News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by frostburg on Friday October 28, 2022 @08:54AM (#33370768)
The anti-EU brigade in the comments isn't exactly giving a good showing of its intellectual caliber, with the most common arguments being that EU representatives are unelected (true in the same sense that the president of the USA is unelected) and that regulation is impossible because Twitter is an american company (self-explanatory).
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by INTPenis on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:06AM (#33370889)
I don't know about everyone else but we sure as hell had an election for EU parliament here in Sweden. We could elect a party, or individual MPs.

During the last EU election here I even called individual MPs and talked to them, or their office staff, about various subjects. So they're quite accessible.

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by ThalesX on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:09AM (#33370913)
They're talking about the commission, not the parliament.
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by hef19898 on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:13AM (#33370952)
And the commission is nominated by the elected governments of EU member states.
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by jansan on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:18AM (#33371003)
There were candidates for the commission's presidency, and Frau von der Leyen was not one of them. In fact, she was not on any lists before the election and her name only popped up afterwards, which made the whole election a farce.

It's like having a presidential race between Biden and Trump and then installing Weird Al Yankovic as president after all votes are counted.

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by hef19898 on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:21AM (#33371041)
Since the head of the commission was never ever voted for in the EU elections, who ever was proposed was just providing a face anyway. Much like the Chancellor in Germany, you vote for a party that proposed a person to become chancellor in case said party leads a coalition government. There is no way to prevent said party to just have someone else being elected chancellor by parliament. It is still democratic so.
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by origin_path on Friday October 28, 2022 @11:41AM (#33372855)
That's not accurate.

Von Der Leyen was not proposed by any party. The parties proposed other leaders. The "spitzenkandidaten" system that led to Juncker becoming EU President was only used once and was ignored this time. In fact nobody knows why or how Von Der Leyen became the EU President, only that the council leaders disappeared into a secret meeting and at the end, the deed was done. What was discussed? Were countries bribed or threatened to go along with it? Nobody knows.

So no, it's really nothing like the Chancellor in Germany or leadership anywhere else. The EU's own misinformation campaign around this topic is clearly highly effective. Normally, the people who run the country are elected by at least some local voters and then by the party itself. With the EU Commission, the president just ... turned up.

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by foepys on Friday October 28, 2022 @12:53PM (#33374015)
Von der Leyen was made president of the commission because Lagarde was made president of the European Central Bank.

Germany and France wanted these positions and decided amongst themselves who got which. Both wanted the ECB presidency more.

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by origin_path on Saturday October 29, 2022 @10:41AM (#33384422)
That's certainly one theory. Point is, it's just speculation. Nobody knows and the council members, despite theoretically answering to voters, systematically refuse to say anything about what goes on in those meetings. Isn't that curious?
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by data_maan on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:29AM (#33371134)
It seems people here from the US have fundamental misconception of how the EU works.
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by checkyoursudo on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:30AM (#33371145)
> It's like having a presidenctial race between Biden and Trump and then installing Weird Al Yankovic as president after all votes are counted.

This could still happen in the USA. The electors (the 538 people in the Electoral College who actually pick the president) could vote for anyone they wanted, and if enough wanted Weird Al then he would be POTUS. States have made laws to require electors to vote for the person who won the state election or face punishment, but that is not a Constitutional requirement or anything.

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by Calamitous on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:30AM (#33371152)
Honestly, I think Weird Al would be the best choice anyway…
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by mcv on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:29AM (#33371136)
> It's like having a presidenctial race between Biden and Trump and then installing Weird Al Yankovic as president after all votes are counted.

Is that meant to be a bad thing? Because you make it sound like a good thing.

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by data_maan on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:17AM (#33370997)
That's amazing. How did you get through to them, did you just get their email from their website?

We need more examples of this, to show that you can actual reach your representatives.

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by INTPenis on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:30AM (#33371149)
I misremembered, it wasn't during an election it was actually when we heard about the initial voting about chatcontrol, or one of the encryption breaking propsals that preceded it.

