News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My next Mac might be the last by highwaylights on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @03:27AM (#33327283)
“But what about security? Are you sure you want to stay on an older version of Mac OS? — Thankfully I’m tech-savvy enough to know what I’m doing. The two Macs I use most are still on High Sierra and Mojave, and haven’t received security updates in quite a while. I haven’t had any security-related problem whatsoever.”

How do people keep thinking nonsense like this, and then repeating it online to endanger other non-technical folks who also don’t know better?

Author has no idea if he has had any security problems, because most malware isn’t about to alert you to it’s presence.

You don’t run out-of-support software on an internet-connected computer.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by hinoki on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @03:45AM (#33327416)
https://nvd.nist.gov/vuln/detail/CVE-2018-4192

https://nvd.nist.gov/vuln/detail/CVE-2019-8601

Remote execution vulnerabilities happen in JavaScriptCore. Tech-savvy won’t save you, all it takes is some malicious ad code or some hacked server providing malicious JS (or media files, etc. etc.)

Re:My next Mac might be the last by newaccount74 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @03:56AM (#33327497)
Are there any proof-of-concept exploits for these issues anywhere that people could try out for themselves?

I think it would go a long way to convincing people if you could for example visit a website that eg. changes your desktop background when you visit it, to show how dangerous it is to run unpatched systems.

There are so many documented vulnerabilities that only apply to certain scenarios, that people (myself included) just think, "Hey, that sounds very theoretical, I don't think it applies in my case"

Re:My next Mac might be the last by sph on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:13AM (#33327624)
I've been asking every chance I get whether these security issues affecting unsupported operating systems are actually being exploited in the wild. Three times I've asked, yet so far, no one has shown any proof whatsoever. Add to that proof of Spectre and Meltdown drive-by exploitation in the wild, today.

While I do not condone the use of an insecure version of the OS, herd immunity is an underrated factor. Unless you're targeted, malware developers don't spend too much time on 0.5% market share, just like web developers don't optimise for unknown browsers.

Prove me wrong.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by bagels on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:22AM (#33327710)
Well, it hasn't happened for quite a few years, but it was quite common years ago to get drive by ad malware on up to date systems even. It's the main reason I started turning off JavaScript, and later using ad blockers. I can't imagine it's impossible today.
Re:My next Mac might be the last by cedilla on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:43AM (#33327869)
It's the prevention paradox all over again.

With Sepctre mitigations rolling out in under a month to almost all PCs, of course there is less incentive to build an exploit. But we know how it was when 90% of PCs were unpatched XP boxes.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by muricula on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:48AM (#33327907)
Wannacry used the exploit from EternalBlue to create one of the most famous ransomware worms in recent memory, and wasn't the only malware to leverage that one exploit: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2019/05/etern... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WannaCry_ransomware_attack

Despite lots and lots of POCs, I haven't seen attackers use spectre in the wild yet. Maybe sophisticated actors are using it but they haven't been caught yet, or more likely they just use more traditional and reliable ways to get info leaks. But if traditional info leaks dwindle, they may turn to speculative execution attacks.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by blaser-waffle on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @12:19PM (#33332665)
The level of access required to make Spectre work, basically shoehorning microcode into the CPU, means that you'd already have some deep hooks in the box anyway. Easier to use other methods at that point.
Re:My next Mac might be the last by muricula on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @02:36PM (#33334496)
Spectre does not require changing the CPU's microcode. You just need to be able to run native code or even javascript. https://security.googleblog.com/2021/03/a-spectre-proof-of-c... https://leaky.page/
Re:My next Mac might be the last by highwaylights on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:59AM (#33328009)
“Prove me wrong.”

No. That’s the point. The burden of proof isn’t on anyone to disprove your untestable theory about market penetration (although in the case of JS vulnerabilities your premise is completely baseless anyway).

That’s like saying “you can’t get cancer from smoking if you immediately drink a herbal tea after every cigarette because of it’s mystical healing properties. Prove me wrong.”

Re:My next Mac might be the last by anonymous_sorry on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:18AM (#33328548)
I don't think it's untestable. All you need is a counterexample or two to prove it incorrect.

Unless your proposition is that there are groups exploiting minority unsupported OSes but that they all remain successfully undiscovered, like Russell's teapot[0].

But as others point out, there actually is at least one known counterexample - WannaCry/EternalBlue.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell%27s_teapot

Re:My next Mac might be the last by sph on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:46AM (#33328760)
I'm not the one making the claim here.

