention of surprise in the top level comment was not meant as "how wasteful, losers, boooh!", but as an statement of amazement, "have we/they really come that far that a part of me is unimpressed by two of three?", and on a meta level surprise about how a non-reuseable F9 feels less disappointing to me: a non-reuse F9 is a valid compromise to eke out the last bit of payload, whereas the FH raises an expectation of being better in every way that's then disappointed by "a third of a step back" in terms of reuse compared to what we now consider a regular F9 launch. We consider the reusable F9 regular, crazy!

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by dotnet00 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @01:59PM (#33424860)
Yeah, I understood that, I just enjoy talking about the contrast between F9 and FH and how F9 improved so much that it mostly took over FH's market :P

Eric Berger also put out a pretty good piece talking about all of this yesterday: https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/10/the-worlds-most-powe...

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by bell-cot on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:17AM (#33422385)
When you are watching SpaceX launch videos, pay attention to the velocities at which the various engine burns begin and end. Reaching higher velocities (for comparable payloads, etc.) requires burning more fuel - so there is less fuel left in the tank to perform boost-back burns, entry burns, and landing burns. Not enough fuel for a boost-back burn (the typical situation) means "barge landing". Not enough fuel for an entry (& landing) burn means "expended first stage" - which also means "remove the weight of the useless landing legs before launch".

And if the customer is paying SpaceX to take a heavy payload to a high velocity / orbit...well, they are paying for it. Today's launch was actually the third-most-performant (and -expensive) Falcon Heavy launch mode. #2 has both side boosters landing on barges (so the boosters don't need fuel for boost-back burns). #1 expends everything - just like all of SpaceX's competition does.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by pfdietz on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:37AM (#33422659)
If you watched the liftoff, after the vehicle was above the fog, the plume from the core looked much weaker than from the boosters. I think they throttle that stage down so it's using less fuel, leaving fuel to be burned after the boosters are done. This will also reduce the velocity at which the boosters are staged so they have an easier time getting back.

After the boosters stage the core will be throttled back up (if it hadn't been already).

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by bell-cot on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:51AM (#33422890)
Correct, and that throttle-fiddling is required to get a good performance boost from using side boosters.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by pleo__ on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @02:12PM (#33425061)
Additionally, the center core is throttled to make sure the vehicle safely gets through the dangerous "max-Q" part of the launch where stress from the atmospheric drag is highest.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by pfdietz on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @03:00PM (#33425824)
Makes sense. They throttle even on the F9 for that reason, and the FH is essentially three F9s with an upper stage that is not the mass of 3 F9 upper stages.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by pfdietz on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @02:58PM (#33425809)
An earlier design has propellant transfer from the boosters to the core stage while they were still attached, but I guess that was decided to not be worth it (if the engine thrust growth was high enough simple throttling would be enough.)
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by bell-cot on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @03:39PM (#33426370)
Propellant (and oxidizer) cross-feed systems would have added a notable amount of weight, a lot of design complexity and cost, and a metric sh*t ton of critical failure scenarios.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by ape4 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:58AM (#33423011)
And this customer asked for no filming later in the launch. So they are rich and secretive - I wonder who that could be?
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by ErneX on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @12:11PM (#33423236)
It was a launch for the US Space Force.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by bombcar on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @01:26PM (#33424322)
> Not enough fuel for an entry (& landing) burn means "expended first stage" - which also means "remove the weight of the useless landing legs before launch".

Landing gear? Where we're going we won't need landing gear!

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by willis936 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:19AM (#33422418)
It's not impossible, but it's certainly trickier. You'd have to save plenty of fuel to kick back into the atmosphere and land, re-entry is much more strenuous, and you'd have to complete a full orbit to land back where you launched. Nothing is a showstopper, but it would take development.