Either way, yes I was able to just call their office numbers listed on their websites and get through. I also in some cases got personal replies to my e-mails from individual MEPs.

If you call their office most likely someone else will answer the phone but in some cases, if you're lucky, you can just ask if the MEP is available.

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by pjc50 on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:22AM (#33371059)
MEPs are surprisingly accessible, because the public and journalists hardly ever bother with them. Journalists tend to focus on domestic political theatre rather than the boring details of actual policy.
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by origin_path on Friday October 28, 2022 @11:37AM (#33372799)
"we sure as hell had an election for EU parliament here in Sweden"

And it was irrelevant because the EU Parliament isn't a real Parliament, no more than the assembly of representatives in North Korea is. It lacks the so-called right of initiation, meaning that only the EU Commission has the power to change the law. As a consequence nobody who cares about politics bothers going there, except in cases like Farage or Le Pen as a way to get free money they can spend on campaigning against the EU as a concept. Why would anyone who cares about politics spend their time in a body where political ideas are worthless because you aren't allowed to propose them?

Would you like more evidence? The commissioner who made this tweet about the DSA flew over to California and told Musk to obey the new regulations before the EUP had even had a chance to vote on it at all. In a normal government, the legislature has to actually vote to pass new rules before the executive tells people to comply. But the EUP is a rubber stamp designed to grant the surface level appearance of legitimacy to the Commission's decisions, not a body that can actually keep the EU in check, so Breton didn't even bother waiting for it before starting to implement the DSA.

That's how much the EU itself cares about its "Parliament", so why should anyone else care?

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by simonsarris on Friday October 28, 2022 @11:39AM (#33372825)
really?! All this time. Why didn't you fix the thing where they decided every single website should have a popup, instead of browser vendors having an option?
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by jajag on Friday October 28, 2022 @08:59AM (#33370820)
European commissioners aren't elected in any sense of the word, they're appointed by national governments. Even if the US president is elected via an electoral college, the outcome of that vote is very much driven by the popular vote - it's in absolutely no way comparable to the way commissioners are put in office.
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by frostburg on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:03AM (#33370857)
The national governments are either elected directly or by a directly elected parliament; there is not as much difference as you think when you consider the state-level mechanics of the electoral college (commissioners also have a lot less power, this one is just pointing out the obvious fact that Musk isn't the law, the law is the law).
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by jansan on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:29AM (#33371133)
There were six candidates nominated for the head of the EU commission before the election. What is the point of the whole election if somebody completely unrelated finally gets the most powerful position in the EU?

https://www.dw.com/en/candidates-for-european-commission-pre...

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by eastendguy on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:03AM (#33370862)
> they're appointed by national governments.

...which are elected.

So if you want e. g. a right-wing EU commissioner just vote for your local right-wing party. It is that easy.

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by raspberry1337 on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:29AM (#33371132)
>..which are elected.

How indirect can democracy be until its still democracy?

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by hef19898 on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:35AM (#33371199)
Short answer? Very.
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by mcv on Friday October 28, 2022 @10:24AM (#33371736)
I think most national governments are also appointed. By the national parliaments, which are elected.

Maybe the EC should be appointed by the EP. That way it would be about as democratic as most national governments. Of course the problem there is that the EP is incredibly fragmented and there are almost no European parties; they're all national parties, so it's going to be hard getting a majority of those to agree on a government. I guess that's a big part of the reason why it's done by the smaller number of national governments instead, and the EP can only approve or reject.

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by origin_path on Friday October 28, 2022 @11:50AM (#33373006)
Only in theory. In practice the head of the Commission has the ability to veto the countries proposals, an ability you won't find in any treaty because it's not meant to exist. Nonetheless, Juncker said:

https://www.rp.pl/swiat/art1359931-juncker-kaczynski-nie-chc...

"Nobody knows this, but last time I rejected six commissioners that had been presented to me by national governments.