The claim is other people saying "don't use an old OS/mitigations turned off because of drive-by malware."

I am the one asking for proof of this. I know the vulnerability is real, but is there malware on the web, right now, that I might chance upon and risk my data?

Re:My next Mac might be the last by moreira on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @05:36AM (#33328285)
I think you're right. If the vulnerability is there and we know about it, it should be straightforward to write a proof-of-concept that anyone on a vulnerable system can experience for themselves.

e.g. If a JavascriptCore vulnerability allows RCE on a Mac running whatever old version, write something to exploit it and execute the "say" command on that Mac, so anyone running that version can go to that webpage and literally see "wow this is a real exploit that actually works and anyone can abuse".

I'd love to see that. Kind of like the XSS script alert triggers, stuff where you can just paste a bit of code and prove that it -is- exploitable, without it actually doing anything harmful.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by sph on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:52AM (#33328808)
AFAIK there is a proof of concept for Spectre or another one of those speculative bugs, but it's academic, so not actually malware on a shady website that tries to steal my bitcoin.
Re:My next Mac might be the last by saagarjha on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:08AM (#33327588)
They’re a bit of a pain to implement but it might be worth doing…?
Re:My next Mac might be the last by newaccount74 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:20AM (#33327689)
I wonder if they are actually possible. Remote code execution in the javascript engine does sound dangerous, but then you also have to get past address space randomisation, and then you need another exploit to escape the sandbox...
Re:My next Mac might be the last by saagarjha on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:27AM (#33327749)
Right, all of which get patched every update as well. In theory chaining them together is doable, it’s just effort.
Re:My next Mac might be the last by forgotmypw17 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @10:50AM (#33331238)
Adblock is the most effective security application we have today.
Re:My next Mac might be the last by connordoner on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:05AM (#33327555)
Thank God someone else said it.
Re:My next Mac might be the last by unsafecast on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:18AM (#33327670)
I run out-of-support software on an internet-connected computer, and I'm aware of the risks. I'm just really careful and I acknowledge that I'm at risk every time I go online.

I assume the author thinks the same way.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by bowsamic on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @05:00AM (#33328015)
It's impossible to be careful if you aren't doing security updates, because there's literally no way that you can even be aware of most of the dangers. These things are designed to be covert. It really is more like driving a car with no safety features that might fall apart at any moment because you think your reaction times are very good. The car might fail in a way that you cannot even see, based on vulnerabilities in the car that you are not aware of
Re:My next Mac might be the last by kilpikaarna on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @05:20AM (#33328166)
Hyperbole much? Do you really think the potential consequences of driving the car of your analogy are comparable to the potential consequences of using an out of support operating aystem on your laptop?
Re:My next Mac might be the last by bowsamic on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:48AM (#33329766)
You have purposefully misinterpreted my analogy in a bad faith way. The point is not to compare the severity, but to compare the total invisibility of the danger. That's why it's an analogy and not totally equivalent, it is only comparable in some ways... I swear to God sometimes Hacker News is so tiring
Re:My next Mac might be the last by prepend on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @11:55AM (#33332298)
There are safety features, they are just out of date.

I think a more accurate analogy would be like driving a car frozen with the safety features from the year 2010. Millions of people do this.

Or driving a car without patching the firmware. Again, this is common.

I agree the risk is unknowable, but I think it’s estimateable enough so that it can be accepted or rejected.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by adamckay on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @01:59PM (#33334040)
> I think a more accurate analogy would be like driving a car frozen with the safety features from the year 2010. Millions of people do this.

I don't think it's any more accurate really, because whilst newer cars can said to be safer with more recent features, there's nothing that can compromise a 2010 crash structure or airbag without you noticing. The same cannot be said for internet connected machines.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by enneff on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:21PM (#33335617)
No, it’s like driving a car whose airbag is known to have a fault that will send shards of material into the driver’s face in the event of an accident. (A real issue that many manufacturers had to issue a recall for.)

This is actually a great analogy now, because Apple (or whoever) regularly issue “recalls” for their known-insecure software in the form of software updates. If you follow the discussion in the info sec community surrounding these updates, often the vulnerabilities that are patched are being actively exploited.

One recent iOS update that comes to mind is one that patched an issue where a PDF sent via iMessage could give remote code execution with no user interaction or visibility. (Actively exploited.)

So yeah, you can drive around with your faulty airbag if the possibility of getting your face mangled doesn’t bother you. Or you can just follow the recall procedure, which is a bit inconvenient but it seems much less inconvenient than facial reconstruction.