Also from Central Europe?

Yes.

From Hungary?

Not.

From Poland?

Not. If I wanted it to be made public, I would have done it long ago. Let me just remind you that governments only propose commissioners, but it is the President of the European Commission who accepts them and divides their competences between them, and the European Parliament approves or rejects it."

The EU spreads a lot of misinformation about its own operations. Here Juncker "reminds" the journalist of an arrangement that is explicitly not allowed by the treaties, which say the head of the Commission must accept whoever is sent by each country. He also admits that "nobody knows this" and that he never made it public. In case you think he would have accepted a right wing commissioner, let us recall this is the same man who railed against "stupid populists", said "The European Parliament is ridiculous, very ridiculous" and kept threatening eastern European countries that elected conservative governments with fines and sanctions. Von Der Layen is even worse, reacting to Italy's recent election of a right wing politician by saying that "if things go in difficult directions, we have tools".

What happens in reality doesn't match what's written in the treaties much of the time. It's very effective misinformation. This thread is full of people making claims about how the EU works that reflects its own claims (or propaganda), but doesn't match the documented reality of how Brussels decision making actually operates.

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by jen20 on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:06AM (#33370888)
> the outcome of that vote is very much driven by the popular vote

We’ll see about that when the far right has finished installing election officials wherever it can.

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by pmoriarty on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:22AM (#33371060)
Not to mention perversions of democracy like gerrymandering and the use of easily hackable electronic voting machines.
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by pjc50 on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:15AM (#33370976)
HN should be more generous towards Thierry Breton: an EU commissioner with a computer science degree!

> Breton received a master's degree in Electrical Engineering and Computer Science from École Supérieure d'Électricité (Supélec, now CentraleSupélec) in 1979 and later graduated from the Institut des hautes études de défense nationale (IHEDN).[6]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thierry_Breton - former VP of Groupe Bull and various other high-ranking telecoms posts there.

Also:

> Breton received world attention after an interview with the Wall Street Journal in 2011 when he reiterated his intention to ban internal email, dubbed as "the pollution of the information age", at Atos within 18 months (known as the zero-email strategy), replacing internal emails by a set of enterprise social networks, enterprise instant messaging, collaborative tools etc..., both being developed inhouse and partially aggregated from other vendors

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by raspberry1337 on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:35AM (#33371206)
I don't see any of these comments. Could it be that you are disingenious? pro-EU sentiments seem to attract the biggest turds. I say this as an unfortunate member of our bureaucratic european union.
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by frostburg on Friday October 28, 2022 @10:08AM (#33371568)
When I wrote that, the thread was empty and I was referring to the Twitter thread, not this one.
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by k__ on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:08AM (#33370902)
"EU representatives are unelected (true in the same sense that the president of the USA is unelected)"

To be fair, both are kind of a shit show.

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by 323 on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:08AM (#33370907)
> true in the same sense that the president of the USA is unelected

Really? That's some knot-twisting you have right there.

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by pjc50 on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:17AM (#33370995)
If you say the US is a democracy, a whole bunch of people will come out of the woodwork to explain that it's a republic and the President is indirectly elected. Certainly the President is not elected by popular vote, a very important fact recently. Nor does the Federal government run the presidential elections.
Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by xxs on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:26AM (#33371111)
>a very important fact _recently_

Not only, George W. Bush didn't win the popular vote, either - that was 22year back.

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by rascul on Friday October 28, 2022 @09:28AM (#33371123)
It's both a democracy and a republic. The terms are not mutually exclusive and an indirect democracy is still a democracy.

Edit: Also, it's not just a single system. At different levels the positions are directly elected.

Re:In Europe, the bird will fly by our EU rules by weberer on Friday October 28, 2022 @12:22PM (#33373547)
The US is a republic rather than a democracy because people don't vote directly on laws. Its unrelated to how the president is elected. An example of a democracy would be the Swiss system.