And if you don’t care about your data being compromised and sold to bad actors, who may then steal your identity and cause a LOT of trouble for you, then by all means run known-insecure software. That seems like very poor risk assessment to me.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by jjav on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:09AM (#33352966)
> So yeah, you can drive around with your faulty airbag if the possibility of getting your face mangled doesn’t bother you. Or you can just follow the recall procedure, which is a bit inconvenient but it seems much less inconvenient than facial reconstruction.

An interesting example, in that the airbag recall took many years due to the volume of units that needed to be recalled. So no matter what you wanted, you were stuck driving around for a few years with a known risk in your face (literally).

Re:My next Mac might be the last by bowsamic on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @04:47AM (#33341251)
The risk is not at all estimateable, since you have no idea what the vulnerabilities are
Re:My next Mac might be the last by MonkeyClub on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:49AM (#33329775)
> Hyperbole much?

Nah, I’d say GP was within the limits of hyperbole /s

Re:My next Mac might be the last by highwaylights on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @05:02AM (#33328025)
“I acknowledge that I’m at risk every time I go online..

I assume the author thinks the same way.”

Just from reading the article, it does not seem that the author thinks the same way at all.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by resonious on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:27AM (#33327751)
Yikes, yeah. I wonder if this person is tech-savvy enough to check their machines for botnet nodes.
Re:My next Mac might be the last by pmoriarty on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @05:34AM (#33328269)
How does one do that?
Re:My next Mac might be the last by boppo1 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @07:04AM (#33328893)
Probably wireshark + process manager.
Re:My next Mac might be the last by prepend on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @11:56AM (#33332325)
I use littlesnitch and watch for any unknown outbound connections.

I once had tripwire setup and would look for any system changes but it got to be too much work.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by bowsamic on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:56AM (#33327978)
There are a scary number of tech people who think that as long as you don't click on an obvious virus ("download more RAM!" or "win free iPhone") then you're totally safe
Re:My next Mac might be the last by chaosbolt on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @05:21AM (#33328170)
Meh you probably are if you're like me, a nobody.

Most non targeted viruses will just wait for you to copy paste some crypto private keys or credit card numbers, or encrypt your files and ask for a ransom. Hackers just want money and it's honestly a numbers' game.

Most tech people who use crypto use a hardware wallet, most banks today will get you your money back (although the merchant ends up losing money if not insured) + you can just limit your card spending if not planning a big buy, and ransomware is a non issue for me since I keep everything important on a couple external disks.

Now if you work at a big corporation you probably have a work pc that's kept updated and where you face the same security issues as anyone else.

And if you're a journalist or brag about the millions you made in bitcoin on twitter then you become targeted for more sophisticated attacks.

>tech people who think if you do X then you're totally safe

Most tech people who think this aren't in a cricical enough position to worry about something more than a keylogger or ransomware, but if you're a network engineer at Google and think this then you shouldn't be working there.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by bowsamic on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:36AM (#33328681)
Do you seriously think most vulnerabilities are used only for famous targets? Whatever gives you the illusion of safety I guess
Re:My next Mac might be the last by tiagod on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:45AM (#33328748)
There's plenty of examples of 0day drive-by attacks being deployed to general public targets through ad-networks.
Re:My next Mac might be the last by paulcole on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @07:42AM (#33329202)
What’s one example?
Re:My next Mac might be the last by marcinzm on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:07AM (#33329401)
Re:My next Mac might be the last by newaccount74 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @01:58PM (#33334035)
> the zero-day vulnerability has allowed the group to break out of the iframes and display malicious code to visitors and perform redirects

That is of course something that shouldn't happen, but it's not a particularly severe threat.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by thfuran on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @10:11AM (#33330683)
So, botnets are a myth, I guess?
Re:My next Mac might be the last by prepend on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @12:01PM (#33332406)
1.5 million people pay for AOL still [0].

It’s not that botnets are a myth, but there’s some users who actually do click on scams and let people remote into their machines.

Just because botnets are real doesn’t invalidate GP’s points.

[0] https://www.google.com/search?q=aol+number+of+customers&ie=U...

Re:My next Mac might be the last by prepend on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @11:58AM (#33332366)
> then you're totally safe

I don’t know anyone who thinks they are totally safe.

But I know a lot of tech savvy people who don’t run anti-virus or any countermeasures and think they are acceptably safe.

I know it’s cliche to link to xkcd, but this comic seems relevant… https://xkcd.com/463/

Re:My next Mac might be the last by lgreiv on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @03:21PM (#33334966)
Of course there are pros and cons to this position, but just to state a con: anti-virus is usually running with elevated (if not maximum) permissions, tends to load basically any input and once in a while tries to be clever by using self-written interpreters or something along the lines of that.

Using a native AV that does basic heuristic detection is fine and dandy and usually comes with a low performance penalty and requires few rights that other parts of the system do not already have.

Using a non-root user for the daily grind and switching to elevated privileges only if required, running a PiHole (or a software adblocker) and monitoring outgoing traffic using Littlesnitch or LuLu likely comes at a better attack surface/performance/security trade-off, though, AFAIK.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by prepend on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @07:27AM (#33342172)
I think the point is that on controlled images like voting machines you shouldn’t be installing anything at all this an anti-virus is unnecessary.
Re:My next Mac might be the last by lgreiv on Wednesday October 26, 2022 @05:11PM (#33349508)
Ah, excuse me. I was not referring to the XKCD at all, I should have been clearer. Agreed, as usual „it depends“.
Re:My next Mac might be the last by enneff on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:24PM (#33335657)
Most of the countermeasures that are sold (such as AntiVirus software) are pretty much snake oil. The single easiest and most important thing you can do to keep your systems safe is to keep them updated.
Re:My next Mac might be the last by m00dy on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @05:11AM (#33328079)
Nothing is safe, Mr. tech-savvy
Re:My next Mac might be the last by vegai_ on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:04AM (#33328458)
Re:My next Mac might be the last by ThePowerOfFuet on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:08AM (#33328480)
> You don’t run out-of-support software on an internet-connected computer.

The rail industry, alas, begs to differ.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by oftenwrong on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:29AM (#33328621)
What have you seen?
Re:My next Mac might be the last by abudabi123 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:31AM (#33329616)
Search newspaper headlines dated within the last 10 or 5 years?
Re:My next Mac might be the last by ThePowerOfFuet on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @02:58PM (#33334744)
Lots of Windows 2000/XP and horribly-outdated Linux.

They were acceptable decisions made back in the days before railways started deciding to network all the things, which wasn't really foreseeable at the time... and railway stuff tends to last 20-40 years.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by pelagicAustral on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @08:17AM (#33329491)
Is this a dig at OS/2?
Re:My next Mac might be the last by ThePowerOfFuet on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @10:30AM (#33330936)
No, because that's actually still supported:

https://www.arcanoae.com/arcaos/

https://www.ecomstation.com

Re:My next Mac might be the last by anton96 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @09:29AM (#33330208)
I think people have different perspective or objective of security.

I would tend to think the author would be mainly concerned about having his bank account data leaked and loosing money or having some online account hacked and loosing access to it.

As your rightly said, the author might already run some malicious program without knowing but as it doesn't impact his life in any meaningful way, that is totally virtual to him and sort of not existing then.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by prepend on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @11:51AM (#33332233)
I don’t think it’s nonsense.

It’s important to be conscious of security, but that doesn’t mean automatically upgrading to everything all the time. There’s no way, that I know of, to be completely secure so I’d rather be conscious than a false feeling of safety.

I run Catalina 10.15.7 and I think I run it secure enough. Of course maybe I’m rooted and all sorts of bad stuff, but I don’t think so. Of course, maybe the most recent version has an unknown zero day (negative day?) and would also be rooted.

I think it’s naive to have a blanket rule like never run out of support software because sometimes we must. I run old devices that aren’t patchable or supported because they still have use (YouTube/Netflix) and I use them in an appropriate way, I think. I won’t conduct banking, but if someone breaches my Netflix account, I don’t care much. If it’s part of a botnet, I don’t care much. Of course it’s inconvenient and I don’t want to harm others, but then I also don’t want to keep buying dumb terminals for things and companies don’t seem to be changing their support timelines.

This isn’t even mentioning stuff that’s risky like continuing to run my smart lightbulbs even though Phillips stopped supporting them years ago.

I believe in calm technology and I’m not going to keep replacing stuff just because it has a non-zero risk.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by comte7092 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @12:33PM (#33332863)
>If it’s part of a botnet, I don’t care much. Of course it’s inconvenient and I don’t want to harm others.

“Letting your machines become part of a botnet is nbd” is quite the take.

Re:My next Mac might be the last by prepend on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @01:06PM (#33333318)
That’s not it at all. I just don’t think there’s a great risk of my machines being part of a botnet. Past performance doesn’t guarantee future performance but so far I’m a few decades in and no botnets so far (knock on wood).